6 ms·
Tesla's net profit comes from selling regulatory credits, not cars
- nix23 6y agoCNN's dirty little secret: Its net profit doesn't come from making news.
- Swenrekcah 6y agoYou're being downvoted, I suppose for the 'fake mainstream media' vibe, but giving the benefit of the doubt what you say is true. The stations aren't in the business of informative newsworthy news so much as they are providing addictive 'entertainment', somewhat like facebook but less effective. What they say is not false, but it's often not quite the essence of the matter.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 6y ago>What they say is not false No, what they say is false. As @Dumblydorr says, "Tesla wouldn't be eligible for credits if they weren't selling electric cars".
- nix23 6y ago>What they say is not false, but it's often not quite the essence of the matter. That's how you change the truth. Don't lie, but left out what you don't like, and write boldly whats your views are. That's not news, but believable propaganda.
- jessaustin 6y agoLittle-known fact: the negative recursion of the acronym "CNN" is an homage to that of the acronym "GNU".
- pseudolus 6y agoIf the net result is an overall decrease in emissions and spurs other manufacturers to move to electric vehicles then I'd chalk it up as a win, especially as the credits appear to be only temporary.
- michaelt 6y agoIs it? I mean, if I brought an EV to prevent 5 tonnes of carbon emissions per year, but the EV manufacturer engages in carbon credit trading and sells a coal-fired power plant the right to emit 5 tonnes of carbon emissions per year, I might as well just buy a gasoline car because the same amount of pollution ends up in the atmosphere either way.
- totalZero 6y agoThe credits are temporary insofar as other automakers are starting to make their own EVs. How is Tesla going to make a profit when nobody needs to buy its ZEV credits?
- guepe 6y agoBy building less new factories?
- totalZero 6y agoCurrently they are constructing a factory in Berlin and another in Austin TX. Tesla sold about a half of a million cars last year. Nissan sells about 3 times that figure in the US alone. Toyota sells about 18 times that figure globally. Without being too presumptive, it certainly seems like Tesla is not going to imminently stop building factories.
- _ph_ 6y agoAnd they are still expanding the Shanghai factory, which just started building Model Ys. Indeed, Tesla is not going to stop building factories, but also for that costs are going down as are the costs for the individual cars. When the revenue due to the certificates goes down, there are many financial knobs to turn to insure Tesla stays barely profitable. And of course in times of expansion, you would only aim for minimal profits and rather invest any margin achieved.
- prepend 6y agoTwist: that was always Tesla’s plan. The beauty of cap and trade is that it puts a price on a negative externality and then let’s the market work to fix it. Funny that CNN poses this as a secret as it’s always been in Tesla’s quarterly filings and not a secret at all. When companies have to pay to not have electric cars, it spurs innovation in companies to develop electric cars.
- zpeti 6y agoLiterally every "tesla short" or anti tesla website/media property has been going on about this for years in every article. Thanks CNN for the clickbait title.
- bob33212 6y ago"Covid Variant has Scientists Worried!", "Big Moves in BITCOIN", It has got to be sad to be a journalist trying to do real work and your company is just pushing out garbage like this.
- api 6y agoNobody pays for real work. The media gets paid for clicks.
- prepend 6y agoI recently watched the great BBC adaptation of Hitchhikers’ Guide to the Galaxy [0] and was reminded of the Golgafrinchan Ark Fleet Ship B/A/C [1]. I feel like we are all now on Ark B and we are witnessing articles and tweets and whatnot from people who are oblivious to the reason why we were shot into space first. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hitchhiker%27s_Guide_to_the_Galaxy_(TV_series) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hitchhiker%27s_Guide_to_th... Especially funny as they never show the question that results in the answer to life, the universe, and everything. [1] https://hitchhikers.fandom.com/wiki/Golgafrinchan_Ark_Fleet_Ship_B https://hitchhikers.fandom.com/wiki/Golgafrinchan_Ark_Fleet_...
- cecilpl2 6y ago> The $1.6 billion in regulatory credits it received last year far outweighed Tesla's net income of $721 million -- meaning Tesla would have otherwise posted a net loss in 2020. Perhaps a better way of ending the sentence is "Tesla would have otherwise invested less in future R&D, so as not to post a loss". Whether to spend all the money you make is a business decision. See Amazon turning tiny profits for over a decade as a great example of why income doesn't matter to a growth stock.
- HenryBemis 6y agoThat is a nice strategy. They bring in a lot of revenue selling these 'credits', and by the time everyone else wakes up to the fact and starting doing 'electric', they will be far ahead in R&D, quality, experimentation, etc. They become the front runners for this industry.
- spacemanmatt 6y agoI think that depends on an assumption that existing auto makers cannot repurpose and retool their empires to produce EVs. Tesla is far behind them from that perspective.
- Ygg2 6y agoEVs seem lot less complex than ICE vehicles. What is the point of having advanced gearshift when a simple controller can achieve similar things? In other words. Their advanced tools are made for a different type of motor.
- choeger 6y agoYou still have to build suspensions, door mechanics, interior, AC, sensors, and a lot more stuff at scale. Legacy auto builders are really good at that by now. Yes, their knowledge on ICE design won't matter that much in the foreseeable future, but there's a lot of precision engineering and large-scale manufacturing to be done still to sell dozens of millions of cars (in thousands of varieties) every year.
- tontonius 6y agoAutomotive gross margin excluding regulatory credits: 20.7% (ir.tesla.com)
- totalZero 6y agoNot so fast. They reported an operating margin of 5.4% last quarter. You can't really ignore opex for a car company... https://tesla-cdn.thron.com/static/1LRLZK_2020_Q4_Quarterly_Update_Deck_-_Searchable_LVA2GL.pdf https://tesla-cdn.thron.com/static/1LRLZK_2020_Q4_Quarterly_...
- spodek 6y agoA dirty secret about ICE cars: they benefit from huge subsidies and the public paying its externalities too. We'll ride a lot more public transit and bicycles when cars of all types pay their true costs. Another dirty little secret about Tesla and Musk: they aren't helping the environment. Helping the environment means fewer cars and of those we can't get rid of, make them electric. Their strategy is more cars. That is, the tactic of electric is useful within a strategy of de-growth, but they have a strategy of growth. In fairness, they are a car company. A meaningful strategy to shrink the market would require changing the playing field, which would likely have to come from outside the field -- government or leadership at the level of Mandela or Dr. King.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- laurent92 6y agoEach time we help the environment by 5%, leaders let the population grow by 5% (often by immigration saying « We need it »). Population and footprint are increasing just like it always has, and our efforts are just being used to squeeze a few more of us here.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 6y agoExcept countries don't share the same footprint per capital, at all. Simply compare the carbon footprint of a US inhabitant vs a Vietnamese. We could be a handful of billions more on Earth and reduce the global footprint, so the size of the population not the issue but how we live (big house, big SUV, lots of meat, etc). And of course, if the world's power continue to promote the American Way of Life as the way to go, all countries will look like the US and we'll destroy our habitat. But that's not a population problem but one of culture.
- laurent92 6y agoThey also work to raise the lower countries’ population consumption levels, so ecology is just economy in the West, more spending in the East, but still exponential growth of our footprint.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Dumblydorr 6y agoIt does though. They would not be eligible for credits if they didn't sell electric cars. And why would we discredit them for being out ahead of sound government policy, unlike other makers who lagged tremendously behind? That's somehow a negative, that they're working to solve an important issue quickly?
- usrusr 6y agoYes it's just regulation working as intended. But it also means that once incumbent carmakers sell enough electrics to consume the bulk of their cross-subsidies themselves Tesla will eventually have to consider a new angle on the old "lose money on every sale but make it up in volume" joke. Sure, there are economies of scale to tap, but those tend to resemble log curves at best and given the massive number of identical cells per single car scale might be quite far into the flat already.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoGAAP gross margin of 20.6%, so they make a lot of money per car, each marginal sale adds considerably to their bottom line, even without regulatory credits. It's the fixed expenses, like R&D and Elon's stock options that turn the profit per car into a near loss.
- yardie 6y agoOr in other words, "gas-guzzlers will continue to get more expensive as each one sold subsidizes a Tesla." When I see the price velocity of what a F-150 or GMC 2500 costs compared to a decade ago the Cybertruck doesn't look like a bad deal at all.
- tchalla 6y agoIf you are like me, who likes to look at the numbers for a quick fact check - you can look at the Q3 2020 report here [0] (Q4 doesn't show up yet). TSLA received automative regulatory credits of 397M while it's Net Income was 331M. > Automotive Regulatory Credits > In connection with the production and delivery of our zero emission vehicles in global markets, we have earned and will continue to earn various tradable automotive regulatory credits. We have sold these credits, and will continue to sell future credits, to automotive companies and other regulated entities who can use the credits to comply with emission standards and other regulatory requirements. For example, under California’s Zero Emission Vehicle Regulation and those of states that have adopted California’s standard, vehicle manufacturers are required to earn or purchase credits, referred to as ZEV credits, for compliance with their annual regulatory requirements. These laws provide that automakers may bank or sell to other regulated parties their excess credits if they earn more credits than the minimum quantity required by those laws. We also earn other types of saleable regulatory credits in the United States and abroad, including greenhouse gas, fuel economy and clean fuels credits. Payments for regulatory credits are typically received at the point control transfers to the customer, or in accordance with payment terms customary to the business. > We recognize revenue on the sale of automotive regulatory credits at the time control of the regulatory credits is transferred to the purchasing party as automotive revenue in the consolidated statements of operations. Deferred revenue related to sales of automotive regulatory credits was $0 million and $140 million as of September 30, 2020 and December 31, 2019, respectively. Revenue recognized from the deferred revenue balance as of December 31, 2019 was $140 million for the nine months ended September 30, 2020. [0] https://www.sec.gov/ix?doc=/Archives/edgar/data/1318605/000156459020047486/tsla-10q_20200930.htm#Consolidated_Statmnts_of_Cmprehnsve_Loss https://www.sec.gov/ix?doc=/Archives/edgar/data/1318605/0001...
- dalbasal 6y agoMaybe I'm high on dissident sugar from reading reddit this WE, but leaning into that... Boomer media tropes are really grating me. "Dirty little secret?" You mean the most cited fact in any article interview presenting a bear case on Tesla? You mean governing policies that are intended adopted in order to have this exact effect?
- tcskeptic 6y agoThis is really irritating: BREAKING — Tax incentives and business model working as intended to solve a problem! I do wonder about this kind of article, are these genuine or is this the work of a competitor or short seller’s PR firm pushing a story?
- wooger 6y agoI always thought the longer term plan was to lead in battery manufacturing, and then diversify into other fields, plus sell batteries to other manufacturers.
- pmiller2 6y agoGuess what? Neither do car dealerships: https://yourautoadvocate.com/guides/how-do-car-dealerships-make-money/#Car_dealers_dont_make_money_from_selling_cars https://yourautoadvocate.com/guides/how-do-car-dealerships-m... A more accurate title for TFA would be "Tesla doesn't make money from car buyers," though. They do make money because they sell cars, just not so much from the people that buy them.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoIf you exclude both regulatory credits & Elon's stock options then Tesla is significantly profitable. If you're cherry-picking revenue to exclude due to "reasons" then you have to be fair and cherry-pick similar expenses to also exclude. If so, Elon's stock option expenses should also be excluded. - they're non-recurring. The company has to hit higher EBITDA and market cap goals for Elon to get another award, so at steady state Elon gets nothing. - they don't impact cash. Elon gets stock, not cash, and he doesn't sell them so it doesn't even affect float.
- bryanlarsen 6y agoAn average internal combustion (ICE) vehicle emits 66 tons of carbon over it's life time. Estimates of the externalities caused by a ton of carbon vary, but $150 is a reasonably median estimate. So we can also say that every ICE vehicle receives a $10,000 subsidy for being allowed to pollute without having to pay to clean up that pollution. What would GM's income statement look like if it had that $10,000 per vehicle on it?
- rcMgD2BwE72F 6y agoI bet the $10,000/car number is mini, tiny, little compared to the actual cost of climate change (e.g $119 billions won't be enough to protect NYC from sea level rise https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/17/nyregion/sea-wall-nyc.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/17/nyregion/sea-wall-nyc.htm...). The global cost of climate change simply cannot be priced in $ when it isn't even sure mankind would survive +5°C.
- bryanlarsen 6y ago$10K per car * 1 billion cars -> $10T. So more than the estimates of what it would cost to prevent climate change, but less than the estimates of what it would cost to mitigate it. > isn't even sure mankind would survive +5°C. Humans live in Siberia and the Antarctic. The human species will survive. But whether civilization survives is a different question.
- JoshTko 6y agoThis article, or at least the title, is silly. Profit is going to be tiny for any company during growth so profit from credits will seem to have outsize impact on profit. Tesla has industry leading gross margins at >20% so their profit will come predominantly from selling cars once fully at scale.