8 ms·
Many popular subreddits are quietly operated by moderators with industry connections. Some of this occurs naturally. People who were deep enough into a niche t
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
Many popular subreddits are quietly operated by moderators with industry connections.
Some of this occurs naturally. People who were deep enough into a niche to become moderators of a subreddit in the late 2000s and early 2010s are also likely to end up working in that industry or starting business in that industry.
However, many companies have realized that being in the good graces of subreddit moderators can be very good for their business. It's becoming common for brands to reach out to subreddit moderators with offers of free products or even paid job offers to bring them onto the company's side. I know of several companies that routinely send free gear to relevant subreddit moderators. The arrangement is "no strings attached" but it usually results in a favorable moderation outcomes for the company. Moderators have a lot of power to influence conversations on Reddit in non-obvious ways.
In some ways, having a subreddit that champions your products while maintaining an appearance of being impartial is better than explicitly spinning out of Reddit. People know not to trust positive Amazon reviews, but Reddit conversations are generally assumed to be authentic.
- brodouevencode 6y agoGave up on reddit a long time ago because of the moderation problems.
- jefurii 6y agoHow is this different from other media? It's already common practice with magazines that contain product reviews. There's nothing stopping companies from doing this with bulletin boards and blogs.
- brodouevencode 6y agoYes, this is true. The problem lies in that they've historically waved the free speech flag in one hand while throwing the banhammer with the other.
- abcdjdjd 6y agoAhhh, yes, and you literally just described Section 230 exemptions vs. being a publisher. Yes, publishers are able to act as publishers and also get held responsible for what they publish. Social media sites are exempt from this under Section 230 rules, but that assumes they are not unfairly moderating their sites and turning into publishers. Yes, you literally just described what is a publisher and why their abuse of Section 230 law is not ok. You all who are supporting this overmoderation of Reddit seem to want Reddit to be a publisher. Well, with becoming a publisher and unfairly moderating the site, you lose Section 230 protections. You can't have your cake and eat it too, but that is what Reddit and many of the supporters of overmoderation want to do.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Social media sites are exempt from this under Section 230 rules, but that assumes they are not unfairly moderating their sites and turning into publishers. No, it doesn't. Section 230 has nothing about “unfair moderation”; it explictly allows online services to act as publishers within certain boundaries (to which the “fairness” of any moderation is not relevant, only whether the content is user-generated rather than first-party) without being legally treated as publishers for most civil liability purposes.
- 430scuderia 6y agoI mean just look at geographic subreddits like r/canada and r/vancouver they all have people, moderators with extreme alt-right views often banning people for sharing opposing views. Astroturfing is common as aged reddit accounts are easily obtainable and Reddit algorithm isn't sophisticated enough to detect this. /u/maxwellhill is also the biggest mystery of all. Even pinging the username results in a ban. This single account has been responsible for almost 70% of what you read on r/worldnews and its not far fetched to suggest that a small group of people actively dictate the world landscape. Majority of people on reddit do not read beyond the headlines much like other social networks. People simply do not care to objectively ask for truth and are punished for doing so on Reddit. Viral content is recycled over and over for hoarding karma points. Some users were caught fabricating heart wrenching stories for virtual internet points. I believe that these are farmers, creating thousands of accounts to be sold to people with commercial interest. Very different than what HN does and it is the right way to maintain meaningful discussions. Too much of Reddit is just trolls and maladjusted individuals creating their own pseudo-realities like r/aznidentity or other Red-Pill subreddits.
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoI would assume bringing up that username results in a ban because it is now unfortunately associated with QAnon belief, and moderators want to stamp out QAnon conspiracies.
- x86ARMsRace 6y agoMe as well for the same reasons. I get curious about what's happening there sometimes, and at this point it's just a wasteland. It's difficult to find a thread that isn't politicized in some way, or does not have at least some toxic elements to it. I've been told sometimes that it's 'just the mainstream communities', however the most toxic encounters I have had were always in the more niche threads. It devolves into downright vitriolic flame wars if you disagree with someone, and generally "agree to disagree" just inspires more wrath.
- detaro 6y agoThe answer to flame wars because of too much politicization is fairly certainly not "we need less moderator powers!".
- abcdjdjd 6y agoWhen those mods are literally playing a role in it and removing posts from one side of the political argument, but not the other side, in that discussion then yes they are part of the problem.
- x86ARMsRace 6y agoThere's a few sides. Sometimes giving the moderator too much power means they also have too much power of abstention. If they selectively don't enforce rules, toxic behaviour can be enabled. Worse when rules are enforced against one participant but not another. Sometimes vague rules get arbitrarily used against the unpopular.
- abcdjdjd 6y agoCurious, what alternatives have you found that are similar to what reddit used to be (besides this site)? Also, what alternative sites have you found replaced Reddit for you, even if they are not similar to what Reddit once was?
- optimalsolver 6y agoWhat's your opinion on the moderation here on HN?
- fjabre 6y agoRuqqus.com but unfortunately still small. And also infected. I've been on Shroomery lately and I really like that forum. I think the concept of Karma points is bullshit and punitive. It makes people negative. PG should know that by now and so should Reddit. Karma is inherently toxic. Anything that encourages vanity is. And karma encourages it more than anything. As do likes / dislikes. Numbers of votes. Numbers of likes. It's all the same. People competing for attention. And justified by an angry mob because Karma.
- wott 6y ago> Ruqqus.com but unfortunately still small. And also infected. I just went to see what it was. I selected the category 'Hobby' and here's the list of themes of the posts which came up top: GunsNAmmoDeals, GunsNAmmoDeals, Cannabis, Guns, ProGuns, LASER, TheFirearmBlog, TheFirearmBlog, Plinkn, TheFirearmBlog, bobross, Physical_Removal I mean, that's some hobby I guess, but a bit monomaniacal :-/
- fjabre 6y agoThis is what happens when we divide people. People congregate form tribes and fight each other. We keep calling each other Nazi's and Socialists - every social network online today.
- abcdjdjd 6y ago>Moderators have a lot of power to influence conversations on Reddit in non-obvious ways. You had the above quote when I was commenting on your post, but may have edited it out. But I think this line right here is also why reddit is becoming unusable and going downhill fast. Basically, moderators are given way too much power and users have no recourse against mod abuse really. Users can't vote a moderator out for example. Many times, mod abuse is also hidden, so you can't see a log of what they have been removing and hiding. Both of these things would show clear mod abuse in the open, but reddit seems to want to hide this. Moderators should really only have the power to remove illegal stuff or have clear rules linked for each removal or ban. Mods should not be able to turn on "filter" features that auto hide or auto delete posts, as they regularly just use it to target posters or topics they don't like, even if it is still on topic and popular in the subreddit. Also, mods are more and more removing or locking posts mainly because they politically disagree with them. They use excuses or hide this corrupting behavior all the time. Many times a lock posts will be done with a claim "its too hard to keep moderating this post", when reality is they were just removing posts that didn't break rules and were posts the mod simply disagreed with. Add all the above and more and combine it with clear corrupt interests, and you basically ruin what reddit once was. Which was a place to go to free discussion on many topics. It is not longer that. It is just a place where mods basically abuse their power on most subreddits and astroturfing is more and more the norm. Its almost like people forgot their was a an upvote and downvote button. The mods really have no reason removing posts, outside of clear violating posts that may break laws, since the users can choose what they want to see with the upvote and downvote button.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fjabre 6y agoI couldn't agree with this more. As someone who has gotten to the top of Reddit front page twice with my free (no ads) web app I now cannot. It's all but impossible. Mods are so over protective they will ban you for practically nothing. If you attempt to evade the ban even innocently they will sniff you out. I think Reddit's mod tools are disgusting and foster censorship and make Reddit a more negative and critical place. A new post type as the OP suggests like IMGUR? This point is laughable OP. Good luck getting passed mods. They don't let you do shit like that anymore. Mods rule with an iron fist on Reddit even to the chagrin of their communities. Shame on reddit and its handlers for taking Reddit in this direction. I have since left reddit and only very casually browse it from time to time. Lots of group think. You will get banned simply for disagreeing with mods in some extreme cases. Reddit didn't used to be this way. I had been a user there for over a decade. They so casually banned me it left a bad taste in my mouth. Reddit has gone to the dogs or in this case the mods. It's embarrassing how far Reddit has fallen. I met Steve and Alexis at MIT startup bootcamp. They were awesome. The reddit they created is no more.
- grecy 6y agoFor years there were daily posts on /r/movies that got to the top like "Remember how good <80s movie> was? Watch it now on Netflix!" It wasn't even thinly veiled, but of course you got downvoted to oblivion if you even mentioned dropping a named platform from the title.
- chongli 6y agoIt’s interesting how Reddit‘s failure to effectively monetize and cut their most important users in on the action, the way YouTube and Twitch have done, seems to have led to a grey market. This hurts Reddit (obviously, since they’re cut out of the market) but it also hurts users due to a lack of transparency. This exposes users to all kinds of astroturfing, shilling, and other misinformation. In a way, it’s quite similar to the issue of Amazon product reviews. Amazon tried to push off a core cost centre from their business onto the backs of volunteers. Now the system is totally corrupted by manufacturers and their paid shills.
- PaulDavisThe1st 6y ago>Amazon tried to push off a core cost centre from their business This is absolutely not true. Customer reviews were conceived of as a barrier to entry that could not be trivially recreated by competitors. They were also conceived (naively, as it turned out) as inherently more trustworthy than anything created by company editorial/review staff. There was never any question of "well, we could do reviews ourselves, but ... nah, let the customer do it". The goal was to harness a subtle kind of network effort to do both of (1) improve the usefulness of the site for users (2) create barriers to entry. [ EDIT; s/others/users/ ] (#2 amzn employee)
- r00fus 6y agoThe proper metric is not "authentic" but "useful". If a channel's usefulness is outweighed by it's cooption, then it deserves to be ignored. Take for example some of the Apple related blogs & ecosystem. I don't doubt for one second that Apple monitors them and may even feed them leaks. Why would a subreddit be somehow immune from this corruptive pressure? Better to know the system is corruptible rather than look at reddit as somehow above the fray.
- random5634 6y agoThe Nikola subreddit is funny. Instant ban for the slightest questioning of any of Nikola Motors statements. There are a bunch of other reddits where stuff just silently disappears.
- thefz 6y ago> Many popular subreddits are quietly operated by moderators with industry connections. There's a dangerous cabal of Reddit "power mods" who rule the great majority of most popular subreddits. Its existence and composition goes way beyond the simple "being in the field".
- maest 6y ago> Reddit conversations are generally assumed to be authentic. r/hailcorporate would disagree, but, sadly, their corporate marketing detectors are too sensitive and they can come off as tin-foiled kooks. Still, more content than you think is astro-turfed on reddit (and I've been claiming this for years).
- higerordermap 6y agoI think there should be stricter rules for subreddits whose names sound "official" or "primary". There is this subreddit: r/india. Which is full of toxicity towards Indian culture. But people are more likely to stumble upon that subreddit. There's also a hard-right subreddit that's equally biased, but at least that's not named r/india.