11 ms·
Dark Patterns at Scale: Findings from a Crawl of 11K Shopping Websites (2019)
- jonnypotty 6y agoInsurance company I use to work for made it really difficult to actually buy their car insurance online cos they'd virtually always loose money if you bought their online deals. The website tried to get you to phone with your quote so that sales reps could bump your price up for basically no reason. If this was too much then they'd pretend to talk to their manager for a few mins to "see if they could get you a good deal" come back on the phone and make up another price for you. Worked on old people best. Lovely.
- nicbou 6y agoDid it increase total profit? I won't pick up the phone unless I have no other option, and I won't call someone just to get a quote. Besides, those sales rep cost money too.
- Nextgrid 6y agoI bet it doesn't make any more profit than an equivalent service managed fully online, but making all the people in the current operation redundant is "politically" difficult (or even impossible/very costly depending on employment laws) so they continue as-is.
- jonnypotty 6y agoYes it did.
- jakevoytko 6y agoThis is interesting - I feel like the site should separate dark patterns that add information from ones that lie or obfuscate. In my experience, consumers feel differently about these categories. I've sat in on a few dozen user research sessions for ecommerce. This was qualitative research that included their general shopping habits, and additionally testing new features. The most interesting thing that I learned is that consumers (a) are generally pretty aware of when they're being pressured, and (b) are fine if it's transparent and accurate. A classic example of this were low-stock notifications. The shoppers were generally okay with being told that something was low stock if that was really true. Many people could name specific items they lost because they were sold out. Some could also name instances of when they had bought something "1 item remaining" and seen it on sale the next day. They preferred having the information because it helped them make an informed decision. It turns out that lots of people browse the same items for a while, and use sales or almost-out-of-stock as a "now or never" moment. The most interesting user session I ever sat in on was for a countdown timer for a sale ending. The designer refused to design it at first, and then was like, "fine, I'm going to design the hell out of this and then show you in user research that nobody wants this." And then she showed it to 5 people in user research, who were generally okay with it on the condition that it counted down to the actual sale ending. Some said they actually liked knowing, because when they're just looking on their phones they might not be in a good position to buy it, and want to know how much time they have later to get it. They said that they'll often refresh the page to see if the timer resets, because if it starts ticking from the same time, they feel like the site is just scammy and they'll leave. Anyways, I'm not trying to defend lots of these patterns. Most of them are clearly wrong, and the ones that I mentioned above can also be used to lie and deceive. But I wouldn't put them all together - in my experience, consumers generally want accurate information even if they're aware that the company is doing it to pressure them.
- inetknght 6y ago> In my experience, consumers feel differently about these categories. So the ends justify the means if people are okay with it?
- mattcwilson 6y agoIf consumers prefer a pattern, who is harmed by its use?
- Y_Y 6y agoConsumers.
- vharuck 6y agoI think it's more the reasons, if they include honest facts, partially justify the means. Of course, this could be because everyone thinks they're to smart to be influenced. In which case, they appreciate the true information but ignore the psyops.
- marcosdumay 6y agoThe example session makes it clearer that they are talking about fake social proof and artificial urgency (if the promotion ends in 15 minutes, it is a fake one created just when you entered the site, real ones last until a round time or for days). Unless the examples are misleading, they should just name those categories better.
- phasetransition 6y agoThanks, it was not clear to me how e.g. (genuine) social proof is a dark pattern
- jakevoytko 6y agoTotally, I agree that some of their specific examples mention this. Reading the whole site, it was not clear to me whether they holistically viewed "being honest about these things" as inside or outside the scope of their categorization, which prompted my comment
- 6chars 6y agoI believe this kind of thing is a big contributor to Amazon's hegemony in online shopping. I'm reluctant to order from other sites because there's a whole new set of dark patterns I may fall victim to. At least I'm familiar enough with Amazon to know I'm not getting charged for things I didn't intend to order, the low stock warnings are somewhat legitimate, etc. I'm not saying Amazon doesn't have its own issues, but at least it's a known quantity. If it weren't for Amazon's dominance, other sites would be able to compete without resorting to these dark patterns, so this is a self-perpetuating cycle: people only shop on Amazon -> the only other sites that can survive are the ones that engage in deception -> trust in non-Amazon shopping sites decreases -> people only shop on Amazon -> ... I don't mean to cast these scammy shopping websites as victims. My concern is more about how the legitimate sites that could exist don't because they're crowded out by Amazon (and other big players like Walmart) and the scammy shopping sites this article discusses.
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoSimilar for platforms that let you build ecommerce sites, like Shopify, Squarespace, Wix, etc. They might be cookie cutter and usually over-priced for the level of hosting you get and the poorness of the wysiwyg site editing experience, but they solve a big problem of letting you get up and running with a trustworthy site fast. It’s interesting though because there still are plenty of scam sites hosted by those platforms, plenty of dark patterns on Amazon too.
- Nextgrid 6y ago> other sites would be able to compete without resorting to these dark patterns Is there any evidence that e-commerce sites were any less scummy before Amazon started competing?
- 6chars 6y agoI don't have any evidence to back this up, but in my recollection, that is the case. But it's hard to even compare e-commerce now to back before Amazon, when the web was much more niche and a lot of dark patterns weren't even technically possible yet. It would be interesting to see where e-commerce would be today if a company as dominant as Amazon never came about. My hypothesis is that people would have more trust in a random shopping site they click on when Googling a product they want to buy, but it's impossible to test that.
- kmfrk 6y agoIs there a decent domain blocklist of the offending scripts used for this?
- jacquesm 6y agodeny: all allow: news.ycombinator.com
- fortran77 6y agoIn California, if you sign up for something on-line the law requires that you be able to cancel it on-line, too. This has been a wonderful development, and now it's easy to cancel things like XM subscriptions, etc.
- dd36 6y agoSince when? I tried to cancel NYTimes and it was an ordeal.
- fortran77 6y agoHere's some information: https://www.cnet.com/news/companies-must-let-customers-cancel-subscriptions-online-california-law-says/#:~:text=A%20California%20law%20that%20went%20into%20effect%20July,must%20be%20able%20to%20cancel%20the%20service%20online https://www.cnet.com/news/companies-must-let-customers-cance.... And here's the Bill that became the law: https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtml?bill_id=201720180SB313 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtm...
- TT3351 6y agoI had great results switching my payment method to recurring via PayPal and then using the PayPal interface to cancel the recurring charge, FWIW. Any time a merchant with recurring charges lets you use PayPal you can usually cancel the subscription in that way.
- anaerobicover 6y agoI did the same for a magazine that made cancellation all but impossible, using a virtual credit card. I switched the payment method for the subscription and set the card to deny all charges. Then I just had to endure two months of "you're losing access to your subscription" spam. :/
- scarlac 6y agoSame situation for Denmark and possibly other European countries
- cratermoon 6y agoWasn't there an article here recently about some site that was supposedly telling you how many other people were looking at the same item, and a look a the javascript showed that it was basically a (small) random number generated on page load?
- sriku 6y agoIt lists "forced enrollment" as an example of "forced action" which is tangential action required tobe completed. For me, a recpatcha step asking me to classify traffix lights or cars is one as well.
- is_true 6y agoI've implented the urgency pattern but it was purely based on finances. We needed cash flow to make some payments.
- tyingq 6y agoIf you've never used it before, try out https://booking.com https://booking.com They are fairly infamous for fishy looking inventory warnings, aggressive push to register/login, cross/up sell, etc.
- danpalmer 6y agoThere's also a secret search term that turns on every single live A/B test, making the site essentially unusable. I don't know what it is but a Booking.com employee may be willing to share if you every catch them after a few drinks.
- reaperducer 6y agoCan confirm. I've had booking.com tell me "Hurry! There are only x rooms left!" when I've been to the property before, and know that x is a number larger than the entire number of rooms that exist.
- omnibrain 6y agoIt's really bad, but it's still my favourite site to book hotels. I can filter for all criterias that matter to me and have all my bookings in one place. And their hotline worked for me when something went wrong. Luckily my brain can filter most of the dark patterns.
- tyingq 6y agoYes, there appears to be good talent there. All the darkish patterns also add up to a really high conversion. Also, Perl is apparently the backend, which gives me a bit of nostalgia.
- tgv 6y agoI do (did) use it too, but then book through the hotel's own website, unless the price difference is too big. I'm not going to oversubsidize some search engine.
- MikeDelta 6y agoIndeed, sometimes the same hotel has a better offer on their website. We always double check. BTW, booking got fined by the Hungarian Watchdog for 6.1 million GBP for these practices [0]. [0] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-booking-hldg-hungary-idUSKCN22A3AZ https://www.reuters.com/article/us-booking-hldg-hungary-idUS...
- veselin 6y agoWhat concerns me when reading such articles is that if lying is so prevalent and there is still no action against the bad actors, then the GDPR tracking checkboxes on many sites are likely also just sent to /dev/null? At least in my experience, one gets subscribed to many things they explicitly opted out from. It is very easy to say later if somebody digs to just say yes was clicked instead of no or there was a bug affecting a small portion of their traffic.
- julianlam 6y agoThis is the second time I've seen an article rise to the top of HN after I've heard it on CBC's Spark. Interesting...
- vz8 6y agoAs I write this, I am attempting to reduce the number of licenses allocated in the Adobe admin portal. After hunting through the site, it appears easy to add, but impossible to remove licenses without going through sales support (instant response with a human), who then transfer you to the "Cancellation Team" which are remarkably hard to find online and have not replied to previous attempts at cancellation. This is my third try, and the wait has been ridiculous. After finally being connected to a member of their cancellation team, they are "reviewing my request" and 1-2 minutes (please stand by) has turned into 15+ This experience has been so bad (on top of many others), that I'm strongly considering moving our entire org to open source tools (aside from InDesign for the publications group, which our partners require).
- wildrhythms 6y agoTruly disgusting. Why is it normal to be able to sign up for a service (such as internet service) completely self-service, with no human interaction, but as soon as I want to cancel the service, I have to call a 1-800 number and interact with a human? Comcast/Xfinity does this. Anti-consumer at best.
- yabudemada 6y agoIf you do, please be sure to donate (time or money) to the open source projects to help better them! This is how open source can exceed commercial software. At the very worst case, if the projects tumble there's always a possibility to "fork" as an insurance policy.
- vz8 6y agoWe do, and thanks for mentioning it, it's worth bringing up. We donate to various projects: on Github, FSF, EFF, direct to a developers, and even Patreon in one case. Autodesk had our money for a while, then we moved to use and support Blender and never looked back. ... we even bought a license to WinRAR, I kid you not.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoWinRAR isn't Open Source. I'm curious though, why go with rar rather than, say, 7z?
- swiley 6y ago*manipulation "Dark patterns" sounds like some cheesy term someone uses when they don't want to admit malice.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- aww_dang 6y agoSome of the things listed are sales techniques I expect from a business. If businesses want to set themselves apart by being more straightforward, that's another way to sell. I'm left wondering if the authors take advertisements at face value as well? "After extensive research, we found that the stain could be removed, but not as easily as shown in the TV advert. As academics, we conclude that this is dark and deceptive."
- nottorp 6y ago> Some of the things listed are sales techniques I expect from a business. Sounds like Stockholm Syndrome to me?
- secfirstmd 6y agoOne of the worst I came across is TeamViewer. You can sign up instantly for your organisation. They throughout your time on them send you a spammy marketing email once every 3 to 5 days - the sort of stuff that's everyone ignores. You get one renewal remind amongst all that crap a week before your final month, usually sandwiched between two other mails. Then when you want to cancel it...there is no easy link to cancel online they way their is to sign up. To top it off, you have to cancel it before that final month before hand by opening up a ticket on their system. Then it's not automatically cancelled, they setup a call to speak to a rep. If you miss that and then you enter your final month - they automatically renew and make you pay for another year up front! Even endless calls with the German call centre does not get a refund for this dark pattern. TLDR: avoid TeamViewer
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoImagine if each of the the web developers creating these websites actually ran a physical store and had to deal face-to-face with the public. Real, live customer service. No keyboard to hide behind. What would those businesses be like? Would anyone shop there?
- CyanDeparture 6y agoI am massively against most of these, but I think a few are ok: - Low-stock Message - when this data is true, I'm very happy to see it. I can say for sure it's true on the nike website, thing have gone out of stock an hour later or after I have ordered it. So I appreciate it when it's true. - Countdown timers - A countdown timer to the end of a sale seem perfectly reasonable to me. Some sales are quite good and I like to know when they're going to end.