8 ms·
Why cats are crazy for catnip
- blindm 6y agoIs the high similar to heroin/morphine etc in humans? Because if it is, then is catnip not addictive to a cat? What if a cat discovers whole fields of the stuff and decided to revel in it until death? It's unlikely but it could happen
- soulofmischief 6y agoA cat is not going to OD on catnip. Also, from the article: "Big or small, the felines surrendered to the substance, rubbing their heads and bodies in the patches for an average of 10 minutes"
- leadingthenet 6y agoSooo, more like DMT for cats?
- FrozenVoid 6y agoWhat if a human discovers whole aisles of cheese and decided to relish in it until casomorphin overdose?
- taneq 6y agoI've made my choice, leave me be.
- aasasd 6y agoWhy must you tantalize me so.
- lordnacho 6y agoSelection. People who are in their cheesy death throes don't have a free hand to write on HN.
- leadingthenet 6y agoAren’t personal attacks like this a ban-able offence on HN? Edit: twas a joke, guys...
- Nursie 6y agoStops having an effect pretty quickly. They'd wander off, then maybe come back later. I've observed mine do that with catnip and silvervine.
- failrate 6y agoAnecdotr: one of our cats, upon presented with unlimited amounts of catnip, consumed it until it became basically K-holed and then refused to touch the stuff for a few years afterwards, suggesting the equivalent of a hangover.
- minitoar 6y agoLol we’ve all been there, if only eating too many sweets.
- wasdfff 6y agoMy parents grow large bushes of catnip. The cat walks up to the bush, chews it some, and passes out in the bush. Seems to enjoy himself.
- Ensorceled 6y agoWhy was this: > The team, which has already patented an insect repellent based on nepetalactol, At the BOTTOM of this article.
- aceazzameen 6y agoCats are going to love people who spray that stuff on.
- tgtweak 6y agoCat cologne missed opportunity tbh
- matthewmacleod 6y agoBecause it's a pretty reasonable place to put openly declared competing interests in a news article about a paper in one of the publisher's journals?
- cosmodisk 6y agoNot just catnip,valerian too,which is a 'top recreational drug' for cats, apparently. When we were kids,we used to give small amounts of valerian root to our cat to chew. The cat would literally tear anything apart just to get it. Then,a few minutes later,it gets high, and just keeps rolling over purring with satisfaction.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoOur cats are definitely more into valerian than catnip, they dive face first into the stuff, eat it, roll around in it, etc. With catnip, no reaction.
- eps 6y agoValerian is the cat drug in my home country. Mentioned it once to a friend, a Canadian, and brought him a bit the next time I went back home for a visit. His cat had no reaction. Zero. But the catnip worked as expected.
- gwern 6y agoThat's a little surprising, since Bol et al 2017 (https://bmcvetres.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12917-017-0987-6 https://bmcvetres.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12917-...), testing catnip/Valerian/silvervine/honeysuckle on ~100 cats, found that the response to each is correlated. (I get a tetrachoric correlation of 0.6 for catnip/valerian in my analysis: https://www.gwern.net/Catnip#optimal-catnip-alternative-selection-solving-the-mdp https://www.gwern.net/Catnip#optimal-catnip-alternative-sele... ) I think you probably just got unlucky there.
- yokaze 6y agoMost cats, that is. 50-70% do not respond to catnip.
- EE84M3i 6y ago>Most cats, that is. 50-70% do not respond to catnip. Wouldn't that be the opposite of "most"?
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoI suspect like most things in nature it's a bell curve; of varying responses. My cat responds, but not super enthusiastically. I've had other cats that just ignored. And other cats that went crazy for the stuff.
- malobre 6y agoSource ? According to https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5356310/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5356310/ only around a third of cats does not respond to catnip.
- jbarberu 6y agoMy anecdata confirms this, one of my three is not a nip-head.
- helen___keller 6y agoI've considered growing actinidia kolomikta, a species of kiwi berry vine, which is noted on wikipedia as being highly attractive to cats. The article mentions Actinidia polygama so I wonder if it's just the entire genus
- throwawaygal7 6y agoI think it is most of the genus, I've seen cats eat the shoots on Actinidia plants (Arugata). I know silvervine is in a lot of catnip mixed, I think not all cats react to whatever pheromone is in catnip so a lot of mixes have several different euphoria in them to try to increase efficacy.
- pvaldes 6y agoNot my experience growing arctic kiwi. Cats don't ever seem to stop to take a look but I could be wrong. I will watch more carefully.
- dirtyid 6y agoNew cat utterly unresponsive to catnip, wonder if defective. Have never encountered a cat that didn't go cray for the nips until now. Last cat was so into it, I worried whether she experienced withdraw symptoms. Literature on that is pretty mixed though.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoCan't smell? Can detect food when hidden?
- code_duck 6y agoSpeaking to an Australian friend, I learned that 25% of cats don't respond to catnip at all - or cat mint, as they call it. Apparently the branch of the cat family in Australia are ones that don't have the catnip genes, so she had never witnessed a cat acting crazy in the characteristic cat way. My previous cats did two different things - one would instantly flop down and roll in the catnip, then lazily lick it off her paws. The other cat would make a beeline for any catnip and intently eat all of it, shoving aside the rolling cat.
- gwern 6y agoI've compiled all of the reported catnip studies and run some large-scale surveys of my own: https://www.gwern.net/Catnip https://www.gwern.net/Catnip https://www.gwern.net/Catnip-survey https://www.gwern.net/Catnip-survey Globally, catnip immunity rates are closer to a third, but Australia is at the extreme with about half cats not responding. Villani 2011 https://www.gwern.net/docs/catnip/2011-villani.pdf https://www.gwern.net/docs/catnip/2011-villani.pdf establishes that catnip response is highly heritable but polygenic (not Mendelian), and to a first approximation, no one studies cat genetics - so it will be difficult to prove that there's some sort of founder effect on Australian/Mexican/Spanish cats causing a lower genetic propensity.
- glenneroo 6y agoThis is quite amazing. The longer I read, the more impressed I am that you went through all the trouble. Considering the time and money spent on surveys, et al., was this ever published as a study? p.s. This is the ultimate thread-killer. Had this been posted at the very top of the thread, most of the comments and speculations posted would be irrelevant. Can @dang please pin this to the top? ;)
- lemcoe9 6y agoAnother opportunity for a shameless plug of my website: https://ipkitten.com https://ipkitten.com It simply serves you a random kitten GIF (some of which involve catnip) and provides your IP address alongside some other connection information. EDIT: The ARIN JSON endpoints have rate-limited me, so ISP information is currently unavailable.
- spiffytech 6y agoPerfect - looks like this will be my new go-to IP checking tool. I'll add it into my kitten dev toolbox alongside https://placekitten.com/ https://placekitten.com/
- tgtweak 6y agoYou should cache the cidr ranges and arin responses for a decent amount of time since they seldom change.
- pantalaimon 6y agoIt only shows IPv4
- cafeoh 6y agoonly shows IPv6 for me.
- leblancfg 6y ago> Our findings suggest instead that rolling is rather a functional behavior. People smoke weed all the time and it decreases violence. But that’s not why they do it. Chances are just as good that the insect repellant is just a nice side effect of these cats getting high, not the other way around.
- 3395810 6y agoThey get high from ingesting it. Not from rolling around in it.
- matsemann 6y ago> Chances are just as good that the insect repellant is just a nice side effect of these cats getting high, not the other way around. In evolution, couldn't it be that the trait of enjoying catnip made them more resilient to mosquitos and thus had a higher chance of surviving, or so?
- leblancfg 6y agoSure thing, although I would argue the increased evolutionary fitness would be very small. The fact that they roll in it vs just inhaling it to me also suggests this. Maybe their use of the word "functional" is different than mine, and we're saying the same thing. But to me there's a big difference from saying e.g. "Our findings suggest that chimps using sticks to dislodge food is a functional behavior."
- de_nied 6y ago> People smoke weed all the time > and it decreases violence https://i.imgur.com/61JXtJ7.png https://i.imgur.com/61JXtJ7.png
- Nursie 6y agoA timely article. I just put some silvervine powder in a paper bag and watched our kitties go mental, sticking their heads in, rolling around. Great fun.
- S_A_P 6y agoCatnip is the only socially acceptable drug that I’ve seen that you can administer to animals. Imagine the outrage if you substitute catnip with cannabis or alcohol and post it to YouTube. Granted in the case of alcohol you most certainly could kill the animal.
- jbotz 6y agoHow were they able to patent this? I've known for 20 years that catnip works as a mosquito repellent; there was a 2001 paper that showed that its essential oil, nepetalactone, was 10 times more effective than DEET[1]. Soon after this a variety of "natural mosquito repellent" products based on catnip appeared on the market. I've made homemade repellent myself by soaking catnip in alcohol and it works great, although it wears off faster than commercial DEET-based repellent; have to keep reapplying. Anyway, another patent that shouldn't have been issued. [1] https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2001/08/010828075659.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2001/08/010828075659.h...
- ballenf 6y agoWere you ever mobbed by cats while using? I could see that effect really freaking someone out who wasn't ready for it. Like a scene from Hitchcock's The Birds but cats.
- EGreg 6y agoSo you trade mosquitoes for cats... Sounds like what Israel did but with rats for cats... in a different way hehe https://blogs.timesofisrael.com/concerning-cat-population-in-israel/ https://blogs.timesofisrael.com/concerning-cat-population-in...
- buescher 6y agoHere's the patent. The claims are a little more specific than I think you're imagining - that's typical for making something like this patentable. https://patents.google.com/patent/US7524888B2 https://patents.google.com/patent/US7524888B2
- s1artibartfast 6y agoStill extremely broad. >sesquiterpenoid mixture, wherein the sesquiterpenoid mixture is an elmol/hedycaryol mixture having a purity of 55% or more (..plus any possible carrier)
- CuriouslyC 6y ago
- zvrba 6y agoMy cats get high after eating tiny bits of green olives. They roll, are crazy for more, will literally lick my clothes if I spilled a drop of the pickle, and one of the gets a bit playfully aggressive. Just the smell of olives attracts them like crazy. Have also tried catnip, but no observable effect. I don't overdo it, I don't have olives very often in the fridge, and even then they maybe get a tiny piece once a week.
- gverrilla 6y agoI'm curious: what was the situtation when they first ate olives?
- zvrba 6y agoI never gave them olives by conscious decision; it never occurred to me that they'd like i t. I think I spilled some brine (few drops only) on the kitchen desk, the cat appeared to be there at the same time, sniffed at it, licked it and got crazy for more.
- hrnnnnnn 6y agoOur cat loves olives too, it's the only vegetable he'll eat. Always wondered if it was a unique quirk but I guess not!
- dokem 6y agoMy cat acts the same towards my sweaty post-workout socks. He can't seem to get enough of 'em. And he doesn't seem to care for cat nip nearly as much.
- SideburnsOfDoom 6y agoCats are known to like fatty and salty foods, and not have a "sweet tooth". Olives are oily, and preserved in salt
- zvrba 6y agoThis is beyond liking. The effect is similar to that of catnip when I watch videos of cats high on catnip. They start rolling, rubbing against surfaces, they beg for more, etc. And shortly after (10-ish minutes) the effect wanes off.
- qwerty456127 6y agoThey are not. I haven't met a cat crazy for catnip or valeriana since I was a kid. They either ignore them completely or express occasional moderate interest.
- Schiphol 6y ago> Most scientists and pet owners assumed the only reason that cats roll around in catnip was for the euphoric experience, Miyazaki says. "Our findings suggest instead that rolling is rather a functional behavior.” There is no incompatibility between proximal and distal, what they call functional, explanations of behavior. Once you have a brain with a reward system, a good way to encourage (discourage) a behavior that is (dis)functional is to make it (dis)pleasurable. A similar distinction in explanations of human behavior is what anthropologists call [emic/etic](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emic_and_etic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emic_and_etic). The emic viewpoint is that of the subject themselves; the etic viewpoint is that of the anthropologist (the ethologist in this case). A classical, and beautiful example is Malinowski's description of the [Kula ring](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kula_ring https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kula_ring) in Papua New Guinea. Participants in the ring see themselves as exchanging presents; Malinowski showed that there is a further political and economic significance to the ring. The two perspectives are perfectly compatible.
- dalbasal 6y agoEtic/emic is an insightful metaphor, mr airport. These things are complicated. Even in your type example, I doubt that papuan chiefs were oblivious of the political elements gift giving. OTOH, a purely etic viewpoint is (anthropologically) incomplete too. The political/economic machinery that outsiders/scholars find doesn't work, or make any sense, without the emic/cultural perspective. The same could be said of most political processes. The US just changed presidents. Leading up to it was weeks/months of ritual. Processes and procedures in many state chambers, and such. Most of it doesn't have a practical role, yet its culturally essential. We're often warned not to personify animals. I think more often we make the mistake of personifying people, so to speak. We always have rationalisations, but the way it works is usually after the fact... or only rational within an irrational/cultural frame. Leonard cohen said that free will is overrated. It exists but is rarely exercised. More often, we act because we are compelled. If cats were people, they'd roll in catnip because they're compelled to do so... but then cite this article and mosquitos as the "reason."
- armada651 6y agoI think you're misreading that paragraph. It is specifically saying the euphoria is not the _only_ reason that cats roll around in catnip.
- zwieback 6y agoI tried growing some catnip but the plants got eaten right down to the roots by someone. I tried again this time with a cage around the plant and it worked great but my cat just gets annoyed when I wave it in her face. Apparently she falls in the sober population
- leadingthenet 6y agoMaybe this is a weird question, but why do people give drugs to their cats? Is it to see them have fun? Is it so the owners have fun? Is it good for them? I never quite understood why catnip was so socially acceptable when we view other drugs with such different eyes.
- chmaynard 6y agoA thought-provoking question, thanks for asking.
- lreeves 6y agoFor the same reason I smoke weed. They clearly love it and it has no adverse effects (just don't let them eat it, use it in toys).
- the-dude 6y ago> has no adverse effects I used to think that too. And I still smoke ( hash, which is different ). However, it does make me complacent, which sometimes make me endure situations I would otherwise change.
- lreeves 6y agoOh I meant catnip, haha. I think pot definitely has some mild side-effects for sure.
- _underfl0w_ 6y agoComplacency is a huge downside. I'm also much less motivated to work on side projects. Not to mention the toll on the lungs. Ask Willie Nelson if you'd like anecdata about how that can play out over a lifetime. I've recently made the leap to edibles exclusively after a stint with a hot-air vaporizer (a la Volcano devices) and I now find the resin smell of smoking incredibly off-putting. The coughing, hacking, and lung stiffness that results from a bong rip even more so. Doesn't lessen the complacency, but the delay your metabolism introduces can help you get started on projects before it sets in!
- rpiguyshy 6y agoi recently moved into a house with some other people. they have cats which they have owned for many years. after living here for a while, i was sitting on the couch watching star trek with these people when one of the cats came up and sat on my lap. they were shocked. that cat didnt sit on any of their laps, ever. and they became a little jealous. this happens literally every time i take up residence with people who own cats. their cats become very attached to me and the owners become jealous. one time, very very jealous. most people are very blunt. they do not see past the surface of anything. they are impressed with superficial charm and not much else. they arent able to see inside a person, to figure out how their mind works or what it would be like to wear their shoes. they dont build models to explain the world and they arent interested in knowing how anything works. they dont listen when people speak. most people are stupid. and most of the time, this kind of talk is cast aside as being too vague and qualitative. but i have quantified it with cats. when you consider a cat, the first impulse is to anthropomorphize. and since the cat cant speak, your assumptions about what it wants are guided by your anthropomorphism. most people only get this far and so most peoples relationship with their cats are really relationships with themselves. but some people pay close attention to what the cat is doing and how it responds to things, and carefully pack away that data instead of just writing it off as noise or "thats just what cats do." eventually you are able to demonstrate to the cat, through your actions, that you understand what it is feeling and what it wants. when a cat realizes that you are paying attention, that you are listening, it is a very different experience for the cat. the cat understands whats going on and will act in a way that is designed to communicate. and they will also trust and love you much, much more than anyone else because they know you are listening. thats the key, they are smart enough to know. most people assume they are dumb, and attribute their aloofness to it. people get super jealous because they think they are showering their cats with love. and they try to fix it by loving them more, but it just makes it worse. if a person has cats and has not unlocked this line of communication, in my experience they also havent deeply understood other humans or anything else. and i almost never meet people who have.
- mopierotti 6y agoI have fostered roughly 25 cats (one at a time), and what you wrote about communication resonates with me. Most cats seem to develop a sort of pidgin[1] language in collaboration with you to communicate how they feel or what they want. It's different for each cat, but is usually some combination of vocalization tones, body postures/movements, eye contact, or even the location in the house they choose to do those things from. They can be surprisingly great communicators. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pidgin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pidgin
- alex_duf 6y agoSo an insect repellent that cats, big or small are going to be attracted to? I mean, I don't think I'd want to put that insect repellent in the savannah, north america or a place that has lots of feral cats.
- pvaldes 6y agoThe idea of a super friendly lion passing out in my arms while purring like a motorboat sounds really tempting...
- ivan_ah 6y agoDirect link to research paper: [ The characteristic response of domestic cats to plant iridoids allows them to gain chemical defense against mosquitoes ] https://advances.sciencemag.org/content/7/4/eabd9135 https://advances.sciencemag.org/content/7/4/eabd9135
- ivan_ah 6y agoOn a lighter note, and for anyone who hasn't seen cats on catnip in practice, check this out: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P0OB9p0zqx0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P0OB9p0zqx0