10 ms·
>It's a never-ending shit-show. At least some of us are getting rich in /r/wallstreetbets. This is sad because most of what you've said can be applied to lotte
by gruez 6y ago
>It's a never-ending shit-show. At least some of us are getting rich in /r/wallstreetbets.
This is sad because most of what you've said can be applied to lotteries as well, which historically has been criticized as being a "tax" on the poor. The end result is the same: people putting themselves in a worse place financially (on average), just so they can cope with their bleak existence.
- pmorici 6y agoI wouldn’t compare what happened with GME to the lottery at least not for the people who understood why they were doing what they were doing.
- viraptor 6y agoIt's still a lottery. They didn't know if there would be enough real following or if most people were just trolling. Even if they estimated that well, they still had no idea where the peak was.
- tomc1985 6y agoExactly this. Many of us have been WSB for a while and it is really hard to know whether all this GME buzz would amount to anything material until it actually happened
- pmorici 6y agoA typical lottery in the USA has odds of like 1 in 300 million. The fact alone that more than 100% of float was shorted put the odds of this happening way above any chance you have of winning the lottery. Suggesting that just because there was an aspect of chance involved that it is on par with a lottery is ridiculous.
- viraptor 6y agoWith 1/300M you're likely thinking of a jackpot. Winning anything is much lower. Powerball is 1/38 for the lowest payout. And in the same way, there will be a lot of people around breakeven point in the GameStop lottery, some small winners and some people who are now set for life.
- esperent 6y ago> Powerball is 1/38 for the lowest payout I'm not familiar with the Powerball, but I'm guessing that's for a prize of somewhere around $5 for a ticket price of $2. Hardly relevant, is it?
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoAll those small wins fuel buzz / conversation, and likely increase participation.
- 8note 6y agoDo lottery entrants have influence on their probability of winning?
- alasdair_ 6y agoThey influence the magnitude of the expected payout, certainly. (In a negative way)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ALittleLight 6y agoThe problem with the lottery is the odds and the expected value, not the concept of risk and reward, which is present in all manner of investing.
- PartiallyTyped 6y agoThen you are not paying attention. The floating shares are fewer than the shorted shares. Even if all the floating shares were bought, there are not enough shares to cover the short's position.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoSo what? The same share can be bought more than once in just the same way it can be sold more than once; in fact, the one necessarily entails the other.
- PartiallyTyped 6y agoWhat happens if nobody sells? Say 40% of total shares are floating. You the hedge fund owe 60% of the shares because you shorted them. Even if your position is closed immediately (hint, it won't), you would still need to find the remaining 20% of the shares that you owe. Who will give you that 20%? Well I of course, but the difference is, I get to dictate what the market price is. We saw this happen in 2008 with Volkswagen. 1% of the total shares were floating because Porché had purchased the remaining, the rest of the shares were owned by institutions and they were not selling them.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> What happens if nobody sells? This has nothing to do with the ratio of short shares to float. What happens if there are 300 shares floating, 20 short shares, and nobody sells?
- PartiallyTyped 6y agoThey owe more shares than there are available and they pay interest on said shares. Even if nobody sells, the interest gets accumulated and they are bleeding.
- thaumasiotes 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- christophilus 6y agoExactly. I first heard the bull thesis from Michael Burry. Hardly a gambler. GME was comically over shorted in a console release year. Burry predicted a short squeeze way before WSB picked it up.
- gruez 6y ago>Exactly. I first heard the bull thesis from Michael Burry. Hardly a gambler. The problem with this argument is that there's always an "expert" that can justify your speculative positions.
- strulovich 6y agoBut we’re comparing it to a lottery. We can find plenty of experts rationalizing some stocks or history, all with convincing narratives. But can you find a expert explaining the numbers which came up in lottery last night with such a believable narrative (wrong or right)?
- gruez 6y ago> But can you find a expert explaining the numbers which came up in lottery last night with such a believable narrative (wrong or right)? Isn't that what fortune tellers are? The only difference is that most people know that trying to predict the lottery is bullshit, but most don't think that's the case for stocks despite evidence to the contrary (eg. that actively managed funds underperform passive funds on average).
- rokobobo 6y agoExcept, if a whole generation YOLOs hard enough, maybe the government will actually choose to bail them out for once.
- edoceo 6y ago2k stimmy incoming! GME PLTR BB NOK to the moon! Get iN! BEars R fuk :rocket-emoji: (20x) - am I doing it right?
- willis936 6y agoA whole generation is not YOLOing. We’re just trying to keep a roof over our heads.
- throwaway894345 6y agoThe argument is that we’re working to keep a roof over our heads now because we YOLOed through college. And while that doesn’t describe me, I had a lot of peers who partied through college, skipped classes, hardly worked, majored in women’s studies / art history / literature / etc and still managed to live in the dorms, buy daily lattes, have the latest iPhones, etc.
- willis936 6y ago>The argument is that we’re working to keep a roof over our heads now because we YOLOed through college. And while that doesn’t describe me Nor me. I worked throughout all of undergrad. My work paid for my grad degree. I have an MSEE and am looking at $50k of student debt. My income is such that I expect the only way my debt will go away in the next ten years is through PSLF. Owning a house before I’m 40? I’m not so sure. Where exactly is the YOLO? The generation didn’t piss anything away. We’re getting shafted.
- sokoloff 6y agoYou have an advanced degree in EE, paid for by work who valued that enough to pay for it, and don't expect to be able to clear $50K in student loans in 10 years. Are you still working in a job requiring that degree, because if so, that does seem like you're getting shafted (especially compared to the equivalent on the CS side of EE/CS).
- katbyte 6y agoBut we all know what the lottery is, sadly playing the stock market is glamorized beyond belief rather then shown for what it is:gambling
- fsckboy 6y ago"diversified" "buy and hold" investing in the stock market is not gambling.
- 8note 6y agoIt's lightly better than gambling, since you still end up with ownership of something
- gruez 6y agoThese people are most likely buying options. Saying that they end up with ownership of something is a stretch.
- justsid 6y agoEh, owning debt is always a possibility with options. But I agree, especially the people who YOLO large amounts of money on dailies. But honestly, that’s what makes WSB fun. There’s a mix of everything, serious traders, reckless gamblers. It’s insanely entertaining, even just from the sidelines.
- thrwyoilarticle 6y agoBets is in the name.
- ollifi 6y ago/r/wsb is kind of insanity, but I’ve come to think that maybe young person can YOLO a bit against the odds somewhere in life. If something returns poorly on average, but has high payouts at the top it might just work out. Your life won’t be the average case but single sample. Lottery is too improbable but some other things ”no rational person would do” can be ok. Main thing is to get over with it soon and protect the downside. Of course if you get lucky you need to be contempt with the nice head start and switch strategy to doing the boring rational things. Not sure if these qualities are often found in one person.
- 55555 6y ago> I’ve come to think that maybe young person can YOLO a bit against the odds somewhere in life. If something returns poorly on average, but has high payouts at the top it might just work out. Your life won’t be the average case but single sample. This is indeed, after all, a website about founding startups.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 6y agoThe only difference between being a founder and gambling is the social signaling. In both cases, luck is a larger component than grit (lots of amazing folks have failed through no fault of their own). No shame in gambling your way to wealth if you don't care about the social signaling.
- kyawzazaw 6y agoI bet there is some sort of positive social signaling in gambling your way to wealth as long as you succeed
- silexia 6y agoAnyone else notice that WSB reads like a religion? And that Trump supporters have faith without evidence, just like religion? Perhaps most humans cannot truly be atheists, but will always be caught by something to believe in.
- chasd00 6y agoIsn’t this an explore/exploit problem? If you have time to recover then do it, if not then better to cash in on a sure thing even if the upside is lower.
- gruez 6y agoNot really. The explore/exploit analogy only works if the higher risk investments have higher returns, as we see with stocks (higher risk, higher returns) vs bonds (lower risk, lower returns). I'm skeptical that speculating on options have higher returns commensurate with their risks.
- the_drunkard 6y ago> This is sad because most of what you've said can be applied to lotteries as well, which historically has been criticized as being a "tax" on the poor. The end result is the same: people putting themselves in a worse place financially (on average), just so they can cope with their bleak existence. Damn. I've never considered the psychological effects of the lottery system, but in a way I think you hit the nail on the head. Anyways, in the GME scenario it appears that most retail investors are actually in a better place financially because of it.
- pas 6y agoCentral banks are printing money. IPOs are hotter than hot. The odds are in favor of WSB for now.