3 ms·
Despite the common saying, absence of evidence is evidence of absence a lot of the time. To put it in boring mathematical terms. If you have a bag filled with
by IshKebab 6y ago
Despite the common saying, absence of evidence is evidence of absence a lot of the time.
To put it in boring mathematical terms. If you have a bag filled with a million playing cards, and you inspect 1000 of them and they're all red, that's pretty good evidence that there aren't any black cards in the bag! But blind followers of the "absence of evidence" dogma would say "No it isn't! Just because you haven't found a black card yet doesn't say anything about whether there are any black cards at all." which is clearly nonsense.
The differentiating factor is have you looked?
I think it's reasonable for people to assume the WHO had actually investigated how people contracted covid (otherwise why bother tweeting?), in which case them saying "[we looked but] we couldn't find any evidence of human to human transmission" is clearly misleading.
- ceejayoz 6y agoNo, see, this is precisely the problem. You're just making up a different version of the tweet to fit your narrative. > I think it's reasonable for people to assume the WHO had actually investigated how people contracted covid... The tweet explicitly says "Preliminary investigations conducted by the Chinese authorities". The WHO team didn't get there until Jan 20. https://www.who.int/china/news/detail/22-01-2020-field-visit-wuhan-china-jan-2020 https://www.who.int/china/news/detail/22-01-2020-field-visit... > otherwise why bother tweeting? Because everyone was wondering at the time if they had the evidence yet. > "[we looked but] we couldn't find any evidence of human to human transmission" is clearly misleading That's not what they said, though.
- IshKebab 6y ago> Preliminary investigations conducted by the Chinese authorities Right it doesn't matter who looks, just that someone does. The Chinese looked! And they didn't find any evidence of human-to-human transmission. That is evidence that there isn't any. Not very compelling evidence but still evidence.
- ceejayoz 6y ago> That is evidence that there isn't any. Again, this is a bit you're adding out of nowhere. The WHO did not make that claim in the tweet, and is quoted on the same day as that tweet saying evidence of human-to-transmission is likely to emerge.