7 ms·
I've always wondered about capacitors for bulk storage in cars. What happens in an accident? What happens when that capacity is bent/dented/broken? A Li batt
by sandworm101 6y ago
I've always wondered about capacitors for bulk storage in cars. What happens in an accident? What happens when that capacity is bent/dented/broken? A Li battery will catch fire, the speed of that fire limited by the speed of the various chemical reactions. But a capacitor is an electrical device. The charge would move so much more quickly. Would this be more explosion than fire?
- derekp7 6y agoI've always wondered the same about a vehicle carrying around 15 - 20 gallons of highly flammable and explosive liquid fuel. What happens in an accident, where a spark in the wrong place with the correct mixture of fuel and oxygen can cause an explosion or hot burning fire? There's been a few times I've driven by a car fire, and even from the opposite side of a divided 4-lane highway, the heat I felt was impressive.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoI'm really sick about this whattaboutism that every internet discussion about electric cars invariably devolves into at least in part. Fire requires fuel, oxygen and ignition (heat). Liquid fuels require external ignition. Batteries do not. But you also have to pump liquid fuels around and generally handle them more to make them do work. Batteries are more dangerous on a fundamental/conceptual level because they have everything they need to release their energy all at once. So we build them with hard casings for the same reason we build large safety factors into pressurized gas containers so in practice it doesn't really matter. Batteries and liquid fuels aren't really better or worse than each other from a "much safety or "won't somebody think of the children" point of view. They just require slightly different engineering considerations for an equivalent level of safety. This is directed just as much (ore maybe even more) at the parent comment as it is at you.
- derekp7 6y agoI agree with you on this, hence phrasing my comment as a reverse "what-aboutism". Handling of liquid fuels has improved quite a bit to where it typically isn't a problem. Whereas at one time you had cars (I'm thinking of a 60's Mustang) where if it got rear-ended gas from a ruptured tank could slosh into the passenger compartment. This isn't much of an issue with modern car designs. And cars have come along way in the ability to protect the occupants. That same protection measures can be applied to the battery compartment if necessary (steal roll cage, elastic restraint system, air bags). Yes, these things need to be thought about, and yes we do have agencies such as the NTSB and insurance standards that will solve the problem.
- EricE 6y agoCapacitors are not batteries nor liquid storage. Unlike chemical based energy storage, capacitors can dump all their energy at once. Literally! Look up the definition of an explosion. I’m super excited about super capacitors - I think they are going to be required in order to make electric cars truly feasible - but the concerns around the safety of them should be dismissed just because they might hold up progress!
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoThere's some pretty basic electrical trickery that can be applied to limit current in the discharge direction without limiting it in the charge direction. I'm dismissing these concerns not because they might hold up progress but because they're well withing what Donald Rumsfeld would call a "known known" of engineering difficulties.
- Tostino 6y agoGenerally super capacitors don't have quite the same oomph as a regular electrolytic capacitor in charge/discharge. They lie somewhere between electrolytic and modern Lithium chemistries. Still can be super dangerous...
- sandworm101 6y agoThe speed of a chemical fire, be it from a fuel spill or chemical battery, is limited by chemistry. Even a fully involved burning fuel tank is limited by the availability of oxygen, the math involves wind speeds and circulation of gas over a flame. Short-circuit a normal battery and the math is all about heat and chemical bonds. Short-circuit a capacitor and the math become quantum, involving numbers like the speed of light.
- Koshkin 6y agoDepends on the fuel. The speed of the 'chemical fire' (which is what it is) inside a shell casing, for example, is very high.
- bluGill 6y agoGasoline is only flammable in a narrow range of air/fuel ratios. Too much air and there isn't enough fuel to sustain combustion, too much fuel and there isn't enough air. There are plenty of people who have demonstrated dropping a match into a gas can and the match goes out with only a slight poof of a flame. Full gas can can sometimes survive the building they are in burning down (if the can is sealed - doesn't melt - there is never enough air inside to light the fuel) That isn't to say gasoline isn't dangerous. However it isn't quite as dangerous as you seem to think.
- giantg2 6y agoMy concern if this is used in cars is, what grid can support this? You'd have people drawing so much power that it charges almost instantly but existing residential lines won't handle it at scale. Maybe specialized stations can handle it, but home charging doesn't seem real. Unless you limit the rate, but then what's the benefit?
- alvarlagerlof 6y agoAt home, does it really matter all that much how fast it is? I would suspect that overnight is fast enough for most. Charging stations could have buffers.
- giantg2 6y agoMy point is why would people trade range for faster, more frequent charging. Most people don't need extra range. The time you need extra range or fast charging is on road trips. Even then, you generally want to stop for food, restrooms, etc and super charger stations can give you a pretty good charge in a fair amount of time.
- bluGill 6y agoMost people do not stop as often as their doctors would tell them to. For medical reasons you should stop often. (experts don't seem to agree on exactly what the right amount is, but for discussion lets call it 5 minutes out of every hour). Note that the stop is to move around, if you sit on a toilet for that time it doesn't count. Many people will stop only for fuel every 3 hours, and try to get everything they need to do (restroom, buy snacks, eat...) in the amount of time it takes the pump to fill the tank. This isn't a good idea, but it is what people in the real world do.
- giantg2 6y agoYeah. I remember a 12 hour trip that I made with a single stop for fuel in the middle. Definitely rough.
- 6y ago