6 ms·
That is so typical. My experience with Discord: I need to login to my account to be able to delete it, except what if I cannot log into it?! At first they disab
by johnisgood 6y ago
That is so typical. My experience with Discord: I need to login to my account to be able to delete it, except what if I cannot log into it?! At first they disabled it, then I e-mailed them requesting them to delete my account, but all they did was a soft-delete, of course. All of the private messages are still there, etc. Even if I were to delete my account myself, it would still leave all my messages intact. I guess my definition of delete is different from theirs. They think delete = disable without saying it is disabled. Of course not being able to re-create the account with the same e-mail just further proves it. All that "delete account" does is remove your profile photo, change your nick, and disable your account, nothing more. I cannot even request them to delete all my private messages. I tried. They just do not give a shit.
- oaiey 6y agoWho owns the message? The sender or receiver? That is a question that bugs me once in a while.
- pepa65 6y agoThe receiver. It's the gift of communication..!
- minsc__and__boo 6y agoI always thought removing the sender identification was a good middle ground. i.e. John Does said, "Hello world" -> [Removed] said, "Hello world"
- simplecto 6y agoTrue, but the content of the message could contain identifying information. This is not an easy issue to solve.
- michaelmrose 6y agoDoes the fact that I can change or delete this comment mean you, or hacker news have less right to it? If I delete it are you doing anything wrong by keeping a screenshot or even sharing it? If I reveal I'm a criminal is it any different? What If it's 10 years later and I've served my sentence? Does it matter if the crime is morally wrong or even illegal where you live? What it it's personal but not criminal, say I've come out as gay or a republican or a democrat or a communist. I think we would be foolish to rely on greater privacy than is provided by terms and conditions and logically we will only acquire more favorable terms by requiring them in law. You gave a good example When you discussed being unable to delete data pertaining to your account. I think on a one to one message your recipient has a right to a record of what you actually said I don't think allowing one side to edit it after the fact facilitates honest conversations nor does it much protect the person who reveals sensitive information to do so. You can already attest to what they revealed or keep a screenshot. I think on a many to many forum like this thread that people ought to be able to control what new users see but people who already received the initial version have a right to the information imparted to them. Basically I view a message as belonging to everyone who received it and the service ought to retain it as long as one person whom it belongs to wants to keep it. I can see good reason to selectively remove content that is illegal say child or revenge porn but I feel like further restrictions ought to fall on the ethical reasoning of the receiver not technology to answer the complex moral implications.
- johnisgood 6y agoJust to add a bit to it or TL;DR some bits: once personal data leaves you, it becomes out of your control, we should be aware of this. The Government may even step in and whatnot, but the information is still out there.
- bzb6 6y agoDiscord does that.
- johnisgood 6y agoDiscord changes your name, so it does that, although it does not really do much if the messages contain identifying information which it most likely does.
- pmontra 6y agoIf I send you a paper mail, you keep it and your descendants could read it in 2121. Of course you own it and they will own it. If I send you an email, same thing, if it survives for such a long time. Does Google/any ISP also own it? If I send you a SMS, same thing, I bet it won't survive. Does the phone company also own it? If I write you on a social network, do you and I own the message or does the social network own it? There are ToS that we might not have read.
- johnisgood 6y agoYou cannot "unsend" a letter, an SMS, or an e-mail. You can delete messages "for everyone" in many instant messaging apps, and you can do that on Discord, too. The thing here is that they did not do what I could have done were I able to access my account. Perhaps it is covered in their ToS or Privacy Policy. To the down-voter: could you please elaborate with what you got the problem so we could potentially discuss it?
- CaptainZapp 6y ago> Of course you own it and they will own it. While the receiver of a letter on paper certainly owns the letter she doesn't own its contents. The copyright of the letter remains with the author. So you can frame the letter and hang it on your wall you violate the authors copyright if you publish it without authorization.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoNo idea why this is being downvoted, because it's correct. You can't publish letters without permission. This has been tested in court many times. What you can do is sell the physical object. That belongs to you. You can also burn it or destroy it - which is an interesting edge case. This really comes down to different kinds of ownership. The whole point of copyright is that creative/cultural/intellectual property rights are a thing, analogous to tangible property but with a different set of legal and commercial rights and obligations. Electronic media depend on context. ISP and telcos are usually considered common carriers so they don't own the copyright of emails or SMSs. Social media networks either claim all copyright in full (bad news for you...) or have a specific license clause in the T&Cs which gives them reproduction rights. Sometimes these are for specific limited purposes, and sometimes they're a blanket sign-away of all exploitation rights. (Bad news for you again.)
- nindalf 6y agoI think WhatsApp strikes the right balance. The sender can delete the message from both devices for a few minutes. After that, only from their own device.
- Veen 6y agoThe sender owns the copyright, but there is always language in the platform’s TOS to grant them a worldwide licence to do as they please with content shared on their service.
- foepys 6y agoA GDPR deletion request should be enough for Europeans to get rid of everything.
- remus 6y agoWhile it is a useful tool for users there are exemptions for the company. For example, if your account details have been requested as evidence in a trial then the company should not delete your account under a GDPR request.
- minsc__and__boo 6y agoGDPR isn't a blanket deletion. Organizations can still retain personal information about customers for situations where they deem the data is still necessary for the original purpose. e.g. purchase history, legal agreements, etc.
- foepys 6y agoNot for the original purpose. For legal reasons only and legal reasons are quite narrow. A simple message does not qualify.
- craz8 6y agoI’ve implemented email blocking recently where we stored a secure hash of the blocked email so we know we’ve seen it, but we don’t have it stored. So it is possible to do that correctly Discord probably doesn’t do that though
- CodesInChaos 6y agoHashing is better than storing it in the clear, but many email addresses have too low entropy to make hashing an effective anonymization.
- lathiat 6y agoSomeone did a pretty good analysis of that problem here: https://medium.com/@matthew.bajorek/using-hashcat-to-recover-hashed-emails-8ba306aab18a https://medium.com/@matthew.bajorek/using-hashcat-to-recover...
- CodesInChaos 6y agoI ran such an attack on stackoverflow's data dump in 2011 and recovered about 28% of emails, using only a simple laptop CPU. https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/44717/is-gravatar-a-privacy-risk/84734#84734 https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/44717/is-gravatar-a... Somebody else ran a similar attack on a different dataset using a GPU and recovered around 45%. https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/12/crypto-weakness-in-web-comment-system-exposes-hate-mongering-politicians/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/12/crypt...
- 91ffc269f090 6y agoNow try the same with HN. You cannot remove your old posts.
- simonh 6y agoI think this is spot on, when you post something to a communications platform you are publishing content. How can there be any expectation you can then un-publish it? Consider this in the context of bullying or shaming, should someone who sends me an abusive message have the ability to delete all trace of it afterwards?
- Fogest 6y agoThere is nothing more frustrating than searching for information on old reddit threads and seeing that some useful comment that used to be there is gone because the user nuked all their comments via a script. I understand the privacy reasons but at the same time it does ruin a lot of content on sites and can force people to repost old questions to get the answers again.
- endless1234 6y agoThis indeed sucks, but it would be pretty easy to fix. Just allow your nickname to be deleted for old posts automatically. I don't think individual posts' privacy is what people are usually worried about, but the possibility of getting "doxed" when given an easy way to view all of their previous messages.
- Fogest 6y agoI have actually considered using these scripts on my reddit account for privacy reasons but have always been concerned about deleting some useful posts/comments I have made. I definitely would love an option to unassociate my username from posts but still leave the content up.
- 548D4D0A 6y agoI assume you would also be ok with Twitter and Facebook not allowing people to delete anything? For shame! The authors' moral right alone should allow any content authored by them to be un-published. Ever heard of a paper being pulled? You example of bullying is top notch but what about doxing concerns? Plenty of people delete their "content" without being bullies.
- judge2020 6y agohttps://support.discord.com/hc/en-us/articles/360004066391-How-Do-I-Disable-My-Account- https://support.discord.com/hc/en-us/articles/360004066391-H... If you disabled the account yourself, then you should be able to recover it and then press the delete button yourself. If it was disabled for a TOS violation or for legal reasons then they might have a gdpr exemption to deleting the data[0] (NAL). As for messages, those aren’t deleted - while this might be legal (anonymization is seen as compliant with the right to be forgotten) they really should make it an option, otherwise people end up using scripts which do it for them[1]. 0: https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-data-protection/guide-to-the-general-data-protection-regulation-gdpr/exemptions/#ex3 https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-data-protectio... 1: https://github.com/victornpb/deleteDiscordMessages https://github.com/victornpb/deleteDiscordMessages
- johnisgood 6y agoI used ICO and their templates (I think it was ICO) more or less, but Discord did not care. They just disabled my account, but did not delete my messages. I use https://github.com/victornpb/deleteDiscordMessages https://github.com/victornpb/deleteDiscordMessages, yeah. :)
- endless1234 6y agoWhy should an account delete remove private messages from others? If you delete your account at your cellphone cartier, should it remove text messages you've sent from everybody's phones?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoI'm OK with this. Private messages have shared ownership. You weren't sending them to yourself. Yes, there might be identifying information in the content of the messages. Yes, in the majority of cases it wouldn't make a difference. In some minority of cases, though, they would. Abusive ex sending you messages over discord? Yeah, those might be evidence especially when both parties are saying different things. This is the most common example I can think of, but I'm sure there are others. Heck, even if someone wanted to reminisce about days gone by... they should have the right to do so in conversations they were involved in.
- johnisgood 6y agoWell, I thought they would delete them after having requested it, but they did not. In any case, there is a feature on Discord: I can delete messages (for everyone). So as long as I can log in to Discord, I can delete messages. I doubt they actually get deleted though, probably just changes its visibility, but in any case... why would not they do that if I could do it anyway were I to be able to log in?
- anticensor 6y ago> I doubt they actually get deleted though, probably just changes its visibility They are actually deleted, unlike many other platforms. If not, the problem described here would not arise in the first place: https://blog.discord.com/how-discord-stores-billions-of-messages-7fa6ec7ee4c7 https://blog.discord.com/how-discord-stores-billions-of-mess...
- johnisgood 6y agoYeah, I am not leaning towards either way stubbornly, I am open minded about it, I just know that many places really only just changes the visibility. In any case, thank you for the link!
- stef25 6y agoGDPR rules (which may not apply to you or Discord, not sure) say a company MUST hard delete a user's data upon request. Except if company can claim to need it, like for invoicing / tax reasons. Seems reasonable.
- oji0hub 6y agoMajor GDPR violation. If they do business in Europe this can get them into a lot of trouble.
- ArnoVW 6y agoJust in case you are European: you can frame this as a GDPR issue. Send a mail to their Data Protection Officer (often dpo@doman.com) asking to exercise your right to correct and delete any personally identifiable data they retain about you.
- throwaways885 6y agoDiscord does support GDPR requests - might be worth giving that a shot.