5 ms·
These places on the "independent web" are sadly getting more and more obscure to find via search engines. It's an unfortunate reflection of the "mainstream web
by userbinator 6y ago
These places on the "independent web" are sadly getting more and more obscure to find via search engines.
It's an unfortunate reflection of the "mainstream web" that I feel compelled to remark on the use of simple HTML and CSS, only marred by a single Google Analytics script. There's not a lot of content here, but there's also not a lot of bloat either.
- sudobash1 6y agoThat's true, but on the other hand, I find myself steadily finding them anyway (many on HN). This site is obviously not for mass consumption by the general public, so it's OK that it isn't highly ranked by Google. Google is for the average user. Sites like this are discovered by their target audience and spread largely by wires of mouth.
- the_pwner224 6y ago> This site is obviously not for mass consumption by the general public, so it's OK that it isn't highly ranked by Google. Google is for the average user. Sites like this are discovered by their target audience and spread largely by wires of mouth. You find some really good in-depth content for niche areas on these sort of sites (personal HTML websites, neocities.org, etc.). But if you forget the URL, it's usually very hard to find them again on Google even with using specific keywords. Too much SEO spam clogging up the results. I suspect not having Google Analytics scripts on the pages may also contribute. One that I can remember off the top of my head was a blog with a pink-ish background with content on making quills and ink from plants, among other stuff. One post specifically had an easy ink recipe that used walnuts iirc. Google will show you tons of big SEO'd Wordpress blogs with ads/affiliate links but not the old school genuine site. Another one was the blog of a day trader (a real one, not a guy trying to sell day trading courses). Impossible to find. site:wordpress.com helps filter out some of the SEO spam but I think it must have been hosted on a custom domain. It definitely looked like a standard Wordpress website when I read it a long time ago.
- quenix 6y agoThis is perhaps an unpopular opinion, but why do you think sites such as these deserve any sort of high place on a search engine? The goal of a search engine is to present results which are -useful- to a user. These "independent web" sites are a neat relic at best and completely useless to the everyday user at worst. Compared to the tens of millions of competing -useful- sites, they are markedly less deserving of a spot. In fact, it would be unfair to award one to them purely because they are "independent".
- gonzo41 6y agoIf Google were a book shop. You'd only see 10 books and usually the same ones. I guess that drive for more unique content comes from an older view of the net that was more ecsentric. A bookstores a bad analogy. Maybe a fashion store. If you're a heavy consumer of the net you probably hit the edges of your algorithmic fish bowl pretty regularly. I know I do and it's work to get out. Actually, I'd so much like to see different things more often I'd consider turning ads back on if the service could be provided.
- creato 6y agoWhat search terms should a site like this show up for? I poked around and all I found was short generic bios and links to social media and photo sites. I don't understand what searches should return a site like this, other than the person's name and some other identifying info (to disambiguate from the other 10 million Pauls).
- HenryBemis 6y ago> If Google were a book shop.. On the Amazon-CEO news yesterday, someone posted an interview of JB from 1997 [0]. In the first 2-3 minutes he explained exactly that (but for books). There are X million titles on books, they keep a tiny fraction of that in stock for 'next day delivery'. Kinda what Google does (or many search engines). Usually you find the 'most popular' answers on the first page. But when I have a tech problem, I have usually tried the 'first 5 pages' of solutions before I even try to duck it (DDG) for a solution (dear wikihow, yes I did restart my PC!). I assume HN has the type of readers that already KNOW the first 10 pages of solutions, and thus need that tiny level of detail that one gets after digging deep (stackexchange, forums, etc.) Question if anyone who knows: does Google search engine give preference to websites that display Google ads, or it is agnostic? I assume Google's crawlers can 'read' if a website is using X, Y, or Z advertiser's ads. (I haven't used Google for many many years and I usually block any google search and ads related IPs and URLs)(and ads in general). [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rWRbTnE1PEM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rWRbTnE1PEM I suggest you spend the 5mins to watch this video. He made it sound so easy..
- asavadatti 6y agoThis is a good resource to find such content https://wiby.org/ https://wiby.org/
- jart 6y agoHoly hell this is incredible. I've wanted exactly this to exist for years and now it does. Does Wiby still crawl the web? How can we give a project like this wings? It restores the true Internet.
- iFreilicht 6y agoIt seems that you have to submit pages to wiby, and it’s URL and all subpages will then be indexed if they follow their rukes. You can talk about it to others and you can donate, that’s probably all this project needs.
- jart 6y agoWhat are the rules?
- avian 6y agoRules are written on their submit page [1]. They prefer non-commercial, content-focused websites with lightweight HTML. The submit page also suggests they don't do link crawling, but only allow submission of individual URLs. [1] https://wiby.org/submit/ https://wiby.org/submit/
- ricardobeat 6y agoI love the idea, but it seems quite hacker-oriented (for a lack of a better term). Most searches will return something UNIX or hardware related (e.g. "table tennis").
- BallyBrain 6y agoJust did a quick search for 'epson hx-20' and this site popped up. https://int10h.org/oldschool-pc-fonts/ https://int10h.org/oldschool-pc-fonts/ not really relatated at all to my search, but I'm very glad to find it. A beutiful looking site indeed. This is the kind of stuff I remember doing back in the 90s, you'd search for something then something more random would show up but often be interesting to check out.
- jug 6y agoSometimes I try to use DuckDuckGo more for this; to exit Google's filter bubble. I have at times thought the DDG search results are worse, but maybe it's just me unused to be served a tailor-made web, and the actual problem here is that I have grown sloppy and need to work on my search keywords from a "universal web" point of view...
- gspr 6y agoMaybe we need to bring back web rings? I'm only half joking.
- bitexploder 6y agoHeh we need to bring back site rings. Those wacky footers where you would link up to a few other sites you liked. I found a lot of cool sites with those back in the late 90s. Blog rolls were a thing too. Seems like tech blogs (mostly) all got eaten by Stackoverflow.
- coldpie 6y agoHonestly? Yeah. That could be neat. I should go add a "sites I like" listing to my blog.
- shadowgovt 6y agoI think that reflects a change in the way the web is used. Anecdotally, I clicked on the monkey.org link, poked around for thirty seconds, found - an FAQ that didn't answer any questions I had - a list of users (no particular reason to click on any, so I didn't) - a list of domains (no particular reason to click on any, so I didn't) ... and no understanding of what "monkey.org" was or is. I've learned more reading the comments on this HN post than I did from the website. This isn't to say monkey.org should change anything about what it's doing; it seems to be what it wants to be, and that's great. But a search engine isn't going to index that highly, because it generally answers nobody's questions about anything.