4 ms·
> MTG believes that Nancy Pelosi should be murdered Oh please. This sort of rhetoric, while distasteful, is such a common sort of exaggeration that there’s a S
by rayiner 6y ago
> MTG believes that Nancy Pelosi should be murdered
Oh please. This sort of rhetoric, while distasteful, is such a common sort of exaggeration that there’s a Supreme Court case on it: https://www.mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/707/watts-v-united-states https://www.mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/707/watts-v-uni...
> Robert Watts, attended an anti-war rally at the Washington Monument.... Watts allegedly said: “I am not going. If they ever make me carry a rifle the first man I want to get in my sights is L.B.J.”
> The Court agreed with Watts’s counsel’s characterization of Watts’s speech as “a kind of very crude offensive method of stating a political opposition to the President” that did not qualify as a true threat.
The phrase “deserves a bullet to the head” or the like is a (juvenile and violent, but common) figure of speech. It’s invariably used figuratively not literally.
- tptacek 6y agoThat's a little hard to square with the mob that descended on the Capitol, which included people who apparently seriously hoped to kill politicians. We all get that "I'm going to kill him!" is usually just an expletive. It's not always, though. MTG seems like a strange hill to die on. I assume you pretty much share the contempt everyone else has for her.
- rayiner 6y agoWhat does the mob have to do with MTG’s liking a violent comment about Pelosi a year earlier? I think MTG is a nut and should go the way of Steve King. But someone being a bigot and a nut and a conspiracy theorist isn’t an excuse for accusing them of sincerely wanting to murder people for using clearly hyperbolic rhetoric.
- idlewords 6y agoSuch hyperbolic accusations aren't limited to MTG; see the effort to accuse Lauren Boebert of endangering her colleagues by allegedly carrying weapons onto the House floor (open carry is part of her schtick) or allegedly endangering the life of the Speaker of the House by "tweeting her location" (in reference to a tweet that said that the Speaker was being evacuated). Reframing controversial political disagreements as uncontroversial issues of personal safety is a cancel culture trope that has worked well elsewhere and now being imported into our political life. Hence the ongoing theater with metal detectors and armed military guards, as well as the baseless accusations that legislators pose some physical risk to their colleagues and must therefore be expelled.
- tptacek 6y agoI don't know, I think you're both a little off here. You're confident MTG doesn't actually mean it when she talks about assassinating politicians. That may be the case. But she's talking about it with people who do mean it. Somebody comes up to you and sincerely starts a discussion about hanging the traitors, and you play along with them? That's on you. It's not a hyperbolic accusation. (I don't think Boebert is in quite the same league, but give it time).
- idlewords 6y agoIf she's doing something criminal, then charge her. But I think the issue here is that she is associating with extremists, and our political clique considers such behavior beyond the pale. Unfortunately, that norm no longer exists in the other party. The traditional remedy for such extremism was to expose the links to voters, who would be duly horrified and vote her out. But MTG's voters knew exactly who they were electing, and I will wager that she wins again with ease in 2022. She is now a culture hero thanks to the Democratic legislators who voted against her. Overriding the voters' decision based on our own notions of propriety, in the name of saving democracy, is a sure path to ruin. As long as her conduct is lawful, there is no defensible way to get her out of Congress except the hard way.
- tptacek 6y agoI think I agree with you about proposals to remove MTG and Boebert from Congress altogether. Ultimately, the choice of the voters in a district is a big deal, and I can clearly see the bad places this goes if every district is subject to a majoritarian check from Congress itself --- which I'm betting we lose in 2 years anyways. But not seating MTG (or maybe Boebert) on committees seems like less of a problem, and it doesn't seem any less legitimate to me when the majority of the House does it to MTG than when the Republicans themselves did it to Steve King; in both cases, it wasn't the will of the voters that elected these people that created the consequences. Also: it took a long time to get Steve King out, and an superheroic amount of effort from JD Scholten, who had to know his chances were slim and kept fighting anyways; I don't know that you can expect Scholtens to keep appearing to fend these monsters off. But just looping back to the subject of the thread: there's a "rule of goats" thing about wishcasting the assassination of a political opponent, and, in collaborating with people who are almost certainly not being ironic in discussing the possibility, MTG has gone way beyond being an ironic goatfucker.
- cozuya 6y agoI'll say three things in response: 1) There is no evidence that MTG does not believe that Nancy Pelosi should be murdered. There is evidence that she does. She has never apologized for it. 2) If you, or anyone else, makes a death threat to a public figure on social media, you will be at minimum receiving a visit from law enforcement, and will be arrested if you don't immediately disavow what you said or are thought of as a threat. "Watts" ruled that "mere political hyperbole" is not illegal, have fun in court trying to convince the judge of that. Death threats are not just "distasteful rhetoric", come on. 3) The fact that you a) gloss over the rest of my post and b) don't even bother to condemn this stuff is really telling. One more thing: have you ever received a death threat from a stranger? I have, I was playing poker in a casino late at night. I was not frightened, but it was not a pleasant experience. The guy was 86ed, and a few hours later I was escorted to my car by security. I stayed away for a few days despite it being my only income at the time. That was 15 years ago I still think about it some times. I don't wish that experience on anyone. Being a politician must be terrifying. Really sad to see it minimized here.
- rayiner 6y ago> There is no evidence that MTG does not believe that Nancy Pelosi should be murdered. There is evidence that she does. She has never apologized for it. I have a hardcore feminist friend who repeatedly gets banned from Facebook for hyperbolic rhetoric like “kill all men.” Is that evidence she wants to kill all men? No it’s hyperbole. (And it’s stupid that Facebook bans it but the rest of the world doesn’t run by Facebook rules). > If you, or anyone else, makes a death threat to a public figure on social media, you will be at minimum receiving a visit from law enforcement, and will be arrested if you don't immediately disavow what you said or are thought of as a threat. The comment MTG liked, “a bullet would be quicker,” would not be perceived as a “death threat” in any court of law. It’s archetypal political hyperbole. > "Watts" ruled that "mere political hyperbole" is not illegal, have fun in court trying to convince the judge of that. I’d take that case in a heartbeat. It’s a straightforward application of Watts. > Death threats are not just "distasteful rhetoric", come on. 3) The fact that you a) gloss over the rest of my post and b) don't even bother to condemn this stuff is really telling. I condemn MTG completely. But this one is a stupid justification. > One more thing: have you ever received a death threat from a stranger? The whole point is that a violent comment made on a Twitter board about a public figure isn’t a death threat. If I called you up and said “I’m going to put a bullet in your head,” that’s a death threat. If I say “someone should take Ted Cruz out back and shoot him” that’s obviously not a death threat. You know this because you’ve heard this phraseology a million times.
- kasey_junk 6y agoYou’ve spent a fair bit of time recently on HN requiring any “liberal” here to defend the most outrageous muttering of the chattering tv pundits or college professors. People who espouse views that are clearly not in line with the national party or the populace as determined by polling. Yet when people point out an elected national official of the GOPs words. An official that far from sanction, actually has the backing of the caucus in a named vote, you defer to defending it as figurative language. You are applying a clear double standard. One that is dangerous. You demand your opposition abide by the Queensbury rules while your team wallops the referee with a chair and sets alight our country in the process. What could she say that you’d sanction as much as you do anything Robin Diangelo does?
- rayiner 6y agoWhen a progressive liberal says they want to pack the Supreme Court (and destroy the rule of law in the process) they mean it. It’s backed by white papers peddled by fancy think tanks. There’s like PACs backing it. The ideas are published by professors in reputable journals. When MTG “likes” a juvenile comment saying “a bullet would be quicker,” obviously I don’t treat that with the same weight, because that’s a figurative phrase that doesn’t convey an actual plan to kill anybody. I think it’s a fair thing for parties to have to defend the concrete policy proposals of their wings. Not so much random inane muttering of individual members.
- cozuya 6y agoNot having 9 justices on the Supreme Court is not destroying the rule of law, there have been many times that has happened. What a ridiculous, embarrassingly partisan statement. You should be ashamed.
- rayiner 6y agoYou should be ashamed of the embarrassingly disingenuous characterization of the court packing proposal. “Court packing” refers to expanding the court to allow a president from one party to appoint new justices to change the ideological makeup of the court. You know this because the very phrase “court packing” originated in a proposal to do just that: https://www.history.com/news/franklin-roosevelt-tried-packing-supreme-court https://www.history.com/news/franklin-roosevelt-tried-packin... It absolutely would destroy the rule of law. The Senate Judiciary Committee, controlled by FDR’s own party, had this to say: https://constitutioncenter.orgblog/how-fdr-lost-his-brief-war-on-the-supreme-court-2 https://constitutioncenter.orgblog/how-fdr-lost-his-brief-wa... > By June 1937, the Judiciary Committee had sent a report with a negative recommendation to the full Senate. “The bill is an invasion of judicial power such as has never before been attempted in this country. . . . It is essential to the continuance of our constitutional democracy that the judiciary be completely independent of both the executive and legislative branches of the government,” the report read. > Its conclusion was even more direct: “It is a measure which should be so emphatically rejected that its parallel will never again be presented to the free representatives of the free people of America.” Even the mere threat of court packing effectively gutted separation of powers and federalism. Today, a federal government of “enumerated powers” is a dead letter, all thanks to FDR.