3 ms·
This magnesium hydride technology certainly does not solve the hydrogen storage problem in the sense of being better than using hydrocarbons for energy storage,
by adrian_b 6y ago
This magnesium hydride technology certainly does not solve the hydrogen storage problem in the sense of being better than using hydrocarbons for energy storage, as the living beings have been doing for billions of years.
For many applications, using magnesium hydride should be much better than using compressed or liquefied hydrogen, but it remains far worse than gasoline despite the misleading statement from the article "POWERPASTE offers a range comparable to – or even greater than – gasoline".
This statement is false. Magnesium has twice the atomic weight of carbon and the hydrogen from magnesium dihydride provides only 2 electrons per magnesium atom, instead of 6 electrons per carbon atom, as in gasoline.
Because of that, a fuel cell using hydrocarbons (those exist, but the current prototypes do not have an acceptable lifetime) would have a 6-times higher energy capacity per fuel weight.
While the energy per weight of magnesium dihydride is very poor, the energy per volume is more decent, because gasoline has low density.
Nevertheless MgH2 has only twice the density of gasoline, which means that the hydrogen content per volume is about the same as for gasoline. Because when used in a fuel cell gasoline would provide 3 times more current per volume, magnesium hydride remains uncompetitive regardless how the storage cost is computed.
Pure dihydrogen would provide a voltage around 20% higher than hydrocarbons in a fuel cell. That is much too little to make a difference compared to factors of 6 and 3 in current per weight and current per volume.
Instead of wasting time and money to search for impossible ways of storing hydrogen, the energy research should be directed to improving the (already existing) technologies for making hydrocarbons from carbon dioxide and for making hydrocarbon-using fuel cells with better characteristics.
- imtringued 6y agoAre you seriously suggesting we should waste our renewables and nuclear to capture CO2 from the atmosphere and then turn that stuff back into hydrocarbon fuels only to turn 80% of it to waste heat? Seriously, man. There is no future where this is going to happen. We are not going to replace waste primary energy generated by fossil fuels by wasting our low carbon energy. We are going to reduce the amount of waste energy and thus lower the overall demand for primary energy. The energy density of gasoline is worthless if the efficiency is garbage. A transition from ICEs to EVs works just fine without expanding power generation significantly precisely because we get rid of the inefficiency.
- jcims 6y agoIt wouldn’t be a permanent solution but there are trillions of dollars worth of infrastructure built around petroleum fuels. Moving personal vehicles and metro transit to EVs is straightforward, but it’s less so for freight/marine/aircraft and doesn’t account at all for industrial uses of petroleum fuels.
- adrian_b 6y agoYou are right that the main disadvantage of storing energy in hydrocarbons is the low efficiency of the complete cycle, which is indeed around 20% today. It is likely that the efficiency can be improved a lot but it is improbable that the efficiency of the complete cycle could reach much above 50% any time soon. So you are right, for the best efficiency rechargeable batteries are the best. Nevertheless, there are many cases when a maximum autonomy time is more important than the efficiency, together with the possibility of storing the energy for an indefinite time without any losses (e.g. due to self-discharge). In those cases hydrocarbons are optimal. So both technologies are necessary and each has uses for which it is the best. For example, a healthy human can live about one month without eating, due to the stored hydrocarbons, i.e. fat. No future robot using lithium batteries will be able to do that, while performing a similar activity level and having the size of a human.
- gspr 6y ago> It is likely that the efficiency can be improved a lot What makes you think that? I thought internal combustion engine efficiency is widely believed to have hit its reasonable limits?
- Brian_K_White 6y agoInternal combustion, or any form of combustion, is only one way to get energy back out of a hydrocarbon. And a hydrocarbon cycle doesn't necessarily have to be all that efficient to be practical, if the primary energy input is renewable, and the cycle is largely closed (IE, a plant somewhere consumes the same stuff the vehicle produces). The portability, safety, ease of handling, and rapid simple refill of hydrocarbons outweighs a lot of other factors at the point of use for some jobs, mainly vehicles. Most other energy-consuming jobs can use a wide variety of other forms of energy, so this is mostly about vehicles, not energy usage in general. This is why your furnace doesn't burn gasoline. Anyway what they're saying is that entire cycle can probably be improved a lot from what we can manage today. We can surely continue discovering new and better ways to make a fuel cell that consumes a hydrocarbon. And we are definitely still discovering a variety of different ways to synthesize hydrocarbons. Some have a lot of overhead like planting corn and eventually getting a small quantity of a low-density hydrocarbon (alcohol). Some are more direct bulk inustrial processes that are fairly cyclic and lower overhead than farming. We already have a variety of examples of both the consumer and generator parts of the cycle and we are definitely not done discovering all the possibilities.
- 8note 6y agoTIL you can put gas in a fuel cell. Why don't we today? That seems like a handy way to run a hybrid