42 ms·
Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint
- tyfon 6y agoNote that this is 10% of revenue so it is quite substantial.
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoAs it should be. If we only fine them fees equivalent to change found between the couch cushions, then they have no incentive to improve. Especially for private information regarding ones health and sexual activity.
- wongarsu 6y agoExactly. This isn't a small oversight from Grindr, they share especially sensitive information (the fact that someone is gay/Bi) without the option to opt out (nevermind that it has to be opt-in).
- StavrosK 6y agoAnd 30% of profit, looks like: > Authority imposes a fine of 100 Mio NOK (€ 9.63 Mio or $ 11.69 Mio) on Grindr. An enormous fine, as Grindr only reported a profit of $ 31 Mio in 2019 - a third of which is now gone.
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoI mean, if they're still make profit then it's not really hurting, is it? Any impact on the decision makers?
- StavrosK 6y agoWell if you took away 30% of my year's income I'd be quite hurt.
- sofixa 6y agoIt's 30% of profit, not income, so more akin to someone taking 30% of your savings or "fun" money.
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoDo you mean emotionally hurt or, like, you'd struggle to eat hurt? Did they reduce CEO income by 30%? I'd be impressed if they had. Mind you some CEOs take 1000× median income so 30% is still pretty unlikely to hurt them (but I don't know the relevant details in this case).
- StavrosK 6y agoDo you think the fine should have been big enough that the company would struggle to function? It needed to be big enough to make it cheaper to comply than not. I believe it achieved that purpose. Anything else is just revenge.
- fckthisguy 6y agoFor traded companies, the stock price usually takes a bit when this happens. That put a fire under their ass even if loosing a load of money doesn't.
- kristofferR 6y agoGDPR contains special protections for LGBT people, but Grindr shared their users private information with third parties anyway, since they argued that Grindr users might be straight... Pretty shocking and absurd.
- detaro 6y agospecifically, > data concerning a natural person’s sex life or sexual orientation is among the things with stricter rules under Article 9: https://gdpr-info.eu/art-9-gdpr/ https://gdpr-info.eu/art-9-gdpr/
- cblconfederate 6y agono more special than for straight people
- speedgoose 6y agoGrindr collects and share quite a lot. Things such as HIV status, sexual preferences, body type, advertising ids, or GPS coordinates. To third parties from the app, and not always using encryption.
- cblconfederate 6y agoI meant that gdpr has no special provisions for LGBT
- jacquesm 6y agoWhat do you think would be the chances of having an article 9 provision specifically mentioning 'sexual orientation' if everybody was straight? https://gdpr-info.eu/art-9-gdpr/ https://gdpr-info.eu/art-9-gdpr/
- nulbyte 6y agoPresumeably, similar arguments could be made in each of the other classes, but none of them work. While these protections might be related to a history of discrimination, they do not apply to some more then others. They apply to everyone in the class equally.
- user-the-name 6y ago"Companies cannot just include external software into their products and then hope that they comply with the law. Grindr included the tracking code of external partners and forwarded user data to potentially hundreds of third parties - it now also has to ensure that these 'partners' comply with the law." – Ala Krinickytė, Data protection lawyer at noyb This has a pretty wide impact, I'd say.
- SiempreViernes 6y agoThe impact comes from Grindr being responsible for the collected data, obviously just handing that data to a third party to do whatever is not responsible handling of it. Grindr actually distributed data from persons that had opted-out, reasoning that setting a flag should stop the down-stream processors from touching the data. That is literally the gossip girl using the the "don't tell anyone this" principle of privacy protection!
- user-the-name 6y agoThe thing is, third-party SDKs often do data collection on their own. Or, even if they don't, they could do so, and you don't really know if they do or not.
- speedgoose 6y agoYes Facebook's SDK is unfortunately very common for example. But Grindr and applications developers in general are responsible for the data. They have to know and have a data policy with their third parties.
- SiempreViernes 6y agoWell, now the GDPR gives you 10% of your revenue as a reason for not using SDKs that will not give you control of data collection. You always had "respect the privacy of users" as a reason not to use them before, but we all know how well that worked.
- 6y ago
- progre 6y agoDidn't know Norway has GDPR as they are not in the EU but apparently they have. https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=34dfb199-c9ab-463c-8c5c-57404e1a3248 https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=34dfb199-c9ab...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- that_guy_iain 6y agoEEA has all the laws and requirements of the EU but without representiation. So they have to follow the laws and rules but don't have a voice in the rules. I have no idea what the benefit of the EEA is for it's members other than political that they can say they're not in the EU but there must be some, maybe they don't need to pay in like EU members do?
- anthonybennis 6y agoBenefit is equal access to Common Market as an EU member.
- that_guy_iain 6y agoSorry, I meant benefit of EEA over EU membership.
- thefounder 6y agoThey have some "special rights" on natural resources. i.e oil, fishery. I think the EU will close that loophole soon.
- xyproto 6y agoAlso, EU has a ruleset adapted to the climate of central Europe and not to cold places where almost no food grows and eating seals and fighting polar bears is how you stay alive. This is an extreme example, but Norway is more dependent on fish for sustenance than many other countries.
- Vinnl 6y ago> Grindr is now relying on a new consent system and alleged "legitimate interest" to use data without user consent. This is in conflict with the decision of the Norwegian DPA, as it explicitly held that "any extensive disclosure ... for marketing purposes should be based on the data subject’s consent". This "legitimate interest" shenanigans is coming up more and more often, where you have a modal with lots of options to opt in to specific forms of tracking which. Most of those are now off by default, as it should be, except that if you scroll down you still see a number of "legitimate interest" ones enabled, even though you can turn them off manually. Edit: And worst of all is this very confusing pattern with two columns of toggle buttons, one of which concerns "legitimate interest": https://toot.cafe/@peter/105367185171860458 https://toot.cafe/@peter/105367185171860458
- dmitriid 6y agoI've seen this also in a separate tab: https://twitter.com/dmitriid/status/1347577262682607616 https://twitter.com/dmitriid/status/1347577262682607616
- danielbarla 6y agoThe various dark patterns employed by these consent systems are fairly opaque to anyone who bothers to open them, and are clearly deliberate attempts at maintaining the old status quo of "opt-in by default". Frankly, I am surprised at how few of these fines are flying around, though I am quite happy to hear they _are_ happening. I do get that this type of regulation is very disruptive to many companies, but if they cannot survive with informed consent, then perhaps they should not have been so successful without it in the first place.
- colejohnson66 6y agoI’ve also wondered why there aren’t “enough” fines. Are the countries just being cautious because they want to establish precedent before going after the “big fish” like Facebook or Google? Or is it something else?
- 6y ago
- orangepanda 6y ago> Consent must be unambiguous, informed, specific and freely given. A bit ironic, for a dating app.
- Laarlf 6y agoYeah, same thoughts. The gdpr didn’t change much but made small companies like these more vulnerable and web browsing more unbearable. Data is still getting collected and big companies don’t care.
- gspr 6y ago> The gdpr didn’t change much but made small companies like these more vulnerable and web browsing more unbearable. Data is still getting collected and big companies don’t care. You do know that GDPR fines scale with revenue?
- Laarlf 6y agoDo you see Google, Microsoft and Apple? It’s nearly been 3 years and they don’t really seem to care. Pretty sure the EU is too scared to touch them.
- icebraining 6y agoTwo years ago Google was fined 50 million euros by the French regulator. Last year it was 7 million by the Swedish. More will come.
- foepys 6y agoWhatsApp's privacy update differed quite a lot between the EU and the US. That alone shows that the big tech corps are careful.
- rsynnott 6y agoThat's partly down to agreements with the EU competition regulator from the acquisition, AIUI.
- ganzuul 6y agoGreat news! They have been preying on a very vulnerable community.
- peteretep 6y agoAre gay men in Norway a very vulnerable community? My impression was no, but I’m willing to have that countered
- eznzt 6y agoThey have more disposable income than the median.
- throwaway2245 6y agoCould you cite that? If you're comparing median to median, I find that very unlikely. There are plenty of soft barriers to progress for gay men.
- nxpnsv 6y agoCompare to the median of straight men+women, or the median of straight men? In median, even in Norway women earn on average 80% of men. Assuming sexual orientation otherwise doesn't matter, there should then be a difference between gay men and straight people in general...
- ganzuul 6y agoYou are assuming the single foundation of your argument. Please don't do that.
- nxpnsv 6y agoI made likely what the post I answered to found unlikely. I could not find reliable stats for gay wages in Norway. Gender paygap is however very well monitored by http://www.ssb.no/ http://www.ssb.no/ Arguably my point is not great. If you really want to know about gay conditions in Norway, try this report https://www.ssb.no/a/english/publikasjoner/pdf/rapp_201038_en/rapp_201038_en.pdf https://www.ssb.no/a/english/publikasjoner/pdf/rapp_201038_e...
- ffpip 6y agoNYOB seems to be a great company. I have heard of their lawsuits against Apple, Facebook and now a large fine against Grindr. If anyone wants to help them - https://noyb.eu/en/support-us https://noyb.eu/en/support-us . (no affiliation)
- helmholtz 6y agoDecided to put my money where my mouth is and signed up to donate to them. Thank you for the link.
- Lapland 6y agoThanks for sharing, haven't heard about this organization before but happy to support them now.
- Dumbdo 6y agoIt was founded by Max Schrems, whom some of you might now for his lawsuits against Facebook a few years back, which ended the EU-US Safe Harbour and Privacy Shield data trade agreements. It's mainly EU-centric which might be the reason why people here haven't heard of it before. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Schrems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Schrems
- simongray 6y agoIt's incredible what one dedicated man can accomplish through the court system. Makes me wonder what the world would be like if we just spent a little time educating our children about their digital rights in school.
- StavrosK 6y agoThanks for that, I figured advocating for my privacy is worth at least 50 EUR/yr, so I subscribed.
- magicalhippo 6y agoHere[1] is the press release from the Norwegian Consumer Council, which initiated this along with noyb based on their earlier findings[2]. [1]: https://www.forbrukerradet.no/news-in-english/historic-victory-for-privacy-as-dating-app-receives-gigantic-fine/ https://www.forbrukerradet.no/news-in-english/historic-victo... [2]: https://www.forbrukerradet.no/side/new-study-the-advertising-industry-is-systematically-breaking-the-law/ https://www.forbrukerradet.no/side/new-study-the-advertising...
- matsemann 6y agoAnd previous discussion [3] here on HN from the complaint filed last year. [3]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22043209 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22043209
- jellygraph 6y agoThis fine is going to be a pain in the backside for Grindr.
- ChrisRR 6y agoThere's no need to be making stupid jokes here at the expense of gay men.
- hamilyon2 6y agoI can't help but feel this not that simple. Wording in article is odd. If data sharing was conditioned on not paying for the app use, than this could be against what this forum usually stand for. I, too, will happily pay for my data being not used and seeing no ads. Wee need more details about this case.
- magicalhippo 6y agoHere is what the Norwegian Data Protection Authority says: In the cases of Smaato, OpenX and AdColony, Grindr “only” transmitted a signal conveying the data subject’s “opt-out” preference. We understand that advertising partners could choose to ignore that signal. In any case, Grindr would have to rely on the action of others, either the user, the operating system, Grindr’s partners, or a combination of the aforementioned, to halt its sharing of data where so required. In consequence, Grindr failed to control and take responsibility for their own data sharing, and the “opt-out” mechanism is not necessarily effective. Furthermore, for a consent to be “freely given”, accepting to the particular processing operation should be as easy as declining, and the choice should be intuitive and fair. [1]: https://www.datatilsynet.no/en/news/2021/intention-to-issue--10-million-fine-to-grindr-llc2/ https://www.datatilsynet.no/en/news/2021/intention-to-issue-... ("Advance notification of an administrative fine")
- nulbyte 6y ago> I, too, will happily pay for my data being not used and seeing no ads. These are two different things, sharing data and displaying ads. The ad industry has forgotten that you can advertise without collecting hoardes of personal data, and they've convinced the rest of us that it can't be done. The point here is that sharing data in the way Grindr is sharing it with third parties is not core to its business. That is, no one signs up for Grindr because of that functionality. Folks sign up to Grindr to find and message others. That functionality does not require the type of data sharing being reviewed in this case, and that sharing of data is distinct from merely displaying advertising.
- mjw_byrne 6y agoI was a little surprised by this: "The DPA highlighted that users should have a real choice not to consent without any negative consequences." Does this mean that it is unacceptable to run a service which requires consent to share data? That seems overly restrictive - where does that leave services in which sharing data is the whole point of the service? The article goes on to say: "Grindr made use of the app conditional on consenting to data sharing or to paying a subscription fee." Is this the unacceptable part? I.e. Grindr is creating a financial penalty for users who exercise their data privacy rights? Would it be acceptable under GDPR to run an app where the choice is "consent to sharing data or do not use this app at all"?
- zinekeller 6y agoIf a marketing service are upfront about "asking your preferences to serve as a reference to participating companies" and that is the primary purpose, they would be allowed under GDPR. Now the real question is would someone wants to do this? Knowing that around 17% of Americans would do this, it would fly in America. Now, would this fly in Europe?
- remus 6y ago> Does this mean that it is unacceptable to run a service which requires consent to share data? That seems overly restrictive - where does that leave services in which sharing data is the whole point of the service? In this case the issue was that the consent was not informed. That is, Grindr weren't making it clear enough that the highly personal information they collected was then shared with hundreds of advertising partners.
- izacus 6y ago> Does this mean that it is unacceptable to run a service which requires consent to share data? That seems overly restrictive - where does that leave services in which sharing data is the whole point of the service? GDPR literally says that you're allowed to run a service that requires data and you don't even have to ask for consent for that type of data. What you're not allowed is to collect data that's NOT critical for your service without consent.
- Hitton 6y agoI'm surprised about: >Consent must also be freely given. The DPA highlighted that users should have a real choice not to consent without any negative consequences. Grindr made use of the app conditional on consenting to data sharing or to paying a subscription fee. I thought that this was allowed. Kind of puts companies depending on advertising in really bad position. One would expect that having choice of paying or getting tracked would be, at least for some people, better than just having to pay to get to the content.
- dmitriid 6y agoYou can advertise without bulk collection of personal data.
- freebuju 6y agoYeah, but personal data is way more profitable. Hence why every popular site puts all the opt-out buttons & privacy terms behind tiny fonts placed in some hidden inconspicuous corner. I recently stopped thinking of myself as an Internet user on the web but rather an advertising ID holder.
- donohoe 6y agoI would dispute the profitability of contextual vs personalized advertising (see NYT’s experience) but is too early and coffee hasn’t kicked in yet.
- Blikkentrekker 6y agoWhat kind of financial losses are we realistically talking about from being denied such tracking? what kind of percentages of lesser revenue?
- TeMPOraL 6y agoProbably net zero, as long as everyone follows the same rules. Advertising is a zero-sum game, and changing the height of the playing field shouldn't impact relative revenue all that much.
- zxcvbn4038 6y agoThey are sending all of their user's data with an "opt out" flag and leaving it to the ad companies to honor it? Slow clap? It also caught my eye that their TOS didn't allow users a choice in data sharing, it was either agree or don't use the app. That might have some wide ramifications, I've encountered many web sites that won't let you past the sharing opt-in until you click agree - i.e. it is impossible to disagree. It is a completely foreign concept for US companies. Wikipedia says Grindr is based in California, US. I wonder if they will pay the fine or refuse. If they have no assets in Norway I imagine it may be hard to collect from them.
- gspr 6y ago> If they have no assets in Norway I imagine it may be hard to collect from them. I thought, but have never verified, that fines given as GDPR enforcement can be collected throughout the EU/EEA. If this is true, and if European courts uphold the fines when Grindr undoubtedly challenge them, then it's my understanding that the Norwegian DPA can have Grindr assets elsewhere in the EEA seized. Does anyone know for sure?
- killingtime74 6y agoA lawyer would know for sure
- Blikkentrekker 6y agoI think you underestimate how specialized law can be. I have a relative who is a lawyer and legal attorney who would definitely not know this and when asked would answer that it is not his speciality and that he would have to do more research. He's an attorney in employment law, and I asked him some things about criminal law and he did not know, and when pressed to make a guess, his guess was wrong. It seems that law is quite complicated, and that lawyers have their specialities.
- killingtime74 6y agoYes and it seems like this would be an even more specialised area. if we don’t even know which lawyer to ask how can we even hope to follow the law meaningfully
- esarbe 6y agoI'm pretty happy that GDRP finally starts being used to limit that type of data agglutination. Max Schrems and NYOB are doing a great job pushing for better privacy protection in Europe. I just hope that the big ones also either change their behavior or get forced to account for it.
- Traubenfuchs 6y agoBug or user hostile design? Grindr presents me the third party data choice dialog every day. Sometimes multiple times per day. I reject every time. Also, it forgets that I set my units to metric regularly. Grindr is a mess. Besides it big user base, it is a garbage app.
- metalliqaz 6y agosounds like both. sounds like a feature designed to implement a dark pattern is broken.
- xtracto 6y agoThe GDPR has always amazed me. It changed the playing field from "you can use our free app as long as you give us data for marketing or not use it" to "you can provide a free service in the EU as long as you dont collect data for marketing or dont provide it" Without making a judgement on the merits of the approach, as a user/individual I appreciate the power this gives to protect my data. As a company/developer the conplexity of navigating the landmines that this poses makes me understand why a lot non EU companies decide to just block EU users. Is it "good riddance " in both cases? Maybe, but still the fact that innovating becomes more expensive sits there.
- aenario 6y agoAs a company/developer starting from scratch, there is really no complexity nor landmines : Do as you say, Say what you do, Give the user options. You can offer the user the choice between targeted advertising or non-targeted. You can offer the user the choice between paid subscription or advertising. Cant get enough users to pay or consent ? Then you did not find market-fit in the real world.
- xtracto 6y agoOh but GDPR is more than "don't do marketing". There´s stuff like "Right to be forgotten" that implementing controls for it would require a company starting from scratch to spend resources in "getting it right", and then you have things like backups, that may or may not fall in scope. And this is only one of the 8 rights that the GDPR provides.
- aenario 6y agoFirst of all, it's not "don't do marketing", it's don't do "user-tracking-and-profiling based advertising". Marketing is so much more, like actual market research to provide a service users actually want. You have to handle a "right to be forgotten" query within a month, surely this is enough time for one sysop to run a prepared query. If your database is so byzantine that you cant find all reference to a given customer, you are either google or in need of a new architect. Backups do not need to be deleted immediately, they should however expires and be destroyed in accordance to your data retention policy (Say what you do, do as you say).
- stemnic 6y agoThe notice letter itself submitted by the Norwegian Data Protection Authority to Grindr https://www.datatilsynet.no/contentassets/da7652d0c072493c84a4c7af506cf293/advance-notification-of-an-administrative-fine.pdf https://www.datatilsynet.no/contentassets/da7652d0c072493c84...
- Mauricebranagh 6y agoSo presumably the Norwegian government will be fined for publishing everyone's tax returns then :-)
- sleepyhead 6y agoNo because GDPR has exceptions for state usage. Tax returns are not published but some key figures are available but you need to authenticate to retrieve it and it is logged and the log is available to the searched person.
- Nasrudith 6y agoThe point is that comes across as hypocritical and makes the rationales come across as lies. "Consent for data sharing is important - except when we do it!" isn't a very good look even if there are valid reasons for tax return transparency it goes against their own stated principles.
- Hamuko 6y agoTurns out that states have special rights. States also have a monopoly on violence.
- anticristi 6y agoYou don't always need consent. There are 6 legal reasons to collect data. "Public interest" as with tax returns is one. As another example, the post office is allowed to collect and process your address, since otherwise they could not fulfill their contract to deliver your parcel (contractual obligations). Similarly, paramedics don't need to worry about asking for consent from a patient that is unconscious: They can look into their medical records based on "vital interests".
- Mauricebranagh 6y agoCollecting doesn't include publishing it to the public, the NHS collects data about me but it doesn't hand it out willy nilly.
- w_t_payne 6y agoIt seems to me that this precedent potentially kills off a big chunk of the ad-supported app economy. How are investors reacting to this?
- anticristi 6y agoWe need to separate "showing advertisement" from "surveillance capitalism". You can (and should) show advertisement without infringing the privacy of your users. I see two potential outcomes: 1) Ad-supported apps will serve ads without hoarding personal data, e.g., a weight tracking app will show weight-loss ads to everyone. 2) We will see more paid apps. Just as investors don't invest in companies doing financial fraud, I'm hoping investors will also do more due diligence on the privacy posture of their portfolio.
- stevespang 6y agoCould not have happened to a better group . . . .
- gingericha 6y agoQuestion in regards to the user consent pop-ups on websites: On sites that continue to let you browse without making a selection (say the consent banner in on the bottom of the browser window), If I don't make any choice, accept or reject, what happens? Am I giving consent by default?
- anticristi 6y agoConsent needs to be unambiguous. If they assume consent, they operate illegally.
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoBy law or it has to be informed, active consent AIUI. Some sites say 'by continuing you are giving consent' but that's not how it works. You have to be able to use the site without giving consent too.
- robertlagrant 6y agoNo, you aren't.
- abstractbarista 6y agoMan, I'm glad we don't have that legislation over here.