6 ms·
Unashamed MBA checking in here! MBAs are the classic punching bags for HN. It seems we’re willing to bend the “civility” rules a bit here in order to have a nic
by ryandrake 6y ago
Unashamed MBA checking in here! MBAs are the classic punching bags for HN. It seems we’re willing to bend the “civility” rules a bit here in order to have a nice hearty MBA-bash. I’ve seen all sorts of awful generalizations posted here about MBAs that would get you flagkilled if made about other professions or degrees. Some of us actually have tech/coding backgrounds and aren’t the stereotypical pointy-headed-bosses, and it sucks to get lumped in with them but it’s ok—we don’t take it personally. Try to keep in mind though that we aren’t all bad!
- ignoramous 6y agoIf it helps, all those MBA-bashing cool tech startups busy giving away a percentage of their revenue to Amazon, don't realise that AWS was the brain-child of a Harvard MBA.
- reducesuffering 6y agoJassy didn't propose, code, or solely invent AWS in any way.
- ignoramous 6y agoYou're right but Andy, for lack of a better word, willed AWS into existence: https://techcrunch.com/2016/07/02/andy-jassys-brief-history-of-the-genesis-of-aws/ https://techcrunch.com/2016/07/02/andy-jassys-brief-history-... That's gotta count for something.
- lordnacho 6y agoYes precisely. The MBA skill was to get credit for an obvious strategic possibility that required a huge team to pull off. Happens on many levels though, it's not as if engineers don't get credit for team efforts.
- johncena33 6y agoYes, the "idea man" deserves all the credit and everyone else is just a drone there to execute their vision. Sounds like classic MBA culture to me.
- m_mueller 6y agoI think this is hyperbole. Noone said he deserves all the credit - just that this guy's thinking was the missing ingredient that catapulted Amazon's IT department to be at the forefront of a new industry. There were many big IT departments like that around, but theirs was the first to productize at such a level.
- SJC_Hacker 6y agoCloud is basically managed hosting allowing a pay-as-you go model for resource utilization (compute, storage, etc.). Which was also not really anything new as that model existed on timeshared systems prior to that.
- commandlinefan 6y ago> we aren’t all bad! 99% of MBAs give the rest a bad name.
- avs733 6y agokind of like software developers! (according to HN as well)
- xedrac 6y agoWhile not fair to make sweeping generalizations, many of us engineers have had so many bad experiences with MBAs that it's hard to not lump them all together. Their need for control and culture shaping seem to directly harm engineering efforts in almost every case I've seen. I suppose in some ways they will always be at odds with one another.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoI would buy that. Speaking of generalizations, can we just all agree that all HR people are bad people and a pox upon this land?
- astrange 6y agoSurely the ones that run your payroll and 401k benefits are okay.
- goatinaboat 6y agoSurely the ones that run your payroll and 401k benefits are okay. The old "Personnel Department" did that perfectly well long before HR was a thing.
- tal8d 6y ago< 401k benefits Maybe it is because I've never worked in the valley, but I can't think of a positive 401k plan experience. I do remember a lot of onboarding powerpoint with regards to penalties and limitations. The whole thing feels coercive, having to participate in the market when you aren't interested in managing the position - simply to protect your savings from intentionally set inflation rates. All those "unsophisticated investors" (no joke, that is what they call you) are arguably the cause of the dot-com bubble as well, not because people were daytrading pets.com, but because fund managers had to put that surge of disinterested capital somewhere. I imagine that if powerpoint was around back in the day, the guys managing company store credit schemes would have functioned much like today's HR reps.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y ago
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoFully agree. I was referring to a specific case where the payscale for people with MBA degrees was lower than the payscale for people with undergraduate engineering degrees. In my experience, there are many great leaders with MBA degrees. However, you never hear about their MBA degree because they have so many other accomplishments to lead with. They are managers who happen to have completed an MBA program in the past. The troublesome people are those who lean on credentialism in the hopes that merely having the MBA degree will allow them to skip to the head of the compensation structure. Anyone who builds their identity around the university they attended or the degree they received will raise a lot of red flags.
- SJC_Hacker 6y agoThe problem is less people that start out in engineering then switch to MBA/busness track. Its the psych majors / marketdrone people who think that running a tech company is equivalent like running a clothing line or sports drink company.
- hellohello1 6y agoMBAs are the equivalent of butter bars in the military. You get a lot of fresh faced BCOM -> MBA grads who know absolutely nothing but doctrine and are put in a position of power. CompSci -> Work in industry -> MBA usually produces the best managers.
- anticensor 6y agoCompSci -> EngMan path also exists.
- syndacks 6y agoIt's funny to me how HN folk like to point to "community guidelines" and downvote based on them, but then completely eschew them when it comes time to rag on MBAs, managers, or tout some bullshit about how we're approaching 1984 because a random startup decides to potentially use your data to make a buck.
- nottorp 6y agoTell me then, is there a MBA that doesn't assume all employees are interchangeable, and results are proportional to the amount of time spent on working? That's the usual MBA mistake when dealing with IT. Most of what you've been taught applies to ditch diggers or bottling Coca Cola.