6 ms·
Price wise the gap to a zero W is rather small. Fun as this sounds paying a little extra for a full nix environment and wifi is a better fit for me. I ca
by Havoc 6y ago
Price wise the gap to a zero W is rather small. Fun as this sounds paying a little extra for a full nix environment and wifi is a better fit for me. I can see it being useful for low power applications though
- MarcScott 6y agoI like the idea of using it from an educational point of view. One of the big problems our coding clubs face, when using a Raspberry Pi, is that they need all the peripherals disconnected from their standard PCs and used with the Pis. This way Code Clubs and CodeDojos can use existing IT infrastructure to get their kids into doing some electronics projects, at a very low price.
- makomk 6y agoYeah, from what I can tell the previous Raspberry Pi approach of a completely separate, full-on computer was ill-suited to its stated educational purpose for multiple reasons. The trouble is, the climate of, well, fanboyism around the Pi meant that this tended to be dismissed as an issue. I wonder if now everyone will discover how much better microcontroller-based boards are for this, just like everyone discovered the performance benefits of not having an ancient version of ARM when the Pi 2 came out and the practical benefits of integrated wifi when the 3 came out...
- IshKebab 6y agoThey're not really in the same category though. This is a bare metal microcontroller. The Pi Zero is normally used with Linux. I guess maybe you can use it bare metal but nobody does. A more relevant comparison is ESP32.
- dheera 6y agoEhh there are lots of cases where I'd rather have a microcontroller than a full OS. The biggest thing going for microcontrollers is that they aren't vulnerable to file system corruption if you yank the plug on them, making them extremely useful for IoT devices like smart locks / lighting / air quality monitoring / appliances / electronics designed for use in the field where you don't want to sit around figuring out how to ssh in and type "sudo shutdown -h now" instead of just yanking the plug and get on with your day, which you can do safely with a microcontroller. (Strictly speaking yes you could design an OS for the Pi Zero W that mounts in read-only mode and avoids this problem but it's a headache) That said the Pi Pico doesn't look attractive to me; I usually use ESP32s for those projects these days.
- floatboth 6y agoIt's not hard to make a read-only OS image and use a full blown Unix for microcontroller tasks. It's actually easy. It's just silly because 1) high power usage, high overhead of everything and 2) lack of real-time guarantees usually.
- xuhu 6y agoThe Pico is also much smaller which sometimes does matter, and probably uses much less power including sleep states.
- pjmlp 6y agoHaving grown coding for 8 bits, this is more relevant to me. nix clones abound, whereas this kind of boards bring back the hardware/software machine soul back, with Python as the new BASIC.
- user-the-name 6y agoA proper embedded microcontroller like this offers things a system running Linux never can.
- fulafel 6y agoYou can run the Zero as bare metal too.
- user-the-name 6y agoYou can, but the peripherals leave a lot to be desired.
- Prcmaker 6y agoI'll take this over a zero for most of my applications, purely because of power cuts. While there plenty of io on both, not having to worry about my SD card getting corrupted because the power got pulled is really important.
- mytailorisrich 6y ago> Fun as this sounds paying a little extra for a full nix environment For these very small embedded systems a "full nix environment" is a major pain. It is massively overblown and not real-time at all.
- mrguyorama 6y agoSkip coffee for two days and buy both! I have an Arduino nano, a Pi Zero, a Pi Zero W, but this looks neat too
- mmoskal 6y agoYou can never get RPi Zero at $5 in volume. It's always one per household, etc. It's a subsidized educational price. OTOH for this kind of board $4 seems like about the right price - RP2040 looks like ~$1 MCU to me.