9 ms·
The passenger experience would be: 1. Get to the SpaceX terminal somewhere (maybe a major airport because of connecting flights), security checks, check in lug
by pmontra 6y ago
The passenger experience would be:
1. Get to the SpaceX terminal somewhere (maybe a major airport because of connecting flights), security checks, check in luggage and board an helicopter.
2. Fly to the launch platform.
3. Disembark, get up to Starship.
4. Many Gs of acceleration.
5. Fall to destination.
6. Many Gs of deceleration.
7. Disembark, board the helicopter.
8. Fly to the airport, immigration checks, collect luggage.
9. Leave the airport.
The two helicopter hops cost time, maybe not much more than some long rides on airport buses. The acceleration and deceleration will be exciting but maybe not everybody fit to fly can withstand them. I guess it's not for everybody.
- 3327 6y agoPotentially burn in atmosphere twice.
- inglor_cz 6y agoIt is my impression that suborbital jumps are much, much slower than a launch to the orbit and return from the orbit. That would mean that a Starship decelerating to the destination would not create a classic "ball of fire" in front of it and risk a burnup. Returning 1st stages of Falcon 9 do not require thermal protection either.
- peeters 6y agoI don't think they're as different in energy as you're thinking. "Suborbital" ranges from throwing a baseball 100ft to going almost into orbit, and going halfway around the earth is just shy of a circular orbit. It would be different if you were doing a short hop, but Starship is impractical for short hops.
- ragebol 6y ago> I guess it's not for everybody. Neither will the ticket price be, I guess. At least at first.
- d_silin 6y agoJust FYI, you can expect launch and reentry Gs <3, which a healthy adult can handle no problem. Instead of helicopter, ferry can do. Overall the process will be not dramatically different from modern airport experience.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dane-pgp 6y ago> Instead of helicopter, ferry can do. What about a seaplane? Depending on the number of passengers, that might make sense. I also wondered about Hyperloop tunnel starting under the seabed, which a submersible capsule could dock with, but that seems much less realistic.
- ghaff 6y agoNo real way to get from a seaplane up to the rig deck.
- m4rtink 6y agoWhat about a simple floating pier ? Then elevator or stairs from that to the deck. It's not like you need to park these ex-oil-rigs in the super hardcore sea state areas many of them need to operate when actually drilling.
- cnlevy 6y agoOr standard high-speed train on a floating bridge ? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evergreen_Point_Floating_Bridge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evergreen_Point_Floating_Bridg...
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoNo need to dig: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Submerged_floating_tunnel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Submerged_floating_tunnel
- 6y ago
- phkahler 6y agoI doubt point to point on earth will be used for humans.
- inglor_cz 6y agoI am almost certain that, at a certain point, the US military will use Starship to deploy some extra forces (specialists and equipment) to a distant theater of operations under a tight schedule. Or perhaps evacuate the sick and the wounded, if they can tolerate this rough ride but need to see a top hospital urgently. So as far as humans go, that will probably happen. A regular service for civilian customers, that is another story. Just like Concorde, it might prove economically infeasible.
- iso1631 6y agoWill starship land with enough fuel to take off and return to friendly territory? Can starship land in Earth like gravity on a standard concrete area? Concorde's heels were 1) No supersonic over water 2) Limited Range 3) Limited use to reclaim development costs and ongoing maintenence costs 4) Eating into their owners fares -- standard London-NY cost was £8k return, or £13k today. That's in the same ballpark as an F return pre-covid, so BA weren't making more money.
- Mauricebranagh 6y agoAnd the NIMBY / NIH lobbying I think you meant no supersonic overland
- iso1631 6y agoYup, overland. Not many nimbys if you're 20 miles off the coast of NY going to 20 mile off the Singapore coast (not that nimbys would have any say in Singapore), and nobody en-route would even know it's flying overhead. OK you have a 30 minute ride at each end from downtown, but that's not much more than going to JFK/Changi from downtown. 1 hour checkin and 1 hour flight, you're doing end to end in 3 hours rather than 22.
- janmo 6y agoSounds like a nightmare. One key aspect is also the weather. Flying will only be possible under perfect weather conditions for both take off and landing.
- sandworm101 6y agoDon't forget all the vomit. Put ten passengers in a single space, even trained astronauts, and at least one of them will be vomiting during the zero-G portion of the flight. Compare this to a first class seat on a BA transatlantic crossing. (And the carbon costs of rocket-powered passenger services are maddening. This is not a service that anyone should support.)
- ulfw 6y agoDepends on the fish of the day that's served ;)
- emilecantin 6y agoStarship is methane-powered. There are ways to generate methane sustainably (from C02 and water); that's even an essential part of the plan for Mars. I strongly suspect they'll want to test it on Earth before, and having an appliance on the platform that generates the needed propellant for passenger flight would be a very good test (developing something that works reliably with minimal / no human intervention).
- sandworm101 6y agoThe fuels in the rocket. The fuels in the support vehicles. The fuels for the platform. The fuels in the helicopters. Even if all of them are produced from solar power, a 747 needs less than 1% of the same total fuel per passenger. No matter how it is fueled, a ballistic rocket needs orders of magnitude more energy than conventional flight. It is not an energy-efficient means of realworld transport.
- jackric 6y agoThen price in carbon neutral fuel production to the ticket. There will be passengers rich enough to pay it. If you've got a problem with that I imagine your real issues are about status envy not environmentalism.
- 6y ago
- reddog 6y agoI wonder by how many orders of magnitude that this would be less safe and more expensive that as commercial airline first class ticket to the same destination. Those two helicopter hops probably make the trip 100x more dangerous by them selves.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoThey're not gonna be trying to land rockets in bad weather so the helicopter rides should pretty much all take place during ideal conditions. Point to point helicopter rides are also very safe relatively speaking. Industrial and emergency helicopter usage really drags down the average.
- beerandt 6y ago>Point to point helicopter rides are also very safe relatively speaking Not for coastal ops. It falls in the more dangerous category. All rig workers are required to pass HUET- Helicopter Underwater Egress Training. The gyro forces of the rotating blades ensure any splashdown is followed immediately by the helicopter inverting itself- so underwater and upside down. It also involves the immediate need for survival swimming, with a presumption of a burning oil slick at the surface that must be splashed clear each time you surface, until you can clear the wreckage. And since the water might be dirty, or covered in oil slick or debris, this training is often done blindfolded.
- skinkestek 6y ago> And since the water might be dirty, or covered in oil slick or debris, this training is done blindfolded. Is the blindfold rule new? I never heard about it when I took HUET.
- beerandt 6y agoIt's not a rule (that I know of), but it's a standard part of the more serious training classes. The companies I'm familiar with have been teaching it that way for 15+ years. Edited to "often"
- mrfusion 6y agoDo your security/customs checks on the helicopter ride and that transport costs you zero time.
- motoboi 6y agoNah! 1) Get into a rocket, lift-off, land on the platform. 2) Play with a complimentary Space Grenade Launcher™ on the rim of the platform while you wait for refuel. 3) Go to space for some time 4) Land in your destination platform 5) Summon your Tesla over the under-the-ocean tunnel 6) Go home.
- thomasmg 6y agoMany Gs of acceleration: I don't think it would be a huge problem, when lying on your back, in a g-suit or submerged in water. I don't think it would require liquid breathing, which is not fully developed yet. Many Gs of deceleration: for the passenger, acceleration and deceleration have the same effects.
- peeters 6y agoTypically people flying on a helicopter to an oil rig need to be trained to ditch in the water. I think most would consider that prohibitive for the Starship transit clientele, so I wonder if they just live with the risks.
- m4rtink 6y agoThere are regular commuter helicopter services between islands over the ocean in Japan, like this one: http://www.tohoair.co.jp/english/shuttle/ http://www.tohoair.co.jp/english/shuttle/
- matthewfelgate 6y agoWhy helicopter ride to platform not by boat?
- zhoujianfu 6y agoI believe the original mock up video had a boat.
- mncharity 6y ago> The passenger experience would be: Hundred(s) of people per flight, on helicopters? High Gs? Perhaps something more like...? 1. Fly to coastal airport with SpX marine terminal. Board high-speed passenger ferry. Security, immigration, and luggage processing on board. 3. Disembark. Board Starship. (Maybe motion-compensated gangways? [1] - fun tech) 4. Few Gs acceleration. 5. Fall to destination. A comfort challenge - limiting head motion helps a lot. 6. Brief couple of Gs. It's only ~100 m/s terminal velocity. 7. Disembark. Similar ferry. 9. Leave airport marine terminal. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=latTbgwdywo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=latTbgwdywo
- pmontra 6y agoThose gangways look nice. They could make them look like normal jet bridges with the nice side effect of not scaring people with the fear of falling into the sea, etc. About accelerations, many people scream when they are in a car braking or turning at some low 0.x G, so I wonder what a couple of Gs would be to them. Anyway, there will always be plenty of planes and they'll be much cheaper too.
- mncharity 6y ago> Those gangways look nice. They could make them look like normal jet bridges Nod. And given the difference in duty cycle from supply ships and oil rigs, they might be mounted on the rig rather than the boat. Removing the "it has to fit folded up on the ship" constraint. And with luggage perhaps containerized onboard the ship, the containers would need to be transferred too.
- Ajedi32 6y agoMaybe 1 and 2 could be combined by using Seaplanes?
- mncharity 6y agoHydrofoils are sort of seaplanes? They just keep the wing in the water. And so don't have to deal with being not-so-great airplanes, so they can focus on being good boats. Starship might end up even more robust to weather than airliners. As are boats. But seaplanes combine the vulnerability of planes, with the those of poor boats. Taking off in a swell, is not a happy thing. I suppose SpX could hypothetically do JATO rocket-assisted seaplanes. :P But consider the number of passengers. And choices of flying formations of existing seaplanes for each launch, or "let's create a brand new large airliner, and make it a seaplane too!" (even without the seaplane bit, those can be 'bet the aerospace company' gambles), or... order some ferries. Maybe even rent them to start.
- LinuxBender 6y agoWill the passengers require a class-3 flight physical? High-G's can be risky to some people. blood pressure, risk of stroke, etc... Examples would be the number of medical issues that arise at roller coasters and the related posted warnings on them.
- dmurray 6y agoIf the theme park industry can manage to stay in business and settle for posting some warnings, surely this is a hurdle that can be overcome.
- fiftyfifty 6y agoMusk has mentioned using Hyperloop to transport people to the launch platforms. I don't have time to dig up the interview I heard it in but I'm pretty sure he said as much at one point.
- theptip 6y agoIt’s worth noting that Musk quoted 30-60 minutes rocket trip time for any pair of source/destination in the world, so there is a lot of room for time wasted around the launch while still being way faster. That said, they probably have to run hundreds of thousands or millions of non-crewed launches before they can demonstrate it’s safe enough for civilian use. Current tech must be in the range of 3-4 orders of magnitude more dangerous?
- zhoujianfu 6y agoThe genius of this IMO is operating in international waters... I assume that puts them out of FAA/etc jurisdiction? If so, we’ll be riding these way before UAVs.
- DarmokJalad1701 6y agoGiven suborbital speeds and availability aerodynamic lift means that they can significantly limit the G's on re-entry.
- nickik 6y agoNo. It would be a loop/hyperloop type system you get into.