9 ms·
Birdwatch Overview
- agentdrtran 6y agoI'm cautiously optimistic about this, as long as they can prevent brigading, which allegedly they're working on.
- samename 6y agoHow long until Twitter revokes their API access?
- seanyesmunt 6y agoThis is an official Twitter product.
- a_diplomat 6y agoIn other words, they want people to do fact checking for free for them.
- munificent 6y agoYes, just like HN wants you to write content in the form of comments for free. I get your point, but this is an overly simplistic economic reduction of the incentives and value propositions. Yes, Twitter wants you fact check for free. They also want you to write Tweets for free. In return, the hypothetical value proposition is that the tweets you and others read are more likely to be factual. If this is successful at scale, it means that the voters in the hopefully democratic place you live will be more informed and more likely to vote for reality based policies. So, sure, they don't give you a nickel when you fact check. But that doesn't mean it doesn't (possibly) provide sufficient value to you to be worth doing.
- gknoy 6y agoThis seems like it would be very vulnerable to people supporting a viewpoint (whether true or not) brigading the heck out of posts about the other viewpoint.
- a_diplomat 6y agoIt's also the case that there are a lot more people living in undemocratic countries than in democratic ones. I understand the need to have multiple solutions to this problem, but this can never become an alternative for platforms taking more responsibility for content themselves. And, for democratic countries to create a grand coalition to set norms in this space.
- AmericanChopper 6y agoMaybe eventually we’ll circle back to letting people make their own judgements about which “facts” to trust.
- bigpumpkin 6y agoOnly people in the US can become a birdwatcher, yet they can influence the whole of Twitter. Sounds like more recipe for centralization of discourse. If they open it up to foreign countries, then Congress will complain about foreign influence in American politics. Catch 22?
- dan-robertson 6y agoI don’t understand why that’s a catch 22 as it seems to me that the outcomes are different depending on the choice they make. I agree that the way big American tech companies mostly care about the US and suffer from ethnocentrism when stepping outside the US is a problem but I’m not sure what a solution would even look like.
- lhnz 6y agoBack in March 2020, this would have meant getting factchecked or shadowbanned for stating that masks should be protective against coronavirus.
- thatguy0900 6y agoDon't worry, every time consensus changes it will be revealed that we were always at war with Eastasia to begin with, I'm sure.
- a1369209993 6y ago> we were always at war with Eastasia to begin with I mean, you clearly meant to write Eurasia, but that's a really unfortunate typo.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vageli 6y agoGiven the context, I think it's safe to say that it was an intentional 1984 reference.
- offby37years 6y agoOr in January 2020 if it was contagious at all: https://twitter.com/WHO/status/1217043229427761152 https://twitter.com/WHO/status/1217043229427761152
- ceejayoz 6y agoPeople keep mixing up “absence of evidence” and “evidence of absence” with this tweet. There is no reason to believe the WHO was in possession of secret evidence of human-to-human transmission on that date, and they noted that it was entirely possible said evidence would emerge soon. It did shortly afterwards.
- 6y ago
- hirundo 6y agoWhile they're not using this data to moderate by consensus at this point that's clearly the direction they're heading. Consensus certainly has its place, particularly in democratic institutions. But IMHO it's an anti-feature for a forum. It's exactly the counter-consensus opinions that I find most valuable. To the extent that they are suppressed the forum simply loses my interest. Yes, it's useful to see where the consensus is heading. But mostly it's a snooze, and the compelling content is the stuff that challenges it. A better use of this data would be to highlight the counter-consensus speakers so that I can have a listen.
- runarberg 6y agoCorrect me if I’m wrong but hasn’t Stack Overflow used consensus to moderate with great success? What is the reason that consensus driven moderation works well on Stack Overflow but not other forums like Twitter?
- tylersmith 6y agoIt's been a very long time since I've seen anyone use SO as an example of good community moderation. Everyone I know and the general sentiment I get online agree that their moderation is far too heavy handed and leads to an unpleasant experience for most participants.
- shijie 6y agoI would say that with SO, amortized consensus is fine due to there being a "right" answer to a technical problem or question (more or less). Twitter deals mainly in the market of human opinion, which is necessarily far more nuanced with n sides to a story. This makes Twitter the arbiter of truth for their platform. Perfectly legal, as it's their platform, but I wouldn't expect a free exchange of ideas on such a platform.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- CDSlice 6y agoOn StackOverflow there is a simple, objective measure for judging answers and posts by. Namely “Does this answer actually solve my specific problem?” If there are syntax errors or if the answer plain just doesn’t solve the problem it won’t get upvoted or selected as the correct answer. On Twitter what objective measure are you going to use to evaluate “The election was stolen by widespread voter fraud”? The news? Half of the country believes that “liberal” news is full of lies and the other half thinks the same of “conservative” news.
- rrsmtz 6y agoTwitter's owners seem to believe that their platform is an oligarchy of opinion leaders (celebrities, etc.), who influence the malleable minds of their aptly-named followers. And they're probably right that this is the overwhelming use case! I spend a few months in a corner of Twitter with lots of open-minded and free discussion of politics between non-celebrity nobodies. Many accounts in said corner were brigaded, and then shadowbanned or banned outright, etc. I'm still sore about the platform's intolerance, but it was a powerful lesson about the intolerance in modern society. Birdwatch seems to be yet another mechanism which enables and furthers the shutdown of free expression. I'm very happy that HN is still capable of having thoughts that stray outside the Overton window, and that zealots are usually ignored =)
- HNfriend234 6y agoyup, I have had the same experience, so much so that I stopped commenting and posting entirely. Waste of time. There are so many people on there that just seem to be outright trolling, posting outright non-sense, and doing other stuff that is just an outright nuisance. It significantly reduces the user experience. Since HN mainly has startup-minded people on here, I think this actually opens up opportunities for new startups to enter the social media space. There is definitely a large audience who is looking for a more "professional" version of twitter so to speak. Start by blocking anonymous accounts/aliases since this is what every troll hides behind.
- um_ya 6y agoI think it comes down to group size and subject matter which drives meaningful debate. When group size is large, conversation is shallow. HN is a relatively small group with a relatively confined subject matter. Same concept applies on reddit, with small niche subreddits. There's more conversation depth with smaller groups of people.
- ketzo 6y agoI mostly agree with you, but I think HN is definitely a special case. It's not huge, sure, but it's certainly not small - I think there's a very active moderation effort and community spirit that keeps discussion much more productive than your average internet forum.
- jamestimmins 6y agoIt's notable that when it comes to content moderation, most people are positive that the execs at Twitter are morons for not addressing issues sufficiently, but few people can articulate a clear solution to the problem. I too have concerns about how this will play out, but we should be open minded about different solutions to an important challenge.
- dang 6y agoThere's another active thread here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25906672 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25906672. Not sure if we should merge them or what.
- zestyping 6y agoHmm. Brigading is a big concern that's already been mentioned. A concern I haven't seen mentioned yet is that disputes might end up being won through attrition, which is one of the pitfalls of Wikipedia. I used to contribute to Wikipedia, but I just couldn't keep up with folks who had seemingly infinite time to debate or nitpick. Eventually some moderators will get tired and decide to do something less emotionally taxing with their time; what will that self-selection mean for the kinds of people who will stay?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- beastman82 6y agoHow about just stop using Twitter
- sargun 6y agoThis reminds me of oldschool Slashdot Moderation. Or OKCupid moderation. https://slashdot.org/moderation.shtml https://slashdot.org/moderation.shtml
- foolinaround 6y agoIt should not be hard to categorize a tweet into two high level categories - fact and opinion. If it is a fact, then it could marked as true or false, with further proof. If it is opinion, then there could be a different grading.
- Spivak 6y agoUnfortunately this won’t lead to the outcome you desire unless there’s a real tangible reason you want your statements to be put in the category with higher standards. Because otherwise such a system will lead to everything being labeled as an opinion. The reach and impact will end up being the same and even people reporting facts will want to avoid the scrutiny and red tape.
- foolinaround 6y agoI would expect higher attention to facts - and a system that could point this (and other facts) towards other opinions - just allowing readers to make their own informed opinions as well...
- bassman9000 6y agoThrough consensus from a broad and diverse set of contributors https://twitter.github.io/birdwatch/about/faq/ https://twitter.github.io/birdwatch/about/faq/ The first phase of this pilot will be limited to a small test group in the US The pilot will start small and grow over time. Our goal is to admit applicants on a rolling, periodic basis. We will admit all participants who meet the required criteria, but if we have more applicants than pilot slots, we will randomly admit accounts, prioritizing accounts that are likely to participate due to having been recently active on Twitter, and those that tend to follow and engage with different tweets than existing participants do — so as to reduce the likelihood that participants would be predominantly from one ideology, background, or interest space. Aah, the devil in the details. we will randomly admit accounts, prioritizing accounts And there's the catch.
- zuhayeer 6y agoFeel like this will definitely be used to point out sarcasm on tweets too
- known 6y agoSeeking evidence is better