8 ms·
I expect a lot of Redditors will be very disappointed when they realize just how much money hedge funds made, on average, out of this episode. The WSB moderato
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
I expect a lot of Redditors will be very disappointed when they realize just how much money hedge funds made, on average, out of this episode.
The WSB moderators really did everyone a disservice by letting obvious misinformation flood the subreddit. It’s hard to view the later stages of the GameStop phenomenon as anything other than a Reddit-fueled pump and dump scheme.
- allie1 6y agoOr a big Prisoner’s Dilemma experiment.
- mattnewton 6y agoI mean, that’s one take. Another take is a hedge fund who bailed out AMC with debt for shares was richly rewarded, and some of the public short selling hedge funds like Melvin still lost their shirts.
- NoOneNew 6y agoNot at all. The past few days they've shared not only the largest long holders of these stocks, but also the pension funds that were boosted as well. A few teacher pension funds got a good uptick and they were sharing that around. The cats at wsb might be self proclaimed retards, but they're not that stupid. They know lots of other folks are going to make money off of them. You know, if you actually visit the sub, you'd know that.
- 3327 6y agoHi Autist from WSB here. Diamond hands, and deepfuckingvalue we trust. DD is gold. not selling is Diamond. Stick to your guns. Don't let the Algos shake u out. See you techies in Valhalla.
- EugeneG 6y agoAny uptick a pension fund would have had was lost once GME reverted back. Pension funds are buy and hold, so they could care less about short term fluctuations in 0.05% of their portfolio.
- sudosysgen 6y agoGME didn't fully revert back yet, and I'm sure a lot of them realized their gains around the peak and sold. Pensions dont make short term investments, they already had GME shares since a long time ago. They do sell when extraordinary circumstances happen and buy other stocks to hold long term again.
- paulgb 6y agoJust because a fund’s normal MO is to buy and hold doesn’t mean they’re asleep at the wheel and won’t react if their value hypothesis is (more than) realized overnight. (Ontario Teacher’s Pension Fund sold almost 25M shares, for example https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-01-29/reddit-fever-ignites-mall-stock-and-fund-cashes-out-500-million https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-01-29/reddit-fe...)
- TheTrotters 6y agoNB: They sold 25M shares at ~$20/share. That's probably much more than what they paid for these shares but it's nowhere near where GME was over the past few days.
- cj 6y agoGME's 52 week low is $2.57. Without knowing when they entered their position. It was hovering around $4 for a long time last year. Even if they bought in at $5, selling at $20 is absolutely a win. Yes, they could have gambled and HODL'd, but there's no reason to gamble after seeing a 4x increase on a stock very few people expected would ever break $10.
- dashundchen 6y agoJust to clarify from the article - the Ontario Pension Fund was invested and cashed out stock in a commercial real estate company called Macerich that was getting associated with Gamestop on /r/wsb, not Gamestop itself.
- betterunix2 6y agoNot that they had any way of knowing what would happen. $20 could have been the peak for all anyone knew, and by the end of next week selling at $20 might look like a smart move.
- colejohnson66 6y agoExactly this. Wasn’t the whole point to spite short sellers even if it meant losing some?
- randomdata 6y ago> A few teacher pension funds got a good uptick and they were sharing that around. The Ontario Teachers Pension Plan, who was holding GME, is one of the largest hedge funds in existence, worth over 200 billion dollars. For comparison, Maverick Capital is worth only $15 billion. That is not a case of some little guy teachers making out well, it is the rich (if not the richest) hedge funds getting richer.
- freeone3000 6y agoRight, but, it actually is the Ontario Teacher's Pension Plan. It's not simply the name, it actually is the pension fund for Ontario's teachers.
- randomdata 6y agoA hedge fund is a pooled investment fund that trades in relatively liquid assets and is able to make extensive use of more complex trading, portfolio-construction and risk management techniques to improve performance, such as short selling, leverage, and derivatives. That is what the OTPP does. That the hedge fund exists to fund pensions is irrelevant. If you dig into the investors behind other funds, you are likely to find that they are also investing to help fund their own retirement.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> The Ontario Teachers Pension Plan, who was holding GME, is one of the largest hedge funds in existence, worth over 200 billion dollars OTPP is a pension fund. Hedge funds are a different beast.
- donarb 6y agoThey may be a pension fund, but they do use hedge funds to balance their portfolio. https://www.otpp.com/investments/performance/investment-strategy/asset-mix https://www.otpp.com/investments/performance/investment-stra... "Additionally, we complement our efforts by using external hedge fund managers, which gives us access to unique approaches that both add performance and diversify risk."
- gvhst 6y ago13Fs (reports that show what certain funds are holding) are filed quarterly. While you can see who owned GME as of 12/31/2020 the flows of the past few weeks is not public knowledge yet.
- ehsankia 6y agoThere are plenty of "Average people" that entered near the top, and since not everyone can sell simultaneously, that means a ton of people are losing the life savings they dumped into this out of excitement as it crashed back down. I think the point being made here is that the whole narrative of "average people beating wall street" is pretty naive and quite bullshit. All in on, maybe a few handful of people got 10x or even 100x their money, but most of the gains were most likely made by hedge funds and with the exception of one or two hedge funds who were squeezed, the majority of losses will probably be by average people.
- JakeTheAndroid 6y agoWell in fairness to WSB, it was really built around loss porn, not sticking it to the hedge funds. So even those people losing their life savings are contributing the to the WSB cause so long as they show off all the red.
- simias 6y agoLurking the wsb threads now it's clear that none of these people have exit strategies, or even strategies at all. Even if that fabled squeeze was to take place I'm sure many of them would still be left holding the bags because they wouldn't know when to sell. And again, at this point I'm really not sold on that squeeze theory at all, it seems very plausible that it ended last week and now we're just seeing a good old pump-and-dump taking place. In the end some people are going to be very lucky and some others are going to learn a very expensive lesson about the dangers of gambling.
- jb775 6y agoThis explains what's actually happening right now: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gMShFx5rThI&feature=youtu.be https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gMShFx5rThI&feature=youtu.be
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- SignalNotSecure 6y agoI think there is a name for people positioning themselves in the market on the advice of self-proclaimed "retards and autists"
- simias 6y ago>The cats at wsb might be self proclaimed retards, but they're not that stupid. They know lots of other folks are going to make money off of them. You know, if you actually visit the sub, you'd know that. The sub you seem to like so much died last week. Whatever is left of it has been diluted when literally millions of people flooded it. "Eternal September" hit them hard. Right now it's filled with Q-level conspiracy theories, they parrot each other's talking point without understanding any of it ("short ladder" being the most funny and telling example of this). I can assure you that the vast majority of these people are wildly clueless about what's happening right now, they just keep telling each other that they're going to be rich. Look at this nonsense for instance: https://www.reddit.com/r/wallstreetbets/comments/lboqwm/yet_another_short_ladder_attack_to_start_the_day/ https://www.reddit.com/r/wallstreetbets/comments/lboqwm/yet_... Admittedly there are a few voices of reason being upvoted in this thread, but they're still hidden underneath the baseless "hype" claims.
- cashewchoo 6y agoSo much this. /r/wallstreetbets is going to struggle to recover. It's absolutely Eternal September. I've been subbed to WSB for about 5 years, ever since someone at work (prop trading) mentioned it as basically being a bunch of 25-30 yo finance people hanging out and doing dumb shit in their personal accounts for fun. I'll admit, I did some dumb stuff myself, trying to time UVXY/TVIX plays. (Basically netted 0 of course). But it was fun to shitpost about it. This is astrology for finance bros. And it'd been going a bit down-hill already, but most people were still that same description: young blood, day job in finance, knows what they're doing at both a mechanical and risk level, etc. And the content reflected it. Then somehow, one of those internet things happened. WSB became a hit, people flooded in, the mod team was overwhelmed, media attention flooded in making everything worse, etc. I feel like this is what a lot of /r/the_donald people ended up now that they're looking for a new cause. So much of the rhetoric I saw once the WSB Old Guard had been overwhelmed mirrored the kind of stuff you saw out of the_donald back in 2016.
- decafninja 6y agoSeems the daily thread grows so big so fast that it becomes dog slow to even browse. But yeah, a lot of the comments are just one liner garbage memes: HODL! TO THE MOOOOOON! FISTS ON CHEST NO FEAR! TO VALHALLA! DIAMOND HANDS! As well as echo chamber "encouragement" to HODL! until $1000/$9000/the moon because Mark Cuban is on our side!
- notyourwork 6y ago> You know, if you actually visit the sub, you'd know that. I'm not sure this part is needed for you to convey your point.
- UncleMeat 6y ago> The cats at wsb might be self proclaimed retards, but they're not that stupid. The sub count increased 8-fold. Any prior culture it had has been overwhelmed.
- ookblah 6y agouh yeah there are also a ton of people losing a lot bc they got convinced to buy in at 300+. the OGs maybe, but the sub has basically quadrupled in size and brought a lot of new people who don't know anything + people looking to capitalize on that.
- marcinzm 6y ago>did everyone a disservice I suspect they didn't do a disservice to their own bank accounts. Random internet strangers care as much about you as do politicians and hedge fund owners.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI suspect they did. I had multiple friends buy GME and all of them are now in the red on that investment.
- JohnJamesRambo 6y agoThis is my experience as well. Many put their whole stimulus in it, and I can’t escape the idea that Wall Street knew all this would happen and they just found a way to get a large chunk of that other stimulus money that went to the people and not to corporations. An artificial movement that they may have created themselves that had an ethos of “bankrupting Wall Street”. Lol. A taxpayer funded pump and dump of epic proportions enabled by new tech sockpuppeting abilities and control. Before Cambridge Analytica I would say take your tinfoil hat off, but now I don’t know anymore. I consider nothing real online and go from there.
- betterunix2 6y ago"Wall Street knew all this would happen" As if "Wall St." is one giant conspiracy. What happened to criticizing "Wall St." for treating the economy like a casino and driving the stock market into a giant bubble? Where are all those complaints about how "Wall St." is recklessly risking our retirement accounts? The contradictory conspiracy theories are astonishing.
- umvi 6y ago> The WSB moderators really did everyone a disservice by letting obvious misinformation flood the subreddit. Well, on the flip side a lot of redditors learned from the school of hard knocks, which is the best teacher in a lot of ways. Moderators suppressing posts won't teach a lesson you can only learn by losing money.
- Aunche 6y agoHalf of them may learn a lesson, but the other half will just blame hedge funds against for their own mistake.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoIt’s already turning into a conspiracy theory. The popular narrative is that GME would have continued going up, but RobinHood colluded with hedge funds to stop it. It doesn’t make any sense and ignores the incentives that RobinHood had to continue allowing people to buy. However, when to they’ve become completely invested (some times literally) in the narrative that GME was going to make them all rich while the hedge funds went bankrupt, it’s difficult to admit that they were wrong.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoWSB moderators were (and still are) actively suppressing posts that don’t toe the line. I had a seasoned Reddit account that had been in WSB for a long time. As soon as I started commenting about how the short squeeze wasn’t a sure thing, my posts stopped showing up. They’ve been dismissing any comments that aren’t about GME going to the moon as hedge fund shills or bots. It’s extremely difficult to find any posts or comments critical of GameStop in the sub right now. If you sort by new, the critical comments are quickly removed. Moderators aren’t just letting Redditors figure it out. They’re shaping the conversation into the illusion of a consensus.
- mywittyname 6y agoI had to unsub (having been a member for years) because my homepage was full of, "WE ARE HOLDING:diamond: :hands:!!!!I :diamond: LOVE :hands: THIS :diamond: STOCK :rocket::rocket::rocket::rocket::rocket::rocket:" posts with 50k upvotes and a list of gold a mile long. Edit: looks like emojis are stripped
- stefanmichael 6y agoHFTs were printing money throughout this entire ordeal due to volatility and inefficient trades
- blantonl 6y agoVolatility earns hedge funds huge returns. There are a very select few retail investors that really made a lot of money from this hype. There were a TON of professional traders that probably thought this was like shooting fish in a barrel.
- technofiend 6y agoGame theory inevitably takes over; I better sell before the next guy does and lowers the price even further. The only people with diamond anything are the ones who bailed and took their profits early.
- betterunix2 6y agoThe people with "diamond hands" are the ones who opened short positions when the stock was trading in the $300+ range. They are probably to busy looking up which sports cars to buy with all the money they made to bother looking at WSB right now.
- spelunker 6y agoI've been visiting WSB for couple of years now, and generally the mods have been really hands off, so them letting misinformation flood the subreddit is par for the course. Good or bad, that's how it is. Honestly lots of investing communities are like this - do your own due diligence, etc. It is surprising how _much_ misinformation is being spread in WSB as of late, and feels like a weird cult more than ever, but WSB was never about heavy moderation.
- Thaxll 6y agoThe goal was to screw the original shorters.
- scarmig 6y agoI wouldn't be surprised if hedge funds overall made a profit and retail investors overall made a loss in the GME fiasco. More likely than not, even. My pet conspiracy theory is that WSB is just a cat's paw for another hedge fund that saw an opportunity to make money and wanted to try out a new approach.
- betterunix2 6y agoIt is a near certainty that hedge funds fleeced retail investors who bought GME above $100/share. The real problem with WSB is not the people who post there, it is the large crowd of unsophisticated lurkers who overestimate their own knowledge and abilities. The media did not help by hyping this story and making it sound like "Wall St." was terrified by a mob of Redditors. Two hedge funds lost some money, but as many have pointed out, those funds will probably still turn a profit on the year. Meanwhile, a bunch of hedge funds, algos, and prop traders are raking in cash from the spike in volatility, and a bunch of HFTs took advantage of the spike in volume. I expect a small bump in sports car and yacht sales in the NYC region as a bunch of "Wall St. bros" spend the giant bonuses they are taking home from this whole episode. As to the scam aspect, I give it a 50/50 chance that someone saw an opportunity to pump-and-dump some symbols with very high short interest. I doubt it was a hedge fund, it was probably an individual, probably someone living outside the reach of US law enforcement. The alternative is that a bunch of idiots actually came up with the idea that they could take on "Wall St." and managed to trigger a short squeeze, many of whom have yet to realize that the party's over.
- 015a 6y agoIts funny how people don't see the $100,000+ portfolio losses (and much less often, gains) all over that subreddit and don't immediately realize that a ton of the people who visit it are Wall Street finance people. That's seriously the meme among the people only secondarily connected with WSB; its not "autists" or "the vox populi", its wall street bros (WSB?) who have to spend all day being super serious at their job, and WSB is their way of letting off steam. And if you think that these firms weren't already feeding every single post and comment on reddit into their HFT algorithms, you better at least believe that after this whole thing, they're gonna be doing that, and adding some extra weight to `if subreddit === "wallstreetbets"`. From that point of view, WSB is rather icky; its people who know what they're doing (most of the time) subtly and anonymously impersonating an idiot to influence the actual idiots.
- dclusin 6y agoWhereas Hacker News is just a bunch of people who don't know what they're doing pretending to be experts to influence the actual idiots. You can find charlatans pretty much anywhere money or people with money congregate.
- dcolkitt 6y agoThe difference is the HN hype train might cause you some headaches from picking an immature tech stack. Whereas the WSB echo chamber has literally ruined thousands of people's lives and retirements.
- sokoloff 6y agoIf someone is going to ruin their life or retirement based proximately to posts in a Reddit forum, it’s very hard for me to assign root cause to the Reddit forum. At most that’s the first or second “Why?” but there is surely a deeper issue.
- quxpar 6y agoMany people were prudent blue-chip investors whose retirement was ruined by the housing crisis. There doesn't seem to be any 'smart money', just 'big money'.
- duxup 6y agoThe populist atmosphere surrounding it all was very attractive, to me included. But I worry that like a lot of heated populist rhetoric it is misguided, or even entirely dishonest. We just went through a presidency with someone who loved populist rhetoric, but whose actions were anything but. It happens a lot sadly.
- dgs_sgd 6y agoThe subreddit surged from 1 to 8 mil redditors in less than two weeks. I think the mods couldn't have stopped the disinformation even if they tried, just due to sheer increase in volume of posts.
- razster 6y agohttps://reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/lbdfbp/oc_failstodeliver_data_on_gamestop_gme/ https://reddit.com/r/dataisbeautiful/comments/lbdfbp/oc_fail... Might be worth a read. Comments are interesting as well.
- cccc4all 6y agoMost large holdings are public record. Anyone can see which institutions held what positions. Everyone knew who stood to gain and who stood to lose in the short squeeze. WSB crows was going after the short squeeze, anyone that got gains just rode the wave and knew when to step off or not.
- strathmeyer 6y agoPump and dump? Were they the ones who removed the ability to sell stocks? I guess it's important to spread that misinformation around.
- FabHK 6y agoNobody removed the ability to sell stocks. Some brokers removed the ability to buy stocks (because they were near broke and couldn't afford it), which probably saved some potential buyers some money and brought this train wreck to a halt a bit earlier.
- FabHK 6y agoOn the bright side, though, at least it was a zero sum game (well, it will have been by the time the stock is back to where it started). Money was transferred from the early shorts and late longs to the early longs and late shorts; with the market makers taking a bit of a cut. Many other scams (or, for example, theft and robbery) destroy value (as, for example, a stolen wallet is a much bigger loss to the owner than it is a gain for the thief). Or, say, the 2008 GFC made a few people extremely rich (unscrupulous mortgage peddlers, investment bankers creating "complex, highly leveraged, exotic trades [...] without necessarily understanding all of the implications of those monstrosities", etc.), while wreaking havoc orders of magnitude greater on the entire world.
- dheera 6y ago> pump and dump scheme I don't see why everyone is against pump and dump schemes yet the system is literally designed for them to happen. It's an inevitable fact that they will happen when you set up a free market and a bunch of (stupid) humans from the general public, as also clearly demonstrated in the crypto scene. If people don't want them to occur, the short-term incentives, market, and exchanges themselves need to be re-structured in a way such that takes into account what a group of humans with free communication would do.
- betterunix2 6y agoFirst of all, there is no such thing as a free market, certainly not in the capital markets. There are mountains of regulations covering stock, options, futures, and debt trades. Trading is routinely halted on various securities in extreme circumstances. Insider trading is restricted, and the restrictions become more significant for higher level management. Companies are required to report certain information to the public. Markets exist to solve problems of valuation and capital allocation. Pump-and-dump schemes distort valuations in very extreme ways and work against the purpose of equity markets. That is a basic reason why they should be banned. Another reason is that scams introduce unnecessary risk to someone making an investment decision; ideally investors should only focus on risks related to a company's business, not the risk that the information they were given about that company is false. The extra risk will drive away investors and the result will be less capital available to otherwise promising ventures, which again works against the goals of capital markets. It is not really possible to restructure markets in a way that would avoid pump-and-dump schemes, because the problem with a pump-and-dump scheme is not actually related to the rules governing the market. The problem is that the pump-and-dump scheme involves deliberately spreading false information; yet it is equally possible that investors hear true information and rush to buy, and the market should allow for that situation.
- dheera 6y agoI guess my main question is, why does the stock price go up if mountains of people suddenly buy a stock? It's because we base pricing based on a simple free market order book algorithm. If the markets enforced a pricing algorithm that included certain time-based functions instead of basing it purely out of the order book, and mandate that all transactions happen at the algorithm's determined price (instead of the free market price), a lot of problems including pump-and-dump schemes and insider trading could be theoretically eliminated. We could completely legalize insider trading, for example, if we technologically mandated that large orders took weeks to execute while single shares traded in milliseconds. (I'm an engineer, not a financial expert; I view this problem as very similar to e.g. API limits and firewalls that implement rules to prevent abuse.)
- lasftew 6y agoMoney was made by fools at the expense of greater fools. Short-term trading is a zero-sum game, always has been, always will be. Except for the HFT firms and market makers, who basically own the Robinhood flow and who thrive in foolish volatility. Guess who's paying so that r/WSB bros pay zero commisions? It's not the Red Cross.