3 ms·
Probably because those are theoretical losses. The previous paragraph is also relevant: >However, Robinhood is not legally bound to carry out every trade and t
by gruez 6y ago
Probably because those are theoretical losses. The previous paragraph is also relevant:
>However, Robinhood is not legally bound to carry out every trade and the lawsuits will not succeed without evidence the company restricted trading for an improper reason, such as to favor certain investors, according to several legal experts.
As mentioned in other threads, robinhood wasn't able to come up with the deposit needed for their customers trades. In that case I don't see how it's any different than a service outage causing you to lose money, but you don't have a SLA in place.
- Alex3917 6y ago> As mentioned in other threads, robinhood wasn't able to come up with the deposit needed for their customers trades. That's not true, they only blocked trades on those specific stocks. If it was really a liquidity issue then they could have rate limited all trades equally regardless of the stock in question.
- MattGaiser 6y agoThose particular stocks had their deposit requirements increase, not all stocks.
- Anon1096 6y agoThe deposit requirements on those stocks were increased from 2% to 100%.
- gruez 6y agoNot really, because the amount of deposit you need to put up is proportional to the volatility, among other factors. Therefore it makes sense to shut down trading for the stocks that incur a disproportionately high amount of deposit requirements for them. I guess it's possible for them to say "fuck it" and let everything trade until they run out of money, but I don't think they have an obligation to do that.
- ssorallen 6y agoThe collateral required by Robinhood’s clearing house to trade these stocks was raised to 100%, and it takes 2 days for trades to clear. Required collateral for other equities was not raised so there was no reason any other equities needed to be limited.
- freeone3000 6y agoYou'll notice on Friday, a list of stocks with high volatility had restricted trading - including non-meme stocks, like AMD. It's a reaction to higher holding percentages.
- nullc 6y agoThe collateral requirements differ from stock to stock.
- LegitShady 6y agoThe liquidity claim on tv was never supported and was later retracted. David Portnoy also called it out directly as well. Liquidity was not the reason for Robin hoods actions.
- loceng 6y agoFavor certain investors - like the ones shorting? This isn't going to be an obvious clear cut case, and there will be plenty of gaslighting as part of the TENS of billions of $ on the line.
- gruez 6y agoJust because their decision favored another party doesn't mean it was malicious and they would be liable. If at&t had to shut down their network for 2 hours because of a botched firmware update, that would heavily favor the hedge funds (who probably have redundant connections), but that doesn't mean you can go after them for not being able to sell your GME stocks.
- loceng 6y agoThe communications records of everyone involved will paint that picture for us, as to whether favours were played or not.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y agoAssuming someone was dumb enough to put any potential shady deal in writing. Wouldn't be the first time, but it requires a special kind of incompetence to do that.
- FireBeyond 6y agoAnd to be clear, the ones shorting _against_ the position _your customers hold_.
- bmitc 6y agoBut there is the possibility that Robinhood was also cutting trading to appease Citadel, who to my understanding, just happened to re-engage their short positions right before Robinhood cut buying to Gamestop stock. If the story about Robinhood running out of money is true, why wouldn't they just ban buying on margin and not all buying? I don't understand that.
- elliekelly 6y ago> If the story about Robinhood running out of money is true, why wouldn't they just ban buying on margin and not all buying? I don't understand that. Because DTCC requires cash collateral while the transaction is settled whether the transaction happens in a margin account or a cash account. There's no distinction from DTCC's perspective. DTCC (reportedly) increased the collateral on $GME transactions to 100% of the transaction price compared to the typical 1-3% of the price.
- MattGaiser 6y agoBecause anyone buying right away after funding an account or selling the same day as buying is buying on margin. Margin is used to make a lot of the "instant" stuff happen. True cash accounts make them difficult to use for the day trading these people like to do. https://finance.zacks.com/tax-rules-use-proceeds-stock-sales-buy-new-stocks-8465.html https://finance.zacks.com/tax-rules-use-proceeds-stock-sales... https://www.fidelity.com/learning-center/trading-investing/trading/avoiding-cash-trading-violations https://www.fidelity.com/learning-center/trading-investing/t...
- ALittleLight 6y agoI don't understand the "deposit needed" aspect. I can't buy 2 shares of AMC at 12 dollars each but can buy 200 shares of TSLA at 800 each? How does that work?