17 ms·
> This journey began some 27 years ago. Amazon was only an idea, and it had no name. It had a name, and that name was "Cadabra". It didn't become Amazon until
by PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago
> This journey began some 27 years ago. Amazon was only an idea, and it had no name.
It had a name, and that name was "Cadabra".
It didn't become Amazon until Jeff watched a documentary about the Amazon River. His lawyer had already turned up his nose at "Cadabra", and Jeff was looking for something else.
It's also worth noting that the idea didn't grow over time - Jeff always intended to build something like "Sears for the 21st century". The bookstore was just the way in, not the long term plan.
ps. amazon employee #2
- cosenal 6y agoThis reminds me of an essay by @pg about startup names: http://www.paulgraham.com/name.html http://www.paulgraham.com/name.html
- reilly3000 6y agoHi Paul, I :heart: JACK and spend lots with Amazon, cheers. I wonder if you have an opinion on this bit of gossip: Is there any relationship between Jeff's departure and this FTC Tips scandal? https://komonews.com/news/local/amazon-took-away-62-million-in-tips-from-drivers-ftc-says https://komonews.com/news/local/amazon-took-away-62-million-... The only evidence I see is relating to their very similar timing of publication.
- jacobwal 6y agoHadn't heard the documentary story, thanks for sharing! Were there any choices in the first few years that you think made a particularly big difference in setting Amazon up for what it is today? Anything you're particularly proud of that you did there?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- warent 6y agoOut of curiosity has it ever seemed to you that Amazon's success changed Jeff? Or has he always been largely the same person you knew from the start?
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoI haven't communicated with Jeff for more than 20 years. His public persona seems largely consonant with the person I knew 27 years ago.
- xtracto 6y agoThat's kind of sad. I feel somewhat related to this: I was 1st developer of a startup (outside of the US) and at that time I was super close to the CEO. After leaving we kind of grew appart which is a bit sad because I consider him a really good person, and I still own stock in the startup. Of course, absolutely nothing compared to Amazon (hopefully at some point it will... we always said that we wanted to be the Amazon of Financial services)
- thecupisblue 6y agoI'd imagine you'd pour beer with him and tell old war stories. Why not say hi? I bet he'll have more time for it now :)
- rabidonrails 6y agoI think it's probably lost on a number of people who you are (even though you call it out).
- GreenWatermelon 6y agoThis is my first time hearing about him. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Davis_(programmer) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Davis_(programmer)
- SEJeff 6y agoThanks for the candid comment :) Also, hello mr famous internet person: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Davis_(programmer) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Davis_(programmer)
- pjfin123 6y agoOh wow JACK and Ardour are awesome, didn't know about the Amazon connection
- exikyut 6y agoIt says "[Paul] went on to fund the development of" those two projects. That's interesting; I wonder how that worked? Ah, for the day someone figures out the Amazon of funding open source software...
- toyg 6y agoSometimes I think I'm wasting time on HN, then a comment like that comes around and it makes it all worth it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- obenn 6y agoWas it ever named “relentless” at some point? I’ve heard that was the original name, relentless.com still redirects to Amazon.com.
- trts 6y agoThey must have turned off the redirect sometime in the past few years. diapers.com also used to land on amazon.com :)
- ngold 6y agoGotta hedge your bets, but I'm glad that I don't shop at diapers.com.
- B1FF_PSUVM 6y agoIncidentally, books.com was taken early on (say 1990) by an outfit in Ohio. Pre-web, they had a telnet interface.
- gxqoz 6y agoThere are a couple of institutions in the Seattle area that have pretty good generic domain names, presumably because of the tech connections in the area. For instance, the Washington State Fair has the domain thefair.com.
- mmmrtl 6y agoLocal zoo is zoo.org!
- gxqoz 6y agoOh yeah, forgot about that one.
- selimthegrim 6y agoImagine the Seafair pirates or Almost Live! shaking everyone down for domain names.
- biztos 6y agoDoes AWS have a Sears-type analogue or was that a new concept? Just curious, no agenda, I grew up on the Sears Catalogue.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoNo, AWS was definitely not part of Jeff's early vision. And as many people have said, major credit to Jassy for making it what it is today.
- biztos 6y agoThanks, appreciate the reply from an authoritative voice.
- TuringNYC 6y agoHow early do you mean by early? I remember Amazon at campus recruiting (Cornell, 2000) describing something akin to AWS and LoudCloud came up. I asked what business a bookstore had to do with outsourced computing and recall a fair bit of vision even at the time. In light of what we now know, I’m the only one who didn’t have sufficient vision...for not pursuing that job opportunity more seriously.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoI was at amazon from 1994-1996. That's what I mean by "early".
- nly 6y agoApologies if this question is a bit in the nose, but why did you leave?
- raverbashing 6y agoWell the way they're adding services I suppose they could make a "paper" version of it soon. Would be a fun conceptual project
- naqeeb 6y agoThank you for the candidness! I've found it interesting how the story of a startup's early days morph into legends / fables.
- JohnJamesRambo 6y agoSomething that always stuck with me is I remember reading in a book about the internet long ago about how innovative the name Amazon.com was and how it was the future of internet business. It said it needs to be more memorable. You aren’t going to buy your books on Books.com you are going to use Amazon. Turned out to be very right. And this was in the pets.com era. Everyone thought you needed the most generic name possible and that if you got something like books.com or travel.com you had cornered the market on it.
- oblio 6y agoIt depends. facebook.com or messenger.com aren't super memorable. Microsoft also made it work by adding something else next to the name. Microsoft Excel. Microsoft Outlook. Microsoft Access.
- oconnor663 6y agoFwiw, a "face book" is a thing you would get at Harvard (and Yale and presumably lots of other schools too but I'm not sure), kind of like a yearbook but at the start of freshman year instead of the end. So for the earliest thefacebook.com users, the name was actually familiar. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Face_book https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Face_book
- Mauricebranagh 6y agoIts a thing in all US high schools - so for US searchers it would be very obvious Back in the 70's in the UK one of our American teachers mentioned then in our general studies class when we where doing America one term - she refused to show us her entry :-)
- infermore 6y agoIt's definitely not a thing in all US high schools. I'm pretty sure yearbooks are the thing most US high schools have.
- simonebrunozzi 6y ago> His lawyer had already turned up his nose at "Cadabra" True. I've heard (employee #20k-something, joined in early 2008) that the issue with Cadabra was its resemblance to the sound of the word "cadaver".
- gxqoz 6y agoIt's also harder to spell. Some people are going to put an extra d or b in there. Maybe get a vowel wrong.
- jasoncrawford 6y agoI heard the same story (I joined in 2004). The version I heard was that Jeff was driving cross-country NY -> Seattle and was on the phone with his lawyer about incorporation papers, and the lawyer misheard “Cadabra” as “Cadaver”. That's when Jeff knew he needed a better name.
- lostlogin 6y agoThis instantly reminded me of the story about Microsoft posting a dev a dead fish. https://olhardigital.com.br/en/2020/05/23/news/the-strange-story-of-when-microsoft-sent-a-dead-fish-to-ios-creator/amp/%3fgfetch=2020/05/23/news/the-strange-story-of-when-microsoft-sent-a-dead-fish-to-ios-creator/ https://olhardigital.com.br/en/2020/05/23/news/the-strange-s...
- astrange 6y agoThis is not the most interesting story about Scott Forstall and Microsoft. Did you know he invented WordArt? https://twitter.com/natbro/status/1339600779531833344 https://twitter.com/natbro/status/1339600779531833344
- efreak 6y agoThat's an interesting story, but that article and others on the site have weird issues that can't be put down as non-native English. Extra words that make no sense (Steve Jobs founded us), and phrases added into the ends of sentences along with spacing/punctuation mistakes (But please, pretend you’re interested in everyone’s questions, ”Jobs said at the time, as carry* the website Windows Central.*) Odd issues to see on a news website. Also, all postings are double-dated, once within the text and once after.
- danellis 6y ago> It's also worth noting that the idea didn't grow over time I doubt that he started out imagining he would build the world's biggest cloud hosting platform or open the first chain of checkoutless grocery stores.
- eganist 6y agoThe former, probably not. But the latter fits within the context of "21st century Sears"
- breakfastduck 6y agoThe internet - the only place you can find a snarky comment doubting the validity of a statement made by the actual 2nd ever employee of Amazon, who knows infinitely more about what Jeff Bezos wanted to achieve than the doubting commenter.
- danellis 6y agoYes, it's wonderful that there's somewhere we're allowed to do that.
- chrshawkes 6y agoWe're you writing Perl primarily back in those days?
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoPerl got used for some backend tasks. Nothing related to the webserver.
- chrshawkes 6y agoAwesome. Thank you for responding!
- mypalmike 6y agoPerl will never die at Amazon. So much build and deploy tooling is still glued together by Perl.
- zoover2020 6y agoConfig files! And Gurupa, right?
- wildfire 6y agoGurupa is in KTLO mode. Config is due to Brazil (and later Peru) requiring it; especially for rebuilds. At this point Config being necessary is orthogonal to Perl.
- lalwanivikas 6y ago> He is also an ultra-marathon and touring cyclist. Some excellent accomplishments have included the 298 mile Cannonball in 14:01, and a five-week tandem camping tour from Amsterdam to Athens. Got this from your Wiki entry. Hats off to you dear sir!
- suyash 6y agoSo Cadabra came from Abra-Ca-Dabra is it?
- stefap2 6y agoIs it true he used doors as tables to save money ? :)
- krisfreedain 6y agoYes. :) Here is an interesting link / video about it: https://www.aboutamazon.com/news/workplace/how-a-door-became-a-desk-and-a-symbol-of-amazon https://www.aboutamazon.com/news/workplace/how-a-door-became...
- broknbottle 6y agoThat’s still true for the most part.
- frombody 6y agoThis is something that literally everyone that owns a garage and saw horses does. In fact having saw horses and a flat surface in your garage is superior to having a regular table, because all the pieces are easily movable. Nobody is going to ask you, why are there saw horses and a door in your garage, but they will ask you why you have a table in your garage.
- xibalba 6y ago> It had a name, and that name was "Cadabra". Lol, so your take is that you have a better handle on the history of Amazon than its founder? He is likely referring to a point in time when Amazon was just an idea.
- read_if_gay_ 6y agoThe second employee is probably actually more trustworthy than PR signed by the founder.
- meepmorp 6y ago>> ps. amazon employee #2 You know, there's actually a pretty good chance that he's not pulling this out of his ass.
- xibalba 6y agoAnd Bezos, who wrote the email, was employee 0. So, by that logic, Bezos claim > employee #2's claim.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- herpderperator 6y agohttps://www.businessinsider.com/amazon-jeff-bezos-chose-company-name-2018-5 https://www.businessinsider.com/amazon-jeff-bezos-chose-comp...
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y agoThis story is incorrect. I don't know how Brad Stone could have got this wrong, because I told him the actual origin of the name. It did not come from looking up words in a dictionary. It came from a documentary that Jeff watched about the Amazon river. The concept that particular stuck with him was that the Amazon is not just the biggest river in the world, but is 10x larger than the next largest river. In addition to the alphabetic sorting benefits of the name (important back then), Jeff loved the size metaphor.
- newbie578 6y agoOh wow, so awesome to see someone like this. You are basically part of history. I just want to ask two things if it is alright. 1) Any cool anecdotes from Amazon that you can tell? 2) Any advice you have for young entrepreneurs looking to uproar an industry?
- teh_klev 6y ago>> This journey began some 27 years ago. Amazon was only an idea, and it had no name. > It had a name, and that name was "Cadabra". This seems like nitpicking. Lots of projects start out with long forgotten names. I'm involved in one that's pretty successful, but you can see from the code base the name evolved over time (~15 years). Codenames and attempts at product placing in the market evolve, stuff becomes myth or forgotten. I can absolve Bezos (this once) of not remembering exactly what that embryonic Amazon was to begin with, or was called, because it was ~25 years ago, probably during a period of great turmoil. And the tone of this comment feels like someone who checked out of the company too early and feels a bit sour at doing so. I say this as a single digit employee who could have made a small fortune a couple of times but either bottled it, or the gig wasn't right for me. I missed out on some nice payouts, but I'm not that sour about it. It was my choice.
- hartator 6y ago> This seems like nitpicking. I don’t know if it’s nitpicking. If it’s true that the Amazon #2 employee took time to post this here, Jeff Bezos should have remembered and be precise in his speech.
- teh_klev 6y ago> Jeff Bezos should have remembered Who cares? It's getting into deep time (internet-wise), memories fade, do we care, I don't despite opening my first Amazon account ~1998. It was called "something", big deal. Not everyone has photographic memories of these things, perhaps Paul does, but wasn't asked to recall those memories. Again, who cares? And they might have worked through twenty other names after Paul left. I'm 54 I would have trouble remembering exact details of important things from 25 years ago, and Jeff is older than me, so give the guy a break, it's likely off of his event horizon until he writes "the book".
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago1) The name "Amazon.com" was chosen in 1994 (or possibly January 1995). 2) Subsequently, the company never considered any other name 3) I'm older than you and Jeff 4) I don't have a photographic memory 5) I've been asked twice in court, on Amazon's behalf, to remember things that happened/took place/were done back then. [ EDIT: added "subsequently" for clarity ]
- acvny 6y agoProbably `Cadabra` came from `Abracadabra`: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abracadabra https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abracadabra
- redthrowaway 6y ago>ps. amazon employee #2 Please tell me you held onto your stock
- danans 6y agoWhy would it matter if they didn't? All they would have if they held it is more money on top of the gobs they already had. When you have that kind of money, if you want to grow it the surer strategy is to invest in lots of stuff, not keep it all sunk in your previous employer. It's probably more fun too. And beyond a certain point that stock and the accompanying valuation in AMZ probably isn't so gratifying in itself, and unless one has a juvenile obsession with out net-worthing others, you need to find something more personally meaningful to do with it, whether that is start a new industry (Elon Musk) or address pressing global health issues (Bill Gates). It sounds like the GP has spent some of his funding free software.
- codezero 6y agoPut into perspective that the dot boom happened around 1999-2001 and the dot bomb set in hard by 2003. Between 1996 and through that roller coaster people went through a lot, and since then there have now been two financial crises in the US, one ongoing. It probably doesn't feel good to be asked this question. I say this as an early employee of three startups.
- 2rsf 6y ago90% of startups fail, in Las Vegas you have a 14% chance to win now make your choice. I sold my stocks (not Amazon but a very early employee at a small company that still exist and somewhat profitable) as soon as I could and ended up selling at an all time high so YMMV
- loosetypes 6y ago> the idea didn't grow over time I always find retrospective and hypothetical discussions of idea genesis and maturation fascinating. Amazon retail aside, I wonder if you (or anyone else) would be willing to give perspective on AWS: Was it similarly fully formed on conception? I’ve heard the (potentially stylized) stories about holiday traffic bursts, selling off-season compute to startups, etc. But assuming AWS the idea did need to grow with increased perspective, the times, and experience - do you think AWS could have become what it is today if that had been the goal from the onset?
- hn2fast 6y agoYeah, I imagine that managing one's expectations is the most vital at the formation stages, which could be what is meant.
- ayewo 6y agoThere was a large thread recently [0] where Paul already answered a similar question. He had left (Jan 1996)[1], long before AWS became a thing. 0: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25693618 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25693618 1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25697941 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25697941
- not_knuth 6y agoCoincidentally, I saw this recently: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25671097 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25671097 Giving it the benefit of the doubt, I could not help but wonder if this was the Usenet post you saw back in the day that made you apply for a job at Amazon :)
- exadeci 6y ago>Your compensation will include meaningful equity ownership. I'd wonder how much that's worth today.
- croes 6y agoAnd one of Bezos first ideas for a name was Relentless.
- cercatrova 6y agorelentless.com redirects to Amazon.com
- ma2rten 6y agoDo you have any interesting anecdotes from your time at amazon?
- WallyBalls 6y agoTo be fair, "Sears for the 21st century" is not what Amazon is today. It's a whole lot more than that. And that does seem to have grown over time. Stuff like AWS and Alexa and all of that. That's likely what he's referring to.
- melomal 6y agoI read somewhere that there was also a mention of calling it 'Relentless'. I'll do my best to remember where it was that I read this.
- knuthsat 6y agoWas employee #1 (not at AMZN) and saw the origin story change in front of my eyes.
- erikbye 6y agoA couple of Paul Davis’ submissions on HN deserve more discussion. Especially relevant to open source. https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=PaulDavisThe1st https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=PaulDavisThe1st
- herodoturtle 6y agoWhat advice would you have for us solo founders in terms of maintaining healthy relations with our first employees? I won't ask what Jeff did wrong for obvious reasons, but what did he do really well? I loved your other comment on here about living a fulfilled life. Thanks for sharing.
- narcissismo 6y agoWhose idea was it to put a sketch of a penis underneath the word 'Amazon'? That logo is brilliant.
- snickms 6y agoLately I've seen boxes marked with just the penis - no 'Amazon' at all.
- polynomial 6y agoWhat did his lawyer have against "Cadabra"? Offhand it sounds a bit too close to cadaver for the marketing dept, but what would a legal objection be?
- wuschel 6y ago> ps. amazon employee #2 I hope it worked out for you! Early days employees bear a high risk. How was Amazon back then when only a handful people ran the show? Any lessons to be learned?
- richardknop 6y ago> ps. amazon employee #2 Oh wow that's nice. Yeah, Amazon was definitely a better name choice.