2 ms·
Particularly ever since the New Democrats took over the party. Their whole shtick was injecting a bunch of right wing policies into the Democratic Party, under
by monocasa 6y ago
Particularly ever since the New Democrats took over the party. Their whole shtick was injecting a bunch of right wing policies into the Democratic Party, under the idea that voters had shifted to the right and the only way to win was to follow them. Clinton made good on his promise to "end the welfare system as we know it". Obamacare was an unashamed rewrite of Newt Gingich and The Heritage Foundation's 1993/1994 HEART Act, all the way to the individual mandate.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Democrats https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Democrats
IMO a lot of the both party's issues right now stem from the fact that Democrats have moved so far to the right that only the far right positions differentiate a Republican from a mainline Democrat opponent.
- minikites 6y agoI think this is a great analysis. One factor I would add to both your comment and about the political divide in general is earmarks. Eliminating earmarks (political "pork" in bills) seems like a great way to eliminate wasteful spending. Except now we're in a situation where many of our representatives and senators can't point to a new bridge and say "I'm the reason we have that, now re-elect me" so they move to culture war issues as a way to fire up the base. This effect, combined with gerrymandering for House seats, means that the only thing many politicians have to fear is a primary fight. In an effort to avoid primary challengers, the Democrats and Republicans both ran to the right, leaving us where we are now: Biden, a Republican by 1960s standards, is painted as a "radical socialist" against all evidence, because it turns out the base, because there's literally nothing else for politicians to offer to their constituents. I've heard rumblings that earmarks might be coming back and I really hope they do.
- adventured 6y agoThe Republicans have moved very far to the left over the past 30-40 years, from where they used to be. Topics no longer up for serious discussion in the Republican Party that used to be very common: Doing away with Social Security / replacing SS. Getting rid of Medicare and Medicaid, replacing them with entirely private systems. The gold standard, going back to it. Cutting spending (actually attempting to do it, not just paying rare lip service to it). Getting more aggressive with the war on drugs. Increasing punishment for crime, putting people into prison for longer sentences. It was George W Bush's administration that implemented the successful Housing First program for homelessness assistance, which would have been considered an exceptionally bad welfare state program by the 1980s Republicans. Back then it would have been considered to encourage homelessness, they would have said it entrenches it. Today's Republicans support rampant welfare give-aways in the form of stimulus checks. That would have been considered a crazy Socialist program universally by Republicans just as recently as the early 1990s. Giving people checks during a recession was unthinkable by Republicans as recently as 20 years ago (eg the 2001-2002 recession). Trump - with wide Republican support - just implemented the best criminal justice reform in US history. That would have gotten near zero Republican support in the 1980s. The Republicans in Reagan's time were very militantly against gay marriage, and any form of sexuality being shown anywhere at any time. In the early 1990s Murphy Brown - a fictional TV character - deciding to raise a child on her own was a very controversial matter among Republicans, so much so that Dan Quayle made it a prominent issue. Republicans just 30 years ago were radically more conservative than they are today and that's putting it mildly. Those same Reagan era Republicans were almost universally - with very few exceptions - strongly in favor of the war on drugs. Every other word out of their mouths was about how to further criminalize drugs. Today the exact opposite is true, very few Republicans are in favor of the war on drugs. Trump just came and went and the Republicans barely lifted an eyebrow at trying to roll back the positive momentum of drug liberalization. If people on the left think Republicans today are far right, well, ha. They don't remember what Republicans were like back then apparently. Today's average Republican is a centrist Democrat circa the mid 1980s and early 1990s.
- minikites 6y ago>Cutting spending (actually attempting to do it, not just paying rare lip service to it). When did this actually happen?
- pmiller2 6y agoThey didn't. It's a cornerstone of their electoral strategy to blow up the national debt when in power, then crow about debt reduction when not: https://www.salon.com/2018/02/12/thom-hartmann-how-the-gop-used-a-two-santa-clauses-tactic-to-con-america-for-nearly-40-years_partner/ https://www.salon.com/2018/02/12/thom-hartmann-how-the-gop-u... Edit: deficit -> debt
- mullingitover 6y ago> Giving people checks during a recession was unthinkable by Republicans as recently as 20 years ago (eg the 2001-2002 recession). It was extremely thinkable in 2001 when George W. Bush did it[1]. [1] https://www.sfgate.com/politics/article/Bush-signs-1-3-trillion-tax-cut-bill-300-600-2913184.php https://www.sfgate.com/politics/article/Bush-signs-1-3-trill...
- flamble 6y agoI agree with your point about the Democrats' disastrous rightward slide but I don't think that the resulting problem is that Republicans now struggle to distinguish themselves. They're still the party of further tax cuts and deregulation, even if the Democrats have become the party of the status quo ante (or a "return to the Obama years"). I do agree, however, that economics deeply receded in importance for a decade or two. But during that time, parties were quite content to focus their message to voters on cultural issues: patriotism vs multiculturalism, religious freedom vs tolerance, etc, and distinguish themselves that way. The problem that the Republicans had was that after decades of the conservative media stoking their voters' rage to searing intensity, Trump came along and gave the base what it wanted, which was an end to the restraint and doublespeak, and posturing / policy which produced as many "liberal tears" as possible; politics as punishment. Now in the aftermath of his presidency they have to figure out how to appeal to the mass of their voters' who are still fiercely loyal to Trump while continuing to serve the interests of their donors, who would like someone more stable. The Democrats, for their part, are trying to figure out how to digest the left wing of their party and appeal to its voters while spending as little as possible (see the $1400 vs $2000 debacle).