5 ms·
Stromatolites: A Billion-Year-Old Living Organism
- cheph 6y agoI am not sure by what criteria you can say these are billion year old living organisms. If you meant they have been around that long, sure, they have, but a stromatolite is not a living organism by most (if not all?) definitions. It is a layered sedimentary formation. It is about as much an organism as an ant heap without ants is an organism. And I'm pretty sure that none of the individual organisms that create stromatolites are even close to a 100 years old, never mind a billion years old.
- taneq 6y agoI've always wondered the same. They're only an organism in the same sense that a reef is an organism.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoThey are not claiming that those very organisms have been alive for that long (the title is poorly worded). The point they are making is that stromatolites have existed for billions of years according to the fossil records.
- cheph 6y agoMy complaint is exclusively with the title, not the article, which I don't think supports the claim in the title.
- rflrob 6y agoHow “old” is a single-celled organism? I don’t know the precise details for Cyanobacteria, but it could be a relatively equal split (unlike budding, a perfectly reasonable alternative). In that case, are both offspring of a cell division the age of the “parent”? If so, why stop at the time since one generation? “But wait”, you may complain, “they are constantly exchanging molecules with their environment!” So is the “age” of the organism the point at which none (or equivalently half or any other fraction you choose) of the atoms inside the organism were inside the organism previously? That implies you could watch a single, discrete cell not dividing, and it’s “age” would be constantly fluctuating, not simply monotonically increasing. It’s entirely possible that age is not a meaningful, well-defined concept here. But less philosophically, when people refer to “living fossils”, they generally mean that the organisms haven’t changed much in form or physiology in a long time. There’s no reason to believe that they aren’t subject to the same pressure to adapt to changing conditions via natural selection, but those adaptations aren’t readily visible.
- cheph 6y ago> How “old” is a single-celled organism? Good question, I looked around a bit for this, it seems the life of a single celled organism is taken to be from division to the next division, but really this is a bit odd, because nothing died there. Clearly age for such organisms is not a well defined concept.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vikramkr 6y agoBuilding up oxygen being something that gave the "kiss of life" is an interesting perspective, considering that oxygenation was responsible for one of the largest mass extinctions ever
- Razengan 6y agoDon’t you know, life needs oxygen, anything else isn’t life. (A jab at searches for extraterrestrial life that maintain oxygen as a key criteria)
- gameswithgo 6y agoIts a waste product or a necessity so either way its a chemical signature to look for.
- cheph 6y ago> (A jab at searches for extraterrestrial life that maintain oxygen as a key criteria) I am not aware of any searches that have oxygen as a necessary condition for life and I doubt they exist. It is not even considered a very good biosignature[1][2] because there are potential abiotic process that can replenish it, but it can be used as a biosignature, but that would work for life even if the life does not use oxygen, so using oxygen as a biosignature is not saying that life needs oxygen. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biosignature#False_positives https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biosignature#False_positives [2]: https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/full/10.1089/ast.2017.1727 https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/full/10.1089/ast.2017.1727
- pseudolus 6y agoThere was some publicized and disputed research that emerged a few years ago that dated the emergence of certain stromatolites in Greenland to 3.7 billion years ago. However, a certain consensus has emerged that the structures are not the remnants of stromatolites but rather just rock structures [0][1]. [0] https://astrobiology.nasa.gov/news/on-the-ground-in-greenland/#:~:text=The%20vigorously%20debated%20stromatolites%20from,of%20ancient%20rocks%20in%20Greenland.&text=4%20to%201.6%20inches%20tall,result%20of%20non%2Dbiological%20forces https://astrobiology.nasa.gov/news/on-the-ground-in-greenlan.... [1] https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/2018/10/news-oldest-stromatolite-fossilized-life-rocks-greenland/ https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/2018/10/news-olde...
- codecamper 6y agoblue green algae aka cyanobacteria. They also may be the solution for quickly turning back global warming. George Church says that altering cyanobacteria dna to protect them from their natural viral enemy, the Cyanophage, could allow them to proliferate and they would then pull co2 out of the air, and after mostly sink to the bottom of the oceans. Not entirely sure how he imagines controlling it all, but it is an interesting & out of the box idea.
- peter303 6y agoChemotrophs probably existed before photosynthesis. The latter is a rather complex sequence of enzymes and took a while to evolve. Chemotrophs hijack natural rock chemistry reactions. Most likely it was the weathering of fresh, hot basalt at underseas volcanos. Some of these metabolic pathways require no enzymes to proceed. Then enzymes would evolve to allow such life to expand into less opportunistic environments.
- NelsonMinar 6y agoI was frustrated that article didn't have pictures. Here's a nice gallery: https://www.gettyimages.com/photos/stromatolite?phrase=stromatolite&sort=mostpopular https://www.gettyimages.com/photos/stromatolite?phrase=strom...
- abrookewood 6y agoAgreed. I didn't really understand what a stromatolite was. But as soon as I saw the picture I recognised them.