11 ms·
If you read the other threads it's clear what's happening is that robinhood's product isn't designed to cope with high volatility[1]. Is this a flaw in their pr
by gruez 6y ago
If you read the other threads it's clear what's happening is that robinhood's product isn't designed to cope with high volatility[1]. Is this a flaw in their product? Yes. But then again, they are a discount brokerage for a reason. It's not any different than any other consumer product that shits the bed during 99.9 percentile events.
[1] Specifically, they're required by the DTCC to put up a deposit on every trade their users make. During periods of low volatility this is fine because they can come up with the money, but when volatility goes up so do the deposit requirements, which can cause them to become insolvent. This is further compounded by the fact that their product invisibly hands out margin, eg. "instant" deposits of $1000, or giving you the money before it settles (2 days later).
- nightski 6y agoObviously the situation needs to be investigated. But I think there is a real possibility they did nothing wrong here. Despite this, the main problem I see with Robinhood is that with it's gamified UI, ease of access, etc... these 99.9 percentile events are mainly what it is designed for. It's encouraging people to pick up the "hot stock" on social media on a whim. While there may not be legal repercussions for this, it's fundamentally incapable of it's core purpose. If you are new to RH you might not realize that the platform has outages all the time and it costs its users a lot of money. It is straight up dangerous to trade on this platform for the purpose which the UI glorifies. Index funds have done a lot more to democratize finance than RH in my personal view. While commission free sounds fantastic, it comes with some very large hidden costs.
- newacct583 6y agoThat I think is the real scandal here. Robinhood was built to market to (and in some sense coevolve with) the wallstreetbets culture of crowd-sourced market manipulation. And that was a great growth hack. Until it grew enough that the crowd source market manipulation was... actually manipulating significant markets. GME has been ballooned to the tune of something like $13B over the past few days, based almost entirely on a flawed understanding of short trading. And absent any discussion about Robinhood in particular, I think we need to be asking whether or not this crowd of people who didn't quite understand shorts were fed those lies at the direction of users who did. Someone has (or will have) made a ton of money here at the expense of the late-arriving GME traders. It seems like we should find out who.
- Miner49er 6y agoWhat is the flaw in the understanding of shorting?
- newacct583 6y agoMost people seem to have been led to understand that the short leverage of 140% meant that when the short call happens, the hedge fund will "have to buy more stock than exists" to settle, and thus that something like an infinite price spike will happen. The same people tend to refer to this as a "naked short", which it is not[1]. Most of these people seem to have latched onto a theory that the short calls are all coming due today and that they NEED to buy as much GME as possible ahead of the metaphorical rapture. But the hedge funds in question closed out their short positions days ago. The stock right now is being propped up by simple (and misinformed) speculation. And effectively all of the purchase price that people are paying right now is going to end up being transferred to the people with earlier positions who are getting out at the peak of the bubble. [1] A naked short is a short sale where no underlying stock was borrowed first. This is a crime, but only possible for certain very privileged traders with control over the various tracking records. Leverage over 100% just means (for example) that you borrowed a share, sold it, then later went to the same buyer and borrowed it again. You end up owing them "two shares", but not necessarily the same share twice. In practice what happened is that as the stock started rising, Melvin closed its position buy repeatedly buying and returning shares to the tune of 140% of the capitalization. (Edit to add: it seems likely that it did so in combination with a bunch of loans and favors from other hedge funds with the ability to buy and hold GME across the inevitable collapse. The WSB folks complaining about hedge fund corruption and insider dealing aren't wrong.)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- samstave 6y agoHow does one borrow a share of stock?
- vincentmarle 6y ago> But I think there is a real possibility they did nothing wrong here. They did blatantly lie about their liquidity problems. They didn't mention it in their fluff blog post. Their CEO smirked on national TV and insisted it was not about liquidity. Turns out it was. That's the problem.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoNo sector of the finance industry is ever honest about liquidity... too much fear of a panic.
- lupire 6y agoIB chairman was honest, and WSBers predicably called him a criminal for it. https://www.cnbc.com/2021/01/28/interactive-brokers-restricted-gamestop-trading-to-protect-the-market-says-chairman-peterffy.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/01/28/interactive-brokers-restrict...
- ashtonkem 6y agoI wouldn’t really take any subreddit on its word about what the law is and who has broken it.
- swalsh 6y agoThe messaging was certainly problematic. But the actions seem to be done in good faith.
- valuearb 6y agoIf he admitted how close they were to insolvency Robinhood would be out of business and no one would be getting their trades closed. Financial firms never warn about liquidity issues to prevent a run on their bank.
- FemmeAndroid 6y agoNot commenting and saying it wasn’t a liquidity event are very different things.
- cma 6y ago> Despite this, the main problem I see with Robinhood is that with it's gamified UI, ease of access, etc... these 99.9 percentile events are mainly what it is designed for. It's encouraging people to pick up the "hot stock" on social media on a whim. Landline phones and CNBC in the dot com boom and after could do much the same. They had a show where a guy just yelled out symbols all angry with cheesy soundboard effects. Only difference was higher commissions and no buying into fractional shares and stuff.
- mike00632 6y agoThere are worse problems with Robinhood, all of which I'm surprised people aren't bringing up more: 1) They've had outages where 100% of stocks were unavailable for trading. 2) Their business model is to offer their users inferior prices and then collect on the arbitrage (Yes, this is illegal. Yes, they are in trouble with the SEC over it). 3) Robinhood isn't transparent with their users about the risks of trading options and trading on margin. Some of the barriers they've removed for their users to make risky bets were there for regulatory reasons, it's not just a matter of their app being over-gamified.
- MrMan 6y agothank you
- alexpetralia 6y ago(2) is false. You can't offer "inferior prices" to customers. It's called the Order Protection Rule of RegNMS. You must price improve the customer, by law. If a bid-offer is 23.01/23.02, Robinhood (but actually Citadel/Two Sigma) _must_ transact with a buy order at 23.0199 or less (the subpenny rule only applies to quotes, not actual trades). The reason Robinhood sells this order flow is because Citadel/Two Sigma would rather collect a spread of almost 1 cent (23.0199-23.01) from _you_ rather than a hedge fund, who may conceivably move the market against the market maker. They are "paying for order flow" (PFOF) - much less than 1 cent - to collect the 1 cent spread from you. Robinhood is in trouble with the SEC for a failure to disclose this relationship to customers, _not_ for having the economic arrangement to begin with.
- filoleg 6y ago(1) is pretty weak too. Yes, they had outages where 100% of stocks were unavailable for trading, which is factually true. What makes that assertion weaker is the fact that other brokerages had the same kind of outages too, and not with less frequency of occurrence either. Which is why (1) is not really a meaningful point against RH specifically.
- 6y ago
- ghaff 6y agoCommission free is pretty much the norm these days. There are exceptions, but the norm. I don't disagree that, for most people, just investing in index funds is probably the best approach.
- lupire 6y agoThis is the weird part. If RH is in the wrong, the crime they committed was giving users what the users thought they wanted (all gas, no brakes, no seatbelts).
- ashtonkem 6y agoIt seems to me like the regulatory framework around brokerages like Robinhood that gamify trading need to be fixed, but it smells like something that’ll take an act of congress.
- Dma54rhs 6y agoWhich makes retail harder to invest and one of the reasons why people are mad is that they are not allowed to participate in the stock market. It doesn't seem like there's a winning formula here. The term professional investor is already under fire but it's literally by the decision makers to protect you. Not many people like that.
- YinglingLight 6y agoCitadel fulfills most of Robinhoood's orders. Citadel owns Melvin Capital, which is collapsing as we speak. Our new Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen has been paid $810k by Citadel for her orator skills. Our new Press Secretary stated that Yellen will not recuse herself from any potential involvement with GME.
- himinlomax 6y agoThis explanation is plausible, but then the question becomes RH's lack of openness, and its CEO's laughable non-answers in interviews on the issues. Their hands may be tied here, but they look bad any way you look at it, and for good reasons.
- valuearb 6y agoThe only honest answer the CEO can give is “we are a thinly capitalized startup with a unique business model, that meant when the DTCC jacked margin requirements on BME further trades would have pushed us into insolvency” That’s not the kind of message any CEO wants to put out in public,
- rdiddly 6y agoIt can be spun. "We did it to ensure the stability and integrity of our platform."
- valuearb 6y agoSure but if the the statement gets too close to admitting a liquidity crisis the market will close their doors the next day.
- himinlomax 6y agoThat maybe a reason to lie, but that's still fucking lying.
- Miner49er 6y ago> [1] Specifically, they're required by the DTCC to put up a deposit on every trade their users make. During periods of low volatility this is fine because they can come up with the money, but when volatility goes up so do the deposit requirements, which can cause them to become insolvent. This is further compounded by the fact that their product invisibly hands out margin, eg. "instant" deposits of $1000, or giving you the money before it settles (2 days later). Assuming they aren't allowing any margin to be used on GME (including instant deposits) how could they possibly not come up with the money? Does that mean they are doing other stuff with users money and only fractionally paying for shares? The clearinghouse (normally) just assumes they are good for it if they ever need to come get it? EDIT: Apparently it is a fractional deposit that the clearing house requires. Apparently though, it can't be client money. So my next question is, why is that?
- tonfa 6y ago> So my next question is, why is that? Don't most brokers allow you to continue trading before settlement? (so someone has to put collateral for that) I guess most traders would complain if they had to wait two days after every trade :) Edit, maybe best is to look at the explanation from Money Stuff: > But at some level of volatility things break down. If a stock is really worth $400 on Monday and $20 on Wednesday, there is a risk that a lot of the people who bought it on Monday won’t show up with cash on Wednesday. Something very bad happened to them between Monday and Wednesday; some of them might not have made it. You need to make sure the collateral is sufficient to cover that risk.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Miner49er 6y ago> Don't most brokers allow you to continue trading before settlement? (so someone has to put collateral for that) Sure, but I wonder why RH didn't just change their rules to being that you won't be able to trade instantly with any sold GME, and then used client funds as collateral? This seems much better than stopping buying altogether. I suppose maybe the code wasn't in place for something like this, idk.
- psychlops 6y agoI wouldn't call it a flaw. Their product can handle the high volatility, their finances can't. At least, that's what we believe is true since they got a $1B loan yesterday. But Tenev, the CEO, was on TV yesterday saying that it wasn't a solvency issue...so.... Interactive Brokers Chairman, Petterfy, highlights that in his interview. He also said it caused clearing issues and that his firm could afford it. They just, you know, decided to halt trading cause he thinks the squeeze was illegal.
- valuearb 6y agoThe only thing Robinhood is lying about is their solvency.
- bilbo0s 6y agoI agree. I would bet they don't have available funds. They framed it as, "We're stopping this to help you." But the reality was more like, "We're stopping this because we can't legally facilitate any more of these trades since we don't have the money to spare."
- pishpash 6y agoIt is both, they need to help themselves and help customers who would be harmed if Robinhood had gone under suddenly. An orderly unwinding is better for everyone.
- psychlops 6y agoI believe this as well. He did not do himself any favors and let himself be cornered on two interviews. I respect that he cannot come out and say they have solvency issues, as his accounts would empty fast turning a potential solvency issue into a real one. But he didn't seem to even have a clear idea of, nor a numerical way to explain why they were having settlement issues. My guess is that they will be spending more money in their clearing department this year.
- shawndrost 6y agoDo you believe that about all the brokerages that halted trading on GME et al? Or did Robinhood call a halt due to insolvency, and coincidentally, other brokerages called a halt for unrelated reasons?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- crazynick4 6y agoI think volatility is an issue for any broker. Does RH wait to confirm an order until they find a counterparty or does their system just accept it and then find someone to clear it with after the fact? If it's the latter, and they find themselves in a situation of extreme volatility/zero liquidity, they could end up holding the bag.