9 ms·
Covid-19 rarely spreads through surfaces. So why are we still deep cleaning?
- Causality1 6y agoSafety theater, pure and simple.
- throwaway122378 6y agoFear mongering
- _nickwhite 6y agoI've said this from the very beginning of the pandemic that it makes no sense at all focusing on surfaces and raiding stores for hand sanitizer. Even the CDC themselves says this: "On the other hand, transmission of novel coronavirus to persons from surfaces contaminated with the virus has not been documented."
- collyw 6y agoThe CDC did say that masks didn't work. Then they said that they do work.
- michaelmior 6y agoI don't recall ever hearing the CDC say that masks don't work. My understanding is that initially there were recommendations against the general public wearing masks out of a concern that mass buying may have limited their availability to health care providers. In any case, the science is pretty clear now that they do work.
- the-dude 6y agoOur CDC ( Dutch equivalent RIVM.nl ) actually said they believed masks might be dangerous as it might give a false sense of security and ordinary citizens would not be able to handle them properly. Mask are mandatory now in confined public spaces, but they have never started a campaign to train the public to handle the mask properly.
- michaelmior 6y agoI do recall hearing similar concerns hear in the US (although I can't recall now where these statements originated from. People wearing masks improperly is certainly frustrating. (e.g. nose out, chin strap, etc.)
- the-dude 6y agoIt was not so much as wearing them improperly, but putting them on improperly ( the proces ).
- cactus2093 6y agoIn California, once the guidance changed on masks in April they were still hard to buy so the guidance was “if you don’t have a mask, just wear a bandana or scarf over your face”. We have studies showing that this doesn’t work nearly as well as a surgical mask much less an n95, but I still see people doing it all the time. There hasn’t been a public health campaign in the past 9 months to say “now that the shortage is over, wear a mask that actually works” which is crazy to me.
- the-dude 6y ago> doesn’t work nearly as well At getting infected or spreading infection?
- cactus2093 6y agoboth
- JohnPrine 6y agoSource on those studies?
- cactus2093 6y agohttps://aip.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/5.0016018 https://aip.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/5.0016018
- sempron64 6y agoIn order to limit buying the CDC pushed the lie that masks would not significantly affect the chance of catching COVID in a non-hospital setting. Then when that became too obviously wrong and PPE supply increased they changed their tune. This cost me a LOT of trust in the institution — that they would lie to manipulate mass behavior. Even early in the pandemic, the Asian countries which got the pandemic under control all required masks, and they have experience with coronaviruses. After the above fiasco I don’t trust the CDC or any U.S. local or federal government agency to say that COVID won’t spread on surfaces when they are motivated to say so to save significant money and resources by skipping disinfection protocols.
- sempron64 6y agoTo add a source: >Who does not need PPE: CDC does NOT currently recommend the general public use facemasks. Instead, CDC recommends following everyday preventive actions, such as washing your hands, covering your cough, and staying home when you are sick. https://web.archive.org/web/20200325060652/https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/healthcare-supply-ppe-index.html https://web.archive.org/web/20200325060652/https://www.cdc.g... You can see why this was interpreted to mean “masks don’t help”. There is no implication they are a good idea.
- collyw 6y ago> In order to limit buying the CDC pushed the lie that masks would not significantly affect the chance of catching COVID in a non-hospital setting. Is it actually a lie? I don't believe there is conclusive evidence either way. (It certainly doesn't appear to have made much difference here where we have had a mask mandate for months).
- packetlost 6y agoI very distinctly remember them saying "there is no evidence to suggest wearing a mask reduces the chances of contracting COVID-19" which is extremely different from saying they don't work, especially in the early days when there was barely any evidence/data at all. Edit: actually, the CDC did recommend people who were either sick or caring for those who are sick wear masks and gives a clear reason as to why that's the recommendation: https://web.archive.org/web/20200324155703/https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/prepare/prevention.html?CDC_AA_refVal=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.cdc.gov%2Fcoronavirus%2F2019-ncov%2Fabout%2Fprevention.html https://web.archive.org/web/20200324155703/https://www.cdc.g...
- darkerside 6y agoNot the CDC, but surgeon general was spouting this garbage in March. https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2020/02/29/health/face-masks-coronavirus-surgeon-general-trnd/index.html-general-trnd/index.html&ved=2ahUKEwiniJuwqsvuAhVoMVkFHc8NCGUQFjADegQIChAP&usg=AOvVaw1NaS-ROiDo_3-1x-FMFJhH&cf=1 https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2020/02/29/health/face-masks-coronav... CDC is referenced in the article too, but this tweet was just egregious.
- tolbish 6y ago> “Seriously people- STOP BUYING MASKS!” tweeted Dr. Jerome Adams, the U.S. Surgeon General, on Feb. 29. “They are NOT effective in preventing general public from catching #Coronavirus" So the surgeon general, not the CDC. https://time.com/5794729/coronavirus-face-masks/ https://time.com/5794729/coronavirus-face-masks/
- Tostino 6y agoYeah, and the rest of the world still said "masks are a good idea" through all of that. It was pretty obvious what the CDC was up to at the time (trying not to cause panic buying, etc) but it was a terrible idea for them to do it.
- comodore_ 6y agoFauci and the WHO said the same thing. Only mask if you're sick or if you take care of sick people around you but you don't need to mask if you're healthy. Edit: [0] is a archived version of the WHO public advice about when to use mask from late april. It probably was up even longer: > If you are healthy, you only need to wear a mask if you are taking care of a person with COVID-19. Wear a mask if you are coughing or sneezing. Masks are effective only when used in combination with frequent hand-cleaning with alcohol-based hand rub or soap and water. If you wear a mask, then you must know how to use it and dispose of it properly. [0] https://web.archive.org/web/20200421063423/https://www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/novel-coronavirus-2019/advice-for-public/when-and-how-to-use-masks https://web.archive.org/web/20200421063423/https://www.who.i...
- collyw 6y agoThe rest of the world didn't say that. Many of the world's politicians felt the need to be seen to be doing something, so forced masks upon us despite little hard evidence.
- throwaway2245 6y agoThis quote might be stale, e.g. New Zealand suggests that it has identified cases of infection via lift button and bin: https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/427446/rubbish-bin-the-likely-source-of-covid-infection https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/427446/rubbish-bin-the-l... Obviously this is disputed, because it's impossible to tell - saying "not been documented" is quite a neutral statement. Even if surface transmission is unlikely, a single case could be enough to trigger a wider outbreak. So, if you are doing what you can to prevent aerosol transmission, then it also makes sense to minimise surface transmission.
- AuthorizedCust 6y agoThat is just a hypothesis. We know little about the soundness of the evaluation of all likely vectors for this case. Also, "if it would save just one life" is where you're going with the last sentence. Diverting attention into non-existent or rare transmission vectors removes attention from known transmission vectors, which will increase infections.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- throwaway2245 6y ago> Also, "if it would save just one life" is where you're going with the last sentence. Please read again. If a virus is transmitted even once via a surface, it is then free to transmit onwards by whatever method is most efficient. This is likely to cause an outbreak whenever R>1. Preventing an additional outbreak is more relevant in NZ than in the US, perhaps.
- sokoloff 6y ago> pressing a button on a lift shortly after someone with Covid-19 used it If you rode in the lift shortly after someone with COVID-19 used it, it seems that airborne transmission is quite plausible.
- usrusr 6y agoAs far as I remember, in the early days it was assumed that most spread was via visible droplets and surface because all well-studied viruses that spread by aerosol would spread much faster in a zero-immunity population than observed with SARS-COV2. But those are all viruses that have many generations of adopting to humans under their belt. Compared to them the new one seems to be barely able to make landfall in humans at all. Now we know full well that the virus is aerosol-capable and the implied "surprisingly bad compatibility with humans" is consistent with the number of observed mutations that spread faster, probably quite a few evolutionary low hanging fruits to increase hit rate while spreading. Back to topic, I think that in early days the surface focus wasn't a bad guess, it just happened to be wrong.
- branon 6y agoSame reason we're still wearing masks, I'd imagine. It's not necessarily about what is the most effective, it's about increasing the odds. And more than that, it's about what's seen by politicians, their constituents, the media, and society at large as effective. Safety theater, as another commenter put it.
- cactus2093 6y agoHow is wearing masks safety theater?
- jojo2000 6y agoIt's written on the box : does not stop germs or viruses. A mask is made for surgeons to stop blood or other bodily fluids. Furthermore, disposable masks are full of harmful chemical compounds. And last, if you wear a mask and touch it you bring the germs closer to your mouth. And last, if you're not ill you ain't transmittin' nothin'. This is a joke.
- nomdep 6y agoCovid is not really airborne in the sense it doesn't float by itself but travels through micro droplets of saliva, which is... (dramatic pause) a bodily fluid! How on Earth, after a year, you are so ignorant about it?
- nikbackm 6y agohttps://first10em.com/covid-19-is-spread-by-aerosols-an-evidence-review/ https://first10em.com/covid-19-is-spread-by-aerosols-an-evid...
- thehappypm 6y agoAerosols are exactly the droplets the comment is referencing
- 6y ago
- s9w 6y agoIt also doesn't hurt people (more than other seasonal infections), so why are still talking about it? Because this is not about health at all.
- mschuster91 6y agoRegular deep cleanings and disinfections of "shared surfaces" has a distinct advantage, even if it doesn't help much against SARS-CoV2: it reduces the spread of other contagions - like the regular influenza, herpes, hep-a or e.coli. The regular flu, for example, is all but non-existent in the world at the moment. If there is one thing to be learned from the whole covid-19 disaster, it is that a lot of life and productivity loss can be prevented by relatively simple measures.
- woliveirajr 6y agoOTOH, there are discussion [0] about "hyper hygiene" and long-term effects on imunne system, including leukemia in children [1]. Contact with some diseases is desirable, just not with _all_ diseases. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25989726 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25989726 [1] https://www.theguardian.com/science/2018/dec/30/children-leukaemia-mel-greaves-microbes-protection-against-disease https://www.theguardian.com/science/2018/dec/30/children-leu...
- Tade0 6y agoThe question remains whether these measures are cost-effective. You can't put a price on human life(unless you're an insurance company), but you definitely can on sick days. I have a data point, namely a few friends who seasonally get the flu and take sick days for that. On average it shaves off ~2% of their annual work hours. At this rate I can't tell if this is worth the trouble, especially that a few of them definitely catch those viruses from their kindergarten-attending children.
- mschuster91 6y agoThe flu and cough season alone was responsible for ~20 in 100 employees going off sick in Germany 2019 (https://www.barmer.de/presse/bundeslaender-aktuell/berlin-brandenburg/standortinfo/barmer-gesundheitsreport-2019-202108 https://www.barmer.de/presse/bundeslaender-aktuell/berlin-br...), with an average sick time-off of 14-22 days a year. This is a lot of lost productivity, even when one takes into account that the 2019 flu season was nasty (I was off for two weeks too, hardest hit in about one and a half decades for me). Side note: I assume you're American - just ask yourself how many of your friends and colleagues go to work while symptomatic because you don't have mandatory sick days that don't count against regular vacation and so end up spreading contagions... I agree that the sick days number in Germany seems quite excessive but I rather had a loss in productivity than getting sick from co-workers and ending out sick for weeks.
- tootie 6y agoI think in a lot of cases it's already been budgeted, it sends a signal that care is being taken and also it probably is helping reduce spread even if the benefit is small. And if not covid, it's at least killing other germs.
- _Understated_ 6y agoBut isn't the immune system classed as anti-fragile? By this, I mean that if you don't use it then it gets weaker. With all this constant disinfecting, are we not doing ourselves out of our ability to fight things off in future?
- tootie 6y agoThere's not really any proof that hygiene hypothesis leads to better outcomes. Yes, the immune system generally only strengthens when it's exposed to pathogens, but being exposed to lots of pathogens also damages your body. And controlled exposure to pathogens (ie, vaccines) can trigger an immune response without injury. So, we're likely trading weaker immune systems for millions fewer deaths. Look at the mortality rates due to infectious disease in countries with poor sanitation.
- graeme 6y agoThe better question is why aren’t we ventilating. It is justifiable to clean high contact surfaces as a precaution. But this is like optimizing the last 2%. The most important thing other than masks and distancing would be opening windows, installing air purifiers that kill viruses, and setting hvac’s to bring in outside air. Co2 meters could be used to gauge effectiveness. One year in official guidelines in most cases don’t mention ventilation and in some workplaces people are forbidden from ventilating because it isn’t in the guidelines. We’d be a little chilly or a little warm, but the virus would spread much less readily.
- the-dude 6y agoIn schools for that matter.
- etothepii 6y agoMy friend made a website about it, https://openyourdamnwindows.com https://openyourdamnwindows.com
- graeme 6y agoGreat site, thanks!
- ketamine__ 6y agoI applaud your friend.
- account42 6y ago> It should be too-cold inside. If the heating can cope in winter, then the ventilation is inadequate. Yeah, no thanks.
- Someone1234 6y agoBecause most of it was "COVID theater" rather than intended to actually make people safer, the public cannot see the [likely more effective] things you're suggesting. Same thing with checking temperature at the door (it doesn't work because people can either never get a fever or be infectious before/after one). Even when it comes to masks we still have very few of the public using well fitting N95 and manufacturers mass-producing masks that barely even cover the side of people's faces (i.e. they don't work as well as they could, even for cloth!). This was totally forgivable in the early days since "better than nothing" masks, but it has been almost a year and effective mask/mask usage still isn't being promoted nor guidelines for producing high quality masks exists.
- sschueller 6y agoThe one good thing that has come out of this is that most people now wash their hands after using the toilet. I used to see so many people not washing their hands and in a gym where everyone touches everything it is quite disgusting.
- Someone1234 6y agoAside from being just unpleasant also a major source of infection (norovirus, rotavirus, etc often called "24 hour bugs"/stomach bugs/erroneously "food poisoning").
- comodore_ 6y agoI suspect that in 5-10 years we will see a significant increase in allergy patients, even more than we are seeing now.
- csunbird 6y agoI am also afraid of the "fear of people" trait that we all have gained during this pandemic sticking as well. Before pandemic, me and my friends were able to just share a bar/cafe table with 5 random strangers and have a beer with them, nowadays it feels it is impossible for me to do something like that.
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoIt won't last. Whenever restrictions have been lifted in Europe, restaurants and pubs quickly go back to full capacity. Right now in Italy and Poland, thousands of establishments have defied lockdown and reopened, and it turns out that a large number of local population was waiting eagerly to go out again.
- netsharc 6y ago> large number of local population Wouldn't this observation be biased? The paranoid would know socializing is still not safe, and the reckless would think "Relax, it's just a flu", and so you'd see bars full but full of the reckless.
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoBut many of the paranoid are paranoid due to social factors, not due to a reasoned reading of COVID data. So, once large gatherings of people return, the social pressure on the paranoid will be less and their paranoia will abate.
- Ekaros 6y agoI'm happy that now I have valid reason to scream murder when random person tries to talk to me...
- matthewmacleod 6y agoReading between the lines - because there was some suggestion that surface transmission might be a problem, this is largely now thought not be be the case, but it’s a relatively low-cost measure that was already put in place and increases public confidence, even though broadly speaking it’s likely to have a minimal effect on transmission rates. Cleaning high-contact surfaces was not an unreasonable precaution to take; it’s probably something we will slowly stop doing now as the pandemic starts to ease.
- cactus2093 6y agoThe article is really not as definitive about it as I was expecting from the title. Basically it’s “we don’t really know, we don’t even really examine most sources of infection, we’ve never done controlled trials on it, you can find the virus on lots of surfaces, most of the time it’s probably not infectious but sometimes it could be, there have been a few documented cases of infections from surfaces”. It’s clearly a lower risk than airborne transmission but it seems like we can’t say with much certainty how low. The only estimate of a risk probability mentioned is a 5 in 10000 chance of being infected if you’re out in public touching things. Not even sure if this was from a real study or just an expert’s back of the envelope calculation. I don’t know exactly the parameters involved but if you had taken that chance every day for the past year you would have had a 17% chance of getting infected at some point which is relatively significant. And seems like it would be likely worse at times the outbreak is at a higher peak, or if you’re an essential worker taking that chance multiple times a day.
- stdbrouw 6y agoNitpick: really more like a 15% chance over 11 months. 1 - (1 - 5/10000)^330 => 0.152 (But I think you make a great point, it sounds like a tiny chance but it really does add up.)
- d1sxeyes 6y agoIt's a bizarre measure, why wouldn't you mention it as 1 in 2000 unless you're deliberately trying to make the denominator look bigger.
- tialaramex 6y agoIf you currently have elimination, it makes sense to deep clean potentially infected surfaces. For example if you're a New Zealand restaurant which seated the woman who subsequently turned out to be infected last week, when you got notified by the public health department you might want to clean everything just in case before re-opening, as well as having all the staff who had contact with her take a test, and so on. Such practices are costly, but a new outbreak would be far more expensive for everybody. Where it makes less sense is if you have endemic virus and you're basically not bothering to even control that why bother cleaning surfaces when they'll be re-contaminated shortly afterwards? In fact several countries have this practice while also ensuring sick people who work as cleaners feel obligated to stay on the job to feed their families, so the people cleaning may spread the virus. As to ventilation, that's expensive. One hypothesis for that New Zealand case is that she was infected through the AC at the isolation hotel. Another guest in that hotel tested positive and was transferred to quarantine but obviously you could be infectious days before you test positive. That hotel is being closed for an upgrade, but this is expensive and it's only practical for New Zealand to do this for their managed isolation & quarantine facilities, in a country with endemic virus you'd want to do it in every building. Personally I just assume all surfaces outside my home are contaminated, and any humans who get within a few metres are infectious and spreading viral particles. But I'm lucky, I don't have to go out and do a job out there.
- maxerickson 6y agoPresumably ventilation improvements will continue to pay off in the future. Which isn't to say that it is easy to just upgrade everything, more that we should account for how damaging an airborne virus can be when we construct facilities.
- ketamine__ 6y agoPurifying air is cheap. Whole house purifiers cost at most $8,000 installed. Most people spend 3-8x that on a car. Many people on HN own a Tesla. They can afford it.
- fasteddie31003 6y agoYou know there are downsides to being too clean. Your body needs some low level pathogens to fight off to exercise your immune system. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1448690/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1448690/ The trendy term for this is maintaining your microbiome.
- themark 6y agoIt feels like the risks of sanitizing everything outweigh the perceived benefits.
- specialist 6y agoI'm old enough to remember when offices were cleaned regularly. I applaud the renewed interest in basic hygiene.
- LatteLazy 6y agoThe Real question here imho is how can we reduce the gap between knowledge and actions. We know all sorts of things but governments outside Australia and Singapore seem totally unable and unwilling to do basic things like enforce mask wearing or run testing or tracing programs. Too much deep cleaning is fine frankly, it's too few masks, no quarantine of travellers, workplaces remaining open etc that's the issue.
- neutronicus 6y agoI have a couple friends who have been constantly agitating for deep-cleaning for the past decade. They aren't going to let the chance to change norms around it just slip away
- grishka 6y agoHere in Russia they're paying a disproportional amount of attention to surfaces. The covid law in both Moscow and St Petersburg mandates masks and gloves. McDonalds gives you plastic gloves and doesn't give you your order until you put them on, but pretty much no one else is having it. Though all signs and announcements do mention gloves just so it appears that the law is being followed.
- victor106 6y agoAnyone know of Any air purifiers that can trap coronavirus?