10 ms·
Good. I'm tired of fake Economics where the value of a company or the product is not made from the real value of it, while some yuppies get rich in the proccess
by anthk 6y ago
Good. I'm tired of fake Economics where the value of a company or the product is not made from the real value of it, while some yuppies get rich in the proccess. The more they cry, the better.
Hope is collapses so "middle" and low class workers can get fair prices of what they earn by doing actual hard work.
Because this will create a good crash, dont fool about it. It will harm everyone, but at least this Century will be less focused on speculation and more on actual earnings.
- ramblerman 6y agoI also don't care about a hedge fund losing out but Id hardly call the current value of Gamestop to be "real" Economics. And for the few /r/wsb guys and girls making a killing there are a lot more late comers who will lose big, and can't afford to.
- agildehaus 6y agoNo, it's not real economics. It's the little guys coming together to fight the big guys at their own game.
- ceejayoz 6y agoA lot of little guys are gonna be left holding the bag at the end, though. The stock was probably overvalued at $10. It's definitely overvalued at $400.
- vsareto 6y agoBased on how people acted during the pandemic, these people will be more than willing to be bagholders, constantly deny they are bagholders, and constantly deny anyone else is a bagholder.
- criddell 6y agoPeople were shorting this stock when it was an order of magnitude less expensive. Isn't it an even more attractive short target now?
- ceejayoz 6y agoYes, but there's a fairly hefty risk of it rocketing up again before collapsing, which could wipe out such short positions. (Again!) Not a move I'd make with my retirement funds.
- FabHK 6y agoNot a move you should make highly leveraged. Perfectly legitimate move to make if you have a sufficient capital cushion. (yes, I now, shorts carry unlimited risk in theory, but in practice the risk is limited. Regulators will (correctly) step in when the market cap of some retailer during the pandemic eclipses the market cap of, dunno, Apple and Tesla or whatever.)
- milesvp 6y agoMaybe. Part of the problem currently, is there are too many short positions compared to the total issued shares. It’s what makes this a short squeeze. If you try to short now you’ll help elleviate the squeeze, though you may have problems finding people to lend the stock to short. But what makes shorting even scarier right now is the price is based on the marginal willingness to sell right now, vs the marginal willingness to buy + the forced buying due to margin calls. There is a major assymmetry that is driving the stock to positive infinity. And while we both know the price can’t go to infinity, we can’t be sure that a short right now won’t have it’s margin called due to all the margin calls before triggering a margin call on the stock just shorted. So risk is very real for a short at the moment, and you need a lot of cash reserves to try to weather the current situation.
- emteycz 6y agoWhat is "real economics" if law, contracts and supply/demand isn't real economics? Stock price was never supposed to closely mirror company's financials, that's a meme pushed by socialists that want to portray the stock market as wrong ("out of reality"). The financials are merely a indicator. It's stock market and what matters are the dynamics of that market, and the company itself is only a small part of that.
- Karunamon 6y agoIt's hard to not read this as a pathological corner case.
- emteycz 6y agoYes, that it surely is - but from the Wall Street side; shorting 140% of stock should've been caught by regulators as it's illegal and totally impossible for retail investors. I don't think it was missed by mistake, though. People rallying to make profit from their mistake is nothing wrong, just new - this is the first time the small boys (instead of other big boys - but you can just ping them on Bloomberg terminal and make a deal with them) were able to catch them and coordinate their capital (the same thing the Wall Street guys are doing together, just bigger scale). It won't happen again as long as the big boys play according to the rules.
- zwkrt 6y agoAnd who’s responsibility is that? WSB has been rallying around GameStop for over a month. It has 2 million subscribers. GME shows up 10s of times per day. There have been endless squabbles over it. If some rubberneckers come in now and lose money they could just as easily lost it by doing a thousand other silly things. TSLA and other meme stocks show that value is relative and fickle. We used to think advertising and social media were just used to tell people to buy a company’s products, but it is obvious that they are just as good for directly raising capital. Is it a capitalist utopia or a populist dystopia? I think it’s both.
- krona 6y agoNobody on wsb went out to make a 'killing', or at least not in the way you think. You don't know the half of it.
- monoideism 6y agoParent isn't claiming GME is "real" economics. Parent is claiming GME will help pull down our current fake system, and help the middle and lower classes receive fair compensation from the system. Whether this approach works or not, I don't know. But the status quo isn't tenable for a democratic society. This chart says it all: https://www.epi.org/productivity-pay-gap/ https://www.epi.org/productivity-pay-gap/
- kuu 6y agoWhat did happen around 1979 to have such a clear change?
- atombum 6y agoRonald Reagan happened.
- sokoloff 6y agoIt's not at all clear to me that 1979 is even the best reference year to pick. It looks to me like the trend lines broke in 1973-1975, but by the nature of this type of chart, careful choice in starting year can provide a chart that suggests a different break point. (It's probably better to think of these as "fuzzy" lines, which are 10% starting in each of 1946, 1947...1955.)
- nostrademons 6y agoYeah, 1973 is a much better reference year. Both because that's what the data actually says, and because there was a very clear cause: inflation. 1973 was the year of the oil crisis, the year that fixed exchange rates under Bretton Woods became floating exchange rates, and the year that the 1970s inflation happened. Inflation doesn't affect all professions equally. Differentiated professions (those where there's only a limited supply of workers, and a limited number of positions) can bargain for higher wages, because there's nobody else that can take the job if you don't. The common people can't, because that's what it means to be common: you are easily replaceable. Hence when inflation hits, the upper classes capture the vast majority of the new money and new wealth created, while the lower classes get stuck with the same nominal wage, which purchases far less.
- mrh0057 6y agoWhy do they care this time. No one cared in 2000 and the 2008 bubble. No one cared that new investors are bidding up worthless SPAC and new public companies. Why do they all a suddenly care that retail is going to lose a ton of money when retail always loses a ton of money. Retail always joins the bubble towards the end of the cycle.
- mdoms 6y ago> Id hardly call the current value of Gamestop to be "real" Economics. Yeah that's the whole damn point. Some normies figured out how to play their fake little game.
- yanderekko 6y ago>It will harm everyone, but at least this Century will be less focused on speculation and more on actual earnings. It's far more likely that this would lead to narrowly-targeted regulations than some sort of collapse in global finance, as much as some people would like to see the latter.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ashtonkem 6y agoBe careful what you wish for. The upper classes tend to recover from these crashes much more rapidly than the lower classes do.
- ta1234567890 6y agoBailouts for big companies owned by the rich, $2k paycheck (if lucky) for the rest.
- xyzzyz 6y agoDuring previous financial crisis, the government bailout was in form of loans, and buying assets for pennies on the dollars (that government ultimately made profit on). The people getting $2k check, no strings attached, are getting better deal than Wall Street.
- Tenoke 6y agoThis comparison is unfair. The cost of just the first stimulus checks was ~269b[0] and the second ~ $464b[1] and these are the lower estimates I've seen. For comparison the 2008 bailout cost ~498b[2][3], possibly less after the government made some of it back. So no, the government isnt spending more on bailouts for the rich than on covid relief for the rest. 0. https://www.pgpf.org/blog/2021/01/what-to-know-about-the-second-coronavirus-stimulus-checks https://www.pgpf.org/blog/2021/01/what-to-know-about-the-sec... 1. http://www.crfb.org/blogs/how-much-would-2000-checks-cost http://www.crfb.org/blogs/how-much-would-2000-checks-cost 2. https://mitsloan.mit.edu/ideas-made-to-matter/heres-how-much-2008-bailouts-really-cost https://mitsloan.mit.edu/ideas-made-to-matter/heres-how-much... 3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Troubled_Asset_Relief_Program https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Troubled_Asset_Relief_Program
- NullPrefix 6y ago>government made some of it back Government or the people working for the gorvernment?
- 6y ago
- Hamuko 6y ago>I'm tired of fake Economics where the value of a company or the product is not made from the real value of it I still don't understand how Tesla is valued so high when they're still figuring out panel gaps.
- castis 6y agoNeither can anyone else, which I think is why we are where we are right now. TSLA shot up on what I'd always assumed was the equivalent of a feedback loop. I dont understand what will happen if/when that comes down but my blind guess is that it won't be pretty.
- dcow 6y agoTSLA is pretty obviously valuable to many people. The days of it being cool to be anti-elon are over. Go rent a Tesla for a day and try it out. You’ll understand.
- InTheArena 6y agoThey have a fantastic product, and are sitting on a technology that every single car vendor has to sucessfully mimic in the next 8 years, or be out of business. Also 50% YoY growth. It's overpriced, unquestionably. But the bull case is Amazon.
- jasonv 6y agoHave you seen the stories about the new Land Rover Defender? What if "panel gaps" weren't the most notable thing about Tesla's accomplishment, impact and opportunity?
- wlesieutre 6y agoDepending on why you're looking at a Tesla there may not be another car that you could buy with similar price and performance. They don't have the competitive pressure on every quality detail compared to most other automakers.
- Raidion 6y agoI mean, there are a lot of good reasons to question Tesla's valuation, but the panel gaps is a weird one. Tesla has accomplished putting together the best mass market electric vehicle and selling it for a profit (with government incentives, albeit). There are a LOT of people who can figure out panel gaps. There are not a lot of people who can figure out how to make the economics and supply chain for electric cars work. The fact that they haven't made that a priority speaks to Tesla's priorities, not their abilities.
- vonwoodson 6y agoTotally. You know Uber has yet to turn a profit? This is in spite of talking as much of an advantage of a labor force as possible.
- xyzzyz 6y agoThey can make profit any moment, by killing Uber Eats and focusing on ride segment, which is very profitable. Look at financials.
- kumarvvr 6y agoFor all the thrashing the 'big ones' get, I am sure a large percentage of the actual GME shareholders are institutional ones. The retail ones are driving the prices and narrative, but they are a small drop in the bucket.
- simonh 6y agoA few punters losing money on GameStop stock (and an awful lot of them will lose), and possibly some hedgies taking a minor trim, is hardly going to bring down our system of economics. Bear in mind all but a few of these small investors haven't made a single penny. They only make money when they actually sell, and as soon as a significant number of them do sell the price will fall and the money the others think they have made will vanish. And then some. So a few hedgies might lose a few bucks, but all the WSB people piling in are not a cuddly gang of friends, and not all on the same side and the savvy among them surely know that. The smart ones will sell and leave the rest holding the can. It's the poor saps piling in at $300+ who genuinely think they are sticking it to the man that I worry about. The people who have actually made money so far are the ones who already had stock and have ben selling on the way up, because the stock being bought must have come from somewhere, not the ones who have gone long now and will end up long when it collapses again. It's amazing how many journalists and commentators get this so badly wrong.
- newacct583 6y agoYeah. It's market manipulation from every angle and every party right now. All the crowing about "sticking it to the man" is almost certainly prosecutable as securities fraud. And yes, the folks holding the early shorts either have financing available to hold until it comes down or have transferred the position to someone who does. The people holding the bag at the end of this are indeed going to be individual investors, most of whom thought they were sticking it to the man.
- simonh 6y agoRight, once the stock actually collapses and drops way below it's trend price, those holding the shorts and expecting to make a few bucks on them will end up making an absolute killing. Sticking it to the man my arse.
- supernovae 6y agoAll they need to do is beat the current calls that mature this friday. There are an ungodly amount of shorts about to mature... The big issue, is that the shorts on GME surpass the total outstanding shares... Melvin went 140% short on GME and they should pay the price for that stupidity.
- fractionalhare 6y ago> It will harm everyone, but at least this Century will be less focused on speculation and more on actual earnings. Yeah I'm not sure GME is exemplifying a new regime of market focus on actual earnings instead of speculation...
- xwdv 6y agoYou are confused. Deriving prices from actual earnings and fundamentals isn’t inherently better than people simply agreeing on what a share is worth based on their own feelings and information. One just rises quicker than the other, because it takes in account expected future values.
- ASalazarMX 6y agoThis is the same problem that puts demagogues in power: humans in great numbers behave like a herd. You infuse a strong emotion in enough of us, and it snowballs. We are dumb, our emotions and instinct get the better of us, and we need to come to terms with that if we want to be less vulnerable to manipulators.
- devchix 6y ago"Somebody ought to take society by the four corners of the sheet and toss it all into the air! Everything would be broken, most likely, but at least nobody would have anything, there'd be that much gained!" -- Thénardier, Les Misérables, Marius, Book 8