18 ms·
Remembering Windows 3.1 themes and user empowerment
- jeromenerf 6y agoSome people still enjoy « ricing » their desktop, especially the Linux desktop, from the wallpaper to their editor syntax highlighting scheme. It can even be automated. Bike shedding ninja level.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- _a1_ 6y agoGenerally I agree with the article, but it would be nice for the author to enable dark mode of the website for dark mode users :) (it's possible in CSS to detect if the user is using dark mode, and adjust the colors automatically)
- bovermyer 6y agoThat's not a commonly known or used trick.
- suprfsat 6y agoOnly known to users of such niche websites as YouTube, Twitter, and Facebook.
- bovermyer 6y agoBig sites might support it, sure, but have you visited the wider web recently?
- swiftcoder 6y agoIt's becoming pretty widely used these days. ~25% of websites I visit flip dark mode correctly.
- speedgoose 6y ago> Remember changing colours on the computer? You can do that in Windows 10. It can also change automatically based on your current wallpaper. Similarly to installing Nova Launcher, perhaps the author need to use GNU/Linux or Windows instead of a Mac.
- p410n3 6y agoWindows 10 has themes now too
- HelloNurse 6y agoExcept that Windows 10 themes are a severe security/malware hazard, not a customization of harmless graphical elements.
- DaiPlusPlus 6y agoEh? Windows 10 themes are just wallpaper packs and a defined accent color. I assume you’re referring to UxStyle etc as used since Windows XP? That doesn’t involve loading any executable code (unless there’s an RCE vulnerability in the theme resource loader, I suppose) - patching the signature checks in UxTheme.dll isn’t that big a deal, imo.
- chungy 6y agoWindows XP themes are PE binaries. They totally run executable code. This might even be the main reason that the operating system as-is only allowed themes signed by Microsoft.
- userbinator 6y agoThey are PE binaries... that don't have any actual code, only resources. And there is a flag used with LoadLibraryEx, available since at least Win95, LOAD_LIBRARY_AS_DATAFILE, that tells the system to not attempt to execute code in the file (if present).
- cbanek 6y agoI was just twiddling my GTK theme for the first time since the 90s the other day. I guess my tweaker gene got activated again. It is really fun though, and getting even more dark mode was worth it!
- Santosh83 6y agoThe question is: can we design deep configurability (and composeability), and hence put more accessible creative power in the hands of the user (instead of say having to edit obscure configuration files or even worse, do a full recompile, or simply have no choice at all), without exploding complexity of the system or is this fundamentally mutually exclusive? Power + complexity will only ever remain niche. But if we can design a system (be it a single program or an entire machine with OS), that is both powerful but intuitive to use, even down to deep layers, then we could actually empower 'end' users into becoming authors of 'creative computing'.
- bitwize 6y agoSomething like X resources gave the user deep configurability indeed; what's more, because they lived on the X server they communicated user preference to even remote clients. A graphical tool to allow users to set preferences through X resources, similar perhaps to Visual Studio Code's preferences pane, might be a great way to allow users to tweak their apps with power and precision. Of course, literally no one uses X resources these days, all settings live in XDG_CONFIG_HOME. And it's all moot under Wayland, which doesn't even allow remote clients.
- squiggleblaz 6y agoI don't think that's the concern that led to the loss of color configuration. You probably aren't hardcoding colors anyway, but using widget toolkits and the like. It's mostly because marketers wanted it to look pretty, and that means more complex widgets, so they can't be configured as easily as the relatively flat UIs of Windows 2000 and before. (The new era of flat uncustomisable flat widgets is a direct continuation of the branding approach — its their marketers saying "I know better than you what your working tools should look like".)
- ryandrake 6y agoThis attitude of “we know better than the user what the user wants” is pervasive throughout technology, not just software. Products of all kinds are getting less configurable, less adaptable for different purposes, less integratable with other products, and less suitable for uses beyond what the manufacturer intends. If hammers were invented today, they would be locked to a particular manufacturer’s nails, have software that prevented them from hitting anything else besides nails, and have DRM that self-destructs the tool if you stopped paying the $5/mon subscription.
- Finnucane 6y agoI remember before OS X on the Mac, one of the fun things to do was trade sound effects for system actions, like the Enterprise door swoosh for window actions, and so on. Then Apple took the fun away, because Jobs didn't like fun.
- allenu 6y agoI remember having a lot of fun on Macs in the '90s. We used them in my high school typing class, and I loved the monkey "squeak" sound whenever an error dialog would appear. That was also the time you'd often see the Star Trek After Dark screensaver set up on them.
- whichdan 6y agoI used to love experimenting with LiteStep and Winamp themes and browser themes when I was younger, but honestly user interfaces are Good Enough now that I'm relatively happy with the out-of-the-box experience. But it's still disappointing that a generation of potential computer nerds won't have the same experience of being able to treat their primary computer as a blank slate for personal expression.
- fullstop 6y agoI was the same way with Windowmaker themes. Now I use a fairly boring desktop with a dark theme, and I'm happy if GTK and Qt themes coexist nicely. With that being said, a lot of themes were UGLY or clones of OS X or Windows.
- acquacow 6y agoI spent years making litestep themes and moderating theme submission on litestep.net I still have a mirror up of the old owns.com minimalism site as well. http://dave.oc7.org/minimalism/themes.shtml http://dave.oc7.org/minimalism/themes.shtml Some folks still run litestep, but it's definitely not the community it was. We still have a small chat presence on discord and that is about it.
- fullstop 6y agoHisham keeps popping up in my life, it seems. He's the guy who created both htop and LuaRocks.
- joshmanders 6y agoThere will always be tinkerers and people who want to customize their stuff to their personality, but I think the majority of people don't want to tinker, they want to "get shit done" and the standard wallpaper and theming of stuff now days is visually pleasing enough to not mess with it.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoPersonally I couldn't care less about things being "visually pleasing", to me this is an accessibility feature. People with sight issues or dyslexia might want to use different fonts and weights, they might want high contrast colors, etc. The aesthetic personalization opportunities are second to that. More importantly: this isn't hard. They did it in Windows 3, an OS that had an 8MB install size and required a mere 2MB of RAM. That we can't provide this functionality in 2021 with all these supposedly highly skilled software "engineers" who consider themselves so ridiculously productive because of all the complicated abstractions they use, on hardware that is several orders of magnitude more powerful than was available to Win 3... well it's completely ridiculous and we, as an industry, should be ashamed.
- zepto 6y agoI’m curious - have you experimented with the range of accessibility options in Mac OS? Are there particular ones that are missing when it comes to dyslexia?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoI don't run MacOS on any of the PCs I own, so no. Neither do I have any of the disabilities mentioned. I just feel that being able to change colors and fonts is a significantly broader and more simple solution than bespoke accessibility features tuned for specific disabilities.
- joshmanders 6y ago> I don't run MacOS on any of the PCs I own, so no. Neither do I have any of the disabilities mentioned. So what I'm understanding is you're saying an OS that is used by a LOT of people, is inaccessible, but you neither have any of the disabilities nor the OS you're complaining about to back this claim up? Because macOS has tons of accessibility options including font sizes, etc.
- robin_reala 6y agoThis seems to fly directly against recently articles about the massive uptick in iOS customisation after 14 launched. The #ios14homescreen hashtag on Twitter seems extremely popular: https://twitter.com/hashtag/ios14homescreen https://twitter.com/hashtag/ios14homescreen
- vanderZwan 6y agoHow does it fly against it? To me it appears to say "well of course that's popular, the configurability gives users a sense of ownership over their device"
- toyg 6y agoThe post is from mid-2019. I think the development you mention tallies very well with how the post ends.
- meibo 6y agoI remember having lots of fun with cheesy widgets like that on my first Android phone in 2011, nice to see the iOS folks catching on. Always thought that they were missing out!
- saagarjha 6y ago> massive uptick in iOS customization Take a look at r/jailbreak.
- johannes1234321 6y agoYou renner the times where in a browser one picked colors and font for background, text and links and many sites followed those choices? Now one has to spent time to tweak the Userstyle By finding the right CSS classes and things to change ...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- recursive 6y agoStill has settings in firefox. Right on the first page of options too.
- johannes1234321 6y agoWhich are mostly useless, since "everybody" has CSS on their site ...
- recursive 6y agoI sometimes use it to detect when someone sets foreground/background without setting them both.
- smhenderson 6y agoAnd for fonts there's a check box to override site choices so even if the majority no longer support this Firefox will help you override that. I don't usually mess with colors but I do like to set consistent fonts. It makes some sites look a bit off here and there but it helps me more than not overall.
- HelloNurse 6y agoUp to Windows XP I used to change Windows colours and occasionally fonts and border sizes in order to distinguish real windows from fake ones in popups and banners, now the Windows 10 automatic colour changes are a mediocre substitute.
- finnthehuman 6y agoI think what UI customization shows us is that software vendors providing customize-ability correlates with a lack of confidence in the defaults they ship. When someone creating software has a strong opinion about the "right" way, they can't see the possibility that anyone would ever have legit disagreement with their brilliance so they take away control. And when they can't figure out the right solution to something, they ship flexibility so it can be the user's fault that it works like shit.
- rileymat2 6y agoOr they have moved to the next level up and seen one size does not fit all?
- agumonkey 6y agoAfter watching a computer chronicles episode with win2 or win3 MS marketing employee pitching the new options.. it felt exactly like the most recent apple/android talks (grossly: custom backgrounds, colors). My conclusion: whenever the core product is done, the company will sell you the 'make it your own' pitch, because that's the easiest path.
- janci 6y agoUnfortunately, that does not imply they are right.
- drewzero1 6y agoOn the flip side of that argument, it shows an extraordinary mount of hubris in their ability to know what the user wants to see. Allowing customization is considerate to the user, like saying "I made this and I think this default configuration works best, but you can change this if it doesn't work best for you." There is not necessarily a "right solution" for 100% of the users. The best user experience comes from strong defaults that don't need to be changed, but can be if the user requires it.
- qwerty456127 6y agoI wish there were real high-quality Linux and Windows themes imitating Windows 3.x, 98 and XP (and some other old OSes perhaps) realistically, not just "kind of like that". I would even pay money for such if I were satisfied. Ideally, they should also be easy to combine in different ways. E.g. I want Win3.11 pixel art icons, Win98 window&panel styles and WinXP non-antialiased fonts - these 3 things make me feel orgasmic.
- petepete 6y agoHave you tried Chicago 95? https://github.com/grassmunk/Chicago95 https://github.com/grassmunk/Chicago95
- qwerty456127 6y agoNo, I haven't! Thank you very much! I have brought this subject up many many times and nobody could suggest anything which would be really close to any version of Windows (I don't insist really this old, interested in a good WinXP clone as well). This one seems by far the best. The screenshot makes me drool :-)
- tomcam 6y agoThat’s dope AF, thanks
- there 6y agohttps://github.com/jcs/progman https://github.com/jcs/progman
- anthk 6y agohttps://b00merang.weebly.com/desktop-themes.html https://b00merang.weebly.com/desktop-themes.html
- qwerty456127 6y agoFunny and sad: every single theme I checked says "KDE - No" (or just says it requires Gnome).
- drewzero1 6y agoWhen I first started playing around with OS X the appearance section of the control panel seemed unfinished, and I naively hoped they would add more color options in a future update. Nope, just aqua or grey! At the time I'd been using Internet Explorer for Mac and really wanted to see the color-configurable interface happen system-wide. I thought it made sense to let people set their interface colors to match the fruit of their iMac if they wanted, since you could do that in OS 8 and 9. Eventually the computers themselves lost color/individuality as well.
- saagarjha 6y agoIntriguingly, this is one of the things Apple has recently made customizable…
- afandian 6y agoRISC OS 3.11 (which was approximately contemporaneous) went a step further and allowed users to define the system palette LUT arbitrarily using the !Palette utility. https://guidebookgallery.org/screenshots/riscos311#appearance https://guidebookgallery.org/screenshots/riscos311#appearanc...
- mschaef 6y ago> RISC OS ... allowed users to define the system palette LUT arbitrarily For 8-bpp LUT graphics, Windows 3.x had a palette negotiation mechanism in the API that reserved 20 color entries to the OS and let the focused app control the remaining 236. Applications that weren't focused got a combination of whatever was left over and dithering to fill in the gaps. (In 4-bpp modes, the palette was entirely fixed.) This wasn't necessarily a bad solution to limited hardware, but non-LUT modes with 16 bits of depth were a huge, huge improvement once they were available.
- grishka 6y agoThemeability doesn't rule out consistency. As long as all UIs use the system theme, they look consistent, no matter what that theme is. A good example of that was Windows XP and all the funny and atrocious themes you could put on it with WindowBlinds.
- wott 6y ago> Themeability doesn't rule out consistency. As long as all UIs use the system theme, they look consistent, no matter what that theme is. Agreed. That's why the GUI toolkit must provide as exhaustive as possible a set of widgets, and those widgets must be versatile; so that applications developers can build basically everything from those widgets and not feel the need to build their own from a raw canvas or something like that.
- wongarsu 6y agoHaving just one widely used GUI toolkit would also help, something both Linux and Windows are struggling with (Windows especially, with Win32-style WPF vs Fluent-style UWP)
- OkGoDoIt 6y agoAlso on Windows you’ve got WinForms and MFC and I think another C++ UI framework as well. Microsoft has switched their preferred UI framework every five years or so, often leaving behind the old framework in the dust when it comes to new UI paradigms they want people to adopt. So you’re kind of forced to roll your own if you’re stuck on a legacy framework but want your app to look modern. It’s a mess. Now they’re just starting to roll out a new one called “WinUI”. I’ll wait a few years before deciding if it’s worth the effort to learn or if it’s just another one for the scrapheap.
- userbinator 6y agoMy choice, and it has stayed so for nearly 3 decades, is Win32. All the other bloaty trends just aren't really worth much to learn. So you’re kind of forced to roll your own if you’re stuck on a legacy framework but want your app to look modern. Perhaps "look modern" is not a good thing after all. Especially considering the discussion here.
- richard_todd 6y agoOn the Windows side, isn't it a side-effect of the shift from standardized common controls to WPF that happened around the vista time-frame? It's much harder to provide consistent user theming against non-standard controls. Similarly, on the early web you could theme sites easily with your browser settings, but as theming power shifted to web developers with CSS, that capability melted away.
- squiggleblaz 6y ago> On the Windows side, isn't it a side-effect of the shift from standardized common controls to WPF that happened around the vista time-frame? It's much harder to provide consistent user theming against non-standard controls. Not directly. If you code in Win32 on modern Windows, you pretty much have to enable themed widgets. Once you've enabled themed widgets, you give up the ability for the user to control the appearance. I don't believe there was any technical reason for the change; it was the desire to have themed widgets (or in plain English: branded widgets) which made them uncustomisable.
- marwis 6y agoMost native desktop development in Windows is nowadays based on WPF and as parent mentioned WPF broke the consistency with the rest of Win32. WPF does it's own vector-based drawing that completely ignores legacy Win32 API except for some basics such as control colors. Even its standard Windows theme is a poor imitation of actual Windows style - you can easily spot WPF apps with default theme because they stick out like an eye sore.
- cgrealy 6y agoIs WPF actually that popular though? Honest question... last time I did any WPF dev was 2008 and I haven’t really seen it used much since. MS certainly aren’t hyping it much (although that could just be the decline of the desktop app in general). My impression was that it wasn’t worth it for small apps and not performant enough for things like CAD, etc.
- arketyp 6y ago>Looking back, I feel like this trend of less aesthetic configurability has diminished the sense of user ownership from the computer experience, part of the general trend of the death of “personal computing”. This, and end of story. What's personalized today are things like the extensions for your browser and your Google account. OSs are becoming terminals.
- selfhoster11 6y agoUnpopular opinion: optimising for "branding" is what killed theming. Everyone wants to have their own custom colour theme, brand-associated font or button style, which clashes with uniformity of system controls. If everyone renders buttons in a custom way, they bypass the native, theming-capable, accessible-by-default system controls. As long as product managers are happy, it doesn't matter that users aren't.
- pwdisswordfish5 6y agoI thought this was obvious.
- bitwize 6y agoThis was true in the 90s as well, or have you never used Kai's Power Tools? What's more recent is that the OS vendor now considers UI font and color choices part of their brand, and thus fixed them immutably for "consistency" i.e., to advertise the Apple-ness of the Apple UI even in screen shots of the OS in action.
- encom 6y ago>Kai's Power Tools Page curls. Page curls everywhere!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- II2II 6y agoI suspect there is more to it than branding. You can still establish a brand through the design and texture of controls, while letting the end user have limited control over colour. That is evident in the classic Mac OS as well as modern Windows. What we are most likely seeing is push-back over some of the excesses of themes. Branding is likely part of that, but the astounding number of controls likely played a negative role in the user experience as well.
- forgetfulness 6y agoTheming was HUGE in Linux back in 2005-2010, consistency was paramount, adherence to toolkit was extremely important just like Apple claimed. For Apple it was about delivering a consistent branded experience, for the GNOME and KDE communities it was about being able to consistently customize the experience. In Windows? Always a free-for-all of such heavy customization on the side of the third-party applications that a Windows look and feel was never really a thing, nor was theming because of the same thing. Then GNOME 3.0 came and they went for the consistently branded experience approach, and you were left with a black and gray desktop environment that at best tolerated customization. And it works alright, but Desktop Linux at most you'll get to work alright, the third party app ecosystem is small, without the feeling of ownership and freedom that an end-user can have with their system, customizing not the kernel but the things they're actually interacting with, what's left? An unremarkable desktop environment with few applications, that you'll want to replace with macOS as soon as you have the money.
- toyg 6y agoI agree wholeheartedly with this (2019) post. I’m still very much a fan of customizations, forever mourning the end of easy tweaking of icons and themes on non-Linux. I used to “refresh” my desktop every two or three years, but nowadays tweaking Windows or MacOS is unsustainable: every couple of months an update will likely break all your carefully-laid-out hacks, and the knowledge is getting harder and harder to acquire. So I limit myself to wallpapers, browsers, and IDEs (IntelliJ is quite skinnable). I understand the rationale for the market evolving as it did: the world of computers is now much seedier than it was in the ‘90s... every customisation option will be jumped on by malware writers of all sorts. Tweakers are now effectively banished from commercial vendors, but at least we’ll always have Linux.
- gmueckl 6y agoMore configuration options come with an increased risk of inadvertently pointing one of the gun's barrels at ones own foot without noticing and then pulling the trigger. To stay with the theming example: it's nice and dandy have control over theme colors. But what happems when you set button background, window background and text color to white by accident? How do you recover from that? Back in the 90s you'd have been stuck with a mostly unusable UI. Somehow that was OK. Nowadays, things like that are tolerated a lot less. Configuration options in mainstream products are (often) fussed over to the nth degreee to make sure that there isn't a way to get the whole thing into a bad state. The result is usually somewhat more robust. And that's enough to satisfy most users most of the time.
- bussierem 6y agoI can understand what you mean, but let's be fair -- preventing things like "all white UI" can easily be coded into the configurability. Yes, the full iteration of possible situations you could get into are quite large, and maybe you miss some -- but there are also options for coding in some kind of "reset" quick-switch that doesn't require the UI. Also, I'm not sure I buy the claim that "things like that are tolerated a lot less". Are they? Or has it just been so long since we've had anything like that, that we just assume people would hate it even more?
- gmueckl 6y agoWell, I'm sure you'd hate it if your smartphone would keep white text labels without outlines on your home screen if you set a very bright custom background. I've just tried it on my phone: if I set a mostly white background image, I can still use the home screen because the text also has a dark drop shadow (for exactly these kinds of situations!). That illustrates my point quite nicely I think: there are fewer settings now, but - when done right - those that are available behave quite well. Theming was just the first example that came to my mind. It's a pretty benign one in the grand scheme of things. There were other ways in which you could misconfigure your system. These were also the days before PCI, USB and hardware auto-detection. You could easily pick the wrong driver and/or wrong settings for some hardware and the system would mostly just try to run with it, not knowing that anything was amiss. Pick the wrong mouse driver? Set the wrong COM port for the serial mouse? Tough luck.
- flohofwoe 6y agoI want Linux-like anarchy^H^H^Hthemability on Windows and macOS. I'm not keen on tweaking the appearance of every little button, but I want to go 'theme-shopping' from time to time and change the appearance of my desktop. Just to make it look a bit different now and then. It's interesting that the most slick and stylish desktops are now on Linux (of course there's 99% trash, but the remaining 1% are a lot more aesthetically pleasing than both the current Win10 and macOS themes).
- forgetfulness 6y agoThe themeability ran on anarchy but on the community-organized kind. Users expected apps to use the Desktop's toolkit and having their custom widgets respond well to theme engines. But that's only for KDE nowadays, there was a period where GNOME was breaking theming with new releases and its maintainers argued for why they just supported the standard Adwaita theme and not anything else. KDE comes with a historic sloppiness at the individual application level, you'll quickly notice that padding, margins, lines, orientation are all over the place and it's just how KDE application developers roll.
- MayeulC 6y ago> of course there's 99% trash I'm offended. 99% of the number of desktop environments, or the installation, or the stylized installations? As with everything artistic, the last is a matter of taste, and the more opinionated a visual design is, the more you are likely to disagree with it. For the rest, please give names.. I've seen magnificients {i3, sway, KDE, GNOME, XFCE, cinnamon, etc}. ricing is a popular sport.
- flohofwoe 6y agoWhen you look through the themes on sites like https://www.gnome-look.org/browse/cat/135/ord/rating/ https://www.gnome-look.org/browse/cat/135/ord/rating/, sort by rating and then skip the first few result pages, most of those themes don't look that "great". I don't understand how that's offending though, it's a normal quality distribution (also see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sturgeon%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sturgeon%27s_law)
- armagon 6y agoI'll agree, this is one of the things I don't like about macOS. It looks like in the past there were hacks to do this, but Apple broke them. (Similarly, I'm so glad there's a hint of colour in the sidebar in the Finder again; I hate when Apple says, "We've got two indistinguishable shades of grey; one for available, and one for inactive. You can take it, or you can take it.") As to the point about setting a desktop background, though, I hardly ever see my desktop background, so changing it doesn't seem very important.
- helmholtz 6y agoI used to change my desktop background approximately once per afternoon. It was a disease. Modifying Gnome themes. Downloading custom launchers for Android. Tweaking the colors representing my calendars. All with good intentions, mind you. "This green mountain background will calm me down in the morning" etc. At some point, I realised that if I just take a deep breath, slow down, and accept that I can modify myself to align with my tool rather than the other way around, a lot of friction is removed. I set my background on every device to a solid black, and it's now three years since I changed them. My trello boards are still blue background. My calendars are whatever the default theme is. It's sometimes nice to tweak the tool for your need, but it's also sometimes nice to understand that everything doesn't need to be a huge annoyance. One can just adapt and move on.
- saagarjha 6y agoYou can adapt and move on. There's no need for everyone else to go with that, though.
- helmholtz 6y agoFair enough. Just the perspective of someone who was deep into all this stuff. I suppose I've become one of those born-again ascetics who become zen minimalists in their second birth and leave their .vimrc untouched.
- 6y ago
- city41 6y agoAllowing customization also increases the feature area of your product, thus increasing need for support, dev time, qa time, increased chance of regressions, etc.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoThe OS handled this, and it was just changing some colors and font settings. It's not like today where there's a whole Turing machine handling your needlessly complicated custom interface rendering. I'll say it again: people did this in the 90s, with orders of magnitude less computing power, significantly more constrained development tools, and fewer developers. That we think this is something we can't do today is evidence of a deep sickness in our industry.
- ryandrake 6y agoThere are a lot of things developers were doing in the 80s and 90s that developers of today will insist simply can’t be done.
- wott 6y agoThey're too busy dropping platforms support, dropping backends support, dropping 32-bit support... in the name of the burden of 'maintaining' code that works, is proven (on the field) and basically hasn't moved in 10 years.
- ryandrake 6y agoNot to mention dropping features and taking what few powerful features remain, and burying them deep in a “hamburger” menu so the main screen can have more whitespace.
- city41 6y agoI'm not really sure the developers are making these decisions. It's usually a project manager or someone in the role of deciding where to put money.
- hashkb 6y ago> In the old days of Windows 3.1, it was common to walk into an office and see each person’s desktop colors, fonts and wallpapers tuned to their personalities, just like their physical desk, with one’s family portrait or plants. Author (and many commenters here) take as a given that this is a good thing, but I'm not so sure. Starting with the physical desk metaphor - you probably have trinkets and photos and whatnot, and then a mess. An idiosyncratic mess, but still a mess. I'm defining "mess" here from the perspective of everyone who isn't you; which you could argue doesn't matter in the physical desk metaphor. Thinking back over the ~10 offices I've worked in, maybe 20% of people keep their desk tidy in a way that I could find a pen or a stack of post-its at first glance. Maybe it doesn't matter if someone else can be productive at your desk; but it can't be denied that the average human will (literally) leave food to rot on their desk. Let's move to the virtual desktop. We've been saying we love our Windows 3 customizations, and randomize our wallpapers and Winamp skins every few minutes, right? Back when we were playing all those video games? But now we're adults with jobs (maybe even coworkers) and productivity actually matters, right? But we still wish for the power to make our desktops messy. Why? Maybe it doesn't matter if someone else can be productive at your computer, but it can't be denied that millions of hours have already gone into making you productive there. Upon reflection, is this a freedom that you actually need; one that helps you in any way? What purpose was served by that flat, warm, old can of soda on your desk? Do you like all that paper everywhere? Do you even know what most of it is? Unless your job function is some type of artist, you're almost certainly better off using the consensus interface; and if it has problems, contributing the fixes for those problems back to everyone. And clean up that takeout container that's slipped halfway onto your neighbor's desk. Edit: I'm all for customizing the way that things work. Rebind your hotkeys, script stuff, write your own text editor- if it saves you time and you can prove it, go for it; but when it comes to colors, transparency, animations, all that stuff... just get your work done and then go outside or watch TV.
- mrob 6y ago>you're almost certainly better off using the consensus interface; and if it has problems, contributing the fixes for those problems back to everyone This is usually impossible, because UI designers' goals are not your goals. Designers optimize for distinctiveness ("branding") and good first impressions from inexperienced users. This results in anti-features like low contrast text, excessive whitespace, and mandatory animations. There's no point complaining because it's working as intended. The only option is to switch to one of the few remaining systems that still respects the users.
- joshspankit 6y agoI remember the explosion of artistic creativity that lived all over the web. I could go to deviantart and see beautiful, new, and innovative designs every day (which some being all 3!). In Windows XP I could install most of them easily. On OSX there were less places for customization, but the icon sets! chef’s kiss
- tacticaldev 6y agothis idea was probably one of the first points that drew me into the Linux community when I was young (so many decades ago). The idea of customizing and even modifying my own Window Manager was intriguing!
- zepto 6y agoI have been playing with Linux desktops recently after only using it as a server or embedded OS for years. It seems a lot harder to make serious changes than it used to be because of the rise of desktop environments.
- tinus_hn 6y agoOn Windows most applications don’t even use the normal title bars and controls. What’s the use in allowing people to customize their colors?
- signal11 6y agoYou can use nonstandard controls and still allow people to customise colours. There are APIs (GetSysColor for instance) which’ll let you query and honour user settings, assuming you care to and don’t put your branding / Look & Feel preferences ahead of the user’s.
- tinus_hn 6y agoThe fact you can doesn’t mean apps do. They probably fixed it now, but this is what Microsofts own explorer looked like in 2018 with Dark Mode: https://www.howtogeek.com/fyi/microsoft-adds-a-dark-theme-to-file-explorer-in-the-latest-windows-10-update/ https://www.howtogeek.com/fyi/microsoft-adds-a-dark-theme-to... You can guess about the support in third party apps.
- userbinator 6y agoFor comparison, Windows 98 dark theme: https://i.imgur.com/jVM9dUA.png https://i.imgur.com/jVM9dUA.png
- tinus_hn 6y agoWindows 98, when most apps still used normal widgets. As an example these days the Windows OS includes Microsoft apps that are built using the QT toolkit (OneDrive). That’s the example developers follow.
- 1970-01-01 6y agoToday customization is effectively a big hassle for everyone involved. We no longer have "PCs" in the workplace, just "assets". User customization becomes a security threat on top of a broken feature. The popular "app" that gets your daily cat wallpaper should be rejected by your security team. The OS "theme" that enables dark mode will effectively break some legacy UI you need to do your job.
- acquacow 6y agoThere was a free/shareware app for Apple's OS 6/7/8 called Kaleidoscope. It was a resource editor that would let you change pretty much any aspect of the desktop interface. Apple folks definitely had customization before OSX, but not sure if OSX killed that entirely or not.
- joshspankit 6y agoIf by “folks” you mean users: yes. And yes: OSX killed that entirely (not just did they kill it, but as users found ways to crowbar in and do customizations, Apple changed the UI code to block each crowbar hole.)
- kitsunesoba 6y agoKaleidoscope is by far the best implementation of system theming I've used. A single file was responsible for the appearance of window chrome, window controls, control and text colors, fonts, desktop icons, cursor, text selection color, etc. Furthermore, the schemes were free to rearrange and reshape window chrome as the artist pleased, meaning it was possible to do things like have a titlebar on the bottom of the window or to make the titlebar into a vertical tab that hung off the left or right edges of the window. Heck, it was even possible to make windows take on odd, non-square shapes. The results weren't always practical, but it was a great enabler of creativity, and made for probably the most true-to-the original OS themes on any platform. The only thing that even comes close is probably WinXP/Win7 msstyles, but even those have significant limitations compared to Kaleidoscope. Some arrangements of Linux desktops come close from a technical perspective, but suffer from the customizability being divided into 500 small pieces, making it a bit arduous to get everything to match up. EDIT: One other thing — Kaleidoscope had something unique that I have yet to see replicated elsewhere: there was no installation process for schemes. You could keep your schemes wherever you pleased, and switching them was as simple as navigating to the desired scheme in Finder and double-clicking it. Boom, done. No obscure and/or hidden directories to copy things to, no incantations to make them show up in a control panel. More things could use that classic Mac flavor of simplicity.
- asiando 6y ago
- freetonik 6y agoShameless plug: I started documenting and collecting screenshots and screencasts recordings of old software at UI museum[1]. There is a great intro tutorial from Windows 3.11[2] and extensive collection of screenshots as well. The level of consistency and overall caring is very high by today’s standards. The tutorial explains core GUI concepts like mouse movements and windows. This is something I’d gladly show to my parents, for example. 1. https://ui.codexpanse.com/ https://ui.codexpanse.com/ 2. https://ui.codexpanse.com/windows-311-intro-tutorial-video.html https://ui.codexpanse.com/windows-311-intro-tutorial-video.h...
- Narishma 6y agoThat tutorial dates back to Windows 3.1 at least, if not earlier. Edit: I also suggest you scale those Windows 2 screenshots to the correct aspect ratio. They currently look very stretched.
- syx 6y agoNice collection, a similar project you could take a look at is Toasty Tech's GUI Gallery[1] 1. http://toastytech.com/guis/index.html http://toastytech.com/guis/index.html
- freetonik 6y agoThere's also GUIdebook[1] 1. https://guidebookgallery.org/ https://guidebookgallery.org/
- gambiting 6y agoIt's truly shocking to me how few people even change their wallpaper. I work in a video games studio and like 90% of people have the default windows logo on blue background wallpaper. Don't get me wrong, it's a nice wallpaper, but people have their custom figurines and personal trinkets on the desks, but won't bother to change the wallpaper on their desktop.
- Joker_vD 6y agoFor how long, approximately, can you see your desktop's wallpaper during a day? I see mine for about 5 seconds during the boot, after that Chrome auto-launches, and I never see the desktop until the next reboot (all the non-browser apps I use are pinned on my taskbar). So what's the point to change it? Instead, I always change my mouse cursors to the Garfield theme from defunct Microsoft Plus! -- they are of pretty nice orange color.
- gambiting 6y agoI have 3 monitors, I very frequently have one monitor empty so it's nice to have something pretty on it.
- doodpants 6y agoI constantly see at least parts of my desktop wallpaper peeking out from around and in between whatever windows I have open. (I personally have never felt any need or desire to use apps in full-screen mode.)
- mschaef 6y ago> won't bother to change the wallpaper on their desktop. I use OSX and enjoy the fact that the wallpapers are dynamic with the time of day. Any photos I'd use myself don't do that, and I don't see much of the background anyway. (This is a far cry from the days when I remember skipping wallpaper to save on memory, etc.)
- tokai 6y agoIt's shocking to me that anyone would chance the background on a work pc.
- zepto 6y agoThe article is misguided at best. The amount of desktop customization on MacOS vastly exceeds anything that was possible on Windows 3.1 by an order of magnitude. Yes, tweaking the individual colors of desktop elements is more limited. However, look at the accessibility features, and you’ll find many ways of customizing the desktop that make read differences in people’s lives. This whole idea that disabling tweaking colors on the desktop theme is part of a slippery slope towards a computer ‘you don’t own’ makes no sense. Windows 3.1 was not open source. Mac OS is vastly more extensible and programmable than any desktop environment from that era. That said... I do agree that we live in a world where people who create OS’s have vast power over the experiences of those who use them, and this is not where we should be. The real step down this path came when both Apple and Microsoft copied the desktop metaphor superficially from Xerox but left behind the end user programmability of the Smalltalk and Mesa environments. Their goal was to create an environment for the delivery of shrink wrapped software. That is what Windows and the Mac were about.
- tacotacotacos 6y agoImproved usability killed theming. When you are no longer bogged down in a tool, you’re less concerned with how it looks. You’re more focused on accomplishing your task. Theming is alive and well in code editors like VS Code and Sublime — because we stare at them for 6-10 hours a day.
- JohnBooty 6y agoempowerment Customizing themes and such -- was it really empowerment in any meaningful sense, though? It was more like a really banal illusion of empowerment. Your Windows PC was locked down with all kinds of proprietary file formats and restrictive licenses, and wide open to malware. But hey, you could change the colors of your title bars and stuff. Was that really "empowerment?" I mean, yes, changing your window colors is orthogonal to licenses and security and such. But despite fond memories, I can't see Windows 3.1 as "the good old days" no matter how hard I try.
- nickjj 6y agoBack in Windows 98 you could set your title bar to be a gradient between 2 colors. That used to be a fun way to customize your look. How did we get into a world where 20 years later with Windows 10 you can't even set a dark title bar color because Windows will say "that color is not supported". There's a cut off when picking a custom color where if you go below a certain shade of darkness it denies you.
- kube-system 6y agoText visibility? IIRC, Windows 9x would allow you set text and the background to the same color.
- nickjj 6y ago> Text visibility? In this case disallowing a darker color creates less contrast and visibility because Windows will use white text behind it. It's also one of those silly limits where one shade is allowed but then you make a 000001 adjustment to it and suddenly it's disallowed. It feels like an arbitrary decision to not let users pick the color they really want. To me it feels like the complete opposite of user empowerment.
- userbinator 6y agoHow did we get into a world where 20 years later with Windows 10 you can't even set a dark title bar color because Windows will say "that color is not supported". What's worse, early versions of Win10 didn't even let you set the colour of titlebars at all! https://www.cnet.com/how-to/how-to-restore-color-to-the-title-bars-in-windows-10/ https://www.cnet.com/how-to/how-to-restore-color-to-the-titl... Presumably it was only put back after massive outrage, which then begs the question of why they even removed the feature in the first place. 8.1, the version immediately before 10, still had the feature. The behaviour of recent (i.e. post-XP or so) MS Windows development teams continues to amaze and puzzle me.
- Arainach 6y agoA "consistent design language". The developers who worked on the feature argued against it (among other things it was almost impossible to tell which window was active since "Black on White" isn't easily distinguishable from "Gray on white"). Selfhost feedback said the same thing. It didn't matter - the designers had their mocks, the PMs sided with them, and that was how it shipped. The public response was entirely predictable (for "not being the target customer", it turns out that we knew how they think pretty well) and soon enough we added a toggle for color and APIs to control title bar colors back in TH1.
- rbanffy 6y agoI remember I used to customize my desktop a lot. Then I started moving, from Windows 3 to 95, then some Solaris with OpenWindows, then CDE and it all got a little bit boring. These days the only thing I change is the overall theme to "dark" and that's it. I'm happy I don't do that anymore.
- marktucker 6y agoI have a small b2c business and one of our key differentiators is the customizability. Users LOVE to turn stuff on and off and customize fonts, colors, and every bit to their liking. Sure it makes bugs and some users post ugly screenshots, but there’s definitely still value there that users recognize. I’ve also noticed that surprisingly many of my friends have changed their Gmail theme.
- thisisauserid 6y agoI fun prank used to be setting someone's color scheme to black on black with black highlights. It didn't work as well on later versions of windows because the button highlights were always visible. In 3.1 you'd have to guess where the buttons even were.
- tomcam 6y agoHow did you restore it, you monster?
- userbinator 6y agoWin3.x and 9x are based on DOS, so all you need to do is boot to a DOS prompt and edit CONTROL.INI (a text file) to change the colour scheme or its colours.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tambourine_man 6y agoThe epitome of theming was on with Kaleidoscope. You could not only change colors, but the complete shape of every widget. And there were a few very tasteful themes, among the ocean of crazyness one would expect. This Twitter handle shows what was possible on early OS X: https://twitter.com/osxthemes https://twitter.com/osxthemes Web Archive's page: https://web.archive.org/web/20050216050114/http://www.kaleidoscope.net/What_is_Kaleidoscope.html https://web.archive.org/web/20050216050114/http://www.kaleid...
- anthk 6y agoCompared to any Linux desktops and WM's that was nothing.
- tambourine_man 6y agoLinks please.
- anthk 6y agoThere are uncountable, literally. Search for fluxbox, blackbox, fvwm, and so on, screenshots since 1996.
- masswerk 6y agoKaleidoscope 2 was really great. Technically, it was a more accessible frontend to the built-in Theme Manager of OS8 and OS9, and it facilitate some radical theming. Here are some of my own Kaleidoscope schemes (still available as free downloads): https://www.masswerk.at/schemes https://www.masswerk.at/schemes
- tambourine_man 6y agoNice collection and great looking site. Congratulations
- ogre_codes 6y agoWhile I do greatly miss the ability to theme, I'm not sure it would work with a modern architecture. You used to have window "Chrome", titlebars, borders, buttons, etc as very distinct and separate from the window content. Now the line has blurred greatly. On top of that, the number of cross platform apps has increased so even if you could control the bog standard apps, things like Slack wouldn't follow. This last bit used to be a big problem with Linux, if you ran a Gnome theme, and fired up a KDE app, it was like an alien suddenly landed on your desktop. Statically linked apps were often worse because a static linked KDE app wouldn't even have the same theme as the dynamically linked ones. Java based apps, apps built with other toolkits, all added their own unique and clashing bits of chaos to your interface. One of the upsides to MacOS, is third party toolkits have a single target look to try and mimic. Even so, I still miss being able to theme. The recent post about Mira Furlan passing reminded me of a Babylon 5 theme I wrote for Windowmaker what seems like a lifetime ago.
- jbjbjbjb 6y agoThe ironic thing a lot of the popular theming on Windows and Linux is to make it to look like Mac! I was thinking it would be great if someone redid the tiled wallpapers in windows 3.1 to be hi-res and realistic. The one with the leaves would look amazing.
- HeckFeck 6y agoI recently set out to try a simpler window manager and custom desktop on Linux. This led me to discover Fluxbox. The sheer variety of themes for that WM is unfathomable. Enough to suit anyone for a lifetime. The go-to source for Fluxbox themes: https://tenr.de/styles/ https://tenr.de/styles/ (currently down, hopefully not permanently) Mirror: http://web.archive.org/web/20201019233308/https://tenr.de/styles/ http://web.archive.org/web/20201019233308/https://tenr.de/st... Nothing has this same variety today. I hate how serious computing has become.
- ecliptik 6y agoFluxbox is still my goto window manager whenever I setup a Linux for local desktop or remote VNC because of how lightweight and configurable it is. Sad that it hasn't had an update in over 5 years, but also good in the sense that it's not becoming a shadow of it's former self and is still has the same solid principles and themes it's had for years.
- Koshkin 6y agoThere's also FVWM with its Windows 95 theme: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FVWM95 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FVWM95
- BeetleB 6y agoHeh - I used to use Fluxbox before I switched to FVWM. FVWM is at a whole other level when it comes to themability. I'm surprised to see its still kicking. Look at the three highlighted configs on their main page: https://www.fvwm.org/ https://www.fvwm.org/ They have an archive of screenshots of various people's configs at: https://www.fvwm.org/Archive/Screenshots/ https://www.fvwm.org/Archive/Screenshots/ Just compare these two - would you think it's the same WM? https://www.fvwm.org/Archive/Screenshots/2011-04-15_Christine-toogrey-1024x768/screenshot.png https://www.fvwm.org/Archive/Screenshots/2011-04-15_Christin... https://www.fvwm.org/Archive/Screenshots/2011-04-15_Christine-international-1400x1050/screenshot.png https://www.fvwm.org/Archive/Screenshots/2011-04-15_Christin... There is also Enlightenment. It was amazing back in 2002, and everyone was waiting for the next version (which finally came out in 2012!) https://www.enlightenment.org/ https://www.enlightenment.org/ While I really like customizability, I just don't have time to learn each WM's capabilities to customize my own. Once I figured out an FVWM config, I used it for 5-7 years. Then I tried AwesomeWM and although I didn't customize it, I can't go back to non-tiling WMs. I've been using it for almost a decade. EXWM will probably be my next attempt, as I do know some Emacs Lisp if I want to customize it.
- godot 6y agoHere's one counterpoint, that doesn't necessarily argue against the author (I love Windows 3.1 and Windows 95 theming btw!) -- diminishing ownership of the computer experience over the years gave me one great benefit, that is I'm much less reliant/tethered to everything on my computer. Sure, it's not an effect of themes, for sure. It's everything from, code for all my personal projects are in a git repo somewhere online, important personal media are backed up in the cloud or external drives, text chat history are backed up in some app or in the cloud, music is listened to on some app, etc. So much so that if a laptop of mine is bricked randomly one day, I don't suffer much of a loss (other than spending the money to get a new one). Back in the 90s or early 00s, it would've been catastrophic to lose a computer. I would have had so many personal files of all kinds, customizations of all kinds, that would be lost. Nowadays, a machine is mostly disposable. If one is lost, I simply get a new one, and all my stuff is online or accessible somewhere. I no longer think of my computer as a prized possession I can't lose, but rather just another tool.
- marcosdumay 6y agoThat's mostly because computers got cheap. The diminishing ownership of ones's computer only makes your data more linked into your device and the device's manufacturer. We are lucky in that desktops are still free enough that this isn't a problem, but there is severe loss of data when one loses mobile devices, for example.
- andrewxdiamond 6y agoIs there? I’ve used both iOS and Android, and pretty much all of my data, pictures, contacts, chat history, etc, sync to some cloud by default. Perhaps privacy centric individuals who disable the built-in backup systems would have a hard time, but the typical user goes with the defaults most of the time.
- cutitout 6y agoI use FreeFileSync to synchronize my Thunderbird and Firefox Profiles, KeepassXC files, web server stuff etc. I also prefer portable applications that keep their preferences in their own folders. So I also don't mind if a machine randomly dies, but I still have all my stuff locally, plus backups, and what I upload is always a copy. Other than stuff that lives on chat servers or social media, of course, Soundcloud and YouTube playlists -- but that stuff, but that stuff will go away sooner than the files I have locally. Stuff that lives elsewhere is just a way to interact with others and show them things, not the keeper of anything that matters to me. The downside is that I can't just change machines nilly-willy, I need to sync first, at least if things overlap. For example, I can use one Firefox profile on one machine, another on a second machine, and use Thunderbird on a third, but I can't use the same profile on several machines without getting a merge conflict, so to speak. That was confusing and annoying for like a week, since then it's not been a problem, and by now I'm so pampered by it, I simply avoid stuff that doesn't play nicely with my workflow. Smartphone apps, for example, or programs that doesn't allow me to configure the paths it uses, and so on. Since I use applications and work on data, the OS doesn't that matter much. I mind changing Windows from the ass-backwards defaults much less than sticking with the defaults, and I do that as I go along, i.e. when I use a feature or get annoyed by the default, I just change it. That doesn't require any thought and very little time, so the configuration I would have to repeat on a new system isn't something I consider valuable, I'm pretty sure it takes much less time in total than working with the default config, in the long run. If I had to do it more often than every once in a blue moon, I'd find ways to automate it. I am just not interested in something that could go away based on the decision of some pointy-haired boss, which is tends to be inferior software in the first place, anyway. Like, compare Directory Opus with Windows Explorer, one is a serious application, the other is a toy that constantly gets in your way.
- cosmotic 6y agoEvery time I see a headline new feature "dark mode", I think if this exact feature in Windows 3.1, along with all the studies that show dark mode is actually worse for all the things people claim it's better for (except maybe battery life).
- thedz 6y agoThis article is focusing on user customization in the wrong places. OS window chrome is mostly invisible to most users nowadays. The places where customization happens is within apps. Custom emojis, sticker packs, browser themes, slack themes, whatever else. IMO "theming" and customizing visual appearance is alive and well. But it's moved to higher layers.
- zepto 6y agoThere is nothing ‘empowering’ about being forced to design your own color scheme rather than just picking a nicely designed accessibility feature.
- coliveira 6y agoThe reason desktops were customizable in the 90s is that they followed strict GUI rules and used the same toolkits. Nowadays, apps want to have control of their UI to a higher degree, which makes it difficult to provide customization. The same applies to the web: since every app wants to have it own UI, there is no space for user-level customization.
- Can_Not 6y agoFeels like we're living life after the fall of Rome.
- godshatter 6y agoI'm irrationally missing the hotdog stand Windows 3.1 theme. I use KDE at home and will occasionally try a different theme or cursor set when the mood strikes me. But that's the linux way. You're free to customize to a crazy extent. Once you get it setup the way you like it, you can achieve some nice workflow enhancements.
- xtat 6y agocame here to ctrl-f hotdog stand :)
- sildur 6y ago> But then I realized how much I struggled to get my Android UI the way I wanted, until I installed Nova Launcher that gave me Linux-levels of tweaking. The average user does not do this. No. Stop, please stop with the paternalism. I cringe every time someone talks about "the user" in third person, like they were laboratory specimens. We all are mostly average users. There is not really any difference between your father and you. My mother wants to play with things like everyone else. But we, the developers, don't allow them, and we put them into walled gardens without ever giving them a choice. Because we are smarter and we known better, and we are doing it for their own good. Apparently. And all of this reeks of paternalism and elitism. The silver lining will be when all those developers receive the same treatment in 30 years. Sadly, it will be too late by then.
- fouric 6y agoI don't understand the point you're trying to make here. > We all are mostly average users. If by "we" you mean the population of HN - that is blatantly false. The average HN user is far more technically sophisticated than the average computer/phone user. >> The average user does not do this. This is completely true, and not "paternalistic" in the least - it's a statement of fact. > There is not really any difference between your father and you. Absolutely false. My father, as do most of the fathers I know, are profoundly disinterested in customization and learning more about their devices - even after I show them some of the stuff that they could do, and offer to teach them. It's simply not interesting to them - they want to do workworking, or something. > My mother wants to play with things like everyone else. Then your mother is different than most peoples' - including mine. My mother does not want to play with her phone - she wants to use it to get something done, whether that be talking with her friends or watching a video. This also describes my father, and the parents of the majority of people I know. Now, sure, most humans want to "play with things" in the general case. However, that does not extend to every kind of object (e.g. car, gun, workbench, computer, house) for every person, and what's more there is a tremendous amount of variability in the drive that each person has to customize each of those things. The fact that your mother might passingly be interested in changing the wallpaper of her phone does not in any way make her comparable to the /r/unixporn poster who has spent literally hundreds of hours on a single visual theme. > But we, the developers, don't allow them, and we put them into walled gardens without ever giving them a choice. Because we are smarter and we known better, and we are doing it for their own good. That's what the post is arguing against. You seem to be under the impression that separating "users" and "developers" implies taking control away from the former - which is false. Users are different than you - and you should give them power.
- allenu 6y agoI loved theming my desktop as a teenager, but now it's definitely not something high on my list of requirements. I think theming is one of those things that have been dropped because the cost vs. benefit just wasn't there. Theming isn't free. You have to invest resources into adding UI to support customizing it and any new UI you add should follow the themes. When the OS is upgraded and UI is tweaked slightly, you have to consider how to handle existing themes. It all adds extra complexity to your project that you may not want to carry forward long-term.
- Mountain_Skies 6y agoGood Lord, just give me control over the appearance of scrollbars again. Was there some international UI/UX meeting where they declared a holy war on scrollbars? Seems like everyone is trying to make them disappear like they're an embarrassing and unwelcome distant relative they're passive aggressively trying to make go away.
- jart 6y agoWhat is the use case for scroll bars, now that we have mouse wheels? Progress indication? My view is that content is king and any UI element that needlessly takes away space from the content needs to be destroyed.
- ryukafalz 6y agoIndicating where you are on the page, and indicating that content can be scrolled. (I've seen webpages where there's content "below the fold" but where it's extremely easy to miss that depending on your screen size.)
- core-questions 6y ago> now that we have mouse wheels? * Horizontal scrolling * Scrolling when using pen/touch input on non-touch UIs * Making it obvious that a content area is scrollable * Providing context into how much content is visible vs. hidden, and where you are in the document * Making it easy to scroll to a precise location without sitting there twiddling the wheel for minutes to go through something long > My view is that content is king and any UI element that needlessly takes away space from the content needs to be destroyed. Your view makes sense at 640x480. Maybe on a mobile screen. On a widescreen computer display, there's plenty of space for elegant UI controls.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tsukikage 6y agoBeing able to click to go directly some porportion of the way through then fine tune, instead of having to scroll through all the intervening space.
- mawise 6y agoI think stylistic self-expression is important! While this article focuses on desktop and owned devices, there's been similar sentiment about the web (for example: [1]. Facebook gives everyone's site the same uniform styling, so there isn't much room for stylistic self-expression on the web. Unless you run your own site. This was one thing I kept in mind on my side project (easily self-hosted private blogs)[2] where I give people freedom to muck with the CSS however they want. We get to do so much more when we own our own content and platforms. [1]: https://jarredsumner.com/codeblog/ https://jarredsumner.com/codeblog/ [2]: https://havenweb.org/ https://havenweb.org/
- at_a_remove 6y agoI am torn on this. On one hand, these kinds of choices made MySpace very popular. At the same time, they could make particular pages almost unreadable. And certainly in the Windows 3.1 days I was occasionally called to "fix" when someone had made a near contrastless color scheme and couldn't figure how to get out of it. Aside from issues of taste -- and Christmas season is the perfect time to look around at people's idea of good taste -- I think the best thing to come up with in this area, sort of an anti-footgun, would be an automatic contrast checker, similar to checking for different kinds of color-blindness.
- schwartzworld 6y ago> At the same time, they could make particular pages almost unreadable. That's part of the fun of having your own page. Your aesthetic can be whatever you want, including "borderline unreadable". https://www.reddit.com/r/Ooer/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Ooer/ is a great example of prioritizing form over function ad absurdum.
- saagarjha 6y agoThe true Ooer experience is at https://old.reddit.com/r/Ooer/ https://old.reddit.com/r/Ooer/.
- cgrealy 6y agoIs it possible that the reason for this is that the desktop simply isn’t that important anymore? For a non-trivial number of people, a “real computer” (i.e. a laptop or desktop) is still just a web browser with a nicer way of typing. People don’t care about customising their computers as much anymore because they have several devices and almost all of them are for accessing internet services (even “apps” are generally just an optimised UX for a web service).
- jug 6y agoI think this is clouded by nostalgia in case it's implying greater customizability than today. It's little more customizable than Windows 10 which has both light and dark modes for even more than the chrome, it has colorizable title bars, and of course it has wallpapers. The accent colors can be customized to take effect on the start menu background, the task bar, and the title bars. This is how my desktop looks right now with merely two additions: TaskbarX for a centered task bar and Rainmeter for some "widgets": https://i.imgur.com/4qoxSkM.png https://i.imgur.com/4qoxSkM.png
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 29athrowaway 6y agoAt least for GTK there is Oomox, a theme generator than provides even more customization than Windows 3.1 https://github.com/themix-project/oomox https://github.com/themix-project/oomox
- miohtama 6y agoDevelopers still do this with editor themes
- fchu 6y agoThe reality is that most users don't care about computer personalization anymore, a computer is just a conduit to the actual desired activity (browsing the web, playing games, watching movies, etc.). Sure, 20 years ago, when content was scarce, people would find joy customizing their Winamp themes/visualizations, or changing their ringtones every week (remember when spending money for 20s of midi music was a $B business?). Nowadays it feels like a chore for most of us.
- perryizgr8 6y agoI just want my pc to look like windows 2000. Don't really care about night mode and other nonsense. Win2000 is when UI/UX design peaked. And you had full control! I could change each UI element's font/color separately. Absolutely legendary. And it was fast and fluid af.