2 ms·
I have one simple policy in 2021. I ignore people who use the term "gaslighting". It's a proxy sign that the person doesn't like the idea, but doesn't have a
by dekhn 6y ago
I have one simple policy in 2021. I ignore people who use the term "gaslighting". It's a proxy sign that the person doesn't like the idea, but doesn't have a good complaint and instead just uses modern progressive buzzwords.
- antiterra 6y ago‘Gaslighting’ has been around as a colloquial term since the 60s and isn’t inherently progressive. Further, refusing to hear an argument because it has a term you don’t like is much more about you than it is the other people.
- eur773yyr 6y agoThey're obviously discussing the term in its colloquial context. Further, your rebuttal says more about you than it does the other poster since you're really just arguing that people who don't entertain dogwhistles are failing in some arbitrary regard.
- dekhn 6y agoSure, it's about me. I'm a qualified and capable person when it comes to analysis and discourse. What i'm saying is that after seeing the word used frequently, recently, I've found that nearly everybody is either misusing, or overusing it, for internet points. Hence my point about it being a proxy for people who are not arguing in good faith.
- hyperdimension 6y ago> I'm a qualified and capable person when it comes to analysis and discourse. Are you, uh, entirely certain about that?
- dekhn 6y agoif you're making a gaslighting joke: ha-ha. If you are asking a serious epistemological question, then strictly speaking, no. That said, I definitely believe I'm qualified and capable when it comes to discourse, and in general, the feedback I get on my writing is consistent with that.
- mikestew 6y agoThe film 'Gaslight' had Ingrid Bergman starring, so not exactly an obscure film. The plot was about what you'd expect. It came out in 1944. But, hey, if you want to exclude arguments because of one "modern" trigger word, I doubt anyone will stand in your way.
- dekhn 6y agoI know the origin of the word and its history. Its usage has increased tremendously in the past few years. I think we've reached the point where people should push back on invalid usage; I see somebody just posted the following to Hacker News: https://thingofthings.wordpress.com/2020/11/16/hermeneutical-injustice-not-gaslighting/ https://thingofthings.wordpress.com/2020/11/16/hermeneutical... It is not gaslighting when someone contradicts you, or intentionally causes you to doubt your beliefs, or leaves you uncertain of what you believe, or even makes you think that they think you are crazy. Gaslighting is about someone lying to you in a way that causes you to lose trust in your own capabilities as a rational person: your ability to reason, your competence to figure out the truth, your capacity to remember things in a broadly accurate fashion even if you are sometimes fuzzy on details, your knowledge of your own feelings and thoughts and desires. And if your mind is unreliable… well, you’ll have to rely on someone else.
- jshevek 6y agoThe prior history of the word is irrelevant to the point that was made about its recent usage.