18 ms·
This would be great news if everyone were invested in minimizing polarization and detoxing the political conflicts that we’re facing. But that’s not the case.
by eyelidlessness 6y ago
This would be great news if everyone were invested in minimizing polarization and detoxing the political conflicts that we’re facing. But that’s not the case.
The biggest divide between the “parties” (which isn’t political in nature and has nothing to do with the very real and significant differences between the parties) is that one sees polarization as a tool and the other doesn’t acknowledge that.
On Twitter, this has been exceedingly shorthanded into “tan suit”. One party is so invested in conflict that they invent it by manufacturing a scandal out of a fashion choice. The other is so invested in conflict avoidance that it pathologically refuses to hold the first accountable for anything meaningful.
In other words the divide isn’t political, it’s about ambition and shrewdness. This won’t be overcome by finding common ground.
Edit: added a comma because it would’ve driven me nuts not to. Also to add a reasonable disclaimer that I’m not philosophically a member of either party, but I caucus/coalition with the one I obviously perceive to not be fundamentally bellicose.
Edit 2: well since it needed clarification, I consider the Republican Party to be the bellicose one and the Democratic Party to be the spineless one.
- witherk 6y agoInteresting, what are some things that you think democrats could do to hold republicans accountable?
- munk-a 6y agoI think Dems have an uphill battle to fight - media seems strongly slanted against liberal policies as evidenced by the lack of deficit spending being anywhere in the debate when tax cuts were happening compared to deficit spending to address the viral crisis. There are entrenched interests that will put a lot of messaging toward suppressing discussions of liberal policies.
- AnimalMuppet 6y ago> media seems strongly slanted against liberal policies Um... what? If you think media is strongly slanted against liberal policies, look at how it treats conservative policies.
- cudgy 6y agoThe media, republicans, and democrats all were complicit in handing trillions of dollars to large corporations, 0% interest loans, and forgivable loans (more handouts) in the form of the covid bailouts, 2008 bailouts, and quantitative easing. All three also seem to support practically any war proposed especially if it involves oil and false weapons of mass destruction to name a few. True Liberals tend to hate wars and giving tax money to corporations mismanaged by rich citizens.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoTrue conservatives don't like giving tax money to mismanaged corporations either.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 6y agoIgnoring your no true Scotsman, you're insinuating that essentially either airlines/cruise/rail/trucking/etc are managed just fine, or there's no true conservatives still in power.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoWell, that means that cudgy is saying that there are no true liberals in power, either. But I'd be interested in how you think money is being given to rail companies. Not to passenger rail service agencies, to the actual rail companies. (And in your list, you forgot the barge companies.)
- munk-a 6y agoI think this is a really good example of why this article is pretty damn accurate. Both true liberals and true conservatives look on their own and the opposition party as being too corporate focused because the majority of neither one represents their interest. It's on the fringes of each party that politicians that represent the interests of the people exist and those fringes are those maligned as fascists and communists, since everyone on the other side wants to pick on them and nobody on their own side wants to defend them. There's a suitable Noam Chomsky quote for this > In the US, there is basically one party - the business party. It has two factions, called Democrats and Republicans, which are somewhat different but carry out variations on the same policies. By and large, I am opposed to those policies. As is most of the population.
- leesalminen 6y agoPretty sure it goes both ways ;). Which is perhaps why the parent didn’t specifically mention party names. The statement is interchangeable for both parties. Ps- I’m not a member of any political party.
- jdub 6y agoIt doesn't go both ways, and that's precisely the point the original poster was trying to make. US parties do not behave the same way. One has been festering extremism for 60 years.
- munk-a 6y agoThe issue is that if you ask different people in the country which party that "one" is - you'll get a fifty-fifty split.
- jdub 6y agoIt's more like a persistent 60/40 (or optimistically 70/30) split, but it's understandable that some people are simply wrong.
- leesalminen 6y agoExactly this.
- DubiousPusher 6y agoThat doesn't make them correct. Constantly averaging your position is a good way to get dragged in the direction of the outlier.
- munk-a 6y agoIt doesn't make them correct but it means that we've got a pretty gigantic societal issue to deal with.
- 6y ago
- eyelidlessness 6y agoIt’s not that I think they could, for what it’s worth. I’ve fought with my lefty friends to stop having completely unrealistic expectations, or at least to be more pragmatic about the way they evaluate outcomes. But what I think they could do more effectively is: 0. Recognize the disposition of their opponents (they’re belligerent and you should start there). 1. Try more, it’s not a nobody-gets-hurt game. We put you in power to wield it! 2. Focus more on goals than appearances. Nobody really cares if you look belligerent too. They just say they do. Your focus groups are lying as much as the opponents’ focus groups. 3. Set a better example by ruthlessly policing your own more aggressively. Don’t give anyone the opportunity to say you’re hypocritical. 4. Be willing to lose. It’s hard when you’re disadvantaged in most ways. But don’t play the hard game with all your betting money! Play the harder game with some of it. People are looking for you to be sincere, not just blab values and go fold every hand at the big kids’ table. Sorry for the extended gambling metaphor but it’s what I’d advise.
- vkou 6y ago> is that one sees polarization as a tool and the other doesn’t acknowledge that. Which one? I've seen this argument argued to hell and back by people on both sides, and I feel that it misses a bit of nuance. My view is that both parties view this polarization as a tool, but they polarize in very different ways, for very different issues. Mind you, by saying this, I am not equating their behaviour. I have very little patience for two-sideism.
- DubiousPusher 6y agoI often say both parties are similar though not symetrical.
- munk-a 6y agoAs long as users are watching, clicking or re-tweeting then news companies will shout "Keep doing that thing!" I think media companies mostly found out that these sorts of petty debates were popular when they all starting trying to drag out news to 24/7 and found that viewers "cared" more about the tan suit discussion than anything else. But there is another big factor, advertisers, making controversial statements on news (or, god forbid, calling out a corporation that advertises with your network) drives away ad revenue and works against the goal of media corporations. Everyone is a lot more comfortable chatting about suit color than talking about poverty in our nation and having a complex debate over how to siphon some of the excess wealth toward addressing the issue. Copy-and-paste this for every other issue that politics is utterly dropping the ball on these days.
- vkou 6y ago> Everyone is a lot more comfortable chatting about suit color than talking about poverty in our nation and having a complex debate over how to siphon some of the excess wealth toward addressing the issue. I mean, about ~40% of the voter base, and about ~60-80% of the political class does not believe that we need to have any debate about siphoning excess wealth, because they do not believe it should be done. Why would they want to debate it, when they can instead talk about literally anything else? When you are cheerleading for the status quo, ignoring the issue makes it go away - at least for another two or four years.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 6y ago[Citations needed]
- vkou 6y agoDo I really need to provide citation for the claim of 'Nearly all republican politicians, and many democrat politicians do not really endorse wealth redistribution'? It should be self-evident from their voting records, and the rather anemic progress on that front when democrats control government. Have we all forgotten Obama's first term? If his party cared about redistribution, they would have done something to effect it. Instead, all they managed to do was pass a republican healthcare reform, and then lose a midterm election. When polled, the voters, on both sides of the divide, view it much more favourably than politicians do, but then they largely go ahead and vote among party lines, so I suppose you may say that they are lying about their preferences. Or that, despite responding positively to left-wing ideas, they respond really positively to the, ah, moral character of the right-wing candidates.
- KingMachiavelli 6y agoYou could post this as a satire and it would work as is. Both sides see each other becoming more extreme & polarizing. It may not be apparent because it's very easy to ignore sensationalism from your own side as sensationalist individuals that don't reflect the party/group itself while sensationalism from the otherside is endemic of that sides philosophy. The 'right' ran something about the "tan suit" but I am also sure I have read half a dozen articles about poorly fitting suits and bad fake hair.
- mikepurvis 6y agoBut where is the left's QAnon? Where is the left's birtherism? Where is the left's Marjorie Taylor Greene? Election fraud claims that drag on for months, enabled by major party players who see an opportunity and refuse to clearly shut it down, culminating in an armed assault that some now claim as a false flag operation? Where is the left's Lindsey Graham, a pathetic husk of a man who waffles between saying "I'm out" and then continues to double down? Of course the tan suit "scandal" was trivial bullshit, but that's the whole point, that that's the source material that Fox News is working with to drum up this kind of outrage— the rest is pure fabrications, a self-feeding cycle where Fox provides a legitimizing platform for it, which then generates the interest and demand for "coverage". So it may well be that both sides see the other as extreme and polarizing, but it's important to not actually equate them, because that is super unfair when one of the sides is in a state of denial about basic reality.
- axaxs 6y agoThe left literally treated the last 4 years as an election fraud scandal that they refused to shut down. I'm generally in the center, but dislike when one party treats the other as solely being the problem. While I can't think of a specific qanon level of craziness on that side, they have their own, different craziness.
- mikepurvis 6y ago"The left literally treated the last 4 years as an election fraud scandal that they refused to shut down." Please cite sources for Democratic senators, congresspeople, and/or party officials advancing these claims.
- BobbyJo 6y agoIt appears to me completely differently, which I guess is something else that feeds into the divide. I get the "they're pitting us all against each other" thing from the people I know I on both sides, and honestly I think they both have a point. The fact that I can't tell which party is which in your story makes believe this more so.
- TheGrim-999 6y agoOnly one party has near complete control over mass media, social media, and big tech. If you want to get a first approximation of who's driving the "scandal", you should pretty obviously look at the ones who control nearly every piece of information you consume. The ones who spent every second of every minute of every day for the last five years straight finding some propaganda to use against Trump and the other half of the country. The ones who are actively censoring any opposition to their political ideology. The ones who have redefined "democracy" to mean them getting their way, and "the end of democracy" to mean any other political ideas getting heard. Maybe you should start there, with the ideology that controls every piece of information you're allowed to consume. Bring on the downvotes, censor me, anyone with different political ideas than you deserves to be censored and removed from society. Bring on democracy! You're not the ones causing scandal, that's for sure.
- munk-a 6y agoPlease don't openly solicit down votes - it's a tactic that has no place on hackernews and will end up getting you down votes completely ignoring the rest of your statement.
- Daho0n 6y agoHow funny, I was 100% sure you meant the republicans but then.. >finding some propaganda to use against Trump Oh boy.
- mattnewton 6y agoI don’t think there is a political party who owns all the media, there is media selling to the highest bidder. How can it all be out to get Trump with the incredible reach of Fox? https://www.foxnews.com/media/fox-news-finishes-2020-as-most-watched-cable-news-channel-in-history https://www.foxnews.com/media/fox-news-finishes-2020-as-most... The truth is nearly all media is just out to get eyeballs and sell ads. If you’re downvoted, it’ll be because of asking for downvotes and talking about censorship without evidence. It’s incredible to me that you cannot see right wing bias as well as the left bias.
- Moodles 6y agoBoth sides are idiots about fashion: The right: Obama's tan suit. (I actually don't know much about this, can't be bothered to investigate as I'm sure it was dumb) The left: Melania Trump's "I don't care, do u?" coat was OBVIOUSLY a secret message saying she doesn't care about migrant children (edit: this is sarcasm: she wore it to say she doesn't care about the media's articles about her, but the media went nuts and said she was saying she hates children, thus proving her point). I could also find articles about Donald Trump sticking his tie to his shirt or something dumb. God what a waste of brain space.
- eyelidlessness 6y agoAnd you can clearly see the difference: - Obama wore some clothes that people got upset about because it didn’t look great on him. - Melania wore a coat declaring she doesn’t care about how thousands of children are treated.
- Moodles 6y agoWait, what? Are you saying Melania actually wore the coat for that reason? Or are you saying the left's outrage is worse than the right? My OP about Melania was sarcastic: she actually wore it to say she doesn't care about the bullshit articles the media runs with. I can't tell if you agree with me or not over text.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- eyelidlessness 6y agoShe either wore that coat for that reason, or because that consideration was so unimportant to her that she welcomed the interpretation. Either way it doesn't compare to a bad suit.
- Moodles 6y agoOh jeez. The first lady didn't wear a coat to secretly tell people she hate children. Even if she did secretly hate children (despite all her charity work), why would she want to "secretly" tell the media this by wearing a coat, and then lying about her motivation? Turn off CNN and stop visiting /r/politics once in awhile my man.
- flamble 6y agoI think "hold the first accountable" is the wrong focus to have here, especially since so much of what the Republicans do violates norms rather than actual rules. I think it would be better to see the Democrats adopt their tactics, i.e. using every available mechanism to oppose everything they do as forcefully as possible, as opposed to meekly waiting for good faith from the other side which will never be forthcoming. The other thing with "holding accountable" is that it can backfire. Imagine a second Trump impeachment passing. It would be perfect for the Republicans. They would have a solution to the problem of his potential reelection bid (which they would like to avoid), while simultaneously he would be a martyr as well as a symbol of what "cancel culture" / "leftist authoritarians" took away from you, the patriots.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoYou think a race to the bottom of decency is a better idea? Really? How do you think that ends?
- flamble 6y agoA race to the bottom of decency is exactly what is currently happening. One side continuing to "take the high road" will do absolutely NOTHING to stop it. It is delusional to think that the Republicans will ever be shamed into cooperation. They don't care, their voters don't care, and high-minded speeches about the need for civility are the stuff of a comedy sketch if delivered while the listener is in the process of hacking you to pieces.
- BitwiseFool 6y ago"Decency" is all a show. Politics has always been about power.
- EVdotIO 6y agoPeople need to really internalize this. It's a game for power, and depending on the circumstances, will use any tool necessary to achieve those means. Our opinions here are worse than nothing, as it accomplishes nothing of value at the expense of projecting our (dare I say propagandized) bias onto millions of people while changing our behavior in very harmful ways to ourselves and others. We all need to just detach, because what is DC really going to do for you? I don't know, but I would put serious money on it being negligible to the impact of your immediate family, friends and community.
- Tycho 6y agoTotally agree. One side constantly levels wild accusations of racism, supremacism, insurrection, attempted murder, etc, while for the most part the other side just rolls its eyes and cracks jokes to “own the libs.” One side thinks the other is evil, the other lot just think they’re foolish. One side invents stuff like Critical Race Theory and works with their media allies to overhaul the education system and infuse everything with divisive/polarising concepts like “privilege” and “systemic racism”, while the other side just continues writing stuffy journal articles about old economic theory. Of course you can find fringe lunatics on either side saying anything, but I’m talking about that which is mainstreamed in Congress, in the NYT, on the big TV networks.
- TylerE 6y agoWhich party claims MTG, DT, and the MyPillow guy? They’re the crazy ones.
- Tycho 6y ago“MTG” is the exception that proves the rule.
- cozuya 6y agoMTG believes that Nancy Pelosi should be murdered. Half of the Republican caucus in the house, today, gave MTG a standing ovation. https://twitter.com/cam_joseph/status/1357116355988910080 https://twitter.com/cam_joseph/status/1357116355988910080 More Republican (citizens) have a favorable opinion of MTG than an unfavorable one. https://twitter.com/ArgoJournal/status/1356995117396201474 https://twitter.com/ArgoJournal/status/1356995117396201474 MTG is the Republican party. Have fun with that, and especially, have fun defending that.
- Tycho 6y agoThey applauded her after she apologized for promoting QAnon. It’s incredible how rather than indulge in a microsecond of self reflection, people like you just latch onto the most extreme caricature of your opponents that your media vendors can muster, ignoring the substantive reality.
- atombum 6y agoI think there's a tremendous irony in this response. Disregarding the "accuracy" of your claims or my own political viewpoints, it seems to me that you are demonstrating the same phenomenon that was discussed in the OP.
- eyelidlessness 6y agoI have quarrel with my enemies. Not because I’m divided from them but because they’re a deadly threat to me and people I love. You can find irony in that all you like but I am personally motivated by not being dragged to death behind a truck or strung up for immutable facts about my being.
- dabbledash 6y agoYeah, if there’s one impression I get from Twitter, it’s that people on the left try too hard to be nice.
- hallway_monitor 6y agoThis honestly made be burst out laughing
- esyir 6y agoMaybe to their in group. They're just as hostile to their outgroup/traitors, if not more so than what I've seen on the right. Now, their means of attack are certainly different though.
- bkirkby 6y agoDoes "manufacturing a scandal out of fashion choice" refer to the party that screams "cultural appropriation!!!" when the person with the wrong identity wears clothing deemed inappropriate? Or are you referring to the party that screams "weak colors" when the president chooses to wear clothing deemed to be wimpy?
- belorn 6y agoI assume by your description that you do not consider identity politics to be a contributor for polarization? It might just be a coincident, but from my perspective, the more aggressive rhetoric and polarization by the right coincided very close to period when the political discussion shifted focused towards gender and race being the top political issues by the left. I could be wrong, but what I remember of before that period, the political discussion was mostly on wars, taxes, social support, and abortion. Scandals had occurred before during elections, but no where near the scale and impact that we have seen in the last 10 years.
- eyelidlessness 6y ago> I assume by your description that you do not consider identity politics to be a contributor for polarization? I don't even agree that the category "identity politics" exists, or that it's a meaningful distinction. > It might just be a coincident, but from my perspective, the more aggressive rhetoric and polarization by the right coincided very close to period when the political discussion shifted focused towards gender and race being the top political issues by the left. I could be wrong, but what I remember of before that period, the political discussion was mostly on wars, taxes, social support, and abortion. Scandals had occurred before during elections, but no where near the scale and impact that we have seen in the last 10 years. Orrrrrrrr the right was exactly as ruthless and shrewd as I described and they shifted the narrative so any topic addressed on the left would be seen as divisive? I grew up in the state that held the capitol of the confederacy and "rebel yell" was a normal staple of our summertime parties. No one had any problem with statements that there was an historical racism problem in the country (even while saying racist shit) until it was defcon 1 must shut down discussion of racism on Fox and [friends intentionally lowercase].
- jokethrowaway 6y agoI think everyone agrees with you, it's just that they don't agree on which party is the crazy one. As an outsider, I assumed you were a Republican until the last line! Anyway, these are small matters, both parties move in the same direction, increasing spending and their power while screwing up on slightly different things. The American century is over.
- john_moscow 6y agoUnfortunately, you can't just approach a group of people, tell them "hey guys, would you mind being nice to each other now?" and expect them to comply. In reality, some social and economical factors tend to make people more united, while others drive them apart. As a person coming from a not-so-nice country, I spent tremendous amount of time thinking why the West managed to build a relatively stable society and Russia failed. My conclusion was that when people need each other economically, or have a common goal, they tend to overlook petty differences. Really, if your hairdresser is good at their job, you don't care that you like different soccer teams or music styles. On the other hand, if you commoditize people and make everyone follow the same routines for the sake of replaceability, people's energy gets redirected to rather pointless infighting over a growing amount of petty issues. Unfortunately, the corporations dominating the global economy have a very direct financial interest in keeping the rank-and-file class commoditized, so unless the society's attitude towards the corporate-run world changes, it is only going to get worse.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 6y ago> On Twitter, this has been exceedingly shorthanded into “tan suit”. One party is so invested in conflict that they invent it by manufacturing a scandal out of a fashion choice. Things like covfefe and trump's orangeness and tiny hands come to mind. Or Biden's stutter meaning he's senile, or at least it did until Bernie dropped out. After that, it was only something those scandal-seeking republicans did. Both sides' social media pounce on anything and everything (and then traditional media follows).
- pelliphant 6y agoThat is true, social media is full of garbage from every side. But the statement here is that on one side, it's goes a lot further than social media...