4 ms·
>It is, therefore, my sworn duty to be skeptical of consumer technology companies encroaching on the territory of high-end audio equipment built by companies wi
by ksec 6y ago
>It is, therefore, my sworn duty to be skeptical of consumer technology companies encroaching on the territory of high-end audio equipment built by companies with decades of experience.
> but their track record with audio hardware is inconsistent. Somehow, the company that makes the HomePod—a marvel of mono speaker engineering—is also the company that continues to make and sell Beats products.
When Beats were acquired by Apple. Especially with Jimmy Iovine in charge of Apple Music ( initially ). I was extremely worried that any of the crap Beats made infect Apple's Audio. Turns out Apple has Firewalled their department pretty well. I remember reading one of the story about HomePod team asking Jimmy Iovine's opinion on its audio quality. His reply was his usual " You need more Bass".
Apple audio engineering teams consist of many engineers from Bowers & Wilkins . One of my favourite brand in Audio Equipment. ( I think, I could be wrong, Steve Jobs likes Bowers & Wilkins too ) And you should notice their taste of Audio have many similar traits.
So Beats continue to make crap, they did improve somewhat since Apple's purchased them. And Apple, continues to be Apple.
But that is only with Audio, the AirPods Max Hardware Design is very much modern Apple and non-Bowers & Wilkins. The weight and comfort issues. Something about Apple's Design Department changed ever since Steve Jobs is not there to be the Editor to edit things. Things like Keyboard, TrackPad or Headsets. User Comfort and usage are no longer the 1st priority. Instead it is aesthetics and design goals, that could be material ( the need to use Metal ), thinner or colour.
Design is how it works, not how it looks. Hopefully recent Mac changes meant they learned a thing or two.
- wincy 6y agoInteresting, I own a pair of Bowers and Wilkins PX headphones and they sound great, no complaints aside from the year the firmware got stuck in some failure state and they wouldn't reboot/function until the battery died.
- runT1ME 6y agoI have the same issue with my PX, every two months or so I have to use the paper clip to hard reboot them. Kind of annoying to need to do for a $400 pair of headphones, but they sound great, look good, and are very comfortable.
- n_kr 6y agoThe only affordable consumer audio products I have liked are from Marshall. They make a good lineup of bluetooth speakers for home use. I picked up one of those, and it sounds very good for its price. It has very decent bass, and generally good response all across the range. And just for fun, I put a processed guitar in aux input, not bad at all. Another one which I like a lot are the range of mini amps from Laney. They aren't targeted for normal home use, but they can be used with bluetooth and aux-in. For their price and size, they sound very good. As a guitar amp...ehhh its OK for the price, but its portable. Its really telling that both are veteran music gear companies.
- gwd 6y ago> I remember reading one of the story about HomePod team asking Jimmy Iovine's opinion on its audio quality. His reply was his usual " You need more Bass". The fact that the author thinks the HomePods have great sound rather makes me doubt his audiophile qualifications. I consistently have to listen to music at a much lower volume than I want because even at a moderate volume, the bass hurts my ears. Listening to classical is even more annoying, as everything is fine until some poor instrument wanders in to the HomePod's "BOOST THAT BASS" range and suddenly the balance is all wrong.
- zachwood 6y agoI returned a homepod after really wanting to like it. I tried several locations, didn't matter, the bass is overpowering. There's a HUGE bass boost. It's unlistenable to anyone familiar with what a relatively neutral frequency response should sound like. I don't know what type of curve they are targeting with all of their auto-eq magic but if you're not going to make it user-adjustable, I don't know why you would choose a bass cannon.
- astrange 6y agoHomePod's frequency response is objectively flat when placed in a free space. https://www.audiosciencereview.com/forum/index.php?threads/apple-homepod-measurement.8425/ https://www.audiosciencereview.com/forum/index.php?threads/a... https://www.rtings.com/speaker/reviews/apple/homepod https://www.rtings.com/speaker/reviews/apple/homepod You might have reflections or room gain if it's in a smaller space. It'd probably help to put it on a speaker stand.
- zachwood 6y agoGuess I just need to move into a place without walls.
- gwd 6y agoAs parent mentioned, I've also tried the speakers in lots of different locations -- on the floor, on a desk, near a wall, not near a wall, in the kitchen, the living room, the study, and the hallway. And I've listened to the same music on my Bose headset (which aren't exactly known for low bass response), and then streamed it over my HomePod; the HomePod was basically unlistenable at any reasonable volume. Maybe it really is just the HomePod managing to hit the bass frequency of every room, and all I need to do is add bass traps everywhere; or maybe all the music I want to listen to is just badly mixed to make up for expected poor bass response on speakers. But it's a bit hard to believe, honestly.
- Anechoic 6y agoApple audio engineering teams consist of many engineers from Bowers & Wilkins Tom Holman is there as well.
- sjwright 6y agoFor those who don’t know, Tom Holman is the TH in THX. He was also involved with the inception of Audyssey Labs and their room calibration technology. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tomlinson_Holman https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tomlinson_Holman
- buran77 6y agoThe rumors that Apple purchased Jimmy Iovine and Beats Music, and also got a mediocre headphones company in the bundle are most likely true. Apple needed to launch their music service, not their audio hardware business, so the acquisition worked and payed dividends on that front. They're probably squeezing Beats for all it's worth now because they can. But I'm sure from an engineering perspective Beats still brings nothing of value to the table now as it didn't then.
- Tycho 6y agoI don't think so. Beats headphones were the first thing since the iPod that was approaching Apple's cachet with young music fans. They were fashionable. That is Apple's turf.
- buran77 6y ago> I don't think so. [...] They were fashionable. I think you do think so. Describing them as "fashionable" is just endorsing my remark that from an engineering perspective Beats brings nothing of value. I was being very charitable when I said "mediocre headphones", the engineering behind Beats certainly had no value for Apple. And even today the most valuable part of the engineering behind a pair of Beats is Apple's W chip. I know I said engineering quite a few times but I want the focus of my comment to be clear.
- Tycho 6y agoBut the headphones business that Beats had built up wasn’t somehow irrelevant. It was the main attraction, although not for any technological edge certainly.
- samizdis 6y agoIf you're not already familiar with Dieter Rams, you might like his thoughts on design; see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dieter_Rams https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dieter_Rams I saw a great documentary about Rams, which was put online as free to watch - but for only a month or so. Not sure whether it was this one, but I think that it might be. There's a chance you might find it archived somewhere: https://www.hustwit.com/rams/ https://www.hustwit.com/rams/ Edit for spelling and to add that it's available on Amazon Prime (for me in the UK): https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/video/detail/amzn1.dv.gti.38b6986a-10af-731f-2dd5-a9991929281a?ref_=imdbref_tt_wbr_pvt_aiv&tag=imdbtag_tt_wbr_pvt_aiv-21 https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/video/detail/amzn1.dv.gti.38b698...
- majormajor 6y ago> But that is only with Audio, the AirPods Max Hardware Design is very much modern Apple and non-Bowers & Wilkins. The weight and comfort issues. My B&W PX headphones suggest that they have plenty of weight and comfort issues of their own. ;) Sennheiser Momentums were much more comfy, but didn't sound as good :|
- fossuser 6y agoApple's mice have always been form over function (with some rationalized nonsense to try and pretend that it's actually about function). That was directly from Steve Jobs who supposedly mistook an unfinished mock as a mouse with no buttons. I like the weight of the Max headphones and how they feel premium rather than plastic, I also use them at my desk and don't think they're uncomfortable. The butterfly keyboard, and touchbar are post-jobs failures though, but we're almost done with them. I guess my point is that there were mistakes during the Jobs era too, people just forget them. > "Design is how it works, not how it looks." It's both.
- discordance 6y ago> Apple's mice have always been form over function I respectfully disagree: https://photos5.appleinsider.com/gallery/31750-53575-magic-mouse-2-turtled-xl.jpg https://photos5.appleinsider.com/gallery/31750-53575-magic-m...
- astrange 6y ago> So Beats continue to make crap, they did improve somewhat since Apple's purchased them. And Apple, continues to be Apple. They don't, they make good headphones now. Nobody knows this because they don't listen to the products, have never listened to them, and rely on jokes they read on the internet 10 years ago.