5 ms·

Signal is privacy focused at the cost of functionality and IMO the UI looks like programmer art - you might like the tradeoffs but I suspect most people won't.

benhurmarcel 6y ago
> the UI looks like programmer art The UI looks like iMessage. So it doesn't seem it should be any issue there.
- brainerazer 6y ago
  iMessage has shitty UI though. Always strange being reminded it is used extensively in US, but then I remember people in US still send non-robot-made SMS (even robot-made are shifting here to messaging platforms though)
  - georgyo 6y ago
    I don't really understand... Does WhatsApp have a better UI? Why? To me signal is the best UI, and WhatsApp looks like a child designed it. Especially with the horrid default colors and backgrounds. But I don't really see a difference in UIs in most chat programs. There are only two types of UIs. Point-to-point (signal, WhatsApp, imessage, etc) and room based (irc, matrix, slack). Their all so similar, I don't understand what is better or worse in Signal compared to WhatsApp.
- reader_mode 6y ago
  How many people would use iMessage if it wasn't bundled with the phone ?
  - pmiller2 6y ago
    What's wrong with iMessage?
    - reader_mode 6y ago
      Nothing, but there's nothing really compelling about it either. Don't get me wrong - the unassuming system design works great for OS app - but you wouldn't attract many users to it with the feature set it has
      - pmiller2 6y ago
        I don't really find that a very compelling criticism, to be honest. When I think about what kind of features I'd want in my messaging app, there are really only two things I can think of that iMessage doesn't have: encryption, and the ability to easily leave a group text. Add those two things in, and I'm there for life. On the other hand, both of these things are essentially limitations imposed by SMS, at least when one end of the conversation is not an iPhone. Both can be fixed, at a small cost in complexity, and if they did that, I think it would hit a good balance between features, usability, and architectural complexity.
        reader_mode 6y ago
        But you're a fraction of a percent of users who care about this. I guarantee you 10x more people are interested in having animated stickers.
cassianoleal 6y ago
Funny, most of my contacts that have migrated seem to be of the opposite opinion. UI in general feels pretty much the same, but things like actual desktop apps with decent UX make a massive difference.
- dunefox 6y ago
  At least 90% in my WhatsApp don't even know what a desktop client for a messenger is...
monopoledance 6y ago
As a long term Signal user, I also came to really hate it for all the bugs and flaws it has. All the encryption warnings become meaningless at some point, because someone is always having issues and refreshes the session or something like that. Does that mean we're getting MITM'ed? You can't delete Signal contacts, like, ever. My signal address book and synchronized chats are flooded with plain numbers, or self-titled user names (which also invites for identity fraud...), because I deleted those contacts in my phone (which ofc I need to do, because it's used for privacy settings in other apps...). That's a problem for many years now, the github issues get closed by maintenance bots. I am a somewhat tech-savvy person, but even for me the user experience leaves me annoyed and uncertain about some basic functionality you expect from messaging apps these days. I stopped recommending it to people some time ago. Don't want to blow my chances to migrate people to something fundamentally better.
- cpach 6y ago
  Just out of curiosity, do you use iOS or Android?
  - monopoledance 6y ago
    Android primary, iPad and desktop clients linked. Comically, every platform has different issues with "deleted" meta-info popping up again. Like "deleted" groups, "deleted" contacts, "deleted" chats... meta links I can't get rid off whatever I do. The worst is legacy groups I left, "deleted", can't even use or join anymore, but also can't get rid of. They reappear every time I refresh the iPad app. Mind you, the group members are still visible, so I am really happy whistle-blowing, terrorism or crime isn't my profession. This made me really distrusting of Signal, when years old meta data popped up again. Like, have they lost some pointers or something? Can I even expect the data to be gone, when I delete my account for good? Doesn't feel like privacy at all...

benhurmarcel 6y ago

> the UI looks like programmer art The UI looks like iMessage. So it doesn't seem it should be any issue there.

brainerazer 6y ago
iMessage has shitty UI though. Always strange being reminded it is used extensively in US, but then I remember people in US still send non-robot-made SMS (even robot-made are shifting here to messaging platforms though)
- georgyo 6y ago
  I don't really understand... Does WhatsApp have a better UI? Why? To me signal is the best UI, and WhatsApp looks like a child designed it. Especially with the horrid default colors and backgrounds. But I don't really see a difference in UIs in most chat programs. There are only two types of UIs. Point-to-point (signal, WhatsApp, imessage, etc) and room based (irc, matrix, slack). Their all so similar, I don't understand what is better or worse in Signal compared to WhatsApp.
reader_mode 6y ago
How many people would use iMessage if it wasn't bundled with the phone ?
- pmiller2 6y ago
  What's wrong with iMessage?
  - reader_mode 6y ago
    Nothing, but there's nothing really compelling about it either. Don't get me wrong - the unassuming system design works great for OS app - but you wouldn't attract many users to it with the feature set it has
    - pmiller2 6y ago
      I don't really find that a very compelling criticism, to be honest. When I think about what kind of features I'd want in my messaging app, there are really only two things I can think of that iMessage doesn't have: encryption, and the ability to easily leave a group text. Add those two things in, and I'm there for life. On the other hand, both of these things are essentially limitations imposed by SMS, at least when one end of the conversation is not an iPhone. Both can be fixed, at a small cost in complexity, and if they did that, I think it would hit a good balance between features, usability, and architectural complexity.
      - reader_mode 6y ago
        But you're a fraction of a percent of users who care about this. I guarantee you 10x more people are interested in having animated stickers.

cassianoleal 6y ago

Funny, most of my contacts that have migrated seem to be of the opposite opinion. UI in general feels pretty much the same, but things like actual desktop apps with decent UX make a massive difference.

dunefox 6y ago
At least 90% in my WhatsApp don't even know what a desktop client for a messenger is...

monopoledance 6y ago

As a long term Signal user, I also came to really hate it for all the bugs and flaws it has. All the encryption warnings become meaningless at some point, because someone is always having issues and refreshes the session or something like that. Does that mean we're getting MITM'ed? You can't delete Signal contacts, like, ever. My signal address book and synchronized chats are flooded with plain numbers, or self-titled user names (which also invites for identity fraud...), because I deleted those contacts in my phone (which ofc I need to do, because it's used for privacy settings in other apps...). That's a problem for many years now, the github issues get closed by maintenance bots. I am a somewhat tech-savvy person, but even for me the user experience leaves me annoyed and uncertain about some basic functionality you expect from messaging apps these days. I stopped recommending it to people some time ago. Don't want to blow my chances to migrate people to something fundamentally better.

cpach 6y ago
Just out of curiosity, do you use iOS or Android?
- monopoledance 6y ago
  Android primary, iPad and desktop clients linked. Comically, every platform has different issues with "deleted" meta-info popping up again. Like "deleted" groups, "deleted" contacts, "deleted" chats... meta links I can't get rid off whatever I do. The worst is legacy groups I left, "deleted", can't even use or join anymore, but also can't get rid of. They reappear every time I refresh the iPad app. Mind you, the group members are still visible, so I am really happy whistle-blowing, terrorism or crime isn't my profession. This made me really distrusting of Signal, when years old meta data popped up again. Like, have they lost some pointers or something? Can I even expect the data to be gone, when I delete my account for good? Doesn't feel like privacy at all...