5 ms·
It's unclear to me if the person who wrote "who controls the Internet" has ever interacted with core internet infrastructure at the router, BGP, major transit a
by walrus01 6y ago
It's unclear to me if the person who wrote "who controls the Internet" has ever interacted with core internet infrastructure at the router, BGP, major transit and transport service provider ISP level.
I find it very hard to take seriously prognostication from persons who've never been responsible for even a small sized ASN.
Persons I do take seriously when they prognosticate on the future of the Internet:
The individuals responsible for some of the most important RFCs of the past 20 years.
The people who have the equivalent of 'enable' on core routers of gargantuan ISPs, and on much smaller ISPs doing very special things in the world like last-mile 1Gbps symmetric FTTH.
Persons recognized in the community of individuals associated with RIPE, ARIN, APNIC, AFRINIC, etc and the various special interest regional network operator groups, as having a high degree of network engineering acumen.
- istorical 6y agoIsn't it possible to keep tracing things back to a more base layer beyond what you've described though? It's kind of arbitrary to draw the line any particular place. Like I could write "it's unclear to me if the person who wrote 'interacted with core internet infrastructure at the router, BGP, major transit and transport service provider ISP level' has ever interacted with electrical grid management, power plant operations, or coal or natural gas pipelines and logistics. I find it very hard to take seriously prognostication from persons who've never been responsible for the electrical input of a nationstate." But then someone else could just respond to that with a similar message about how those who control the powergrid are hard to take seriously when they've never grown their own food or managed the food and water needs of humans who run the powergrid.
- walrus01 6y agoYes, but "The Internet" is an actual specific thing composed of stuff at OSI layer 1, and various other things at layers 2-7 in the rest of the model. If a person whose only experience with it is at the software application layer starts opining about what internet infrastructure should look like underneath what their knowledge base encompasses, I would try to determine what if any experience they might have with actually running an ISP. To follow your analogy, I don't agree with the concept, because it would be more like criticizing an article titled "Who controls the power grid", in which the author opines on some cryptocurrency based solution for something related to the grid, but has no experience actually running the grid as an electrical engineer at the BPA or TVA might have.
- kortilla 6y agoNo, TCP/IP and the ability to exchange routes between different networks is what makes the Internet. All of the value is in these interconnected networks and being able to send traffic to arbitrary endpoints regardless of your provider. There is no “base layer” beneath TCP/IP. That’s the beauty of the Internet. The underlying ISPs connecting together will have different lower level protocols, different internal routing protocols, different hardware, different software, different power sources, different currencies, different spoken languages, etc. AWS/Google/Cloudflare could cease to exist tomorrow and the Internet would continue on just fine. There would be a ton of websites down for US/European residents, but the Internet would work nonetheless.
- jacquesm 6y ago> There is no “base layer” beneath TCP/IP. Actually, there usually are. Physical transport layers run their own protocols and the physical media themselves (in case we are not talking OTA) also count as layers in the stack. And while these have been mostly commoditized whoever controls them does have a lot of power.
- kortilla 6y ago> Actually, there usually are. Physical transport layers run their own protocols and the physical media themselves Whoosh, you missed the point. The “base layer” of the Internet is the one that allows cross-connectivity of the networks. All of the layers beneath tcp/ip are interchangeable and people will still be able to get on the Internet. > And while these have been mostly commoditized whoever controls them does have a lot of power. They were immediately commoditized by design when we standardized on IP. IP over MPLS vs IP over ATM vs IP over frame relay looks no different to the end user. In one minute I can roam from a network based on dwdm to one based on microwave back-haul and I still can connect to hackernews and pull down comments over TCP/IP. When people want “Internet access”, the vast majority don’t give two shits about the medium, the link layer protocols, or anything like that. They want IP connectivity that has decent speeds. That’s the “base layer” that everything on the Internet is built on. Anything below that is transparently (and frequently) replaced because it’s an irrelevant implementation detail stripped off at the boundary of each network.
- m463 6y agoI think he's talking about a layer up. He has a bit of a point. In practical terms, if you want to purchase something on the internet or get an email address you'll interact with companies/platforms he alludes to. Thankfully email is open enough so you have a lot of choices up to installing your own server. But purchasing something is all tied up.
- throw0101a 6y ago> But purchasing something is all tied up. Not entirely: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WooCommerce https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WooCommerce * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_shopping_cart_software https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_shopping_cart_so... What's really tied up is payments: Visa and Mastercard specifically.
- melomal 6y agoThere was a recent post from an A16Z insider that basically made it clear that they are nothing more than a media house with VC capabilities. This is probably why the person writing it doesn't make much sense to you.
- walrus01 6y agoI just had a good chuckle looking at the top google result for a16z, the tagline of their own website is: "Andreessen Horowitz | Software Is Eating the World" I don't disagree with that as a statement, but it's such a funny premise to put as the MAIN THING for your big serious VC website.
- melomal 6y agoThat quote is what made a16z. It's the cornerstone of their image, it seems they are riding that quote into the ground. If you are interested in having some more laughs, this is the full story: https://www.newcomer.co/p/the-unauthorized-story-of-andreessen https://www.newcomer.co/p/the-unauthorized-story-of-andreess...
- SllX 6y agoBehind a paywall but here’s the original: https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424053111903480904576512250915629460 https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424053111903480904576512... Here’s a non-paywalled version: https://genius.com/Marc-andreessen-why-software-is-eating-the-world-annotated https://genius.com/Marc-andreessen-why-software-is-eating-th... If you’re questioning the venue of that second link, as I recall, a16z was one of the earlier backers of Genius.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ketamine__ 6y agoLink?
- nickpp 6y agoThat was a hit piece. Another salvo in the mainstream media's ongoing war on Silicon Valley.
- sgt101 6y agoWhen I worked at one of the biggest ISP's in the world we got extremely despondent when https and other end-2-end encryptions became the standard because we were then unable to understand what traffic was on the wires. For ISPs and network providers now everything is just bits, and it's all commodity. The service layer is now implemented by clients.
- jcims 6y agoI 'grew up' on networking in the late 90's when next to nothing was encrypted on the wire. The amount of understanding I was able to develop about how protocols work by just sniffing the packets was immense. I see folks coming out of school these days and while they far surpass my skills with software development they don't really have any intuition about how the protocols work at the network level, and as a result tend to flounder when things break. However, if I hadn't stowed away all of that info 20+ years ago I think I would be in largely the same position. Obviously encrypted network protocols are essential for security and privacy, but it kind of sucks for folks trying to figure out how things work.
- chii 6y agothat's a good outcome. I would be very scared if the electrical utility company started looking at what i'm using the electrons for, and start disallowing certain types of uses for their electrons.
- 6y ago
- FlyingSnake 6y agoThis reminds me of the quote heard recently: “If the critics aren’t getting their ass kicked in the arena, they’re not worth paying attention to”
- cloudhead 6y agoHe’s talking about the software layer, not the protocol layer.
- zarkov99 6y agoYou know Andreessen wrote the first browser, right?
- Mc91 6y agoThese are the technicians who control IP. For the US this can really be whittled down more - the people who go to IETF and NANOG meetings that work for AT&T and Verizon. Because the vast majority of Americans are dependent on pipes or cell phone coverage from those two companies.
- motohagiography 6y agoInteresting criteria, as I had 'enable' on AS701 among several others for a few years, and understand where the article is coming from. I do think the smart bet would be on divergence before change. The analogy I think that fits is the blockchain community today is like if the NetBSD community grew without Linux ever happening. There is still a more accessible culture-purpose-specific linux-like framework for the next overlay "networking" stack to emerge.
- woah 6y agoA lot of times when people say “the internet”, they mean “the web”