4 ms·
Oh, dear. I really can't believe it. I can see any commercial application like What's App or FB or TWTTR being coy about speech and not having the privacy of
by mc32 6y ago
Oh, dear.
I really can't believe it. I can see any commercial application like What's App or FB or TWTTR being coy about speech and not having the privacy of their users in mind, and bending to prevailing winds --not having fast principles.
But Signal? Signal? Do these idealist engineers not envision the comms that can happen on e-e encrypted systems? They don't think criminals, hooligans, spies, unsavory people, sex criminals, drugs dealers, arms dealers, etc. would use the network?
Oh, but boy, wait, what if people in whose politics we don't believe in use it? Oh, noes. In this case we have to be careful and raise concerns --but those other things, no, that's why we believe in freedom of speech and e-e encryption.
Sigh.
They believe in things, until they don't. Which means they don't truly believe in the principles they said they believed in.
What's that old saw, I believe in freedom of speech for the people I agree with?
Moxie should get up there next time and say: "If you only believe this product should be used by people you agree with, then you took the wrong job".
It's like the Komsomol have come to town.
- edgyquant 6y agoThis was my thinking as well. Their concerns were ridiculous and echoed what we heard a couple years ago when politicians were looking for mandatory back doors. What did they think the point of encryption was other than to allow people to have discussions without interference. I get it, I’m not a fan of the groups they’re discussing by a long shot, but I’m also not working at a non-profit dedicated to providing the world with safe, encrypted, messaging.
- ironman1478 6y agoI mean, people's views on things should change based on evidence. This isn't 'i disagree with their politics so I need to change the platform to silence them'. There was an insurrection on the US capitol due to extremists and online communication tools were a big part of this (though it was social media mostly). Let's not abstract away what happened to downplay how serious the event was. I don't know what signal should do, but it's strange to be surprised that given a new understanding of the world people would revisit their principles. That's what people should do. People should not be intransigent. Also, personally I don't think signal should compromise the quality of their product though. E2E is too important.
- mc32 6y agoDon't call a bunch of selfie taking hooligans insurretionists. That's not how insurrections happen. It's a media blown overreaction because it helps their narrative. Look at how insurrections happen elsewhere. It's not done by selfie taking shamen. I mean WTF do they think? Only "their" revolutionaries can use the app, but others can't? It's like TOR. It can be used by dissidents but it can also be used by enemies of the state, yet the state believes on balance TOR does good.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Don't call a bunch of selfie taking hooligans insurretionists Just because it's a stupid insurrection doesn't mean it's not an insurrection.
- mc32 6y agoOk, so then so was Malheur and the siege of the Seattle police station.
- girvo 6y agoYou don’t see a difference between a local police station and your literal federal Capitol building filled with Senators?
- ekianjo 6y agoInsurrection is a very vague word, any kind of violent protest against authorities can be called an insurrection. Funny the summer insurrections don't get to have that label.
- Klonoar 6y agoMmmm, yes, let's compare: - A group storming the capitol of the US after being fed a steady stream of lies regarding an election result, with the President himself pushing them to go. versus - A group protesting after yet-another-person-of-color was murdered, pushing for equality and a check on police brutality. Totally checks out. ;P
- throwaw4ybio 6y ago>It's like the Komsomol have come to town. You don't think this is over-egging the custard a bit?
- mc32 6y agoI wish you were right. But, it doesn't seem like it. This is Signal we're talking about having a discussion about censoring speech --their whole premise was to NOT be aware of the speech users engaged in from the get go.
- tailspin2019 6y agoAre they actually talking about censoring speech though? I didn’t get that from the article unless I genuinely missed something.
- mrzimmerman 6y agoNo, the question was regarding how to handle activity in the platform deemed illegal under US law. The specific hypothetical was if the Proud Boys were to recruit people for coordinated violence and not “what if I don’t like someone’s politics?”
- girvo 6y agoI mean Moxie flat out said “nah that’s silly, we’re not doing that”, so I guess I’m not sure what the panic is about. An employee quitting over disagreement? Makes sense to me: the employee is entitled to their opinion! I’ve quit jobs over similar. I disagree with the employee, but this all seems like a storm in a teacup at this point?
- mrzimmerman 6y ago> During an all-hands meeting, an employee asked Marlinspike how the company would respond if a member of the Proud Boys or another extremist organization posted a Signal group chat link publicly in an effort to recruit members and coordinate violence. > Oh, but boy, wait, what if people in whose politics we don't believe in use it? Coordinating violence and recruiting people to participate in that violence isn’t a political stance.
- otabdeveloper4 6y ago> being coy Not really. It's weaponized privacy. Freedom of speech for thee (when it's expedient to my political goals) but not for me.
- mrzimmerman 6y agoExcept coordinating violence, which is specifically what the employee asked about, isn’t a “political goal”. Breaking US law isn’t covered by the First Amendment and coordinating violence is breaking US law.
- otabdeveloper4 6y agoFWIW, I agree with you. I don't agree when insurrection and violence is deemed 'political activism' or 'free speech' in countries like Iran, China, North Korea, etc.