7 ms·
The reality is that this is a very difficult situation all around. 1) Lenders probably shouldn't be lending money to people they know cannot repay the debts. T
by arcticbull 6y ago
The reality is that this is a very difficult situation all around.
1) Lenders probably shouldn't be lending money to people they know cannot repay the debts. This is also why APRs are so high - most people simply don't.
2) People who know they can't repay the debts shouldn't be borrowing in the first place. This is also why lenders have to go to such extremes to collect their debts.
This is a function of being poor in a country like America with zero social safety net. If you're desperate and on the ropes and have nothing to fall back on you'll do whatever it takes to get by including take out loans that you can't afford, from lenders who know you can't repay them.
The problem isn't predatory lending, or deadbeat borrowers, it's a deeply unequal society which doesn't look after its own, with rampant wealth and income inequality and a total lack of social safety net.
In an ideal world, folks would be able to rely on unemployment or UBI to get by tough stretches, and this system would disappear instantly. Half the country is busy breathlessly screaming socialism over what the rest of the world considers a "functioning government" and the other half has other things on their mind like walking back stupid bathroom laws, and in the end, nothing fundamentally changes.
- malandrew 6y agoHow do you design an unemployment/UBI system that provides an incentive not to use it unless necessary and not to stay on it any longer than is necessary?
- lostcolony 6y agoYou don't have to. How many people have you met who were happy doing nothing, living with nothing, AND who made good employees doing anything at all? I've met exactly zero. The ambitious won't want to stay there; the unambitious may "unfairly" get their basic needs met, but they're hardly living the high life, and the lost -useful- labor to society is negligible. Almost certainly more than offset by the ambitious who can now take risks they otherwise couldn't, knowing that if they fail they at least aren't going to end up hungry and homeless.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- arcticbull 6y agoThis is in line with the results of Canada's early UBI experiments; substantially nobody left the workforce except to pursue liberal arts or stay-at-home parenting, both of which have intrinsic value. People are motivated by a combination of intrinsic and extrinsic factors, including their social group at work, finding meaning in their lives through their work, and so on. UBI and unemployment isn't provide enough for a lavish lifestyle, you can achieve that through work. > The ambitious won't want to stay there; the unambitious may "unfairly" get their basic needs met, but they're hardly living the high life, and the lost -useful- labor to society is negligible. Certainly true, and of course, automation will replace the missing labor in the pool, and the continued march of development will lead to even lower birth rates (already well below replacement rate of 2.1 is almost every developed nation), and there will be fewer and fewer of these folks in time. Canada's most recent UBI experiment, cancelled recently (2020) by Ford & co, was showing excellent results [1], and so did the earlier one in 1974 [2]. [1] https://newatlas.com/good-thinking/canada-basic-income-experiment-ontario-report-results https://newatlas.com/good-thinking/canada-basic-income-exper... [2] https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20200624-canadas-forgotten-universal-basic-income-experiment https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/20200624-canadas-forgot...
- bumby 6y agoI think the major fault with these studies is there participants know the benefits will end. I think this biases them towards continued working because they view it as a short term windfall that won’t sustain them rather than a long term solution. It would be incredibly hard to design an experiment to control for this. Conversely, I think the hard part about implementing UBI is that it would be incredibly hard to roll back once people become accustomed to it
- arcticbull 6y agoIndeed, I think the challenge is around committing to a 50 year study that they won't cancel later in a discretionary way. > Conversely, I think the hard part about implementing UBI is that it would be incredibly hard to roll back once people become accustomed to it So we are left with something people like and don't want to give up, and that's bad because... :)
- sammax 6y agoThe whole point of UBI is that everyone gets it, unconditionally. There is no not using it or not staying on it. You just get the UBI, and it should be enough to pay for basic living costs, and most people also want to be able to afford luxuries so the incentive to work is not gone.
- liminal 6y agoThe "U" in UBI stands for "universal". Everyone gets it all the time.
- jrumbut 6y agoI would say that while this is a real concern, our current system places way too high a priority on addressing it.
- mlac 6y agoMy concern is that lenders will start loaning against it at ridiculously high rates on UBI income streams - "Get 100K today for signing away your UBI payments!" or "just pay us the monthly amount of your UBI payment!". After thinking about it a while, I realized the law would need to protect the UBI payments from being accessible in bankruptcy. That would significantly limit lenders willing to lend on that money. Those who did would be charging very high-interest rates on it and probably limit the total amount backed by it, so someone can't borrow 200k and then declare bankruptcy but have it be protected. Even writing this out now, I'm not sure that this would work because I'm not sure how you prioritize lenders for someone's assets who declares bankruptcy. I also see upward pressure on housing prices - right now, few landlords know what the market can take for pricing. It would be easy to bump everyone's rent by a few hundred dollars when UBI kicks in because you know everyone can afford it. Technology and the market structure are so efficient at extracting value from things that it's hard to design any policy that will effectively achieve the desired outcome of providing food, clothing, and shelter for all citizens without some wonky unintended consequences.
- jessaustin 6y agoCongress changes the terms of credit and bankruptcy all the time. See the limitations that lenders bribed Biden into including in his "Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act". As a part of a UBI law, they could just say that creditors have no right to recover UBI payments. Take everything he owns, but you can't come back next week to take more. It could be that housing rents in certain situations could increase in response to UBI, but in most cases having more money gives one more choice, not less. A family who are now stuck in a rattrap located conveniently with respect to public transport might move to a better cheaper place in a more remote location and buy an old car. They wouldn't have to stay at the mercy of their current landlord. Other people in other situations might respond in other ways.
- mlac 6y agoI hear you, but I still question how long those on UBI could get ahead of the rat traps before the non-rat trap options become their old cost + the cost of UBI, effectively transferring most of the UBI benefit to the landlords and ending us up in a similar place. In my mind, it's about answering the question of how we lower barriers to moving to ownership and getting people out of the poverty cycles. There are two major hurdles I see: - The current structure right now, and incentives that exist, are so good at extracting money that they might quickly eat up the additional money handed out - whether it's through financial instruments or increased prices for basic necessities. - The people that consistently don't have money are bad at earning money, bad at keeping money, or some combination of the two. UBI only helps the people who can't earn money, but doesn't solve the financial literacy problem or the root cause that a group of people is bad at keeping money.
- IG_Semmelweiss 6y agoNaval ravikant put it succinctly , the real issue is that once the 51% know they can vote to redistribute the wealth of the remaining 49%, then that opens the door to...well, the JRE clip goes deeper https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=eHim7CMOZ6U https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=eHim7CMOZ6U
- account42 6y agoAnd this is supposed to be worse than 1% accumulating most of the wealth how?
- IG_Semmelweiss 6y agoAre you ready to argue that the poor are better off when everyone is poor, and inequality is nonexistent ? Because thats called north korea/ussr... and people routinely risked their lives to escape that equality... Here is how i think your point of view becomes stronger: Say inequality exists - but show how did it get there? Is it corrupt wealth? Does inequality persists because movement between wealth levels is becominy stale? For example, did bezos sell slaves or sell missiles? Or did he get rich getting to sell you stuff which you really like? Or, is there a chance your avg 1%er could be wiped out tomorrow? Or is being in the 1% sticky...like it is in the UK, Italy and france, where the same 5 families had the same wealth since the middle ages ? If you have a fair shot at the 1% , and if the road to get there is morally sound, then you wont hear of anyone to complain of inequality. Show which of the 1% is morally corrupt, and where progress in wealth dynamism is stalling, and im there to argue with you that we need to fix it.
- matthewdgreen 6y agoA big part of the reason that nothing ever changes is because it isn't profitable for things to change, at least not when some moneyed interests can make a profit doing things like predatory lending and others get to have cheap employees. In other words, the lack of a social safety net isn't just some accident that citizens blundered into. It was engineered and continues to be advanced by the people who make money from it.
- refurb 6y agoThis is a dumb take. Canada has a very cushy social safety net and still has payday lending with interest rates of 49%. And the alternative of having payday lending is no lending - that is, these folks would have no way of getting a short term loan. Is that better?
- Scoundreller 6y ago> Is that better? Usually.
- arcticbull 6y agoIndeed if payday lenders are profitable then they are extracting welfare from the worst off.
- refurb 6y agoHuh? If the poor by Apple phone is able extracting welfare from them?
- matthewdgreen 6y agoI think there's a middle ground between "unrestricted predatory lending" and short term lending. The payday loan industry spends a lot of money on lobbying to push things to the former end (see attached article about 1000% interest rates), and have been very successful [1]. (But the overall lack of a social safety net in the US is due to moneyed interests that go well beyond the payday loan industry.) Yours is a typical HN binary take that holds a thing must be an utterly unalloyed good or it must be banned, there's no middle ground for a thing to be useful when moderated and regulated, and predatory in other circumstances. This is a very common intellectual failure mode. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/02/us/politics/payday-lenders-lobbying-regulations.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/02/us/politics/payday-lender...