4 ms·
The goal: to show you only ads for things you care about and are likely to buy and be influenced by advertising for, is good. No, that's bad. The last thing I
by tonyedgecombe 6y ago
The goal: to show you only ads for things you care about and are likely to buy and be influenced by advertising for, is good.
No, that's bad. The last thing I want is to be influenced by adverts.
- tomComb 6y agoI'd rather be influenced by relevant ads that could possibly be useful than ones that will just annoy me. And I'd rather not make ads less effective because that would mean either more ads or fewer publishers.
- amelius 6y ago> I'd rather be influenced by relevant ads that could possibly be useful than ones that will just annoy me. It's easier to ignore ads that are totally irrelevant. The ads that are targeted are the most distracting. I'd rather see ads about some detergent than about a new SSD drive that will catch my attention and makes me forget what I was looking for in the first place. When I need a new SSD, I will just visit a shop. I don't need ads for that.
- bluGill 6y agoBut i'm happen to need a better mousetrap and so if you can in some way let me know you are selling one I'll be glad to take a chance in yours. Sure I can ignore ads for feminine supplies (as a male they are obviously useless to me), but I'd prefer if I didn't have to.
- amelius 6y agoThis is a silly argument. Don't you think you'll have a much better chance of finding a better mouse trap by actively searching Google for it than by waiting for some targeted ads to come by?
- bquest2 6y agoLet's say that your search for mouse traps comes back with the classic type that kills. Wouldn't it be better that you see an ad for a no kill mouse trap that you didn't even know was a thing? Ads can sometimes inform people about products that they didn't even think existed.
- amelius 6y agoBut a Google search is specifically designed to solve this problem. Targeted ads, however, also could mislead, distract, cause overconsumption, and invade your privacy. And if there was a better mouse trap, then any salesman would quickly learn about it (e.g. at business conferences etc), so you could just go to a shop and ask. Finally, if you really insist that targeted ads are superior to anything else, then you could just opt-in to a service that provides ads. And you could tell the service all your private details so it knows how to better serve you (without the service having to guess at it). Just don't assume that someone else needs targeted ads to have a fulfilling life.
- tomjen3 6y agoNot if you don't know that the better mouse trap was even possible. You are not going to search for "breathable, waterproof shoes" if you don't know GoreTex is a thing. Granted somewhere in the last 20 years we have mostly stopped innovating and started optimizing and so now you get ads for branded Skinner boxes (sorry, free to play mobile games) rather than, say, cancer cures but if there were innovating products worth buying, you wouldn't search for them because you wouldn't even be able to imagine them.
- TeMPOraL 6y ago> Not if you don't know that the better mouse trap was even possible. You are not going to search for "breathable, waterproof shoes" if you don't know GoreTex is a thing. Sure I am, if I care about shoes being breathable and waterproof. Why would I not do that, and instead hope a magic box will read my mind and guess what I need?
- mola 6y agoIf you need it you'll search for it. Then an ad is relevant. Otherwise it's probably trying to manipulate you to buy something you don't need or in very rare cases inform you of something you needed but didn't know existed. I have a feeling the latter is fiction.
- JoshTriplett 6y agoWhy pick either of those alternatives? Block all ads, whether "relevant" or not, so they don't compete for your valuable attention. > And I'd rather not make ads less effective because that would mean either more ads or fewer publishers. I'd rather make ads so ineffective that they go away entirely. Some publishers will find a way to adapt.
- passivate 6y agoThe Ad matching service gets paid when you buy something, regardless of whether it is relevant, useful or needed by you. What is effective for you, and effective for the ad network are two separate things. Also, ads by their very nature are designed to manipulate you into buying a product. The more personal information they have, the easier it is to manipulate you. Maybe you're still OK with that, but many people think that this is the wrong direction for the web.
- cratermoon 6y agoOh no, nobody depends on linking up an ad impression with an actual purchase. Not only is that incredibly hard to do, with few exceptions, the conversion rate is abysmal. Money changes hands at the time the advertiser agrees to buy the space on the publisher, based on the CPM of the offer. A publisher that can more reliably link ad impression with sales can charge a higher CPM, but nobody in their right mind would buy and sell ads based only on conversion.
- tsimionescu 6y agoExactly! Even for free market believers, ads are just a way of manipulating consumers so that they are less rational, and so they are a distortion of the market (in favor of the biggest players, of course, as they can spend the most on advertising).
- cratermoon 6y agoNews flash: you're influenced by all kinds of things you don't notice, and not all of those things are what you might consider "advertising".