12 ms·
Turkey imposes advertising bans on Twitter, Periscope and Pinterest
- rtx 6y agoChinese we were real visionaries here, rest of the countries are catching up.
- dastx 6y agoChina is banning twitter because China wants to control who sees what on the platform, which I'm presuming Twitter has refused to do. There's nothing visionary about this. It's called censorship.
- Synaesthesia 6y agoI think they also don't want to cede control of their tech marketplace to US competitors like Google, Twitter, Facebook etc which is what could happen if they just allow anything in.
- wongarsu 6y agoI'm pretty sure that's what Turkey is doing here too. This is Turkey catching up to Twitter. Let's hope the West doesn't try to catch up as well.
- toyg 6y agoDon't hope, shout it from the rooftops.
- yulaow 6y agoI think parent was ironically saying that now even the governments that were criticizing china for censorship are starting to feel they should act in the same way over the main social media platforms. It is sad but is is what's happening right now.
- mrkeen 6y agoDoes China not have ads?
- rtx 6y agoNot without representation.
- trident5000 6y agoNobody gets this is a joke...hah
- m00dy 6y agoI agree with Turkey's position here.
- ThePowerOfFuet 6y agoWhy?
- m00dy 6y agoTurkey has around 80milion people as its population and an elected government. I think these people have the right to summon an ambassador from not just twitter but all big tech giants.
- toyg 6y agoIsn't it a bit of an admission though? Global corps are effectively as powerful as most nation-states now, to the point you need "ambassadors". I expect the next step will be to agree on a Geneva-like convention on this sort of diplomatic mission, where the local representative is guaranteed immunity in exchange for accepting equal representation of a country in the corporation.
- radres 6y agoIsn't it better to admit it than to not do anything about it?
- simonh 6y agoThey weren't just embassies, and the 'ambassadors' weren't just representing the companies, these are state censorship bureaus.
- gus_massa 6y agoDoes the "ambassador of Twitter" has diplomatic immunity, or they can send the ambassador to hail if Twitter breaks a local law?
- teekert 6y ago
- m_a_g 6y agoAlthough not outright blocking those websites is a step up, a 90% bandwidth cut is almost the same as blocking them.
- dastx 6y agoIt's probably a warning of "do what we say or we'll block you because we can't control what you have on your platform". It's a step in the censorship direction.
- StavrosK 6y agoI'd say probably worse than blocking them. If Twitter gets blocked, people will find another way to get on Twitter. If it's not blocked, but is very slow, they will visit it less and less.
- toyg 6y agoWhat about setting up caching proxies inside the country? I expect the practice would eventually be made illegal and cracked on, but with a bit of technical trickery one might be able to keep the cat-and-mouse game running for some significant time. (I know, I know, I'm looking for technical solutions to a social problem...)
- 2Gkashmiri 6y agoyou know when india literally banned internet to 8 million humans, for months ALL connections were simply shut, isps turned off their setup. later when they did let whitelisted websites, i found out not all VPNs worked, it was a "cat and mouse" game but i managed to ssh into a vps i set up through some weird gimmick and ssh tunnelling was the only way to access internet and that too, via 2G internet. it was terrible to say the least and the one phrase constantly being used, big brother style was "misuse" which translated into "dont you dare criticize the govt". i am saying stuff like this will continue to happen. even the assault against parler has shown such censorship can come in many forms and like it or not, it will happen everywhere https://www.greaterkashmir.com/news/business/4g-suspension-500-days-and-counting/ https://www.greaterkashmir.com/news/business/4g-suspension-5...
- roenxi 6y agoThere are a lot of right-wing governments in the world. I can't see the argument for them letting the SV tech companies enter their markets unmolested. If Trump can be banned, why not Erdogan? I imagine it is on the cards sooner or later. At some point that and the access it gives US intelligence agencies to the population has to become a national security issue. China's policy of locking US companies out of the Chinese market looks prudent in hindsight.
- p2detar 6y ago> China's policy of locking US companies out of the Chinese market looks prudent in hindsight. Exactly. I mean, depending on their market penetration, social media platforms are not just a mirror but an active tool for analysis and influence of people's opinions. Age groups, clicks, hash tags, links, time of posting, etc. Why on Earth would governments leave such power in the hands of the free enterprise? Even in the West this just seems bizarre to me. I think the days of internationally available social media platforms are numbered. Enterprises like Twitter, Facebook and Google will either concede to selected rules crafted by governments, authoritarian or not, or just get blocked from operating in their markets. Those who have heavily invested in social media are soon to be in for an unpleasant surprise.
- op03 6y agoThats what was said about Wall St after many a blunder. They are still raking it in. Do you know why?
- p2detar 6y agoNo, I don't know or have an exact opinion about Wall St. About social media, I think it's mostly a generational issue in governance. Those generations in power are still very little informed about the immense power of social media and are only now beginning to see its effects. The congress hearings of Zuckerberg, Doursey and Pichai, and the kind of questions being asked there seem to point in that direction. Needless to say, regulation isn't quite in the best interest of intelligence orgs. More so on the West that is.
- mrtksn 6y agoAfter all that happened, Now it makes sense for a country to have a grasp over the communication of its citizens. That’s said, the primary use is expected to be control of journalism on Youtube. After Erdogan took over almost all of the media, many of the fired journalists started Youtube channels and got more popular than the media Erdogan has a hold on. He now wants to impose the same controls that he has over TV channels. The body responsible is called RTUK and recently got regulatory powers over internet broadcasting too. It infamously fines TV channels that are not friendly enough to Erdogan at the smallest mistake and turning blind eye on pro-Erdogan channels. This is because, the fines need to go through the committee in which Erdogan holds the majority. To what extent you might ask? Well, there’s a talk show host on the TV who got destroyed for having a guest who said “let’s save the kids” when talking about governments dealings with the Kurds and there’s a TV channel who got a slap on the wrist after a public outcry for hosting commentators asking people to keep arms at home and identify potential targets among their neighbours who might be Erdogan’s political rivals. The double standards are off the charts. Youtube is probably becoming Erdogan’s double standards enforcer.Everything is going to be legal, of course. If youtube doesn’t behave, more fines will come. The government would usually turn a blind eye to some practices in the industry and will slap fines to those who are not in line. Turkey has strong as GDPR personal information protection laws, probably a land mine field for ad-agencies and that’s how they will get their fines I would guess.
- _pmf_ 6y ago> for a country to have a grasp over the communication of its citizens It's never the country that has this power. It's particular government bodies.
- DyslexicAtheist 6y agoIn Turkey AKP/Erdogan is the "country". The beef between twitter and Erdogan's AKP is quite old and goes back to at least the times of the coup, and then when the Turkish police got doxxed by CthulhuSec. edit: tone down my own opinion bc toyg is right in their critique
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Dem_Boys 6y agoDoes anybody know if this move is in any way related to the recent Trump/Parler bans? The article doesn't mention any relation but the timing seems to suggest it could be related
- mrtksn 6y agoIt’s not, it was in the making for a long time. TV censorship and regulations body got its power over the internet and the laws leading to this were passed way before the recent US events. Netflix had to cancel the production of a Turkish TV show for having a gay character in the lead and remove content that the government doesn't like. This is happening to Twitter, Youtube etc. now because the time given for them to comply ran out.
- diegoperini 6y agoHistory for the curious reader: The law passed months ago and all major providers are given notice last year. Any social media provider, local or foreign, with at least 1M daily user activity is required to assign a legal representative in Turkey now. Internet bandwith of non-obliging companies will be reduced up to 95% incrementally. Until recently, most social networks including Facebook were silent to this request. They now have representatives as well, alongside Microsoft and a few others.
- Symbiote 6y agoWhat is the 95% based on? Current usage? Or, just some invented number, adjusted according to Erdoğan's political requirements?
- dastx 6y agoKnowing the little governments usually know about tech, I'd say it was a random number chosen by a dice roll, guaranteed to be random.
- mrtksn 6y agoGood question. Here is the text of the law (in Turkish): https://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/eskiler/2020/07/20200731-1.htm https://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/eskiler/2020/07/20200731-1.ht... It says "the social network provider's band width to be reduced by ...%" I'm not a law expert but my guess is that they will send order letters to the ISP's and the ISP's will act the way they see fit. If Erdogan is not impressed, they will give the CEO's a call to improve the bandwidth reduction. If they don't comply, they will have hard time getting the permits to install cables or win government contracts, so they will comply. When a website is blocked in Turkey, it's up to ISP's to choose the blocking method. Some ISP's blocks are stronger than others(some simply block DNS and you are not affected if you use GoogleDNS or OpenDNS etc. others block the IP so your only recourse is to use VPN). Also, some websites are more blocked than the others(On the same ISP you can have some websites IP blocked, others DNS only).
- diegoperini 6y agoThe rumor is it is the magic number that gives you a good enough page load times as long as there is no video content.
- aerodog 6y agoJack Dorsey took the initiative to side with the people who tried to overthrow the Turkish government in 2016. I'm surprised Twitter still survives. The MSM almost entirely ignores this because they're fixated on this "strongman" narrative that makes American liberals feel good about themselves.
- ulucs 6y agoI want to read about this, any sources?
- throwaway313371 6y agoProof? My understanding is that the Twitter block in 2016 had less to do with Twitter as a company and more to do with Tayipp not being able to control the flow of information. Remember Wikipedia was blocked because Tayipp's page was painted honestly, which he found to be very unflattering, and because Wikimedia refused to remove references to the recorded/leaked conversations about money laundering with his (Berkeley-educated) nitwit song Bilal (There is a saying here when somebody does not understand what you are saying: "Explain it as if you are explaining it to Bilal". This is also why soundcloud was blocked for 3 years, because people used it to post the recordings of him telling Bilal to remove all of the cash from the family houses in case they were searched.
- 2Gkashmiri 6y agohttps://www.greaterkashmir.com/news/business/4g-suspension-500-days-and-counting/ https://www.greaterkashmir.com/news/business/4g-suspension-5... this is going to happen to turkey too... people going full vpn, then govt banning vpn, then using shit like kazhakistan certificate thing and before you know it, full on china GFW.
- pjc50 6y agoI suppose this was inevitable after the Arab Spring and the incoherent failure that "democracy promotion" has been across the Muslim world, along with the rise of right-wing-authoritarian governments. Twitter is a revolution-causing technology. We were all bigging this up in 2011 when protestors in Tahrir Square overthrew the military government of Egypt demanding a less repressive one. Unfortunately fewer people paid attention to the followup: the subsequent (apparently free and fair) elections were won by the Islamist party, who immediately tried to impose an Islamist constitution that was in many ways even more repressive. That led to a coup again, effectively going back to a military dictatorship. How it's going now: https://www.hrw.org/world-report/2020/country-chapters/egypt https://www.hrw.org/world-report/2020/country-chapters/egypt Merely having free speech and free elections is not enough to ensure that people don't elect a repressive government. The liberal values need to be more widely embedded in the society, and more work needs to be done to counter propaganda and the inevitable racism and religious bigotry and supremacism that leads to unfree governments. It has also been very convenient for the West to not pay attention to Turkey during the Syria crisis, while they engage in what look like proxy actions on our behalf against Syrian and Russian (and unfortunately Kurdish) forces. And host something like three million refugees.
- chicob 6y agoYet another power gobble, this time over tweets.
- kuter 6y agoFacebook and Google decided to have representatives.I fear that Twitter might decide to have it's own representative. It would be a nightmare here if these companies start censoring everything that the government asks for. Erdoğan is starting loose support. AKP (his party) lost all 3 of the major cities in local elections. I think the best scenario for Turkey would be Facebook and Google deciding to pull out their representatives from Turkey. Legally the next step of Turkey would be to block %90 percent of the traffic. Which would be equal to blocking these sites. There is a lot of AKP/Erdoğan supporters that use these services. This would weaken Erdoğan further. Most educated people in Turkey do/can use a VPN anyways. Only Erdoğan supporters, which are known to have less/none education (big surprise) would be effected from this.
- nradov 6y agoUsing a VPN doesn't require a lot of education, especially if someone else sets it up for you. I think they'll figure it out. The bigger issue will be if Turkey follows China's example and implements a national firewall to block VPNs.
- Blikkentrekker 6y agoI think you overestimate the intelligence of the average man, or rather his problem solving ability. You would really be surprised for how many something as simple as “I accidentally removed my bookmarks bar in my web browser, how do I get it back?” is a test that separates the men from the boys. — dare I say that over half of mankind would fail this simple test.
- ulucs 6y agoI think you underestimate them, most Turks know what to do with the addresses 8.8.8.8 and 8.8.4.4 from the time they were an effective way to circumvent the old youtube block
- kuter 6y agoI remember those days. I think they intercept dns packages these days or block ip addresses. They also had something called url blocking which was intercepting http packages. Not used anymore because of wide adoption of ssl.
- BerkhanBerkdemi 6y agoIf anyone curious, here is the actual (rule of) text[0] (in Turkish) about advertising bans of social media platforms. [0]: https://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/ilanlar/eskiilanlar/2021/01/20210119-4-1.pdf https://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/ilanlar/eskiilanlar/2021/01/2...
- ceilingcorner 6y agoThe recent actions of Silicon Valley companies will turn out to be the single biggest threat to global free communication on the Internet. Every two bit dictator will now wave them around to justify locking down the Internet and restrict the sharing of information. Such a shortsighted move, and yet even on HN we have people thinking it was justified. Frankly, I am very disappointed. We need a revival of late 90s “information should be free” values, and fast.
- macspoofing 6y ago>Every two bit dictator will now wave them around to justify locking down the Internet and restrict the sharing of information. Not just dictators. You think EU is going to let American social companies dictate which of their citizens and representatives (!!!) can and cannot have access to what become a standard mass communication channel (i.e. what social media became)? Hell no. They may hate Trump, but they weren't fans of Trump's Twitter/Facebook ban and they sure as hell won't let Jack effin Dorsey be their arbiter of free speech.
- kuter 6y agoOh also 7 years ago Turkey 'accidentally' created a SSL certificate for google.com https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/01/turkish-government-agency-spoofed-google-certificate-accidentally/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/01/turki... TURKTRUST (The company that did this) is still a trust authority.