5 ms·
Fractional reserve banking in the real economy is utterly irrelevant thanks to the FDIC backstopping a run. In the last [edit: 88] years nobody had lost a singl
by arcticbull 6y ago
Fractional reserve banking in the real economy is utterly irrelevant thanks to the FDIC backstopping a run. In the last [edit: 88] years nobody had lost a single penny to a bank run or default including 2008s WaMu default thanks to the FDIC.
Crypto fractional reserve like tether has no backstop and that’s a completely different beast. It’s what exacerbated the Great Depression.
As with all blockchain unless the state is 100% totally and utterly encapsulated within the blockchain, then it’s garbage in, garbage immutably recorded. Which is why the only thing you can do with crypto is currency and kitties.
- nayuki 6y agoShort-selling shares is basically a form of fractional reserve banking. A short squeeze is essentially equivalent to a bank run. Where is the FDIC helping to backstop a run on shares?
- arcticbull 6y agoIt’s not a bank run, it’s poor risk management and the FDIC doesn’t insure brokerages, that’s the SIPC. Poor risk management is very much not covered by any federal program. Their liabilities are between them and their brokers, and if contagion spreads, their private insurers. This is why you can only short in a margin account and are required to put up collateral. If you sold short 140% of float and bought calls to cover, then we wouldn’t be having this conversation. Play stupid games, win stupid prizes. Similarly if I bought a bunch of stuff on margin and it went under overnight, RIP my account. You can lose money in both directions. “140% of float” doesn’t really mean more shares were sold than exist. There are after all only 100%. It means the same shares were sold more than once by the same or different people, and buying them back cancels the debt obligation.
- ashtonkem 6y agoFrom a social level, there is a huge difference between a bank run and a short squeeze. One affects regular savings, the other wipes out only those that opted into a high risk short position.
- lazyasciiart 6y agoUnless those that opted in are “too big to fail”, and then everyone else pays for it.
- ashtonkem 6y agoIf you’re talking about 2008, then they actually paid for it. The loans that the US government made during the crisis actually paid themselves back with some interest.
- lazyasciiart 6y agoThey still paid for it at the time, and that's why the ones who got themselves into risky positions did not get wiped out. My engineering degree had a great ROI but I still paid for it.
- srkigo 6y agoSo how much do you need to reserve?
- arcticbull 6y agoFor volatile stocks like GME on IBKR right now, 300%, so very much the opposite of fractional reserve banking. Well, fractional, but the numerator is far larger than the denominator.
- tlb 6y agoIt's less than 100 years since thousands of banks collapsed in the early 1930s and most depositors lost their money. The FDIC was created in 1933 and has prevented losses since.
- arcticbull 6y agoIndeed, I was rounding, and poorly at that. Thanks for the correction!
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> then it’s garbage in, garbage immutably recorded. This is the major weakness of proposals to put everything on the blockchain. In real-world scenarios, accidents happen. Records must be corrected. Voting is a great example. If we moved voting to the blockchain, it wouldn't automatically solve fraudulent voting problems. It would just record fraudulent votes on the blockchain. If your grandma accidentally loses her private voting keys to hackers, do we just roll over and let the hackers vote as your grandma? Obviously not. Any future blockchain solutions to anything government-related will certainly have corrective measures and overrides overlaid on top. It's not like we're going to sit back and watch people lose their house because hackers stole the private keys to their property deed, or forbid someone from selling their car because they can't remember the password to their title wallet.
- Tenoke 6y ago>If your grandma accidentally loses her private voting keys to hackers, do we just roll over and let the hackers vote as your grandma? Obviously not. It's not obvious to me why not. It's a trade-off. You put the responsibility on the user to keep their keys but you save a lot by not spending anything on solving fake or real issues like this. In this case if you want assurances like this you can trust a third party that handles that stuff for you.
- oblio 6y agoThe real world wants assurances. That's why every country has central banks, notaries, central depositories, etc. > It's a trade-off. You put the responsibility on the user to keep their keys. Just like for driving or flying or almost any important occupation, we don't only "put responsibility on the user". We have laws against abuse.
- Tenoke 6y agoWe also allow things like bearer shares and gold coins which simply provide value to whoever has them.
- erichocean 6y ago> In the last 100 years nobody had lost a single penny to a bank run or default including 2008s WaMu default. Debasement of the currency, however, has been…high. So you didn't "lose" that dollar from a hundred years ago, it's just worth about a penny now. Where'd the other $0.99 go?
- arcticbull 6y agoAnother irrelevant talking point. The whole point of inflation is to encourage investment as money is only worth something as it flows through the economy. You’re not supposed to save money under the mattress you’re supposed to save value by purchasing assets. A hundred years ago buying roughly speaking any asset would have preserved your entire wealth or created tons of new wealth. Wages have on average kept pace with inflation. You keep a small slush fund for a rainy day in a savings account that at least partially offsets inflation and you invest the rest. You don’t save money, you save value. You transact money. If you’re saving money you’re doing it wrong. This is ECON101.
- IG_Semmelweiss 6y agoI respectfully disagree. The whole point of inflation is to monetize the crazy debt spirals by empires. Its why the romans did it, why the Germans did it, why the british did it , and its why we do it. It doesn't take an econ degree to know that. That was the reason the gold window was closed in the first place. If the whole point of inflation, mind you, is to encourage investment, then why does the fed react by spiking interest rates in the , 60s' 70's, 82 to address inflation...yet introducing a bona fide investment meltdown ? Thats what reveals the facade. If the purpose of inflation was to encourage investment, it is certainly an odd to react to inflation by increasing interest rates, and destroying business investment in the process. >>>>>>You’re not supposed to save money under the mattress, s you’re supposed to save value by purchasing assets. This sure sounds like you know better than everyone else. Its probably an attitude that would be frowned upon by someone that believes in freedom of choice, like we do in USA. >>>>Wages have on average kept pace with inflation. I don't know if that is true since you have no sources, but the total count of people living in the US under the poverty line is exactly where it was in 1959, and now, post pandemic, it is certainly far higher. So even if wages kept pace, which is uncertain, with technology advances and the dollar as the reserve currency, you would expect the total number of people to be lower. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Number_in_Poverty_and_Poverty_Rate,_1959_to_2017.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Number_in_Poverty_and_Pov... >>>>>>>You keep a small slush fund for a rainy day in a savings account that at least partially offsets inflation and you invest the rest. You don’t save money, you save value. You transact money. If you’re saving money you’re doing it wrong. This is valid because there is inflation. But it saddens me to think that you think it is perfectly rational and acceptable to steal money from the savings of hardworking people, who often have to fend off scams left and right...and thus keep the money for themselves, for no real reason other than that it is what... you think.