4 ms·
I really appreciate when people are transparent. There's a lot of good wisdom here. A decade back I co-founded a startup. My cofounder, a brilliant product man
by wpietri 6y ago
I really appreciate when people are transparent. There's a lot of good wisdom here.
A decade back I co-founded a startup. My cofounder, a brilliant product manager, had what seemed like a great idea. Great enough that he quickly got a fat check for the whole seed round. We could have just started building, but both of us were big fans of using user testing to guide product development, so we instead did a lot of user tests.
Six or eight weeks later, we were down at Sand Hill Road for our first board meeting. At this point, according to our VCs, normally they'd just hear about plans. But my co-founder got up and explained that of the 6 key assumptions in our product, 2 and maybe 3 were false. The thing they'd given us money to build was a bust. The room was very quiet. Then he went on to explain the next idea we'd come up with and got them excited about that.
Something we learned later is at the same time we'd raised a seed round, two other companies raised large A rounds to go after basically the same idea. They spent the next 18 months (and north of $10m) trying to make it work.
Not only did that make us feel a lot better about having pivoted, but it was an important lesson to me: the best failures are those with the smallest craters. We bought the same knowledge for less than 1% of the money spent.
- Winterflow3r 6y agoWould you be open to discuss points 2 and 3 - the key assumptions that were wrong - a bit more?
- wpietri 6y agoI honestly no longer recall. My cofounder gives a short talk here that will give you an idea, though: https://vimeo.com/24749599 https://vimeo.com/24749599
- baxtr 6y agoGreat story! What happened to the two other companies? Did they fail?
- keithwhor 6y agoOne is Dropbox and the other is Box.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- zhoujianfu 6y agoOne is Uber and the other is Lyft.
- wpietri 6y agoThey did fail. For what it's worth, we did as well. I think our eventual product idea was much better than our first one, though, and I think our fatal mistake was not about lack of user demand, but on building too much on the theory that we could use Facebook for viral growth. As we were about to go for our A round Facebook changed a lot of things to de-emphasize apps and posting to people's feeds, so our growth numbers fell off a cliff. Turns out investors only like hockey sticks when they go up.
- dillondoyle 6y agoWould you be willing to expand a bit on the user tests? surveys? Counting signups for interest? I'm wondering about other ways to test without a MVP
- exdeve 6y agoI bet they just talk to people, show them the app and watch how they use it. This is the quicker and meaningful user testing I know
- wongarsu 6y agoIt also doesn't require actually building the app, the user can just tell you which action they take and you draw the next app state on a piece of paper
- wpietri 6y agoSure! It depends a lot on the product. But in our case, a key interaction was on Facebook. So we pretended to be doing market research on social media and brought a lot of people in for user tests. Eventually we'd have them log in to Facebook on our test computer, asking them what they though of various posts. What they didn't know was that we used Greasemonkey to alter the Facebook page, inserting fake feed items using their real friends. (We told them at the end if they didn't figure it out.) Some people liked what we were doing, but a lot hated it. So many that it was clear we'd never get the market penetration we wanted. My cofounder did a 5-minute video talk about it if you'd like more details. https://vimeo.com/24749599 https://vimeo.com/24749599 As an aside, surveys are worse than useless for this. Look for things that let you understand live user reactions in circumstances that are as real as possible. Signups are a good metric, especially if they'll give you a credit card number up front. But if you can, always back the metric with live user tests and discussion with real users. If you're patient and ask good questions, you can learn a ton.
- dillondoyle 6y agocool thanks for sharing! (i think from that video this is your market) it seems like influencer marketing is a thing now, though I might guess you were looking at more 1:1 not social media celebrity:many
- jjtheblunt 6y ago> the best failures are those with the smallest craters. what a fantastic quote!