3 ms·
I find your comment somewhat amusing in the context of this discussion. Was it intentional? > This "weak man," tactic is taught in undergrad, the idea is to de
by Jtsummers 6y ago
I find your comment somewhat amusing in the context of this discussion. Was it intentional?
> This "weak man," tactic is taught in undergrad, the idea is to destabilize an opposing view to neutralize the person holding it. [emphasis added]
Where is this taught?
> when half the middle class is educated to act like the seediest of prosecutors [emphasis added]
So you're bringing in economic class now, and for some reason explicitly assigning this behavior to prosecutors.
- splistud 6y agoRegarding the second point, I read it as nothing but a fairly artful simile. Let me know if you need a pointer to where this is taught as well.
- ahepp 6y agoI'm sure we all use this rhetorical strategy often. I know I do. But I also think it's fair to call it out, because the implications of half the middle class feeling this way are very different from say, half of left-twitter.
- Jtsummers 6y agoTo be fair to OP, I wasn't meaning to call them out (in the sense of shaming or other effects). I legitimately found it amusing that they used, or appeared to use, rhetorical methods like the one in the article. But look at half (or more by the time I click 'reply') the comments here. They're discussing whether or not there is a War on the War on Christmas, they fell into the same rhetorical trap the article itself is discussing. This is great entertainment and a wonderful way to clear my mind at the end of work on a slow Friday.
- defen 6y agoIt's not explicitly taught, it's Girardian mimetic desire to destroy anyone with -ist or -phobic thought, as those sorts of people are who are preventing us from creating a utopia.
- imbnwa 6y agoYou're doing the thing in the article. The truth is enough people regardless of political stance struggle to explicitly negotiate with ideas that are counter to their own world-view. That's not an unfortunate trait of any one demographic.