7 ms·
MasterCard to push up fees for UK purchases from EU due to Brexit
- paol 6y agoThe money quotes: "From October, Mastercard said it would increase these fees to 1.5% on every transaction, up from 0.3%. The EU introduced a cap on such fees in 2015 after concerns they pushed prices up for consumers and unfairly burdened companies." "Mastercard is implementing the rises simply as it's no longer bound by the restrictions imposed by the UK being in the EU." Thus proving the caps were indeed necessary. If MC was making money with a 0.3% fee the other 1.2% are pure sweet profit margin.
- roenxi 6y agoIt is unlikely it proves that. Mastercard doesn't have a monopoly on transactions (or if it does, that is the problem). If the profits are extreme other payment processors will step in. It is more likely there are significant regulatory or other burdens taking UK orders for EU goods.
- that_guy_iain 6y agoIf Mastercard is doing it, why wouldn't Visa? Also, I think it's important to remember but most of us don't go and select Mastercard or Visa, most of us don't care. We just use what the banks use. I suspect changing from Mastercard to Visa would be extremely expensive and it's a lot easier and more profitable to just pass along that to the customer.
- mrfredward 6y agoThe customer chooses the card, the retailer pays the fee. Other companies can't undercut Mastercard's fees because the consumer(the person making the decision of payment type here) doesn't know or care what the fee is.
- dustinmoris 6y ago> Other companies can't undercut Mastercard's fees because the consumer(the person making the decision of payment type here) doesn't know or care what the fee is. You got the consumer part wrong. The consumer is the merchant, which can decide if they allow Mastercard cards or not. Same as many merchants don't accept Amex. It's because they don't like to pay the Amex fee. Same as many merchants don't accept Apple Pay or Android Pay or why some merchants only allow card payments for purchases of a minimum amount. Merchants are the consumers and they decide what cards they will accept. Based on what cards they will accept consumers will be picky about which cards they want to have. For those exact reasons I have a VISA credit card as well as an AMEX because I sometimes can't use my AMEX, otherwise I wouldn't even have a VISA CC.
- avianlyric 6y agoVery few merchants have the market power to say no to either Mastercard or Visa. It would prevent to many customers from being able to give them money. Which would then make it pretty tricky for the merchant to make money. Also Apple Pay and Android Pay don’t cost merchants more to implement or use (assuming they have the HW, which any card reader from the past 10 years will have). The card network rules also forbid merchants from not accepting them, but of course rules don’t mean much without enforcement. Finally there is really only one company that can undercut Mastercard, and that’s Visa. It’s only a question of time before Visa bump their fees, there’s no way they’re gonna leave money on the table for long.
- jacquesm 6y agoYou have your terminology completely mixed up.
- geofft 6y agoIn most of the US, credit card surcharges (charging customers a higher price when using credit cards than when using cash or debit/bank cards) are legal. Is it also legal to charge customers a fee based on what type of card they use? A large number of customers have multiple cards anyway, so that would be a meaningful incentive.
- Erlich_Bachman 6y ago> Mastercard doesn't have a monopoly Are we living in the same world? Visa+MC are a duopoly borderlining being a de facto cartel organization and handle the vast majority of all retail transactions in the world.
- avianlyric 6y agoThere is only one other payment processor (at least for cards) and that’s Visa. The margins are extreme, but so are the barriers to entry. To build a new card network you somehow need to convince a bunch of banks and merchants to support your card network. Good luck with that. The EU even forced Mastercard to allow others to start a card network running over their infrastructure, after they bought EuroPay. But it’s so hard to get people to actually use a new card network, that no ones actually bothered to try.
- jonplackett 6y agoThis Brexit 'deal' just gets worse and worse by the day. Weren't they supposed to have turned all existing EU law into UK law anyway as a starting point? Maybe phone operators will be next on this train. I also don't understand how this 'free trade' deal seems to still be costing businesses so much money in customs fees? Isn't the point of a free trade deal that you don't pay customs? At least Boris Johnson got the Coronavirus pandemic right, oh wait...
- gelo 6y agoThe mobile operator 3 have upped their prices on pay as you go. They had a "123" PAYG plan that was 1p/MB 2p/Text and 3p/Min. They now are changing it on Feb 16th to 5p/MB 10p/Text 10p/min. They claim "Some of our international roaming rates are also increasing. This is to keep them in line with domestic standard rates and not a result of brexit"
- martinald 6y agoNo, we explicitly rejected a customs union. Customs union would result in no customs (though probably not as you'd have to also be part of the single market to eliminate all checks). The free trade agreement is different, and a step down from that. Given the amount of trade I think the customs fees will come down significantly over time once things are bedded in a bit more.
- bananapub 6y agoit's explicitly not free trade, the entire purpose of leaving the EU was to erect barriers to trade and remove the regulation (good and...bad). "free trade" is just a phrase the Tories like to say because "we're the party of protectionism and crony capitalism" sounds bad even if it is honest...if they cared about trade between the UK and the EU then they wouldn't have left the single market or the customs union, but they prioritised ending free movement above absolutely everything else including the UK economy and UK global competitiveness. and after all this, they *still* didn't manage to make the far right of the Tory party banging on about europe. they were supposed to transcribe all the EU regulations and law into UK law, but they also granted themselves power to change lots of it via regulation (ie without going to parliament)...it's unclear what specifically happened here.
- viktorcode 6y agoOther countries prove that as well. You can compare 0.3% to the rates charged in the US and elsewhere. On the other hand, there are many cash back bonuses.
- Freak_NL 6y agoWhich presumably you pay for with those higher rates.
- kzrdude 6y agoWasn't britain supposed to inherit all the current EU legislation more or less?
- jacquesm 6y agoSure, but that won't stop MC from raising the prices now that the UK no longer has the bargaining power of the EU behind it. What are they going to do, forbid MC from operating in the UK alone? But the threat of all of the EU banning a particular card issuer has some serious teeth in it.
- dustinmoris 6y agoThe EU has so much bargaining power that in fact they have the greatest bargaining power of all. Nobody has so much bargaining power like the EU. Before the EU people didn't even know what bargaining power means. The EU has so much bargaining power that countries like the UAE or Israel could never get hold of more vaccines than the EU -.-
- Jonnax 6y agoI did a quick search. UAE and Israel have about 9 million population each. The EU has a population of about 447 million. Seems like these two countries are 2% of EU in terms of population.
- dustinmoris 6y agoDoesn't change the fact that countries like Israel were able to secure more vaccines relatively to their population (and their GDP) than the EU has so far. Seems like Israel negotiated better than the EU despite the EU constantly self proclaiming to be the best negotiator with the best bargaining power in the world. So far Israel has negotiated and the EU resorts to threatening vaccine nationalism. From the downvotes I can only imply that truth does hurt sometimes.
- 6y ago
- neximo64 6y agoUnless UK customers get different pricing to EU ones it wont make a difference. The one receiving the funds (in the EU) is the one that is left worse off. The winner is the UK based bank processing transactions..
- cannabis_sam 6y agoIf you ignore volume, sure
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dmos62 6y agoWell normally when I do online shopping price is explicitly the sum of base_product_price, shipping_choice, payment_method. So in my experience, a more expensive payment method translates to more expenses to me, the buyer.
- neximo64 6y agoYour typical shopify store doesn't charge extra for using Amex or a different card provider (or card country). It can only be in the shipping cost.
- throw14082020 6y agoThe additional cost is amortized over all customers.
- mytailorisrich 6y ago> Thus proving the caps were indeed necessary. Hmm, the cap is necessary if the fees are abusively high and hurt businesses, consumers, and competition, not just because people prefer to pay less. I don't see how a change from 0.3% to 1.5% proves anything, especially that this is still abiding by the cap set for non-EEA transactions: The UK is no longer in the EEA so they have decided to apply that cap instead of the intra-EEA one, as is their fair and legal right.
- ketzu 6y agoI wonder why this is interesting to people on HN. * Is it Schadenfreude? * To highlight what EU regulations entail, here a limit on internal fees? * Is it the reliance on large financial provider networks and an insight in their fees? I am kind of curious, maybe because I feel that Schadenfreude posts (which was the main reaction when I saw it on reddit) are not exactly the content I expect on HN, but it is not my place to decide that. edit: restructure comment in an attempt to highlight that this is not just "You shouldn't feel Schadenfreude".
- Mindwipe 6y ago> I wonder why this is interesting to people on HN. Visa and Mastercard's defacto monopoly is a huge issue for many startups, and therefore this is directly relevant. I think a head of steam is beginning to build that V/MC is a situation that cannot be allowed to continue as is.
- ketzu 6y agoThanks for the response. I do see the applicability and their dominant market position. In what way is it a huge issue for many startups? Personally I see issues for consumers on the one hand and companies that provide goods or services that are deemed "not acceptable" by the duopoly. So I'm interested in the issues many startups have. Regarding the article, as far as I found out by googling a bit, they basically rais the fees to their non-internal-EU fees. (But that might not actually be the case.) So it feels less news worthy to me.
- phreack 6y agoThere's a lot to take from this development besides Schadenfreude, as I see it living far from Europe. UK founders for one need to be made aware of this since it likely impacts their business directly. But also, from an economic perspective I find it very important as it highlights that MasterCard is in such a controlling position that they can price hike like this (and possibly more) as soon as they're able to, possibly indicating a lack of competition in the space. It's an interesting example of how consumer-helping rulesets are needed since clearly MC was doing fine before this hike.
- asiando 6y agoWhat you’re feeling is called Schadenfreude. I wonder how long before enough people realize they made a mistake to trigger another referendum.
- meigwilym 6y agoWith the Telegraph currently blaming Brexit on Angela Merkel, I think this may take a while.
- matthewmorgan 6y agoNot only the Telegraph.
- melomal 6y agoYup, the UK right now is blaming everyone but themselves (or at least the papers are). There was fury about Belgian authorities taking away sandwiches etc from UK lorry drivers. I also read that someone in the UK got really annoyed that they had to queue up in the 'Outside EU' line....
- jonplackett 6y agoUnfortunately I think we'll have to feel the pain for a while before in convinces anyone, but that pain is probably going to all get blamed on Coronavirus for the foreseeable future so it may take some time.
- signal11 6y ago> the UK right now is blaming everyone but themselves Only a narrow political class of Brexit true-believers are doing that, and it seems unfair to say they represent the UK in totality. There are plenty of voices in the the UK who've warned about the economic consequences and even now are shining a light on the consequences of Brexit.
- melomal 6y agoTrue but I meant the newspapers more than people. Personally Covid will ride the storm for most of these consequences up until it can longer do so but I imagine there would be some new deals and processes in place by then. Well I hope at least...
- mschuster91 6y agoCall me surprised on that one. The banks were pissed to say the least about the interchange fee cap since it was introduced in 2015 - estimates run on a yearly loss (aka more money in the hands of the consumers) of 1-2 billion € a year (per https://www.euractiv.com/section/economy-jobs/news/europeans-save-up-to-e2-billion-thanks-to-caps-on-bank-cards-fees/ https://www.euractiv.com/section/economy-jobs/news/europeans...). I would not be surprised if the other card networks follow MasterCard here, even if it's just British consumers affected it's still a lot of money that they're leaving on the table. The "downside" (from an US point of view) on this cap is that European credit cards don't have ridiculous card bonus programs that are in reality subsidized by all people not paying by credit cards.
- yuribro 6y agoI thought that the card bonus programs on US credit cards were subsidized not by the transaction fees, but by the monthly interest payments. So actually payed by the non-responsible credit card users.
- mschuster91 6y agoNope, they're (also) paid by the individual sellers. It's utter madness. https://www.helcim.com/us/pricing/mastercard-interchange-rates/ https://www.helcim.com/us/pricing/mastercard-interchange-rat...
- felixfbecker 6y agoI wonder how Amex is able to make money in Europe? They still have a quite generous rewards program (not as generous as the US, but not bad) and I thought they always charged high tx fees (which is also why not all merchants chose to accept it). But the argument being that they also have the high earners = high spenders in their network, and merchants can attract more of those customers by accepting Amex. If the cap was at 0.3%, how can they be any different than MasterCard/Visa cards, which usually don't have reward programs here?
- maccard 6y ago
- zpeti 6y agoSigh, do we really have to play this game? I'll take the other side. I wonder what all the EU citizens think who are not getting vaccinated because the EU thought it would play hard ball with the drug companies, who basically went elsewhere as they don't care about EU bureaucratic games?
- dmitriid 6y ago> I wonder what all the EU citizens think who are not getting vaccinated because the EU thought it would play hard ball What do you mean? Current vaccination plan is 80% of population by summer, isn't it?
- toyg 6y agoDon’t feed the troll.
- mft_ 6y agoGood luck; anecdotally low risk people in Germany more likely to be towards the end of the year, unless something changes.
- ben_w 6y agoThat may be the intention, and it may yet be achieved, but the most recent figures I’ve seen say that the UK is vaccinating at about five time the rate (vaccine doses per 100) as the EU average. For all the many times the UK dropped the ball over this pandemic (and separately over Brexit), the British health systems — both NHS and private — are actually good at vaccinating people. For example, last time I visited friends in the country, I got a seasonal flu vaccine from a supermarket without an appointment.
- dmitriid 6y agoYeah. I'm currently in Sweden, and it's like living in a third-world country all over again. They are now struggling to supply proper needles for the vaccine smh
- corin_ 6y ago
- Mountain_Skies 6y agoSounds like something the UK can quickly solve by passing their own matching legislation if they wish.
- simonh 6y agoIs it possible to legislate on the fees a company in another country charges citizens of that country for a service provided in that country?
- neximo64 6y agoWhy would they want to do that? The company receiving the money (in the EU) is the one that receives less money. The UK bank receives a higher interchange.
- kzrdude 6y agoThey would want to do that to give their own citizens a fair price for the service.
- neximo64 6y agoYour typical shopify store charges the same stuff for everyone, you pick the country and pay at checkout. The only differentiator is shipping costs. So i don't understand the meaning when you say customers. The loser is the EU merchant shop and the winner is the British bank. Everyone on this thread is jumping to the conclusion its some Brexit mania without looking into the detail of who receives the interchange and who pays it.
- kzrdude 6y agoThat sounds very short sighted? Everything has to carry its own costs. If fees rise, prices will probably have to rise to compensate.
- Hamuko 6y agoWhy wouldn't the EU stores just jack up the UK shipping prices? You probably already need to do more just to get something sent out to the UK. Might as well lump all those costs in the shipping.
- Jonnax 6y agoAnyone from the UK: What are you doing to mitigate with personal spending? Now having to pay import duty/VAT on EU imports plus a ~£10 handling fee for delivery company handling. It seems like the cost of living is increasing.
- JosephRedfern 6y agoMostly sobbing into my hands and wondering how over half the voting population managed to get hoodwinked into thinking that any of this might be a good idea, with a good outcome.
- Hamuko 6y agoThe other side had less catchy busses.
- jonplackett 6y agoCan someone explain why that is even happening - I thought the 'deal' was meant to prevent that. Wasn't this what everyone was worried about happening with a hard Brexit?
- avianlyric 6y agoThe “deal” is for zero tariffs and quotas. So we don’t pay for tariffs, but there still plenty of other trade barriers that exist. Such as paying to have your goods checked as the cross the border. Or paying VAT as it crosses the border because we’re no longer part of the EU VAT system. The deal we got is basically one notch short of the hardest possible Brexit. It’s barely a deal, just a face saving piece of toilet paper for Boris to cover himself with.
- jonplackett 6y agoI really hope BoJo is one day held accountable for his serial uselessness.
- Jonnax 6y ago
- detaro 6y agopreviously: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25902440 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25902440
- maxehmookau 6y agoYep, Brexit was a dumb idea. Mobile roaming fees will be the next thing to go up. We voted for this, and the EU is laughing at us. (Who can blame them?)
- kwhitefoot 6y ago> the EU is laughing at us That's not my experience. Most people express sympathy. I think many people in the EU and EEA regard the UK as a sibling or cousin who has inexplicably taken to self harming.
- orwin 6y ago> EU is laughing at us I assure you we're not, most of us aren't at least. I feel sorry for everyone involved, including the EU. I think the "throw that form in the bin" from B. Johnson last year was a low point of politics everywhere in the world and was a tell of a profound lack of empathy. I know some people will feel deseperate because of the new barriers (the Covid crisis did not help at all tbh), and luckily this one sentence is old enough so that not that many people will remember, but this is the kind of "advice" that can push a desperate person a little bit too far. "I'm just joking" doesn't really work when you're an adult.
- maxehmookau 6y ago> I assure you we're not, most of us aren't at least. I feel sorry for everyone involved, including the EU. Maybe that's true. Either way, I'm yet to see the promised benefits. I doubt they'll ever exist.
- jarym 6y agoI would suspect though cannot prove that MasterCard are in cahoots with the UK government on this. Same thing happened when EU tried to cap roaming charges and Vodafone complained that it was unfair because they'd paid so much for mobile spectrum licenses - the UK government lobbied not on behalf of citizens but on behalf of a corporation AGAINST caps on roaming charges.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoThey are only following the rules of the EU cap on fees: There is one cap for intra-EEA transactions and one cap for extra-EEA transactions. The UK is no longer in the EEA so they have decide to apply the latter cap to these transactions.
- jarym 6y agoI'm talking about when the caps were first proposed and introduced - not now post Brexit.
- dingaling 6y agoThe phone companies had a point about roaming charges: the EU is a single customs market, not a flat-price market. It is entirely legal for a company to charge different prices in Germany and Greece, except if they're a phone operator. How is that fair?
- jarym 6y agoWhen I travel from one town to another I don't pay different amounts for my phone calls or data. It should not be any different crossing a border within the EU. It is absolutely fair, mobile operators were cross-charging ridiculous amounts to serve each others customers just so they could each milk the others customers. This type of price fixing was wrong and the EU put an end to it. As far as I can tell the telcos have survived, they're still making money and investing in 5G and the consumers are paying less. How is that not a win-win other than for shareholders of the biggest telcos?
- 6y ago
- sfg 6y agoU.K. residents buying from the E.U. will pay more or the seller make less. U.K. retailers gain an advantage over E.U. retailers. Luxemborg's advantage over the U.K. as a corporate HQ location has decreased, which will make it easier to get companies like Amazon to re-locate or open a second office. Higher costs will incentivize building better payment systems that break the current duopoly.
- gorgoiler 6y agoAt least EU directives are enacted as local laws. Brexit doesn’t mean all those laws suddenly get cancelled. But this fee cap wasn’t a directive? What other EU regulations were never directives, and are going to evaporate now we are post Brexit?
- avianlyric 6y agoI think it was a directive. But it applied to transactions in the EEA. The U.K. isn’t in the EEA, so while the rule probably still exists in the U.K., it just doesn’t apply to anything anymore.
- vmilner 6y agoAs far as I can tell, the UK seems to be treated the same as non-EEA Switzerland here. Any Swiss readers want to confirm that?
- gabriel34 6y agoThose fees are in a contract between the merchant and the acquirer, which is fully under EU law, therefore, if the fee cap is on all transactions, it should apply to everyone, wherever they are. I don't understand how does the location of the buyer affects the processing fees, unless either it is a more complicated issue involving all merchant, acquiring bank and issuing bank, or EU law explicitly caps transaction fees between EU citizens and EU companies, leaving out all international sales.