9 ms·
It's worth noting how much actual political power the right in America has, despite being about 50% of voters. The Senate and electoral college favor them mass
by triceratops 6y ago
It's worth noting how much actual political power the right in America has, despite being about 50% of voters.
The Senate and electoral college favor them massively. This means you should expect to have an uphill battle if you want to change any laws that might counter their preferences.
- whatshisface 6y agoA business that is heavily involved with local government has to sweat Republican politics, a business that is heavily involved with technology, the media, or other forms of nonstate power has to sweat Democrat politics. I guess it would be nice if companies could simply focus on getting their job done and not have to sweat anyone's politics at all.
- hellotomyrars 6y agoIt would be nice if it were possible to be apolitical but in many respects it isn't depending on the nature of your business and that's a reality I think some people are reticent to accept. Corporations exist to make money and there isn't an industry out there that doesn't actively lobby in their interest. Turns out being `apolitical` is kind of a myth.
- xxpor 6y agoPolitics is the the practice of how to organize society. There's no such thing as an apolitical entity. At the most basic level, just the fact that corporations exist is itself a political decision.
- whatshisface 6y agoSure, with a sufficiently expansive definition of political everything is, but in the comment above, "politics" meant "dealing with the preferences of." So the local Republican politician would want stuff if you wanted to build your chemical plant, maybe a new baseball field, maybe campaign contributions. Your Democrat-aligned hosting provider would want you to not run the center of operations of their enemies. You are using politics in the academic sense, where two kids playing tag are engaging in politics, but that is not the only thing that "politics" can be used to describe. Companies should follow the law, not politics.
- 8note 6y agoCompanies should do what their owners want per capitalism. If that's politics, the company should do politics.
- whatshisface 6y agoSure, but the political system should not be such that the owners of the companies have anything to gain by wanting their companies to do politics.
- xxpor 6y agoThe only way that could ever be the case is if taxes ceased to exist. Until that point, there will always be lobbying for lower taxes. Your objection really seems to be engagement in culture wars.
- esoterica 6y agoCompanies have to obey laws and laws are written by politicians. Unless you think companies should be above the law they cannot, and should not be expected to, avoid thinking about politics.
- whatshisface 6y agoThinking about the law is a world away from thinking about politics. Companies should think about how to comply with regulations, but they should not be biting their nails over whether the candidate who's backing their chemical plant will give a speech about Marijuana decrimininalization that's convincing enough to secure him the position necessary to force the local regulatory body to change the acceptable limits on effluents so that it becomes possible to continue running a process on an old line.
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoIt sounds like you are suggesting that regulations should never change. Is that what you mean?
- stale2002 6y agoNo. That is not what the other person said. Did you accidently respond to the wrong comment? What the person said was that a chemical manufacturing company should not be "biting their nails" over some random Marijuana decrimininalization speech, that a random candidate is making.
- amanaplanacanal 6y agoAt the end he was talking about changing the rules on effluents. I guess I just doing understand what he is trying to say.
- whatshisface 6y agoWhy should the rules on effluents be related to marijuana policy? They shouldn't be. Why are the rules on effluents related to marijuana policy? Because politics works according to public sentiment attached to individual leaders and their parties, and the leaders and parties bundle together large packages of unrelated policies. Hence a chemical plant owner becomes interested in issues that have absolutely nothing to do with his businesses, or even his business' externalities.
- mc32 6y agoOne set of influencers is elected and held to account, the other is largely unaccountable.
- triceratops 6y ago> One set of influencers is elected and held to account Are they, though? > the other is largely unaccountable No the market will hold them to account.
- ntsplnkv2 6y agoFirst, the first set isn't a set of influencers. They directly legislate law. Second, the other is accountable to the same laws as anyone else.
- fjabre 6y agoThis is false. The left now has the Senate and the Presidency. The electoral college does not matter. They go the way their states go as was made quite clear in the last election. EDIT: Of course it matters how the voting system was designed. The EC votes the way their State votes. The forefathers intended for states to have some say in the matter. We are a representative democracy. That is how the system was designed.
- triceratops 6y ago> The left now has the Senate and the Presidency. The key term is "now". After getting about 40m more votes. Be honest. Is that balanced?
- fjabre 6y agoWas just pointing out it's quite clear that the nation itself is left leaning. That's honest by the numbers. To say the Republicans have any kind of advantage right now except for maybe the courts is incorrect.
- takeda 6y agoThey had to lose by 7 million votes to actually lose, I would say they have quite advantage. As another user said: "The Senate is split 50-50, but the 50 Democrats represent 41 million more people than the 50 Republicans"
- fjabre 6y agoWe are a representative democracy for a reason. It was designed that way. You can't change the rules of the game because you're losing. The United States was designed as a representative democracy on purpose by the forefathers. That is fact.
- sjwright 6y agoJust because something was designed for a specific purpose a few hundred years ago doesn't mean it serves that same purpose today. Situations change. The Constitution was designed to be amended.
- minikites 6y agoThe Senate is split 50-50, but the 50 Democrats represent 41 million more people than the 50 Republicans: https://twitter.com/AriBerman/status/1352293847385124864 https://twitter.com/AriBerman/status/1352293847385124864 If voting in this country wasn't suppressed at the local level by Republican state governments, the federal government would look very different. It would be much more diverse and representative of real Americans, not just white male Americans.
- cairoshikobon 6y agoBanning speech by half the population is not "soft power" anymore in the world we live in.
- ceejayoz 6y agoThat'd be true, if it happened. Plenty of conservatives left on Twitter.
- ssully 6y agoWhen did half the population have their speech banned?
- takeda 6y agoThe whole argument is so silly. Trump could snap a finger and have cameras ready to air on national TV whatever he wanted to say. If Valve bans me from Steam for my language is that also violation of my free speech or is it their right to protect their platform?
- someguydave 6y agoIt depends - is Valve also claiming liability protection under section 230 as a information service provider?
- triceratops 6y agoBeing an information service provider with Section 230 protection doesn't obligate that provider to allow anyone to post anything.
- someguydave 6y agoNo, but it should make the platform similar to a public square. Taking a government grant of liability protection should come with obligations to the public.
- jki275 6y ago50 Senators are Democrats or caucus with them, and the Electoral college just put a Democrat in the White House -- so you can't really make such a claim with a straight face.
- triceratops 6y agoI said "favors". The 50 Democratic Senators represent 40m more people than the 50 Republican Senators. It's far easier for the balance to tip right than left. The electoral college was decided by about 40k votes this time, and about 80k votes last time. The popular vote margin was in the millions. That should tell you something about how far the EC is from reality.
- jki275 6y ago"popular vote" has absolutely no bearing on anything in this discussion. The US is not a direct democracy, it is a representative republic. The 50 senators who represent semi-conservative states represent the same number of states as the 50 who represent more liberal states.
- triceratops 6y ago> The US is not a direct democracy, it is a representative republic. I'm aware of that. And that structure favors one side more than another. This is not a controversial statement - the numbers (y'know, facts and logic) back that up. States are lines on a map. In the current setup they have more influence than the actual people living in those states. Do you seriously not see how that can lead to disproportionate representation of some views?
- newfriend 6y ago> States are lines on a map. Saying this doesn't make them less important, it just shows a childish attitude. Local and State governments and representation are important parts of the Republic. Dollars are just numbers in a database. Will you give me all your money? Or is it only certain "made-up" things that are important to you? > Do you seriously not see how that can lead to disproportionate representation of some views? Yes, and straight up popular vote leads to the same thing. That's why we have a system that is a combination of popular vote and state vote. * The People are represented by the House. * The States are represented by the Senate. * Both are represented by the President. Seems like a well-balanced system to me.
- modriano 6y agoThe Democratic Presidential candidate has won the popular vote in the last 7 of 8 Presidential elections[0], with the Dems having, on average, about 5 million more votes for those 8 elections. It's empirically fair to say the right represents about 45% of voters (which makes their power even more noteworthy). [0] year,dem_candidate,dem_votes,gop_candidate,gop_votes 1992,Bill Clinton,44909806,George H. W. Bush,39104550 1996,Bill Clinton,47401185,Bob Dole,39197469 2000,Al Gore,50999897,George W. Bush,50456002 2004,John Kerry,59028444,George W. Bush,62040610 2008,Barack Obama,69498516,John McCain,59948323 2012,Barack Obama,65915795,Mitt Romney,60933504 2016,Hillary Clinton,65853514,Donald Trump,62984828 2020,Joe Biden,81268867,Donald Trump,74216747
- nostromo 6y agoThe electoral college actually favored Biden this time. He got 57% of EC votes, which is much higher than his share of the popular vote. This is all pointless anyway for a union of states. Germany is underpowered compared to Luxembourg in the EU by design -- the same is true in the US. Should California ever go back to being conservative, as it was until Clinton, it will disadvantage Republicans just the same.
- triceratops 6y ago> The electoral college actually favored Biden this time I think we're operating on different definitions of "favored". The definition I'm using (and which most of the English-speaking world uses) is "have a fundamental advantage". He won the electoral college narrowly. He won the popular vote handsomely. That's a sign of a thumb on the scale in a pretty fundamental way.
- nostromo 6y ago> He won the electoral college narrowly. He won the popular vote handsomely. He didn't though. He won 57% of the electoral vote and 51% of the popular vote.
- triceratops 6y agoAnother way of looking at it though, is he won the electoral college by a margin of 40k votes (the margin of victory in the states that mattered). He won the popular vote by a margin of 7m votes.
- gowld 6y agoYou're a pretty famous person, so we know you are smart enough to know that nothing above 50% matters. "Favor" only matters to extent it helps a candidate get over 270 EV.
- triceratops 6y agoSorry, you're saying the US should be more like the EU?