14 ms·
Parler Tricks: Making Software Disappear
- lern_too_spel 6y ago> The solution is to choose hardware and software from companies that value your freedom This can already be done with Android. Good for them for making another alternative, but they're really overstating their case here.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoTechnically Google can remove sideloaded apps from your Android too. Nearly every Android in existence gives Google remote root access to everything on the device.
- lern_too_spel 6y ago> Nearly every Android in existence gives Google remote root access to everything on the device. That's the point. You're choosing a phone, not among all Android phones at random (or worse, all smartphones at random, which by virtue of including iOS worsens your odds). Even Android phones made by Google are usable with a DNS block on google.com (as long as you manually sideload OS updates), removing Google's remote root.
- mcherm 6y agoBut it is NOT widely done. Why? Perhaps only a few people value this? Or perhaps it hasn't yet been marketed properly?
- lern_too_spel 6y agoPeople who do value it use it that way (and this is the only widely available platform that allows them to do so today). You'll see many such users on this very forum, but as you observed, there aren't that many in total. This says something unfortunate about the size of Purism's addressable market but not much about Android itself.
- aidenn0 6y agoTFA addresses that point explicitly where they say Google lags a couple of generations behind Apple in lockdown features, and newer defaults are pointing in the direction of further restricting sideloading.
- lern_too_spel 6y ago> they say Google lags a couple of generations behind Apple in lockdown features, Android is already caught up with iOS in lockdown features and in some ways already surpassed. This is a very strange argument for PureOS, which requires apps to request permissions at install time (like earlier versions of Android), and many apps in Flathub just ask for all permissions. I hope PureOS improves this situation because it will also make my desktop better in addition to providing more mobile choices, but to claim they are better than Android already at this simply has no basis in reality. > newer defaults are pointing in the direction of further restricting sideloading. Google itself has said that sideloading will become better in upcoming versions of Android. This is something that I am looking forward to because I develop apps for my own devices that I want to manage the deployment of myself without being restricted to the basic deployment capabilities of the Play Store. https://android-developers.googleblog.com/2020/09/listening-to-developer-feedback-to.html?m=1 https://android-developers.googleblog.com/2020/09/listening-...
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoI mean, yes, this is true, but Purism probably shouldn't be picking this hill to market on.
- prionassembly 6y agoIt's a bit of a reputation risk, yes. We should be glad some people are willing to take it. "Democracy dies in darkness" or something.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoThe insurrection directly was trying to kill our democracy by overriding a vote, the core guarantee of our democracy. But in general, I think "buy our product if you want to try to overthrow democracy" is just in general, a bad business strategy.
- aidenn0 6y agoAnd the insurrection was planned more on FB than Parler. The FB app is still in the app stores.
- jayd16 6y ago(As has been said many times already...) FB tries to moderate the violent comments, Parler did not.
- Nextgrid 6y agoFB profited off the violence and only started moderating once the situation became unsustainable from a PR point of view. The reason this insurrection happened is because people were fed divisive, outrageous and false garbage for years for "engagement"'s sake.
- jayd16 6y agoDon't get me wrong, FB isn't free of blame. But its clear the reason they're treated different is because Parler took a black and white stance and FB is a value judgement and much harder to criticize.
- myWindoonn 6y agoServices, not software. They can make services disappear. A famous rant [0] is applicable here; the way that these corporations exercise control is by owning the underlying hardware. If one wants to avoid this sort of corporate control, then one needs to encourage folks to use Free Software on their own machines. [0] https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/who-does-that-server-really-serve.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/who-does-that-server-really-s...
- kevmoo1 6y agoGoogle and Apple can simply make software disappear. Software that gives access to child pornography. Software to buy and sell black-market drugs. Software that lets people organize terrorism and sedition. There's a point where free speech crosses the "clear and present danger" threshold. I consider this a feature, not a bug.
- framecowbird 6y agoSure, but the question is: who gets to decide where that line is drawn when the answer isn't so clear? Are we happy delegating that decision to a couple of corporations?
- GVIrish 6y agoI think that's an argument against Google and Apple being a duopoly in the smartphone market, not an argument that companies shouldn't be able to make policies about what is and isn't allowed on their app store. So if users could more easily sideload apps or if there were more app stores, then Apple and Google wouldn't be the sole arbiters of what apps can be on people's phones.
- methodin 6y agoWhat's the alternative - the government which a large portion of our country wants to see less of? Not to mention if it were the government's responsibility that any new president can just strip the budget making it ineffective.
- loceng 6y agoNo, open a browser and you can go to http://thedonald.win http://thedonald.win and you'll be free to say anything there, so long as it fits their narrative - otherwise they will ban/block you; I hope the irony isn't lost on people that they want to be able to "censor"/block people, but don't want others to be able to block them.
- j16sdiz 6y agoAre there any due process? Is the power checked and balanced?
- dqpb 6y agoDoes anyone here have their Librem 5 smartphone?
- fsflover 6y agoThere are plenty of people on Purism forums: https://forums.puri.sm/search?q=%5BMyL5%5D https://forums.puri.sm/search?q=%5BMyL5%5D.
- mkl95 6y agoGoogle and Apple can simply make software disappear from their app stores, this is not news. Some people have quickly forgotten the Basecamp / Hey scandal just a few months before the Parler shutdown.
- philg_jr 6y agoI mean, you could just open up your favorite web browser and go to any website you'd like. Why is the lack of an app on the App Store or Play such a major hindrance? Well, I know why it is, because most people have been conditioned to associate every service with an app. But really, it shouldn't be a major roadblock. Also, not totally related this this article, but I also don't understand why Parler didn't have a backup DR plan. All of the major cloud platforms have outages. What is stopping them from renting a few racks, or cages of racks, in a datacenter with multiple Tier1 peers? Sounds like they didn't plan very well honestly.
- stickyricky 6y ago> I mean, you could just open up your favorite web browser and go to any website you'd like. Only if you're willing to hit Russian servers...
- core-questions 6y agoMore like "only while you're still allowed to hit Russian servers". With Carrier-Grade NAT leaving people without their own real public IPs, we're already past the point where people have true unfettered internet access and the freedom to hit / be hit by any IP they wish. I'm not scared of the Russians. The whole thing feels like a lukewarm, microwaved version of the Cold War, and frankly, it's more Hollywood than it is real. "Russian hackers!!!" could be anyone who has a $2/mo Russian proxy address; you can get yourself a /32 of Russian IPv6 space for peanuts; there's no way to know where anyone's really operating from. Unless you think the MaxMinds GeoIP database is somehow irrefutable evidence of state actions....
- yosito 6y agoThere are plenty of apps that don't have a web version. Like the carsharing app I use, for example. Only exists for Android and iOS.
- slowhand09 6y agoWhen your DNS provider removes your record... When your cellular connection becomes an app... When your contact list is removed or hidden... When your text app is locked... When your ISP kills your account... When your webhost provider deletes your site and/or content... When they selectively track your location and post it to political groups they support... When your car GPS stops navigating. When your car won't start to support a suggested lockdown they support... When your cable channel drops all "opposing" news media... How much of Orwell's 1984 do you want?
- gotoeleven 6y agoEncryption can be used for bad things too I hope they ban it.
- LanceH 6y agoPoliticians do bad things, too.
- petraeus 6y agoThe opposite of this is to declare everyone has the right to be featured #1 on these private platform? Nobody has that right.
- fsflover 6y agoIf those platforms are de-facto monopolies, then everyone should have the right to be there (not necessarily be featured #1).
- yosito 6y agoI really like the idea of running an OS like PureOS or other open source, Linux OSes on my phone. In practice though, there are always apps that I need in modern life that only exist for iOS or Android. The carsharing app I use, a few of my banks, and some apps I need for work, etc, all only exist on Android. Is there any solution for running an Android VM inside a Linux phone in order to use these apps that I need that aren't available for Linux?
- fsflover 6y agohttps://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Frequently-Asked-Questions#314-how-are-android-apps-installed-in-the-librem-5 https://source.puri.sm/Librem5/community-wiki/-/wikis/Freque...
- Bud 6y ago"Apps get removed from these app stores all the time, but more than almost any past move by these companies, this one has brought the power Big Tech companies wield over everyone’s lives to the minds of every day people." Everyday Nazis, more like.
- santoshalper 6y agoI absolutely despise the kind of content you'd find on parler, but I am still deeply uncomfortable with Amazon and Google's influence over our lives. You can hold two opposing thoughts in your head at the same time.
- seba_dos1 6y agoSame here. I despise Parler and the kind of people that associate with it, but I'm also not happy with the power over our lives that big tech companies possess these days. Seeing the Librem 5 being recommended by random people in context of Parler makes me feel uneasy, but I guess I just have to deal with the fact that not everything is black and white and that good things (like FLOSS, encryption, autonomy) will also be used to do bad. (I work for Purism on a technical position)
- timeon 6y agoYeah, that post made me sad. Was enthusiastic about purism. Not interested in it anymore.
- NuSkooler 6y agoParler is back up (as a website) and could even host a APK for Android. In addition, there are multiple Android stores as alternatives to the Play Store. For years people have griped over this "fragmentation". Google, Apple, and others are much too powerful. I cannot deny that. Something really needs done. However, they made the right move. It's not "censorship", and yes you do have options if you're the type that wants garbage like Parler.
- dadarepublic 6y agoAs had been said prior, there is an examination to be made around the influence Google & Apple have in the software space. However there is also the obligatory xkcd:https://xkcd.com/1357/ https://xkcd.com/1357/
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- smlckz 6y agoNow that governments are trying to catch up with the latest happenings, they might be able to stop Big Tech to achieve ''sovereignty''. But, as more people move towards free software, the governments in lust of power would like to restrict the freedom of the people in dealings with software. Also, oppressive goverments may use ''free'' software in oppression. How can we take away their ''freedom'' in such circumstances? (Can we? I don't think that is possible.)
- Kusoneko 6y agoAside from the obvious marketing attempt at the end, they are correct in stating this, no matter how you feel about [whichever is the latest thing the 2 app stores decide to remove], the fact that they can practically prevent near everyone from accessing any services that are provided as apps by simply agreeing to remove the app from both stores is way too much power in the hand of a few huge corporations. The duopoly of app stores is the issue here, not so much the removal of something the app store owners find objectionable. I am aware that there are other app stores (f-droid, other android phone companies having their own app stores that they sometimes/used to shove in phones as bloatware, not sure about Apple's phones if there is any such thing), but you need to go out of your way to get them, and most people don't bother, so the reach they have is tiny as opposed to the combined reach of 100% of the market share of app stores the Google/Apple duopoly has. Something that is removed from both app stores effectively doesn't exist for most people.
- quantified 6y agoI mostly agree. However it is a sad state of mind for most people, because web browsers provide an app interface for many purposes. There are so many sites that I don’t want to use the crappy available app for- if the company can’t make a good website, I’m always dubious it can code a decent app.
- threatofrain 6y agoAccording to the CEO of Parler, banks and payment vendors, law firms, text and mail services also cancelled on them. This is why Parler also motivates discussion of alternative currency. This is an expression of freedom of association by multiple parties. Google didn't need to ask Parler's lawyers or bank to quit them. Parler became a hot potato, and whoever is the last one holding it receives a full-court press from all sides.
- dalu 6y agoMuch more troubling is that Telegram proactively removed right wing groups from their service, because those 2 companies removed Parler
- syockit 6y agoThis is totally off-topic, but I really feel like slapping the designer of the font with a tuna or something. Is it intentionally designed to be provocative? Apparently, the font is called Libre Baskerville, but when I viewed it on Google Fonts it didn't have that annoying X-height.
- fsckboy 6y ago> go to any website you'd like. Why is the lack of an app on the App Store or Play such a major hindrance? have you ever been grateful you received a notification on your phone when a message arrived that was of great interest to you? Does your web browser do that, or do your apps do that? you are smarter than the obtuse you are pretending to be to make your argument.
- pennaMan 6y ago>Does your web browser do that, or do your apps do that? On Android, both web apps and native apps do that. iOS only allows Safari that conveniently does not implement web push notifications, thus keeping a very wide spectrum of apps away from the open web and inside their app garden.
- parliament32 6y ago>If Google bans an app, all a user has to do is follow a list of complicated (and often sketchy) procedures, sometimes involving disabling protections or installing sketchy software on another computer You what? Download an .apk from anywhere (browser, email, usb, whatever) and click on it. Android will literally guide you directly to the "unknown sources" toggle. Then install your apk.
- fsflover 6y agoTell that to your grandma.