3 ms·
I live in a city with rent control. Rent here is around half of comparable cities in my area. Issues that economists have with rent control in theory basically
by sudosysgen 6y ago
I live in a city with rent control. Rent here is around half of comparable cities in my area. Issues that economists have with rent control in theory basically don't exist because the rent control system minimizes them.
I think it's absurd to say that rent control doesn't work. Badly implemented rent control is just a useful mitigation. Correctly implemented rent control, with a healthy dose of public housing and private supply increase, actually is a solution - but the rent control and public housing part is a lot more important than the private supply increase and is also the part that YIMBYs such as the author never get implemented in practice.
- astrange 6y agoDo you live in Vienna? That's the public housing system people point to, but it's also the only one that seems to work. SF historically had public housing with the obvious downside that the people who ran it, being US government workers in the 50s, were super racist, so the people who lived in it suffered. Currently there's a system of privatized/contracted affordable housing development, which is effective and produces housing that looks just like market-rate housing, so people don't believe it exists because it doesn't look cheap enough. The author does want public housing but also wants Singapore's HDB system.
- sudosysgen 6y agoI do not live in Vienna - I live in Montréal. We have a system that is a mix of a structurally HDB-like provincial system, municipal housing systems, private construction, private/public cooperation, and rent control. If your issue is that public housing is run by racist people, the solution is to have it run by non-racist people. This tends to be easier when people that live in public housing are more diverse and have a larger electoral impact. The way that we handle the downsides of rent control is by allowing landlords to break the rent-control cycle by doing major renovations, and by making rental contracts basically all end at the same date which allows for a much lower friction in moving. While the author may very well want it, unless they make it their #1 priority, they won't actually implement it as there is much more resistance against public housing than to anything else. The end result will be that the "compromise" will be no new public housing and simply zoning relaxations at most, with continued increase in rents.
- astrange 6y agoThere is public housing happening in CA. Actually, there's an unusual amount of it this year because of the opportunity to convert a bunch of newly bankrupt hotels into housing (https://www.hcd.ca.gov/grants-funding/active-funding/homekey.shtml https://www.hcd.ca.gov/grants-funding/active-funding/homekey...). Besides that, the left-NIMBY alliance means there's noone to directly oppose public housing. The left supports it because they actually want it, and the NIMBYs pretend to be leftists and like using "this should be public housing" as their excuse for why nothing else should ever happen - presumably they don't expect public housing to actually appear, but they run low on excuses if it does. Not much new construction of it happens in SF though, because construction costs in are very high, and there's not much land zoned to allow apartments because they don't want new housing of any kind, public or not. > The end result will be that the "compromise" will be no new public housing and simply zoning relaxations at most, with continued increase in rents. SF's main problem is most of it is zoned for single-family houses despite being a city, so that would be great actually.
- sudosysgen 6y agoIn the long term relaxing zoning for high density doesn't seem to do much for rent by itself. Even very high density cities, when left to the free market, continue to see massive increases in the price of rent until people start moving out, such as Hong Kong. Now of course, relaxing zoning is important and necessary, you can't have a city with single family housing. It's just not a sustainable solution.
- Kalium 6y ago> Now of course, relaxing zoning is important and necessary, you can't have a city with single family housing. It's just not a sustainable solution. Much of SF's voters see this as the greatest of heresies. The honest and earnest expectation is that SF can, should, and shall remain mostly detached single family homes forever. They vote accordingly, and often make common cause with the left-NIMBYs. Perhaps unsurprisingly, this has not produced a sustainable state of affairs.
- kelnos 6y ago> I think it's absurd to say that rent control doesn't work. I didn't say it didn't work.
- imtringued 6y agoHere is the problem with rent control: Politicians implement rent control and consider the problem solved but it isn't. Public housing is the solution and rent control is a hack to let you skip on public housing. There might be communities that have both but that's just proving the point. Rent control did nothing. It's the public housing that did it.
- pas 6y agoSupply vs demand. Rent control is great at that moment. But this means there's and enormous part of the demand that's unmet. If supply would increase there would be no need for rent control. (That said ther are many possible problems that need/would-benefit-from regulatory intervention. Eg. high vacancy rate because speculation and long-term investors. The residents of a city probably don't want to live in a playground for perpetual construction due to "irrational demand" and arbitrageurs supplying it. For example when folks in oppressive regimes try to put their money in foreign real estate, they don't real care about doing that efficiently, hence the high vacancy, nor do they care about ROI or anything, just to have better odds than putting it locally, ie. in China/SaudiArabia/etc.)
- sudosysgen 6y agoThe idea that just increasing supply enough would make rent cheap forever does not bear out. Not only do you need massive supply increases for modest decreases in rent, as the article points out, but if you look at the real world, even extremely dense cities like Hong Kong have extremely high rent as rent eventually catches up. You cannot increase supply forever. Rent still continues going up. The solution is to increase supply and have rent control.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pas 6y agoI've already replied in a different thread, but ... "increase supply forever" ... that is a straw-man. Supply has to increase as long as urbanization and population increase is going on in a given country/state/region. "Rent control" is useful to smooth out the bumps, but it should be called "eviction moratorium" and "negative income tax".
- pas 6y agoIt doesn't work because it solves only a small part of the problem. The current dweller's. Those who want to come to the city can't, plus now it automatically makes every new development a fight club about subsidized housing (affordable/low-income units). Obviously a community prioritizing protecting their members is not surprising, but since members change, it can eventually lead to a stagnant community. Sure, smoothing out supply and demand imbalances is useful, but this means rent control must not be (cannot be) a long term solution. It leads to megacorps settling in neighboring suburbs, puts a lot of tension into the tenant-landlord relationship (which is already usually a delicate one, see the usual neglect of units to extract maximal profits in a non-competitive market), detaches housing prices from prices of other goods and services (and thus the price of those increase due to the available disposable income, which is not particularly bad, but yet another imbalance). And the usual big problem is that it decreases the incentive to increase supply. Which means, unless the regulator steps in it just leads to even longer duration of imbalance. (Eg. city population growth capped.)
- sudosysgen 6y agoI live in a city with rent control. What you're describing simply doesn't happen. You of course still have to address supply issues. But addressing supply alone is not sufficient to bring rent under control. You need both.
- pas 6y agoWhy wouldn't it be enough? There's a very strong prior (base assumption) that prices in a liquid market (like most housing) are determined by supply and demand. The FDA has papers about how above 5-7 suppliers for a given drug the price radically drops (eg. the market becomes efficient due to competition), the same thing works for ISPs and other providers, why would it be different for housing? Also, if the things you mention don't happen, that means there's no need for the rent control, since supply and demand are in balance and prices are stable (or they follow some larger trend, like inflation).
- sudosysgen 6y ago