6 ms·
A company accused Wirecutter of being pay-for-play, based on how how heavily affiliate revenue (allegedly) factors into Wirecutter reviews. [1] The Wirecutter r
by gnicholas 6y ago
A company accused Wirecutter of being pay-for-play, based on how how heavily affiliate revenue (allegedly) factors into Wirecutter reviews. [1] The Wirecutter responded here. [2]
I wonder if this was part of the reason that the Honeywell unit was recommended.
1: https://www.xdesk.com/wirecutter-standing-desk-review-pay-to-play-model https://www.xdesk.com/wirecutter-standing-desk-review-pay-to...
2: https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/our-response-to-nextdesk/ https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/our-response-to-nextdesk/
- seanhope 6y agoI suspect you are right. I bought a wireless router they recommended once, and it was worse than the one it replaced. Since then I have not trusted any online review site.
- ErikVandeWater 6y agoAnd the Wirecutter response even has a factually inaccurate statement in the first 3 sentences: > In it, the company claims that The Wirecutter initially picked NextDesk as an editorial recommendation but later downgraded the recommendation after NextDesk declined to set up an affiliate-revenue agreement. >We want to be clear: NextDesk’s claim is false, and its representation of our editorial decision-making process is factually inaccurate. That claim as described is in fact TRUE. NextDesk was picked, then declined an affiliate-revenue agreement, then the recommendation was downgraded. That was the order of events. The rest I don't know, but it's pretty ridiculous to have that kind of error when these kinds of things often result in lawsuits.
- bostonvaulter2 6y agoDo you have any proof of this?
- ErikVandeWater 6y agoThe rest of the Wirecutter article where it backtracks?
- paxys 6y agoWhere do they backtrack? The article is pretty clear about there being no editorial influence.
- ErikVandeWater 6y agoDid you read about the order of events?
- tomjakubowski 6y ago> In it, the company claims that The Wirecutter initially picked NextDesk as an editorial recommendation but later downgraded the recommendation after NextDesk declined to set up an affiliate-revenue agreement. I believe you're taking "after" in this sentence way too literally. The order of events isn't in dispute, what's at issue is whether Nextdesk's declination to enter a revenue sharing agreement caused Wirecutter to downgrade their ranking. This comment by geofft convinced me Nextdesk (RIP) was in the wrong in this dispute. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22144078 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22144078
- JohnBooty 6y agoYou're reading a causal meaning into "after" that clearly was not intended by the author of Wirecutter's response. They are clearly expressing a simple temporal relation and not a causal one. Please be clear that I have no opinion on the truthfulness of the Wirecutter's response. Perhaps they're truly corrupt as all hell. I have no inside knowledge of how they operate. However, it is absolutely clear you're reading something into the "after" that was not intended.
- pessimizer 6y ago"After" is a temporal word. We have may ways to clearly express cause that could have been used. Generally, one uses "after" to imply cause without explicitly saying it. Instead, Wirecutter has made a factually incorrect statement. That Thing 1 happened, then Thing 2 happened, then Thing 3 happened is not in dispute. Also not in dispute: Thing 3 happened after Thing 2, which happened after Thing 1.
- stdbrouw 6y agoErik posts a comment on Hacker News, next thing you know, there's a military coup in Myanmar. Factually correct. The phrasing implies a causal relationship, which is what Wirecutter disputes.
- victor106 6y agoI used to religiously follow wirecutter recommendations. But I don’t anymore. I had the exact same issue with this humidifier. I got their upgraded version instead and that was better.
- Blackthorn 6y agoI don't trust reviews on the internet at all anymore, unless they come from a single person (not a faceless group) that's known in that space. Affiliate garbage has ruined the ability to find any good information about products.
- notatoad 6y ago>that's known in that space that's the most important. if you're looking for humidifier recommendations online and you find a community of people dedicated to humidifiers and there's one they recommend, then you're probably good. but there's no reason to trust any sort of general review site.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoFriendly reminder: If this is not the internet you want, please try to support indie content producers whose work you think is decent and who take tips/Patreon/et al. And if you can afford it, subscribe to online newspapers and the like (because journalism is in a world of hurt and it is negatively impacting minor little things like freedom and democracy). I blog and I take tips and Patreon and I sometimes hit the front page of HN. I make a pittance. This means that I have no real choice but to do other kinds of paid writing. So I've thought long and hard about this and I've read the stuff on HN for years where people here don't want ads on the sites they visit, don't want paywalls, don't like content marketing and "pay for play" affiliate sites, etc etc etc. And then also do not want to leave tips, support a person's Patreon, etc. If you give writers and other creatives no means to earn an adequate income trying to meet your prissy high standards for so-called ethics [1], then don't be all shocked that they will do whatever happens to actually work to line their pockets, though it involves lying, writing reviews for pay without actually ever touching the product, etc. People need to eat. Not everyone can be a programmer. Make it possible for creatives to establish a middle class income. Stop telling people like me "Writing doesn't pay. You know that. Go get a real job." and find a way to make it pay such that doing the kind of writing you want to see is what gets rewarded and not sketchy garbage. Writing does pay. It just pays for doing bad things and occasionally someone like J.K. Rowling gets stinking rich. It doesn't have to be that way. The world can decide it values good writing and that writers deserve a decent income and make choices to move the world in that direction. [1] These so-called "ethics" seem to boil down to "we expect writers to write for free and find some other means to support themselves while producing quality content as...a hobby, I guess" -- aka slave labor. And then folks get upset if you frame it that way.
- kortilla 6y ago> The world can decide it values good writing and that writers deserve a decent income It has decided. The sad truth is just that “good writing” just isn’t that valuable (as can be seen in how much people pay) if you don’t have some killer content to back it up. Good writing is requisite but not sufficient. Just because something is a sustaining profession for a few people doesn’t mean it should be for everyone who does that. Do you realize how many photographers and other artists are in the same category? > aka slave labor. Something that is voluntary is - by definition - not slave labor. Nobody is forcing you to write. There are people who effectively tweet full time. Is that “slave labor”? There are people to play games full time. Is that “slave labor”? > And then folks get upset if you frame it that way. I hope you can see why. Finally, people don’t get mad at writers because they want to make money. They get mad when the writers’ hide the fact that the money has tainted and shaped everything they are saying. A review site that is shilling products because of kickbacks corrupts the entire thing. Can you imagine your friend recommending you a doctor and then you find out that the friend actually thinks the doctor is terrible but got $1k for the referral?
- ashtonkem 6y agoIf true, this explains the awful towels we bought at the WireCutter’s suggestion.
- alexhutcheson 6y agoWhich ones?
- gnicholas 6y agoPreviously discussed on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22141719 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22141719 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16729408 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16729408 I still use The Wirecutter, but in combination with other sources. I try to ask myself the question: do there appear to be competing products that wouldn't provide the affiliate revenue and therefore potentially be left out of the recommendations? If I'm just deciding between a bunch of stuff on Amazon, then I assume there's no thumb on the scale.
- dylan604 6y agoThis is what makes the internet fun. You want to research something, but then you have to research the trustworthiness of the sites your are finding in the search.
- 8ytecoder 6y agoI’m assuming you have tried consumer report? They don’t accept any incentives from the manufacturers. They even buy all their test products.
- gnicholas 6y agoI have in the past but not much recently. I got the impression they tested fewer products and had a bit of a lag in terms of publication. Perhaps things have changed though?
- 6y ago
- ruph123 6y agoAs a German I and many others are religiously following what our consumer reports "Stiftung Warentest" recommends (except for high-tech products). Germans have very high confidence in the products and many companies print a good test result ("very good" or even "good" on their packaging). Reasons are that they are extremely thorough, unbiased, financially independent and can be quite tough. They have sophisticated testing facilities, do lab tests, test lifetime of products with machines, etc. And they have been sued several times by companies. So when I cam to the US I was very worried of the basically unregulated companies to screw me over so naturally I (digitally) subscribed to the OG Consumer Reports (which historically seems to be the role model of all other international consumer reports). However I am so disappointed about the magazine: - it is not very thorough or strict (rather leniant) - it has a really poor selection of product categories - besides a table of comparing the products features it has very little editorial buying guides that go more into detail. In the case of the German magazine, when you read through some of the guides they can be quite entertaining, they slap the wrists of even the most powerful (german) companies if something breaks or if they falsely advertise features, or if there are critical design flaws in the product. I really wish CR would be as critical.
- guitarbill 6y agoStiftung Warentest is definitely useful, but like you said have a spotty track-record for tech products. Realising that definitely made me more sceptical of them. It's basically the concept of "Gell-Mann Amnesia" - if I can tell their tests are flawed in a field I'm knowledgable in, are the tests they do in other fields that seem reasonable to me also flawed (but I ignore that)? Although they do come up with the testing protocol, I'm pretty sure they don't do the testing themselves, and contract it out to specialist labs/testing companies (not a bad thing). In general though, I agree it's easier to trust them, being an independent foundation, and getting no commission. Wirecutter got acquired in 2016, too. I've also found it hard to get that German experience in other places. At the core, it's just down to how much/how many people care about something like quality. I think the (German) federal regulations and Stiftung Warentest are a result of this culture, but also make it easier to care about quality. It's a nice feedback cycle. The internet can substitute, but it's much more effort.