9 ms·
Peat fires continue to burn at air temperature of -50C in northeastern Yakutia
- mywittyname 6y ago>Pillars of smoke filmed over the areas hit by last summer’s wildfires despite the current long spell of extremely cold weather. Wouldn't cold weather amplify the effects of large fires? After all, cold air is more dense, thus provides more of the oxygen necessary to burn hotter. It also has less moisture.
- colechristensen 6y agoBut it’s also cold. A fire stops burning when it cools below a certain temperate, cold air means a fire has to produce a lot more energy to continue.
- recursive 6y ago> a lot more energy Not relatively. The difference is still a small fraction of the total energy needed even on the hottest day.
- yason 6y agoAny fire with flames is something around 600C and up to even double that. Air is relatively cheap to heat up. I'd wager the combustion process, once fully started, won't suffer much if the ambient temperature is -30C or +30C: the fire is still on a temperature scale that's an order of magnitude higher. Even on a summer day a good breeze of wind or just blowing into the fire too hard yourself will put it out but only if it was just starting. Once the fire is rooted in something more solid, combustible material it will easily heat up any fresh air that is conveyed into the fire.
- chczdc 6y agoAir is cheap to warm. Water in fuel is expensive
- munk-a 6y agoThough if this is a peat fire the water in the peat may have partially evacuated during the freezing process - I'm not so certain that the volume needing to be sent from ice -> water -> vapor would take more energy than the larger volume sent from water -> vapor... I really have no knowledge of ratios here but there are at least some processes working against increasing the amount of energy that needs to be expended to heat the surrounds. Additionally, if this fire is mostly underground then it's likely that you've got some oven action going on where a lot of the heat produced by the fire isn't just whisked away by air to dissipate to nothingness - instead it's trapped by the insulation of earth and being converted into phase changes more efficiently.
- chczdc 6y agoNot an expert. Just a random guy thinking out loud. To burn you have to dry out the fuel matter and warm it up to its combustion T. If the air is -50, the fire has to give up enough enthalpy to not just dry up and warm up the wood, but also melt the water in the fuel. That energy cost is huge. That cold air is dense won’t come close to overcoming the enthalpy of melting and having to dry the fuel. Also that the air is “dry” is irrelevant at -50C. The air is dry because it can’t hold onto moisture so it won’t dry out the fuel. Also, the water in the fuel is frozen so even if the air was relatively dry there would still be a huge kinetic barrier to sublimation.
- fallingfrog 6y agoI’m not an expert either but I have experience with getting fires to burn. Starting a fire in the cold is quite a bit harder. Mostly because if it’s cold, then it’s the middle of winter, and that means the kindling is covered with ice and snow, which has to be melted and evaporated off. A dry log has a lot of potential energy in it. A frozen log full of water and snow has zero or even negative potential energy, as in, even if you get it to burn it might take more heat out of the fire because of the ice than it adds back by burning. But, that might not apply to peat fires because 1) larger, hotter fires make more efficient use of fuel, especially if they are in some insulated space where all the heat is not going straight into the atmosphere and 2) the peat might be dry.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoScouts learn to start a fire in any weather - even cold rain. You split the log and use the dry wood inside for kindling. Wood takes a season to dry in the first place, and isn't going to get wet (inside) just because it's raining. FWIW
- chczdc 6y agoYou still have to reach the fuel’s ignition T and to do that you’re going to have to heat it above 100C, which means you’ll have to spend heat drying it out. Even if the peat moss is “dry” it still has water and if the T is -50, you also have to melt it
- 6y ago
- Aunche 6y agoDenser air also means that fire needs to push out more nitrogen in order to spread.
- tohnjitor 6y agoSurely the air in and around the fire is hotter than -50C.
- chczdc 6y agoAnd heated by the fire giving up heat it also needs to warm up the fuel. The fire gives out a certain amount of heat, if the fuel needs more heat to combust than it gives out in combustion the fire will die out
- rightbyte 6y agoUnder the snow the temperature is way higher than -50c fire or not, too.
- thehappypm 6y agoThere's an XKCD about something similar -- would a toaster still work in a freezer: https://what-if.xkcd.com/155/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/155/ Basically, the difference in temperature between a freezer and room temperature is pretty minute compared to the coil temperature.
- chczdc 6y agoYa, but there’s an extra phase change to melt the water in the fuel which is a significant amount of energy.
- jjjeii3 6y agoMay be this is the reason: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ipAnwilMncI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ipAnwilMncI Every single Putin's friend has become a dollar billionaire and they build multiple big palaces/resorts/etc. for him. But no money for fighting wildfires...
- munk-a 6y agoRegardless of any involvement of a government or any factors of corruption - I'm just purely interested in the fact that nature could sustain a fire like this in -50C weather.
- bserge 6y agoWhy wouldn't it? Cold (within its limits on Earth) does not affect burning, in fact it probably makes it more effective due to convection.
- munk-a 6y agoI am confident enough in my general knowledge that I can be interested in an article on a thing that I can rationally explain but never imagined independently. It's interesting that this fire is happening in blisteringly cold temperatures which is against my intuition as a being that feels like 110F is pretty hot and 40F is pretty cold.
- engineer_22 6y agoYeah pretty neat. -50F is as far from 40F as 130F is. (The absolute difference is 90 degrees F)
- redis_mlc 6y agoJust to provide some context, and since Canada and Siberia have a lot in common, some old memories: :) - -24C is a normal winter temperature in Ottawa when the arctic air mass is over the city. You can still walk to work. (Ottawa is the original Shopify HQ.) Most film cameras don't work because of metal contraction and frozen batteries. Don't touch any metal objects like fences or your fingers will freeze to the surface. - -30C is not that common, but you need mittens and a hat. This starts causing problems, like frozen eyelashes, fairly quick frostbite. So on a clear day with no wind, those temperatures are livable. But if there's wind, then the situation can get serious. "On the coldest days of the year, the temperature can drop to -25 °C (-13 °F) or even below. In 2018, it dropped to -30 °C (-22 °F)." https://www.climatestotravel.com/climate/canada/ottawa https://www.climatestotravel.com/climate/canada/ottawa
- smcl 6y agoI was a bit unclear what was meant by the “zombie” part, but I found this in an article elsewhere: > A ‘zombie fire’ is a fire from a previous growing season that can smoulder under the ground which is made up of carbon-rich peat
- chczdc 6y agoWow that’s insane
- benibela 6y agoSo like the Centralia fire?
- munk-a 6y agoI think the Centralia fire is a great reference - or really any coal seam fire. The interesting thing to me is how this fire is continuing among blisteringly cold surface temperatures - but then again those fires have very little exposure to the surface and earth insulates extremely effectively. It only takes a few feet of earth to effectively dampen surface temperature changes - which is why ice houses were such a commonly used tool.
- dang 6y agoThe submitted title was "Zombie fires in northeastern Yakutia continue to burn at air temperature of -50C". We changed it to what the article says. Submitters: please don't rewrite titles like that—this is in the guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. (But if the article title itself changed, obviously that's different.)
- smcl 6y agoI have a feeling the Siberian Times updated the headline. Normally I spot when the HN title differs from the headline of a news article, and i think I’d be especially observant with this unfamiliar "zombie fire" phrase. But I didn't notice anything amiss when I opened this one up originally.
- recursive 6y agoI recall making plenty of fires while camping well below freezing, even below -10F. There really wasn't a significant difference in the behavior of the fire at any temperature. Unless you count difficulty in starting it due to numb fingers.
- ISL 6y agoIn absolute temperature, there isn't much difference between 273K and 260K....
- chczdc 6y agoI’d say a phase change is fairly significant.
- recursive 6y agoTrue. And more significantly, both of those are a similar distance from the combustion point of the fuel.
- revax 6y agoPlenty of things are nonlinear in physics though. For example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stefan%E2%80%93Boltzmann_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stefan%E2%80%93Boltzmann_law
- Gravityloss 6y agoIf the wood is moist, it makes a difference if it's frozen or not.
- recursive 6y agoWe always brought firewood with us. And we definitely didn't bring wet wood.
- mobilio 6y agoProbably burn something underground. So we're seen smoke from ground.
- bserge 6y agoI mean, cold itself (within Earthly limits) doesn't put out fires. In fact, it might make them burn better due to convection. That said, this reminded me of a lake in Chelyabinsk that is so polluted you can set it on fire according to some locals (I don't remember the video, it was a few Russians filming a short tour of the city)
- astrea 6y ago> I mean, cold itself (within Earthly limits) doesn't put out fires. However, heat is very much a part of the fire triangle.
- bserge 6y agoBut any fire is magnitudes hotter than -50. That cold is a blip on the fire's radar. Once started, and as long as there's fuel and oxygen, it won't stop because of negative Celsius temperatures.
- foobarian 6y agoMy uncle used to joke that his car ran better in the mountains because the air was cleaner and thus had more oxygen. He was not serious, but in case of cold air there would be more oxygen per unit volume due to density so that might improve the combustion.
- munk-a 6y agoThe air pressure is also higher at colder temperatures so if the fire is underground it'd have more forces working in its favor to cycle fresh air to it and the relative temperature difference between the freshly heated and exhausted air and the fresh air would be wider causing there to be more turbulence cycling the air around.
- pletnes 6y agoHence the invention of the intercooler diesel engine.
- geocrasher 6y agoThis is interesting. Are the fires from the summer still burning? Or is this a repeating of the same fire? Get it. Re-peat-ing... I'll show myself out.
- nabla9 6y agoPeat fires like this are smouldering combustion. Smouldering happens on the surface of the material and not in the gas like in the flaming combustion. Compared to flaming combustion smouldering combustion is slower, lower temperature (900 C) vs and flameless. Smouldering is typical for porous fuels like peat. The burning is sustained by heat. The burning beat is little underground. The burning peat is insulated so that the heat does not escape and the smouldering can continue.
- mschaef 6y agoA couple thoughts come to mind, the first of which is that this seems like an unfortunate head start on the next burn season. To the extent these are still burning as things warm up and thaw, I assume they start to significantly spread and grow.
- rbanffy 6y agoOTOH, as the snow melts, it'll flow and block oxygen from reaching the peat.
- pierrec 6y agoI don't understand why the Siberian Times makes it so frequently to the front page of HN, but either way, I like it.
- cozzyd 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Siberian_Times https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Siberian_Times doesn't necessarily point the most flattering picture (at the moment, at least...)
- thesz 6y agoPeat fire is much like gunpowder fire, just much slower. Peat naturally accumulate nitrates (saltpeters among others) which are essential in the gunpowder burning process. As an evidence, I'd like to present a study that proves that peat emits NO2: https://www.jstor.org/stable/2845931?seq=1 https://www.jstor.org/stable/2845931?seq=1 This is why peat can burn underground without much access to oxygen. And, burning underground, it does not need much external heat.
- trhway 6y agoin the ground the temperature doesn't swing that much, and Yakutia is permafrost zone. It is just a juxtaposition of the forest in the snow which usually means no fire and the fire under that forest that looks strange at the first look.
- imoverclocked 6y agoWe see record low temps for weeks in Dec/Jan combined with the worst fires for 40 years. I don’t think the article is saying “it’s hard to have fire in colder terrestrial temperatures,” it’s saying “despite ‘cooling off’ we are still burning.”
- njharman 6y agoI’m less surprised by fires (lots of underground / surface coal and gas fires around world). But holy shit -50C! That’s flipping cold. My education has failed me, I had no idea Earth got that cold.
- taneliv 6y agoHold on to your chair! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oymyakon#Climate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oymyakon#Climate
- Gravityloss 6y agoHmm. Carbon dioxide solidifies at -78.5 C at normal pressure. Omyakon is 750m from the sea level though, and Vostok station at 3500 m. Those temperatures are still getting close to that.
- est31 6y ago-50C is only 80 degrees away from 30C. For a fire that burns in the upper hundreds to lower thousands, this difference is negligible.