14 ms·
I Tried to Get a ‘Leftover Dose’ of the Vaccine Last Night
- 1-6 6y agoI think the vaccine should go to people who want it the most. That way, on-lookers can sit back and take it once they realize that it's safe and effective.
- scotty79 6y agoI think it's exactly how it's done, but those "who want it the most" vastly outnumber the supply so you still have to prioritize and left overs come from failure of specific people to show at specific placed and specific time.
- tialaramex 6y agoThe UK is experimenting with 24 hour clinics which presumably avoids the "left over" phenomenon. If you're never shutting for the day any doses you have right now are for the next patients, if you're vaccinating patients more quickly than anticipated you can bring forward some appointments but you never have this hard cut off. After all, under total lockdown it's not as though you're likely to be anywhere except at home waiting to get an appointment. An interesting contrast will be New Zealand. Since they have community elimination they didn't seek emergency use authorisation, why not wait and study what happens to the millions of people from other developed countries who needed urgent vaccination? They will do mass population vaccination during 2021 but this month or next doesn't mean thousands or even handfuls of deaths, so there is no hurry. This might reduce take up. If you live in New York you probably at least know somebody who got badly sick, maybe died - but if you live in Wellington you likely have stopped even thinking about the pandemic most days unless you work in quarantine or the tourist industry.
- deadlyllama 6y agoIn Wellington (I live there) there's a QR code on every shop you're supposed to scan with your phone for contact tracing. Most people don't but they still see them - so yes it's still on our minds.
- tialaramex 6y agoGood point. There are supposed to be QR codes here. I only visit one place, to buy food every 7-9 days, they don't have a QR code and employees seemed confused about what one was or why I might be surprised not to see one. I gave up rather than expend any more time trying to have a conversation through masks with confused people about something they can't fix. They did, I noticed when I last visited yesterday, begin explicitly telling people that "One adult shopper" does not mean, "What a fun outing, let's all go to the store as a family and increases everyone's exposure for no reason".
- solveit 6y agoThat's insane. Here in Korea you're required to scan the code (or write your contact info on paper) in order to enter the premises.
- tialaramex 6y agoHistorically New Zealand's government has found that compliance isn't massively improved by empty threats, and police resources aren't available to have an officer at the front door of every shop in the country and enforce such a law, so there isn't one. What does improve compliance is an actual negative event. The change in public reaction to funeral restrictions in lock down when people attending a funeral got sick (and I think one died?) was noticeable. Reported consequences make the policy much harder to ignore. And if there hasn't been enforcement the way human memory works, if on Tuesday a human decides complying with a rule is good, they are now more likely to remember having complied with it on Monday, and retrospectively they will come to believe "obviously" they always obeyed that policy, it was the sensible thing to do. That's cheaper and more effective than policing. But it may cost a few lives to provide the example.
- solveit 6y agoYou don't need armed enforcement to get people to scan a QR code, you just need an employee to ask politely.
- sellyme 6y ago> This might reduce take up. [...] if you live in Wellington you likely have stopped even thinking about the pandemic most days It would certainly reduce the urgency of take-up, but I would expect there to be a pretty strong correlation between how well a city/country deals with the pandemic, and the proportion of residents in that region who think that getting the vaccine is important, even if it's a vaccine for a virus that's not directly affecting them right at this moment. I live in a region that eradicated the virus a long time ago, but I still think about it almost every day because the world's so interconnected. It has had almost zero effect on my personal life since March, but the vast majority of my friends overseas are in unending lockdown cycles, and international news is almost exclusively about the latest death tolls or what the vaccine progress is like. It would be pretty difficult to not know what's going on.
- flukus 6y ago> An interesting contrast will be New Zealand. Since they have community elimination they didn't seek emergency use authorisation, why not wait and study what happens to the millions of people from other developed countries who needed urgent vaccination? Keeping it out is proving to be quite hard, an exception for quarantine workers, flight crew, returning citizens and anyone connected to them would make it much easier. It seems like the world is already learning though and countries that have eliminated the virus may find vaccinating the extremely frail to be a net negative and rely on herd immunity to protect this group.
- chrismcb 6y agoIf we only vaccinated every one over 65 then we can basically go to normal, while the rest get vaccinated. That would prevent something like 80% of the deaths and hospitalizations. Some people would do get it but we would have more resources to handle it.
- ryandrake 6y agoI think the idea that once a few at-risk populations get vaccinated we can “go back to normal” is pretty naive. You still get it mildly and can spread it once vaccinated. People outside at-risk groups who aren’t vaccinated yet can die. We don’t know how long the vaccine is good for—maybe we have to get it once a year like the flu, who knows? I’m a gambler and I’d bet we’ll be wearing masks for years, and possibly forever, depending on how the thing mutates and behaves. My parents think they are gonna get jabbed then it’s off to happy hour, and that just seems incredibly simplistic.
- ls612 6y agoJesus man, I sure hope there aren’t many people like you who want to keep living like this forever.
- ryandrake 6y agoNobody wants to but I don’t think we know enough about this disease yet to declare it will definitely be over soon. I really hope it’s not a seasonal disease that needs a different vaccine every year!
- slaymaker1907 6y agoHow many micromorts do we need to be at for it to be acceptable? If you can't name a probability of death that is acceptable then your opinion is worthless (don't worry, lots of people seem to be in this camp). We accept risks for far dumber stuff every day. Maybe its 1 micromort or 100, but there must be some point at which making everyone wear a mask is more trouble than it is worth.
- supernova87a 6y agoYou can tell what kind of pressures the local distribution systems (or lack of) are under, but the missteps are still shameful. You have people over 75 years old who were waiting and registering on whatever reservation system was cobbled together on short notice, and then because the public health authorities now risked throwing out doses for want of people to inject them into, they just opened the floodgates to everyone over 65. So what happens to the people over 75 who were waiting, and now are swamped by the crowds? If they keep on opening up bulk tranches of the population (instead of in small slices) before people of priority are reached, when will the most vulnerable ever get their turn? This is a known problem. Multiple queues of priority and people on call to be given turns the next day if it looks like there's capacity. Instead you have people wondering if they should walk in, visit a county next door, or wait around in case some mistake is made and there are actually extra doses at the end of a day. Or try to scheme/figure out the system however they can, out of desperation. If it can't be done right, let everyone know that it's up to their willingness to wait wherever they can, according to some basic ground rules, and don't make a meaningless (or worse, deceptive) reservations system that gets bypassed at the last minute. What a shameful clusterfuck.
- ghaff 6y agoI'd be less concerned about people over 65 "sneaking in" over people more than 75 than systems that end up being a free for all anyone to get vaccinations because they're in the right place at the right time (and presumably getting second vaccinations as well). A lot is really about overall volume. Even a million vaccinations a day means you're looking at well into the summer until you even approach 50% vaccinated.
- votepaunchy 6y agoThere are 260 million American adults. Already 12 million receiving a vaccine. Approaching 1,000,000 per day receiving first dose. At that rate we’ll need 118 days to have half the population vaccinated with a first dose in mid-May and the second dose in early/mid-June.
- 6y ago
- hprotagonist 6y agoI’d done exactly the same, even against the particular absurdity that tightly controlled vaccine doses could be found by word-of-mouth and the general New York knowledge that, no matter how early you think you are, there will always be masses of your neighbors that beat you to the punch. Though the circumstances of the rush gave it an apocalyptic flavor, there didn’t seem to be any real human descent into chaos. No fistfights or shouting matches about who was in line, no storming of the gates. Just a lot of cold people, all desperate enough to chase down a lead so unlikely it could have been — and actually was — real. That’s the spirit of my city alright. The “general new york knowledge” line strikes very true.
- sillysaurusx 6y agoI'm interested in evidence that the vaccine works. Where should I start? (I know how this sounds, but it's not like that. It's more like, it's a modern miracle that we have any vaccine at all within a year of an outbreak, and I am extremely keen to understand how this is possible rather than just accepting it as a thing that exists now, like airplanes.) EDIT: No complaints, but it's fascinating how polarizing this topic is. One wouldn't expect a straightforward request for information to generate such feelings. Thank you to everyone who provided resources!
- Uehreka 6y agoI’m not an expert, so heaping tablespoon of salt and all that, but it seems like we were on the cusp of a revolution in vaccine development due to this mRNA method of making vaccines, and Covid came around at just the right time where a big infusion of cash into mRNA vaccine research could get the technology over the hump. Again, totally not an expert at all, but from what I’ve gleaned this whole novel mRNA thing is key to understanding why this was so fast and why other vaccines in the future could come really fast as well.
- mindcrime 6y agoThis jibes with my understanding as well. I believe that research into mRNA vaccines began somewhere around the very early 1990's or very late 1980's, so the idea itself is not new. And vaccines (or candidate vaccines) were developed for earlier illnesses like MERS, but none ever made it as far as approval for widespread human use, for various reasons. Mostly, AIUI, because the outbreaks ended before they got that far and so it was no longer economically justifiable to continue the process. So yeah, basically, COVID came along and suddenly there was money and impetus to push the thing over the finish line, and so here we are. That's my lay-person's understanding anyway.
- asiando 6y agoIf there wasn’t evidence, they wouldn’t approve it. Just find the vaccines’ homepage and follow the footnotes.
- steveBK123 6y agoLive in NY and have been tracking the slow jab rate with disappointment to now find we are running up against inventory&deliveries now. Though our daily jabs have gone from appallingly low to only embarrassingly low, we are actually going to go backwards now that it turns out the “strategic reserve” Trump promised to release last week is a phantom. Being under-40 with no kids or seniors in my home, easily working from home, I expect to get vax sometime this summer. This is fine, I’m happy to let seniors, medical and frontline workers get it first. This of course includes teachers so they can open schools for good come August. Glad to see it’s been opened to most of these prioritized people now, and it is intelligent to have a mix of appointments & walk-ins to take out the excess inventory daily. That said, the whole distribution is a shitshow. And this started even before it moved beyond initial phase of medical workers getting it at work from their employers. I know a lot of non-patient facing people in medical or medical-adjacent jobs who got it well before most nurses, EMTs, etc got it. It seems if you are in management or have a PHD you could jump all the way to the front.. of course.
- RspecMAuthortah 6y agoI don't live in NY so I am curious. NY is one of the worst hit states in the country and had 8 months to prepare for this. What do you think went wrong? Is it local/state officials' colossal incompetence, something that they are quite known for? For a state with one of the highest tax rates, you would expect better from them.
- Tokkemon 6y agoThe constant infighting between de Blasio and Cuomo certainly isn't helping things. Cuomo has a very "my way or the highway" style of management but then doesn't release details fast enough for there to be an effective ground game, so individual institutions or counties are stuck to do their own planning. At least there's a somewhat-coherent PR response, but that doesn't help get jabs in arms.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 6y ago
- transitorykris 6y agoDoes getting a leftover dose grant you the right to the second dose within the window?
- supercanuck 6y agoYes.
- gnicholas 6y agoMy understanding is that it's not especially important to get the second dose within a particular window. A surgeon friend got her first dose and said she was planning to delay the second one for a while so that more first doses could go out to others, and that it would be just as effective for her if she got it later. She's also relatively young (under 40), so she isn't as concerned as some people might be. Honestly I don't know how she can be that confident that timing of the second dose doesn't matter, since this doesn't seem to have been tested with COVID vaccines. Perhaps it is a feature of vaccines in general?
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoIn terms of individual results, having the second vaccine would be best, but in terms of getting partial immunity to most people, getting the first one only would be better for everyone.
- votepaunchy 6y agoIf the population was homogenously vulnerable this might be the case, but with a millionfold difference in mortality between the aged and young and healthy prioritizing a second dose is the ethical choice.
- aphextron 6y ago>Honestly I don't know how she can be that confident that timing of the second dose doesn't matter, since this doesn't seem to have been tested with COVID vaccines. Perhaps it is a feature of vaccines in general? Given that this is a completely novel vaccine, and there is zero clinical data to support that statement, there is literally no way she can know that for sure. However, the Moderna vaccine confers an immunity approximately equivalent to convalescent COVID-19 patients within two weeks of the first dose, so she's probably fine.
- lwansbrough 6y agoDrop all requirements for vaccination except age. This vastly simplifies logisitics and virtually guarantees you will not have vaccines expiring.
- TylerE 6y agoI have a extremely mixed feelings on this. I’m in my 30s, but have several of the major comorbidities, including diabetes and asthma. Should I have to wait at the very end of the line like the healthy 30 year olds?
- ghaff 6y agoIt's complicated and I generally trust the CDC recommendations to be reasonable judgements. But they're not infinitely fine-grained. The rules in lots of places have healthy-ish 64 year old being eligible at the same time as healthy 20 year olds.
- ls612 6y agoHaving comorbidities like obesity, diabetes, etc increases your risks from the virus by a factor of 2-4. Being old vs young increases your risks by a factor of 1000. You are at more risk than your peers but still at far less risk than even a person in their 60s.
- nickysielicki 6y agoIf I've already had the virus, do I need to get vaccinated?
- divbzero 6y agoAccording to the CDC: [1] Yes. Due to the severe health risks associated with COVID-19 and the fact that reinfection with COVID-19 is possible, you should be vaccinated regardless of whether you already had COVID-19 infection. If you were treated for COVID-19 symptoms with monoclonal antibodies or convalescent plasma, you should wait 90 days before getting a COVID-19 vaccine. Talk to your doctor if you are unsure what treatments you received or if you have more questions about getting a COVID-19 vaccine. [1]: https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/vaccines/faq.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/vaccines/faq.html The underlying rationale is that vaccines elicit a more consistent immune response [2] and confer immunity with higher efficacy [3] than being infected with the real coronavirus. [2]: https://abcnews.go.com/Health/people-covid-19-vaccine-doctors/story?id=74783687 https://abcnews.go.com/Health/people-covid-19-vaccine-doctor... [3]: https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2021/01/14/johnson-and-johnson-sinovac-and-more https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2021/01/14/jo...
- mixmastamyk 6y ago> Out of over six thousand who have had the virus, there have been about 42 re-infections. Comparing that to the cohort of people who were never infected, that comes out to 83% efficacy. So there’s your comparison number – which means that being vaccinated with either of the mRNA agents provides better protection than being infected with the real coronavirus can. The vaccine comes in two doses spaced by a month or two, and the second boosts immune response. Being exposed to the real thing twice should have a similar effect, but it would be hard to precisely dose and schedule another weak exposure. However, `42/6000 = 0.007` sounds pretty low-risk to me, unless you are elderly and/or in poor health.
- bagacrap 6y agoIt's still mind boggling to be that this isn't taken into account when deciding on the order of vaccine distribution. The incremental protection conferred to a recovered covid patient is far less than that conferred to someone who hasn't contracted the disease.
- treis 6y agoI don't think people realize how bad the distribution problem is. My state is sitting on 800,000 doses. Four times than what they've given out. It's just craziness that after a year of this we can't handle rolling out a vaccine.
- axaxs 6y agoMy current city has about 1 million people in the metro area. They are only doing doses at one indoor building, and to date done 4,000 shots. It's honestly appalling.
- aidenn0 6y agoBe aware also that the federal government immediately increments the "doses given to state" number, while states may not report the "doses given" number back to the federal government promptly, so seeing one number being much larger than the other isn't necessarily proof that there's a distribution problem
- OliverGilan 6y agoI understand the justification for having restrictions on who can be vaccinated but part of me thinks this is all extremely counterproductive. Yes, old people are at greater risk but also the more young people are vaccinated the harder it is for the virus to spread and the faster we reach herd immunity which also ends up protecting old people. I end up thinking about this great video [1] by CGP Grey where he explains that the most efficient boarding method for an airplane isn't actually front-to-back but just random. Surely if we just said anyone could get a vaccine then we'd be more successful in reaching herd immunity right? Edit: You could also just make a portion of the day for older people only and the rest of the time open it up to everyone. I feel like right now we have the worst of all worlds [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oAHbLRjF0vo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oAHbLRjF0vo
- scotty79 6y agoI think the main function of the vaccine in the initial stage is to lower the amount of people who need hospitalisation after contracting covid. So giving limited doses to the people who are most likeley to develop severe symptoms seems like best strategy to achieve that. Even if it pushes back date of achieving herd immunity a little. So prioritizing health care workers (they can easily contract and spread) and old people (a lot of them need hospitalisation) seems like a good idea.
- solatic 6y agoContext: 30-year old living in Israel The Israeli system is slow. It's centrally-planned, and even with central-planning taking advantage of pre-existing distribution networks and patient record digitization, the planners still make mistakes with dose distribution. There are four HMOs in this country, one of them has too many doses for the current age tranche and hands them out to younger walk-ins in peripheral areas, two of the HMOs don't have enough and are slowing down the progress of the age tranche for everyone else. As bad as the Israeli system is, honestly, it's about the best that can be done considering that vaccine distribution in Israel is supply-constrained. They had to stop giving out first doses for about a week until they could negotiate with Pfizer to move up the shipments. What shipments do come in are quickly distributed. As of yesterday, 45+ can make appointments. The US healthcare system is a nightmare. But for all of the US healthcare system's many, many, many weaknesses, vaccine distribution is supposed to be a strength. Doses are mass-manufactured and cheap, about $15/dose. Private providers are supposed to be able to make their own dosage orders through their own pre-existing suppliers and be distributed through ordinary private logistics networks. Intense competition insures a minimum of dose wastage. The state can minimally regulate to ensure that supply chain participants have adequate refrigeration etc. If the state wants to prioritize frontline workers, the elderly, fine. The state is more than welcome to buy as many (cheap) doses as it wants on the open market, and distribute for free to whoever the state deems to be a priority. But if the state cannot adequately take advantage of the relative supply glut, and efficiently manage the total supply that is available, then the state shouldn't freeze out the private market on the excess! What's the goal here? The goal is not to immunize the elderly, or frontline workers. The goal is to end the pandemic. That means getting R under 1.0, and that means mass immunizations. That frontline workers or the elderly represent theoretical optimizations in pursuit of that goal is clearly demonstrating to not work out in reality. Let the free market work!
- AndrewDucker 6y agoIsrael has vaccinated over four times the numbers (per 100k) that the USA has. It's the fastest vaccinating country in the world, by a long way! https://ourworldindata.org/covid-vaccinations#country-by-country-data-on-covid-19-vaccinations https://ourworldindata.org/covid-vaccinations#country-by-cou...
- permille42 6y agoThe person in the article doesn't seem to be in a high risk group. They state they pedaled their bicycle 5 miles to reach the scene. I get that the virus is dangerous for everyone, but I think those of us who are younger and generally more healthy should allow those in high risks groups / high exposure to get the vaccine first, regardless of whatever "leftover doses" exist or not. Perhaps this person is in a high exposure group due to their job? I'm doubting it but I guess it is possible.
- acje 6y agoWhat is the chance of actually having left over doses in a densely populated area? The logistics are pretty simple with great numbers of consumers. It's another mater in a sparsely populated area.
- permille42 6y agoThe claim in the article, which is believable, is that many people either don't want to get the vaccine or don't show for some other reason during a single day. For some unknown additional reason, doses within that day are supposed to be used up. There seems to be an implied expiration for doses, but a single day doesn't make much sense. The result of both these together is that they are supposedly letting people not scheduled to get the vaccine get it on some days. The article calls them "walk-ins". Apparently word of this has been spreading slowly, and in this case went viral and a ton of people showed up to attempt to get some small number of "leftover doses". It seems like chaos to me and a failing of sensible procedure. I am not though a doctor or involved in the distribution process so what do I know. Perhaps there is good reason this happens.
- maxerickson 6y agoFor the Pfizer vaccine, once a vial is mixed with the diluent, there is a 6 hour window to use the 6 doses in it. Shouldn't be creating a huge amount of waste because of that, but it isn't unreasonable to expect that more than 1 vial would be prepared at a given time. From the Prepare instructions on: https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/covid-19/info-by-product/pfizer/index.html https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/covid-19/info-by-product/pfizer...
- forgingahead 6y agoThis is shameful - authorities knew the vaccine was en route to being made available towards the end of last year. COVID has been a persistent nightmare for many localities for the past 10 months. Nobody planned for this? I can't help but feel that the media is responsible for this also - when being informed that vaccines were on the way in the 2nd half of last year, they resoundingly pooh-poohed it and refused to consider the possibility, instead preferring to wallow in the world's misery. It's good for their advertising! Really shameful all around.
- Vaslo 6y agoLet’s be honest, that poo-pooing occurred because they are blinded by their hatred for a certain leader. That’s more important to them than integrity.
- objectivetruth 6y agoStellar media criticism here; I'd love it if you could point out some examples of fair media with "integrity" that, in your opinion, treated "a certain leader" objectively and fairly. I think I speak for many people when I say that we eagerly want to know your recommendations on what unbiased bastions of objective journalism we should be seeking out.
- forgingahead 6y agoDefinitely - see the downvotes on my other related comment about him today. Really sad how people have been conditioned to be so negative.
- aphextron 6y ago> As I got closer, though, I started to believe that if the rumor was true, I would never have been able to justify to myself that I had stayed at my desk and turned down an escape from the pandemic. I just recently got my first shot of the Moderna vaccine last week. When I learned that I would be getting it, I went through the same euphoric excitement the author is describing. Then it slowly dawns on you that this is simply a bandaid. Something to stop the massive amounts of deaths. It's not going to miraculously end everything and make the world go back to normal. There is no "escape". You're not going to be hopping on flights, vacationing, and going to bars again any time soon. This is a real mistaken mindset that I think people are going to have to come to terms with. The vaccine is not a silver bullet. It doesn't just make the virus magically bounce off of you like a force field. You will still get infected if you are exposed, and can very well still transmit it. The vaccine simply keeps you from developing severe disease. We (the human race) have a long, slow, painful slog ahead of us to return to anything even resembling what things were like in Fall 2019. The virus is going to become endemic. Overall population vaccine uptake will most likely look like Flu vaccine rates (<50%). And that means life will never be quite the same.
- bequanna 6y ago> There is no "escape". You're not going to be hopping on flights, vacationing, and going to bars again any time soon. We (the human race) have a long, slow, painful slog ahead of us to return to anything even resembling what life was like in Fall 2019. Wow. You're entitled to that bleak outlook, but unless you're in a super-high risk group, I would advise you to snap out of it and resume living your life. I've literally done all of the things you listed in the past month. Additionally, I'm at the gym 5x a week. If you're safe/responsible, there is absolutely no reason you can't do 99% of the things you want.
- aphextron 6y ago>I've literally done all of the things you listed in the past month. Additionally, I'm at the gym 5x a week. If you're safe/responsible, there is absolutely no reason you can't do 99% of the things you want. The reason I'm not doing those things isn't because I can't. I'm at practically zero risk now that I've been vaccinated. The reason I'm not doing it is because I don't want to be around people like you. In 6 months from now, when there's no excuse to not be vaccinated, that will be a different story. But people going about normal life right now as if nothing were happening are the reason we're seeing 4,000 deaths a day in the US, and they are objectively bad human beings.
- compsciphd 6y agoI'm 41, Israel opened up the vaccines to people over 40 yesterday. Called my HMO, made a same day appointment for their vaccination center at the local stadium, went there by bus in the rain. swiped in with my card when I got there and was given a number. waited close to an hour for my number to be called, got quickly stabbed in the upper arm an soon left. It really shouldn't be that hard. My parents (i.e. 70ish) are now scheduled to get the vaccine towards the end of february in maryland.