8 ms·
Could be? It's an open, publicly-documented market manipulation event. How can there be any question about it? You might decide that this kind of manipulation i
by jeffbee 6y ago
Could be? It's an open, publicly-documented market manipulation event. How can there be any question about it? You might decide that this kind of manipulation is OK due to it's stated goals, but that doesn't make it not manipulation.
- willcipriano 6y ago>Could be? It's an open, publicly-documented market manipulation event. Strange question, what's the bar for market manipulation? For example if a company took out debt to buy their own stock in order to drive up the price would that count?
- jeffbee 6y agoIf the company were to issue a statement that they believed their actions would raise the share price, then yes. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/15/78i https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/15/78i
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pbourke 6y agoSo do everything up to specifically stating the effect that you want, and it’s not market manipulation? This is the “emperor’s new clothes” absurdity of this whole system. The whole fucking market has been manipulated by various parties this year, most notably by the Federal Reserve, yet there’s only a moral panic when some firefighter from Long Island gets a little taste?
- foolmeonce 6y agoStock buy back is perfectly fine and its authorization is usually announced in a press release. Hiding that you are taking new debt to do just about anything would be illegal.
- moolcool 6y agoI can't find any documentation that a short squeeze is illegal. Can you?
- TeMPOraL 6y agoIt's in the SEC rules. "Although some short squeezes may occur naturally in the market, a scheme to manipulate the price or availability of stock in order to cause a short squeeze is illegal." From https://www.sec.gov/investor/pubs/regsho.htm https://www.sec.gov/investor/pubs/regsho.htm. It's an open question whether this case is more of a natural occurrence or "a scheme to manipulate", given that it's all randos who found a Schelling point and are now hyping each other up. I think it's fair to say it's unprecedented.
- OscarCunningham 6y agoIf I were the short-sellers I'd be a bit aggrieved at the SEC not going after WSB here. People keep saying that the hedge funds 'knew what they were getting into', and are therefore fair game. But they could well have thought that they were protected by this regulation. It's unlucky for them that they got squeezed by loveable retail investors rather than another hedge fund that the SEC would have no qualms about prosecuting. In the debate between the free market vs regulation, the worst possible outcome is to have people thinking they are protected by regulation when they in fact aren't.
- willcipriano 6y agoThe shorters should form a class action and sue wall street bets, I'm sure a 5 dollar check in 3 years and a year of free stonk advice will cover it right?
- jsmith45 6y agoWall street bets is not an organization, and does not really even have a defined membership, and I've never heard of a court case with a class as a defendant. But I suppose that would be a really amusing circus show. Class of shorters vs class of buyers.
- hansvm 6y agoThere's a bit of nuance. We're using the word "manipulation" to mean two different things -- one is the colloquial meaning, and yes it's very obvious that the price was manipulated in that sense. As far as the legal definition of manipulation is concerned though, we haven't necessarily met all the requirements.
- bwilliams18 6y agoMatt Levine did a pretty good job explaining why it probably doesn't fit the traditional definition of market manipulation in his newsletter on Tuesday[1], see the second section titled "But is it securities fraud?" [1]https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-01-26/will-wallstreetbets-face-sec-scrutiny-after-gamestop-rally https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2021-01-26/will-w...
- wslh 6y ago> It's an open, publicly-documented market manipulation event. I understand that if someone publicly give you a financial strategy that is sound and it is not based on a ponzi then it is a recommendation.
- Dirlewanger 6y agoEver think that they just like the stock?
- jeffbee 6y agoThat's the thing: there is NO QUESTION as to the motives of the r/wsb traders. They are overtly conspiring to raise the price of shares in order to force specific parties to buy it. That's manipulation!
- ceejayoz 6y agoIt's manipulation, but is it illegal manipulation? Remember, it's perfectly legal for a hedge fund to open a short position, and then release a big expose of the company that tanks its stock price. For a prominent recent example: https://hindenburgresearch.com/nikola/ https://hindenburgresearch.com/nikola/
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- TheCapn 6y ago>force specific parties to buy it I think they forced themselves to buy it by taking the short position they did.
- RHSeeger 6y agoIs it illegal to corner the market on a product because you know someone else is going to need to buy it, so you can charge them a lot because they must buy from you? It seems like what is being done is pretty much this; just for a large definition of "you".
- jeffbee 6y agoYes, it is broadly illegal to corner or attempt to corner any market, and the law directs the CFTC to step in and and void commodities contracts or take whatever other actions it deems appropriate when it finds that a market has been destabilized. See 7 USC 12a(9).
- gnfargbl 6y agoWhether or not it is market manipulation, who do you think the SEC could realistically go after here?
- jeffbee 6y agoMaybe one or two specific individuals, but you're right in general. That's the part that frightens me the most here. The tactics that are being used are equivalent to the ones used by sideshow street racers and political riots: if we get thousands of individuals to break the law at the same time and place then law enforcement will be ineffective.
- gnfargbl 6y agoIt certainly _feels_ like an organized riot, but I'm not 100% sure that it is. In a riot, there are organizers and instigators, and then there is a mob who follows them. Here, I'm not really sure that the organizers exist: the closest thing I can see is the Reddit user DeepFuckingValue, and all they do is post screenshots of their position in GME without futher comment. And have been doing so for the best part of a year. The mob seems to have largely formed itself.
- kchr 6y agoHave you heard of sock puppet accounts? Rogue agents? :-)
- hhhar42 6y agoYou really need to stop accusing thousands of people of lawbreaking when several actual securities lawyers with backgrounds in actual manipulation litigation have said it isn’t as cut and dry as you think. Tying the activity to the riots and suggesting similar organization is also beyond the pale. You have cited neither of those positions throughout your ranting here and they’re harmful speculation. Your commentary in this thread is over the top. I’d use a term you already have (edit: and deleted, looks like) which definitely applies, but I’m not stooping there, and you’re probably on your way to a flag for it anyway. I suggest you step back from HN for a few minutes, at least.
- moosey 6y agoApplying this logic, perhaps we can get "professional" stock ... manipulators off the TV. CNBC can go away entirely. Marketing speak would be replaced with value charts. Ban all forums that discuss specific stock values. Then prevent people from buying stocks in groups. Mutual funds, ETFs, etc... all of these abstractions on abstractions, we can throw them away. The more abstractions we throw away, the closer we get to what all this should actually be meant to serve; people.
- NoOneNew 6y agoAbsolutely. I mean, what's different now in comparison to Ackman shorting hotels then going on CNBC and saying hotels are going to burn financially? Except for the fact it's one rich guy compared to thousands (maybe millions?) of not so rich folks.
- mrlala 6y agoWell.. I think the difference is that if there are literally millions of people immediately acting in a certain fashion (suddenly buying up a specific stock) in a coordinate fashion- that has a very different effect than a small number of large investors taking a bet. I'm not defending the bullshit that is CNBC and 'professional stock pickers' and crap, but it ends up to be a very different thing. Not saying better or worse, but certainly different.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ericmay 6y agoWhich is one take, certainly. But the problem is once you say that this is a market manipulation event you run into other issues. Is going on CNBC and talking about the strength of a company that you invested in market manipulation? Before this blew up you certainly had more reach. Is posting "research" or holding a conference call and telling people a company is garbage while you have the company shorted market manipulation? What about when you short a company and sell a ton of shares to induce panic? What about algorithms that are created to trade shares to reach a certain profitable price based on internal holdings/analysis? Here's another thing - if WallStreetBets was incorporated into a hedge fund and took a huge long position is that market manipulation? It seems to me the main difference is that they aren't behind closed doors talking privately in a legal fiction called a company that is really the problem here... You have to define what you mean by manipulating the market and apply that equally under the eyes of the law. The fact that this was done publicly makes it all the more interesting. Had it been done behind closed doors (like so many things are on Wall Street) it would have been an open and shut case, but it wasn't. So sure, let's say it's a market manipulation event. Ok. Can you tell me what isn't a market manipulation event?
- jeffbee 6y agoYou are not the first person to ponder these questions. There is a great deal of jurisprudence on these topics. Any market participant firm's compliance desk can readily answer all of them.
- acover 6y agoIf wallstreetbets was a hedge fund and they bought all of GME to cause a short squeeze then that is market manipulation - this has been settled [0]. [0] - https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2013-159 https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2013-159 Edit: litigated to settled
- ericmay 6y agoIf WSB was a hedge fund they just have to buy some of GME - not all or even too much. Other hedge funds could buy some too. Just have a "dinner conversation" about it. Just like you and a few hedge funds can get together and collectively short GameStop and other companies... as they are doing now. There's no rule that I know of that says only one entity can make a specific investment. -edit- Don't forget that hedge funds ARE on the other side of this trade. WSB and retail do not have the ability to move this solely on their own. I wonder how long until they're on CNBC/Bloomberg "we saw a great opportunity in the market and executed our position well". If it's market manipulation - was it market manipulation to even have heard about WSB and entered the trade? WSB is a nice scapegoat for the real money that caught these hedge funds in a bad position. Didn't take long before WSB became alt-right, white supremacist, market manipulators... etc.
- qmmmur 6y agoPeople are free to purchase stock how they want to. If those people collect together and discuss potentially profitable strategies for trading who is to stop them? Do you think its possible youve fallen ill to the rhetoric that this is bad purely because the rich people didn't get their way?
- kshacker 6y agoBut people are not being allowed to purchase stock as they want. Robinhood now allows you to buy a grand total of 5 shares of GME.
- spydum 6y agothat's a service delivery problem, just like when a restaurant runs out of a popular dish. Go to another broker.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI have a general, all-purpose opposition to financial trading that’s about exploiting weird market structure tricks to screw people over rather than expressing beliefs about the value of the underlying things being traded. Institutional traders too often get away with doing that kind of thing, and I’m hardly losing sleep over the particular targets of this campaign, but we can’t let the takeaway here be “it’s fine as long as retail investors get to play too”.
- blackearl 6y agoThe issue with that argument is that it's really not “it’s fine as long as retail investors get to play too," it's “it’s fine until retail investors get to play too”
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoThe point is that it's not fine. The institutional investors who have historically said it was fine were wrong. If the average retail investor comes away thinking scummy tactics are cool now that you and I can use them, it'll be a disaster for the cause of real financial reform.
- avs733 6y agoThe SEC has some case studies on this that are really itneresting... https://www.sec.gov/files/Market%20Manipulations%20and%20Case%20Studies.pdf https://www.sec.gov/files/Market%20Manipulations%20and%20Cas... The idea that there has to be behind the scenes coordination (i.e., non-publically available communication/information) runs pretty clearly through all of them, but IANASEC
- asimpletune 6y agoPersuading people that they should invest in X company for Y reason is not market manipulation. People who take a short position frequently announce their short publicly, with the express aim of achieving their goals.
- mbesto 6y ago> Could be? It's an open, publicly-documented market manipulation event. And required the coordination of a 18th century war to pull off. It's one thing if this was "led" by an individual, organization, etc. but it wasn't. It was the wisdom of the crowds who played by the very same rules that the hedge funds play. > You might decide that this kind of manipulation is OK due to it's stated goals Where did every stock holder publicly state their case? If Jim Cramer says "i think you should buy AAPL" and everyone does it, is that manipulation? > How can there be any question about it? Easy. If it were illegal, who would prosecute?