3 ms·
> If a developer is given free reign as to what they can build, they will naturally build the most profitable thing they can on the land they have available. I
by astrange 6y ago
> If a developer is given free reign as to what they can build, they will naturally build the most profitable thing they can on the land they have available. I doubt anyone would dispute that?
There is no such thing as luxury housing[1], and developers in the US are given nothing like free reign, so this doesn't happen - they don't build special gold-plated apartments for rich people. The most profitable building for the landowner would typically have more units, because that means more people will buy/rent units from them.
And of course, the developer is not necessarily the landowner, and so they might be paid a flat rate anyway.
[1] What actually happens is developers call their buildings "luxury" because it sounds good, but they're lying.
- cgrealy 6y agoI never said anything about luxury housing? Housing doesn't have to be "luxury" to be unaffordable.
- astrange 6y agoThe most profitable thing to build on land is usually also the most affordable thing, because it has the most units. Unaffordability happens when zoning makes them build single-family housing, or when the land is so expensive anything would be unaffordable while it's new.
- imtringued 6y agoSingle family zoning is not just unaffordable for the people living there, it's also unaffordable for the government. It also causes car dependence and energy inefficiency. Overall it is a net loss for everyone involved.
- dillondoyle 6y agoI don't understand this? Sure there are cheap developers who use trendy finishes with cheap materials and markets as fancy. But luxury exists. googled definition of luxury includes 'extravagant living.' To me that includes Doorman, butler services, room service and daily housekeeping (e.g. condos at the Ritz), valet, huge amounts of in building amenities. Super high end custom finishings, fixtures, decor which doesn't serve a purpose in terms of extra comfort or use, just aesthetic/signaling. And the epitome of the logo whore luxury condos celebrity architect firm placing giant $10mm Koons or Kaws lobby sculptures (which funny enough there's an ever more high brow snobby art joke that once you're in the lobby you're done lol).
- imtringued 6y agoThose $10 million condos are wealth traps. Nobody lives in them so nobody gets displaced if a billionaire parks his money in the real estate market of your city. If that billionaire had to buy 10 apartments to park his money the displacement would be very high. This type of "luxury housing" is guarding the rest of the city from foreign demand.
- astrange 6y agoMore generally, a tower doesn't cause displacement because it's built up in the sky. Displacement is caused by taking up land, which single-family houses do the most of because they fit the least people on the most land.