7 ms·
Bill would allow tech companies to form local governments
- Tomte 6y agoLook up Tennessee Ernie Ford, "16 Tons" and company stores.
- hawkice 6y agoI mean, mining companies made local governments before. I'm skeptical that single-issue regulatory exemptions will have any impact on long-term growth, particularly for areas like AI or block chains, where the level of regulation is already essentially none. [Edit: I'm going to go out on a limb and say I'm being taken as saying I'm in favor of this idea, despite only really saying it won't work.]
- rodgerd 6y agoSixteen tons, and what do you get?
- myownpetard 6y agoAnother day older and deeper in debt.
- omginternets 6y agoAnother day older and deeper in debt.
- TedDoesntTalk 6y agoBut... blockchain!!!
- RhodoGSA 6y agoI think some people are missing the point here. In order to charter the corporation you need to be a billionaire. I doubt it has anything to do with wanting to make 'More money' as opposed to leaving a city as a legacy, under your vision, ideals, etc. I mean, what else do billionaires dream of?
- icefrakker 6y agoWhile the idea of a city run entirely on blockchain sounds on the face stupid and obviously a scam that is going to bust at public expense at some point, is the idea behind this any different than what Disney has going on for it in Florida?
- gabereiser 6y agoThis is a horrible idea. Mainly because companies operate like an elected monarchy at best, dictatorship at least. Any “company government” would look no different than a dictatorship to the outside. In India, there are blocks of corporate housing for contractors and employees of fortune 500s. If they lost their jobs, they lose their residence. If the company lets them go, they lose their residence. Imagine for a moment, you’re a 10x dev working on a financial platform under contract. The contract is pulled due to funding. You are benched and told “we’ll find you something else to work on”, then a few months later they let you go and you have to move. Government is for people, corporations are for profit, those two are not compatible.
- karl11 6y agoWhat better way to find out whether or not this is true than with a real experiment? This is a fantastic idea, because we could see what alternatives actually look like. If you don't want to live there, you just simply don't live there.
- mlthoughts2018 6y ago“If you don’t want to live there, don’t live there” - the siren song of inhumane exploitation.
- jonathankoren 6y ago“Anyone can buy OCP stock, and own a piece of our city. What could be more democratic than that?” Robocop 2 https://youtu.be/wA_P8CaNwro https://youtu.be/wA_P8CaNwro
- rodgerd 6y agoWe've already done this. They were called company towns. I realise that a lot of modern tech culture would rather re-invent the world from first principles while making 10,000 years of human mistakes at high speed in preference to acknowledging the existence of disciplines outside of STEM, but history, economics, anthropology, town planning, they're all right there with many of the answers.
- Ensorceled 6y agoDoes the sheriff essentially work for the CEO, like in all those old westerns?
- hashkb 6y agoThe CEO will be sheriff. And judge. Probably executioner too
- gabereiser 6y agoReminds me of a company I used to work for...
- pmiller2 6y agoReminds me of every company I've ever worked for.
- hprotagonist 6y agoSign me up for Mr. Lee’s Greater Hong Kong.
- CompuHacker 6y agoAt the very least the government won't hound you to mow the lawn.
- Arrath 6y agoYou beat me to it.
- 29083011397778 6y agoHe has the username to get away with it
- myownpetard 6y agoIs that in the delivery region of Cosa Nostra Pizza?
- hprotagonist 6y agoThat entirely depends on how I'm feeling tonight.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoWill there be Rat Things?
- drivingmenuts 6y agoMeh. I’m gonna go live in a container by the airport.
- _jal 6y agoApparently some people read Snow Crash and mistook it for utopian fiction.
- ASalazarMX 6y agoIt is utopian if you are on the megacorporation end.
- swiley 6y agoWow Google has really been going at it this year.
- jonathankoren 6y agoEvery discussion of companies acting as local governments need to include Lake Buena Vista, Florida, population 10. You know it as Walt Disney World. Walt Disney was a proponent of company towns where the employees/residents would be completely dependent on the company. These ideas were expressed in his plans for EPCOT (the unbuilt town, not the theme park we have today). Some of these ideas were later revived in Walt Disney owned and controlled Celebration, Florida. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lake_Buena_Vista,_Florida https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lake_Buena_Vista,_Florida https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EPCOT_(concept) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EPCOT_(concept) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Celebration,_Florida https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Celebration,_Florida
- lettergram 6y ago“Bring back the company store!” ... said no one ever ...
- forgotmysn 6y agoquick! someone write a Black Mirror epsidoe
- pmiller2 6y agoThey already did! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifteen_Million_Merits#Plot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifteen_Million_Merits#Plot
- g_p 6y agoI wonder how quickly (if this goes ahead) it descends into Kafka-esque cycles of automation resulting in people getting locked out of fundamental services due to the plethora of edge cases that aren't convenient and scalable for the tech company to handle? It strikes me that governments have a responsibility to handle and account for all of the edge cases (people with disabilities, etc.) which companies often tend to neglect in pursuit of a simpler and cheaper "at-scale" solution that works for 95% of people (but ignores the slightly more complex 5%).
- fernly 6y ago> Sisolak specifically named Blockchains, LLC as a company that had committed to developing a “smart city” in the area east of Reno that would run entirely on blockchain technology... I'm trying to picture a municipal fire department, or sewage facility, or street cleaning department, that runs "entirely on blockchain tech".
- willcipriano 6y agoFinally someone applying blockchain tech to company scrip.
- Arrath 6y agoWe're processing the dispatch request for your emergency fire call, we'll get back to you once the transaction is confirmed in the blockchain. Thank you for using FireBlock!
- dhritzkiv 6y agoTip: a higher transaction fee often prioritizes your transaction. We recommend 0.00148BTC for your fire services request.
- Arrath 6y agoQA Bug Report: If the blockchain server farm itself catches fire the request will never process. Response: Edge case, will never happen. Closed NOFIX.
- pbourke 6y agoThe fire department can dispense pure hype, which displaces oxygen and extinguishes the blaze.
- AmVess 6y agoIt's amazing how flagrantly politicians are now willing to sell citizens out for a buck.
- IG_Semmelweiss 6y agoI generally agree with your sentiment, however i must clarify. The article states they are talking about a bill that will provide existing undeveloped barren land that has no citizens on it.
- hertzrat 6y agoIn 50 years, lots of people would be born there who had not been able to make that choice themselves
- crazypython 6y agoIf a company has its own cryptocurrency, would it be plausible for the company to gradually become a city-state?
- paulpan 6y agoWhat's next, full-blown sovereignty? /s
- brobdingnagians 6y agoI do think this is a terrible idea, but then again it is one of the benefits of having separate states where each can experiment with ideas, sometimes very strange or ill-advised ideas. They are reminiscent of company towns, and I would predict they will become even worse. Modern "smart cities" are even more than just owning and profiting off of everything, it is about data and analytics and techno-utopians. I would predict that all of the issues about surveillance and control that are appearing in our society would be amplified on a small scale. It has become fashionable for rich technologists to believe they can solve world issues with technology, themselves as masters. This attempt to try to make a perfect society could just make a perfect dystopian nightmare. They aren't even pretending it is democratic; "the company or firm applying for the zone would have significant say over who would sit on that board". This is a regression of hundreds of years in political theory and development.
- azifali 6y agoSounds like a really bad idea; or a plot from a dystopian novel.
- sambull 6y agoCompany chit on the table again?
- derefr 6y agoCan someone help me to understand: why is a bill needed for this? Don't "company towns" already exist? Were they illegal somehow? Would it be illegal to build one now (in Nevada, without this bill)? Or is this proposing something besides a regular "company town" model (i.e. a regular municipality where everyone who lives there is an employee of company X; and there are municipal elections, but all the options on the ballet are, of course, employees of company X; and where the elected government contracts out many services to... company X)? Is the idea here that the corporation itself would be the municipal government, rather than the municipal government being a regular elected body consisting of company-X employees? If so, would that not make the election for the corporation's board of directors, a municipal election; and somehow create a link between landholding within the incorporated land area and shareholding in the corporation?
- m-p-3 6y agoOne step closer to a dystopia.
- throwaway191234 6y agothrowaway for obvious reasons > Blockchains, LLC to effectively form separate local governments in Nevada, governments that would carry the same authority as a county, including the ability to impose taxes, form school districts and justice courts and provide government services, to name a few duties. I previously worked for Jeff Berns prior to their relocation to Sparks, NV, while this plan was being formulated. Giving control of local government to Blockchains and Jeff Berns is... not a good idea. Jeff Berns is borderline delusional, off in the clouds, thinks ETH and blockchain are the solution to every problem, whether it exists or not, has awful business ideas, and treated his employees pretty poorly. Well, I mean, he was nice in person when he visited every 3 months. But the comp was flaming garbage, the office was crap, the management imcompetent and ineffective, he didn't give a shit what his employees thought. Everything in Jeff's company was complete and utter chaos. The products themselves were straight up idiotic, to be frank. The fact that Jeff had us abandon products after 3 months to start working on his next "big thing" didn't help, either. Lastly, Jeff berns has spent a fortune hyping crpyto, because his real fortune IS crypto. The dude owns boatloads of BTC, BCH, ETC, ETH, and many more, and has since ETH was < $1. He is not altruistic. He is a man who believes that under his "guidance", humanity (his friends, really) can make great steps and he is using the crypto community to further his wealth and influence. TL;DR: Jeff Berns and Blockchains, LLC belong as far away from political/governmental power as possible.
- abruzzi 6y agoThis makes me wonder about a lot of "how will this work" questions. For example will it legally require 100% of taxation be used to provide services, or will taxation become profit center for the owning company? Another is will they be required to follow certain laws that municipalities are required to operate under? For instance, here in NM it is illegal for a quorum of the governing body to meet without 72 hour advance public notification and agenda and no item may be considered if it is not in that agenda. And of course the whole statement that the company will have significant say in the makeup of the 3-person board. What exactly does that mean? Can only company approved people run for office? Is this watering down representative democracy? I don't know because for stuff like this, the devil is in the details. (and what happens when the company becomes insolvent?)
- frongpik 6y agoSerfdom, rebranded as something related to high tech. And there will be enough desperate people who would fill these zones. Tata consultancies and the like hire echelons of h1b workers from India and China and those workers may never see a green card. Moreover, once such zones get a competitive edge by extorting their employees, other companies will have to get out of business or embrace the new business model.
- Frazmatazz 6y agoA manor with boarding houses will now be an "Innovation Zone" with "Coliving Spaces".
- RhodoGSA 6y agoThat, or a company like Tesla announces a new city, millions of Americans flock to it, we redevelop a sense of unity and local progress and all live happily ever after. "you're afraid to take the first step because all you see is every negative thing 10 miles down the road."
- airstrike 6y agoAnd if Tesla goes under or faces some troubles, or for whatever reason decides to close down shop, since everyone's income is nearly perfectly correlated the city collapses all at once and the entire population is now unemployed
- RhodoGSA 6y agoDefinitely amplify's risk for sure. If the company went under, your whole county would go under and the government is not likely to bail them out like they would a city who had too much debt. Since you may even purchase your house on the company land, you could quite literally lose everything. Again, if the population thrives the amount of space is hyper-limited. I don't know if there'd be gentrification per say, since it'd be gentrified from the start but the populace would grow fabulously rich off both stock in the company, increased land value and general prosperity for your entire community. It also changes the incentive structure. You want you company to thrive, so your can community to thrive and vice versa.
- a3n 6y agoInstead of naming rights for a stadium, it's running rights for a whole town. What happens if your town account is opaquely closed?