17 ms·
French news sites prevail in negotiations with Google over "neighboring rights”
- phillipseamore 6y agoI wonder if Google is running a large scale A/B experiment. Agree to pay in France while testing removal of news results in Australia.
- sheepdestroyer 6y agoOnly two test cases, Isn't it the smallest scale possible?
- severine 6y agoGoogle News hasn't worked in Spain for years: https://support.google.com/news/publisher-center/answer/9609687?hl=en https://support.google.com/news/publisher-center/answer/9609... So at least three test cases, and I guess there are more.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dehrmann 6y agoI honestly don't think News is worth the business headache of this. I suspect Google makes most of its ad revenue from brand keywords (the first result for "nike" being an ad for nike.com) and e-commerce keywords. News is a nice-to-have for users, but if they left it to a third party, it wouldn't drive away users or much revenue.
- creata 6y agoWhat makes news sites so special that they, unlike every other website, get to charge Google when they are indexed, and more shockingly, that they can compel Google to index them?
- kevingadd 6y agoFTA: 'In 2019, Google announced it was going to stop displaying "snippets" from French news articles in search results. Google believed that showing only news story headlines, not brief excerpts from articles, would bring it into compliance with the new law.' The problem is that they were going beyond indexing: they were lifting content from the article wholesale and embedding it into search results (without permission). They do this with all sorts of other stuff too, news sites aren't the only ones who get irritated by it.
- rognjen 6y ago> lifting content from the article wholesale From your quote: > brief excerpts
- jasode 6y ago>The problem is that they were going beyond indexing: they were lifting content from the article wholesale and embedding it into search results (without permission). Yes, but your full quoted text further explains that even just linking the headlines _without_ the snippets was still not in compliance. We have 30+ years of the world wide web being built on referred url links (no snippets) without monetary payment but now French news organizations want compensation for it. I don't understand that logic. They get extra visibility + traffic clicks from Google but also want to be paid for it?!? If after a Apple WWDC event, the front page of HN is filled with url links to Apple press releases and announcements, it doesn't mean HN should pay money to Apple Inc to send eyeballs to "apple.com". Linking to other urls (for free) is how the web works. IMO, removing the embedded snippets should have been enough.
- tomklein 6y agoIt’s a win-win already. Google is listing those sites giving them the opportunity to be seen by lots of people and news sites sell subscriptions or put ads on their sites to make money. I don’t really get why Google should pay news sites for promoting them and helping them make money. Personally, I always clicked to read more if I wanted to know more about a certain topic.
- creata 6y agoYep. It feels like the news corporations are just being greedy, but I'd like to see their side of the case.
- the_other 6y agoGoogle and Facebook have been eating such a large proportion of the ad cake for years; of course news want a larger slice! Whether it's "fair" by the rules of capitalism that they get it is up to capitalism to decide, but it's definitely fair that they stake a claim.
- Mauricebranagh 6y agoAh the the massive advertising cash cow supported by journalists paid poverty wages. Before craigslist and property listing companies like right move, local newspapers had 30-40% margins (source a senior press officer I worked on a project with)
- m12k 6y agoI think the problem is that politicians know they should be regulating big tech, but doing so is hard. And then along comes a lobbyist from the news media with some draft legislation that's pretty easy to understand and pass. It doesn't actually solve any real problem, but it's _something_, and it allows them to be seen fighting against the bad guys that they're supposed to be fighting. Even though it means passing bad legislation
- ClumsyPilot 6y ago'News corporation' have been rendered pennyless since the decline of print, people dont want to pay for digital news. This has led to a global decline of standard sin journalism, they can't afford to send investigative journalists around the world, news stories are poorly researched and written. As a society we are paying a heavy price for this stupidity
- simonh 6y agoMy guess is News Showcase, the new service Google has created for this paid linked news, will become a little used search backwater the French mainstream News services go to die. Not hosting them in News itself is as close as Google can get to not hosting them at all. Meanwhile the small independent French news publishers on Google News should get a nice boost without Old News to compete with. How the French News groups don't see this is beyond me, but there seems no limit to the level of stupid coming from European publishers. They probably even think they've finally won, and that News Showcase is a brilliant way to segment their premium content. It's going to be interesting to see how this plays out, but my bet is Google just completely blindsided them - pass the popcorn.
- rognjen 6y agoI think that this is a (smart) move to show Australia what they're willing to do and what they're not. I haven't yet formulated a complete opinion on this whole situation though. On the one hand the issue of Google showing better and better results based on someone else's content is clever and good for their users while on the other it is to the detriment of the creator of that content.
- dannyw 6y agoGoogle should just remove all news sites from their search results completely.
- ketzu 6y agoI can understand if people hold the opinion google shouldn't have to pay for that and that market preasure for news organizations is the organizations problem and not that of google. I have a hard time following the idea that google should use its dominant market position to force others into submission. This sounds distinctively worse than convincing a democratically elected government that you need protection (e.g., because the market is failing to some degree and your industry is important for the country in some form). This wouldn't be a good result for consumers either. Google is not an underdog screwed by some corrupt government and is just too honest and noble to bribe the law away or invest in any form of lobbying.
- bluecalm 6y agoThe problem with convincing a democratically elected government is that existing players can use their power (think of the jobs!) to rescue their bad business and thus preventing better alternatives from coming up. I for one think news industry is worse than worthless. No news would be better than current news. I think there is a need for information but news is selectively picked information turned into entertainment. I don't think we are better informed nor in any other way better off because of this junk. Let it fail and see what comes up next.
- sidibe 6y ago> I have a hard time following the idea that google should use its dominant market position to force others into submission If it's just a case of legally avoiding the new law, it's not a case of using "its dominant position to force others into submission." If they remove the smallest level of what makes them noncompliant, which in this case might be removing search outright (because otherwise they are supposed to link to and pay the news sites), to me that's fair game and not monopolistic. If they threaten to do something to unrelated things like Gmail or GCP, that's not OK.
- v4dok 6y agoNews made their money through ads. Now no one buys ad real estate on newspapers so they have to serve google adds on their websites which is a fraction of the income they would get. Google is eating up the lunch of news, so news have to find another way to monetize. Of course, we come slowly but surely to the understanding that News are essential to the society even without generating profit. But who pays the bills?? Government cant without making them depended on them and hence biasing the news. People are not seeing the immediate value since they are spoon fed this clickbait, bigot garbage and they think they are "up to date. Forcing the ads behemoths to share the pie seems like a logical step, although, its ill-executed and ofc the incentive for Google would be to minimize that cost. This game is now getting started.
- mrtksn 6y agoIn some countries the government pays the bills in exchange of favourable coverage. How do they pay? The owner gets government contracts in other industries or the government buys ads or issues as public service. In lest corrupt countries but still with corrupt journalistic ethics the news becomes the ads. The entire tech journalism business revolve around this. Give me good reviews and I will send you demo units, I will take you to a camp and will give you real good accommodation and slap a paid promotion video order as an extra. extra governmental political journalism is also not any better. You become a mouthpiece for a political group and the funnel money to sustain your publication. You can tap ads business for the stuff that is not allowed to be openly advertised. For example, in some places where doctors are not allowed to advertise the news channels will offer an interview about certain illness in exchange of payment from the interviewer. The news sites get their content and get paid for it, the doctors get their name on news articles that looks legit journalistic work. It's really unfortunate.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoBut this is the government paying, just with Google serving as the middle man. There's no actual economic linkage here, which means that Google's payments to the news organizations are actually a tax that skips the public coffers and goes straight to the news owners. But it's no different than if the government levied a tax specifically on Google and paid the whole of that tax to the news orgs. Both approaches make an equal amount of economic sense. Personally I think it would make much more sense to raise a general corporate profit tax, and use the proceeds of that tax to pay the news. But there's a convenient devil to extract money from, so there it is.
- csomar 6y agoAnyone did (or willing to do) research on how to become eligible for Google cash? I think you can't put particular names in legislation (ie: Pay xx euros for xx clicks for Le Figaro); and I also don't think Google is going to pay up any site who shows up on his News result. So how is the eligibility being determined and what is the process to get the money?
- fakedang 6y agoThere is a process for newsrooms to get into Google News, so I assume they'll use that vetting to determine if a site should be paid or not. Which means that for news that Google links to that does not come from News, but from Search, they will likely not pay for it.
- comboy 6y agoSomebody will make the next version of GPT read the all existing published law and it will be a clusterfuck. Tons of contradictions, everybody is guilty of something, nobody except computer program can hold it in their memory to know when and what should apply. It's madness. Yes I know it's only tangentially related, but I believe most regulations against big tech only establish their domination. These companies can likely invest more resources in legal analysis than the goverment, so they will use most of it to their advantage. Laws should be as general as possible. We have robots.txt, you can even add some new marker, if some news site doesn't want to have it content fetched in an automated way, let it have that but it's already a slippery slope because why should a human be able to read it and write an article citing source if a program cannot do that.
- jokethrowaway 6y agoWhile I generally agree with you (look how VATMOSS, that was supposed to be a way to force Amazon to pay vat taxes, forced all the small sellers - without money to spend on implementation - on Amazon), I don't see an upside for Google. This is likely just change for Google though. They probably consider the value of showing French newspaper content to be higher than whatever the price has been set.
- cannabis_sam 6y agoI kinda want to help make this a reality.. Even though I believe that a solely “mechanical”/“logical”interpretation of laws, misses the point in some really important ways. Approaching law/justice systems as a computer system to be manipulated, usually results in the judge seeing through the manipulation and cracking down on it, while still enforcing the spirit of the law rather than adhering to mechanical minutiae.. (Modulus the differences between common law and civil law jurisdictions, which probably colours my view)
- kazen44 6y agocontradictions also exist in civil law systems (ofcourse). But seem to be far less... cloudy then common law systems. Most contradictions in civil law seem to either be from really old law (think, pre french revolution/napoleonic period) or from weird edge cases which get covered by two laws which contradict themselves. The first one is usually not resolved because it is just straight up ignored. There was a famous example of this a couple of years ago about a law which prohibited people from carrying swords/knives inside city walls.
- jokethrowaway 6y agoGood for you French newspapers. Enjoy the free money. This is exactly why the next Google won't be a French company.
- d0100 6y agoCouldn't Google just GPT3 the titles and not have to pay?
- jeroenhd 6y ago"The French Competition Authority held that the deal Google offered to news sites—let us index your site for free or we won't index it at all—was an abuse of that market power and contrary to the spirit of the new French law." This is why this law is so terrible. If the government wants news media to keep its role in society, it should not force a private entity to pay a "failed to monetize the web"-tax. News companies cannot demand payment while they demand that Google indexes their pages for them. The lobbying of the news industry it truly terrible and has made me question if I want to pay for any news media when the national news service is perfectly fine and accessible for free. I want to support independent journalism, but I don't want to sponsor the moneymaking schemes they're inserting into the law.
- Phlogistique 6y ago> News companies cannot demand payment while they demand that Google indexes their pages for them You have got it wrong. Nobody asks of Google that they pay for indexing news sites in Google Search. And no news company wants to force Google to include their content in Google News. The thing is there are two different services, Google News and Google Search. The news companies have a beef with Google News. Google has been saying: if you do not accept us using your content in Google News, we will remove you from Google Search.
- PoignardAzur 6y ago> Nobody asks of Google that they pay for indexing news sites in Google Search That's 100% what the French media asked for. What they wanted was essentially for Google to pay them a "You make money doing what we used to have a monopoly on" tax; they got mad when Google dodged the tax by following the letter of the EUCD and removing quoted snippets from searches.
- bigpumpkin 6y agoIf I started a small news aggregator app, would I also have to pay these sites or is it only for large companies.
- benlivengood 6y agoThe problem is that news media run terrible ads that don't make them money and the paradox of choice makes subscribing to individual news organizations a losing proposition for just about everyone. Music and video producers make money because they license their content for streaming and online purchases. I'm at a loss for why the news media hasn't figured out how to do this yet. My fear is that ultimately the market values news too little.
- notsureaboutpg 6y ago>My fear is that ultimately the market values news too little. This is a fate that could befall music/movies as well. News media is too "woke" for its own good (for lack of a more accurate, more complex, longer explanation), and people are abandoning it in droves. The type of media that will survive is the kind you see in India that's overly nationalistic. It's upsetting, but that's clearly what the market wants and will pay for.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cheriot 6y agoThey use to do that. The problem is that it makes less sense in a digital world because you want a single URI to consolidate shares and SEO. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Print_syndication https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Print_syndication
- njarboe 6y ago"News" has little value and that's fine. It is "new" things and in this internet world it is fleeting, click-bait articles purely read for entertainment. Main stream research journalism is what I fear the market does not value. The best researchers now have private highly paid news letters.
- renewiltord 6y agoUnsurprising. Old economies have old power structures. They suppress disruptors as much as possible. This is why Europe - a continent generally as large and educated as America - has such few startups. Most startups have been great for the world. Google, Facebook, Amazon, Netflix, Apple. They've made our world so much better. But old power structures are all about the status quo. Strictly, this particular thing isn't why the next such useful startup won't be from France. It just showcases the way that country's power structures operate. They're heavily status quo oriented. It's always about "how do we pay the current church its tithe".
- weregiraffe 6y ago>Most startups have been great for the world. Google, Facebook, Amazon, Netflix, Apple. They've made our world so much better. This claim about massive corporations making the world better is disputed.
- danbolt 6y agoI mean, like, Facebook was fun back when bringing a digital camera to high school made you a big deal online in 2007. Today though, Zuck has access to an archive of me with the worst haircuts I’ll ever have had in my life.
- lapinot 6y agoRight. Disgusting to see these states crushing random corps that try keeping afloat.. oh, or did i mean to say these corps crushing random states that try keeping afloat?
- renewiltord 6y agoIt's neither disgusting nor gusting. It's just that when you do this you also get that. If you want neither, that's fine, but clearly France is trying to also get some startups, but it's not going to work. Because France will eat you if you get big and the risk is too high to be worth it if you only get moderate.