3 ms·
> 5. Argue that the relative simplicity and platonic orderliness of the vision represents rationality That's an elegant way to articulate a criticism I've had
by jiggawatts 6y ago
> 5. Argue that the relative simplicity and platonic orderliness of the vision represents rationality
That's an elegant way to articulate a criticism I've had of many technologies that I have been unable to state so clearly. All those file formats, for example, that seek to replace XML. Think of JSON, YAML, and TOML. They all claim to be simple, but end up too simple in practice and cause just as many issues as they solve. Comments, schemas, and namespaces were there for a reason, they weren't just a "messy design" awaiting a visionary to clean up...
> 6. Use authoritarian power to impose that vision, by demolishing the old reality if necessary
Unfortunately, in the cloud era, we're all faced with trillion dollar behemoth organisations that wield absolute power over their dominions. Us peasants have no hope of changing the vision they choose to impose. Suddenly, the well-established and well-known stable world has become "legacy".
- HotHotLava 6y ago> They all claim to be simple, but end up too simple in practice and cause just as many issues as they solve. The number may be the same, but the set of issues is different, leaving developers the choice if they'd rather work around the lack of namespaces and comments in JSON or around the opaque meta definitions and annoying syntax of XML. And the popular vote was pretty clear on which design is preferred.
- marcosdumay 6y ago> Comments, schemas, and namespaces were there for a reason Oh, surely. The one largest problem of XML is that it's highly redundant. Nobody complains about those, just that it's verbose, had to write, and hard to locate oneself on the hierarchy when reading. All of those are caused by the redundancy. (Oh, and there is the issue that DTDs have an incredibly complex language that nobody knows entirely...) As a rule, if it's a good feature for a programming language, it's also a good feature for a textual data encoding language. Ditto for bad features.