7 ms·
Twitter locks account of China's US embassy over its defence of Xinjiang policy
- tbihl 6y agoAnother instance of hiding objectionable speech that's too weak to stand on its own. I wish they would just leave these things out in the open to die their own natural deaths at first exposure to reason and contrary arguments. Edit: Thread is duplicate of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25855653 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25855653
- epitactic 6y agoAlso previously: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25853749 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25853749
- whimsicalism 6y agoIt seems like some segment of people with power have decided that the lesson to be learned from China is that the great firewall is effective.
- abacadaba 6y agoNot gonna lie, the chatbot comparison where the Chinese internet trained bot became friendly and helpful and the U.S. trained bot became a psychopath was pretty convincing.
- qart 6y agoI know about Microsoft's Tay. I assume that's what you're referring to, for the US example. Which bot was trained on the Chinese internet?
- DataWorker 6y agoGame theory comes into play. If we have to compete with China then we can predict both nations copy each other. State level intervention in corporations, censorship in the name of public safety, maybe even re-education camps if some of the younger congresspeople had their way. We become more like our rivals when we compete with them.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> maybe even re-education camps if some of the younger congresspeople had their way Which younger congresspeople would want 're-education camps' of Muslims? Or at all? Incendiary suggestion and not true. > If we have to compete with China Why do we have to do that?
- swiley 6y agoI miss being a teenager and thinking pervasive computing and connectivity would bring freedom rather than just rebuild traditional social structures but with complicated software mixed into them.
- forinti 6y agoMaybe it hasn't been around for long enough.
- ovi256 6y agoNot just that, now the culture clash is whose traditional social structure to extend to the internet.
- jancsika 6y agoGive sufficient detail wrt what that freedom looks like. The moment you do I bet you'll hit up against some laws that your teenage self should have spent decades fighting against instead of writing code.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoI assume people need some examples to better understand this, so let's provide some. DMCA 1201 is totally useless at its state purpose (stopping piracy) because pirates can distribute their circumvention tools in the same channels as the pirated materials. If you could stop that then you wouldn't need DMCA 1201. So what it does in practice is act as an anti-competitive cudgel to prohibit adversarial interoperability. The CFAA does something similar -- it's excessively broad and basically everything it prohibits which is actually bad was already prohibited by other laws. There are a wide variety of financial regulations (mandatory chargebacks, KYC) that effectively require the result that you can't have a low-friction anonymous digital payments system. This means that if you want to consume media on the internet where the author gets paid instead of them paying to host content, without all your media consumption ending up in a dangerous central database associated with your social security number, it has to be supported by advertising. And then we're back to the dangerous central database. These laws are harmful to a free and democratic society.
- splaytreemap 6y agoI'm starting to think that the degeneration of society into a 1984-style dystopia may now be unavoidable. We need to take power back from big tech and we need to do it now.
- SllX 6y agoWhat for blocking the Chinese embassy? Nah, they should have done this ages ago. I think Twitter is even firewalled from the PRC, so why they let PRC propaganda propagate on their servers is beyond me.
- andrewflnr 6y agoI don't know if you're wrong, but this is not evidence. As long as the Chinese embassy can put out press releases on their own platform, they're not being silenced. If anything, we need to break everyone's ridiculous dependency on a handful of platforms, not the platforms themselves.
- azornathogron 6y agoHow is "break everyone's ridiculous dependency on a handful of platforms" meaningfully different from GPs version, "take power back from big tech"? Doesn't big tech have power because so many people depend on this small set of platforms?
- andrewflnr 6y agoThe phrase "take back power", especially when it comes in the context of "they're blocking people and must be stopped!", seems to boil down to not letting tech companies block who they want to block. I just want competition.
- azornathogron 6y agoOk, I see. That makes sense. It seems there are perhaps three(?) options that come up: 1) Constrain big tech via regulation (thereby in some sense transferring the power to regulators/government, with the hope that it would in turn be influenced by democratic processes) 2) Or, directly influence big tech behaviour through boycotts and other consumer action. 3) Or, break up big tech forcibly or again through consumer action to switch to alternatives, thereby diffusing this power. And you prefer 3. I think I do too.
- Darmody 6y agoIf you look at my history of comments you'll see how much I dislike the CCP but I still think this is wrong. What now? Are they going to stop doing what they're doing? They now have another excuse to show their people how bad and anti-Chinese the West is.
- Darmody 6y agoI don't mind if people downvote me, I don't really post to get internet points but I'd like to see an argument. Where am I wrong? What am I missing?
- mhh__ 6y agoI think HN should require either a comment explaining or upvote on a refutation before a downvote. Considering the rigour displayed in many technology threads it's a little disappointing when you get downvoted without explanation - there seems to be a silent caucus of Trump fans who really don't like seeing their guy criticised but won't actually formulate an argument why, for example.
- chippy 6y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html "Please don't post insinuations about astroturfing, shilling, brigading, foreign agents and the like. It degrades discussion and is usually mistaken. If you're worried about abuse, email hn@ycombinator.com and we'll look at the data." and "Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading. "
- mhh__ 6y ago1) not what I did - I'm providing a hypothesis for what I saw. 2) also not what I did, I'm suggesting an alternative design that encourages discourse. Mindlessly posting the rules is also pretty fucking boring too, it's not exactly Hegelian dialectics in the average thread is it.
- 6y ago
- hawkice 6y agoSo far, this thread seems surprisingly concerned about whether a giant government can get its message out about how great its genocide is. I would like to suggest, humbly, that they examine their hearts and determine whether advocating genocide is the type of thing they would want to restrict in their own terms of service. If not, please avoid criticizing Facebook for their role in spreading the propaganda used to justify the genocide in Myanmar. And if it is, please ease up on Twitter for enforcing that policy. Personally, while I think you should be able to set up a personal webpage saying whatever you like, I find this stuff extremely distasteful and did report the Chinese embassy for advocating violence towards specific ethnic groups. It is a violation of Twitter's terms and tremendously odious.
- EastToWest 6y agoI now wonder what will happen to US Embassy's Weibo account. My impression is that their Weibo account promotes "unpopular" opinions but has mostly been left alone. But I haven't been a Weibo user for the past >5 years so my impression could be way off.
- newpindar 6y agoThis is bullshit. Twitter has absolutely no information on the reality of XJ at all, so it is in no way qualified to block the account for misinformation, when it had no way to assess to correctness of any information about XJ. Western anti China propaganda is not a reliable source upon which to make determinations about factuality. Closing out voices that dissent to that propaganda line does not a more diverse, inclusive and open free press make, and does not help correct the lack of factual information. If the Western public wants to inhabit a fantasy world with regard to China, and exclude pro China voices, even if that's comfortable, it's to the detriment of the West. It's to the detriment of national security. I'm not for war, but the West seems to be, and this torrent of propaganda doesn't help their goal... If you're going to act like China is your event, at least know your enemy. If conflict and competition is the goal, living in a make believe fantasy world about China with stories that sooth your wounded sense of superiority, will not assist you. As Pompeo said, this sort of information control is about fake moral righteousness. It's funny, but also sadly appropriate, that he's also been one of the biggest hawkers of this controlled fake narrative.
- cwwc 6y agocreated 23 mins ago - aka "this is a CCP 50 center" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/50_Cent_Party https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/50_Cent_Party
- browserface 6y agoPerfect. Stay in your fucking bubble. Anyone who dissents to the Western propoganda lies must be a CPC propagandist? Impeccable defense mechanism, ensures you never need to consider anything outside what they tell you to think. You're so duped by the press you believe is free, they have you believing that anything that goes outside the narrative is a lie. They have you self censoring, shackling yourselves, thinking you are free. They have you hook line and sinker, boy. Especially so because you think you live in panacea of free ideas. You cannot free a slave, who thinks herself already free, or who prefers the shackles on. I feel sad for you that you are unable to consider. Logic should tell you to distrust this stuff without extensive first hand experience of XJ, or at least experience of China. I'm sorry for you that you surrender logic to whatever this is that they did to you. I wonder how they got everyone believing that anything outside the narrative is a lie. They are truly masters of psychological manipulation and propoganda. The west really needs to improve its relationship with its populations. It's already abusive and currently teetering on the brink, and nobody really seems to know it. Nobody seems to see nor know how precarious its position is. It's sad to see, but I've seen it for a long time, so i suppose that makes it less painful for me.
- partiallypro 6y agoI wonder what the cross section is between people that object to this but think permanently banning Trump was ok, and vice versa.
- ljw1001 6y agoThey’re both ok with me. Twitter started as a global water cooler, but became possibly the world’s largest propaganda machine. Something had to be done.
- booleandilemma 6y agoWhat's with the sudden blocking spree Twitter has gone on? Has there been a change of leadership somewhere in the company?
- pb7 6y agoPerhaps they noticed the laissez-faire approach doesn't work.
- BitwiseFool 6y agoTwitter employees have been wanting to ban Donald Trump and other right wingers for years. But now that the Republicans are out of power they don't have to worry about repercussions from said Republicans. The capitol riot was certainly a catalyst, but keep in mind that the main reason Donald Trump wasn't banned between 2016 and 2020 was that he was POTUS.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dirtyid 6y agoThere's asymmetry between Chinese propaganda able to operate freely on western platforms, while western propaganda are filtered on Chinese platforms. This is a real foreign policy conundrum since both parties are following relevant local regulations. It's a asymmetry of values, and I was always curious if west would find solutions without adopting similar anti-values of Chinese censorship. But they're converging more and more every year. Up till now, Twitter labels foreign missions / media as warning (though biasedly, i.e. CGTN is labelled state media where BBC is not). Regardless, wholesale deplatforming of a foreign mission is a line that even China has not crossed on weibo. Occasional posts will be removed or shadowbanned, but nothing on this scale. Let that sink in. This is tantamount to private company influencing foreign policy, or further validation of Chinese censorship policy. Either way this reaffirms the Chinese model. I'm sure there's going to be much rationalization and wank over differences between private and government control and muh liberal values. But IMO it's perfunctory. When pro democracy activists and Merkel who grew up in east Germany commented recent deplatforms are going too far, maybe listen.
- neartheplain 6y agoUp till now, Twitter labels foreign missions / media as warning (though biasedly, i.e. CGTN is labelled state media where BBC is not) To be fair, when's the last time a sitting PM asked for "absolute loyalty" from the BBC [0]? My impression is that while both are state-funded, the Beeb is much more free in its editorial voice [1]. [0] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/feb/19/xi-jinping-tours-chinas-top-state-media-outlets-to-boost-loyalty https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/feb/19/xi-jinping-tou... [1] https://politics.stackexchange.com/questions/27282/why-shouldnt-bbc-have-to-register-as-a-foreign-agent https://politics.stackexchange.com/questions/27282/why-shoul...
- dirtyid 6y agoMany diaspora from the global south, who grew up in countries with state media, but now lives in the west will tell you even the free-est western fifth estate is prone to manufactured consent that is frequently indistinguishable from state propaganda. IMO perfunctory rationalization extends into this labelling as well. Of all media sources, state media is probably the easiest to identify. Presumably that's what Twitter's labelling is for, unless it's actually a wiki style reliable source list, in which case it should be advertised as such. If not then BBC / CBC is government funded state media and should be labelled as such.
- peanut_worm 6y agoWhy is Twitter being treated as a public entity by the news lately
- pindab0ter 6y agoI don't use Twitter myself, but a lot of people do. So many, in fact, that you could argue that in a sense maybe it is. This notion is/was strengthened by the previous U.S. President using Twitter as (basically?) his sole media outlet.
- albanread 6y agoAs an alternative to ending free speech for everyone; perhaps users should have to pass a course on critical thinking; before being allowed to use twitter.
- underseacables 6y agoI wonder if Twitter has crossed some kind of imaginary line now that almost compelled it to censor more. I would have liked to see more actions like this in the past, but maybe Twitter needed to cross the Rubicon and censor the president in order to feel comfortable with censoring other countries and entities
- pupppet 6y agoGood on Twitter, companies moving themselves away from being soulless, mindless machines where anything goes, is a step in the right direction.
- Udik 6y agoThe reason for the ban is that the tweet violated Twitter's policy against "dehumanisation". The text of the tweet is the following: "Study shows that in the process of eradicating extremism, the minds of Uygur women in Xinjiang were emancipated and gender equality and reproductive health were promoted, making them no longer baby-making machines. They are more confident and independent." While that "baby-making machines" is tone deaf, I don't see how this is per se "dehumanising" without taking a precise stands on what the real actions of the Chinese government are with regards to the Uighur population.